Federal Trade Commission
Protecting America's Consumers
Docket No. 9346
In the Matter of ProMedica Health System, Inc., a corporation.
FTC File No. 101 0167
[Related Federal Court Proceeding]
June 25, 2012
- Opinion of the Commission [Redacted Public Version]
- Concurring Opinion of Commissioner Rosch
- Final Order [Redacted Public Version]
May 22, 2012
April 27, 2012
- Respondent's Response to the Commission's Notice of Intent to Disclose in Camera Information
March 28, 2012
- Opinion of the Commission, By Commissioner Julie Brill [Provisionally Redacted Public Version]
- Concurring Opinion of Commissioner Rosch
- Final Order [Provisionally Redacted Public Version]
- News Release
February 2, 2012
- Complaint Counsel's Compilation of Materials To Present During the Oral Argument
- Respondent's Compilation of Materials to Present During Oral Argument
January 26, 2012
- Respondent's Reply Brief in Support of its Appeal
January 24, 2012
- Complaint Counsel's Reply Brief
January 19, 2012
- Complaint Counsel's Answering Brief
January 17, 2012
- Respondent's Answering Brief to Complaint Counsel's Appeal
January 11, 2012
- Commission Order Scheduling Oral Argument For February 6, 2012
January 9, 2012
- Joint Motion for Scheduling of Oral Argument
January 5, 2012
- Initial Decision by Chief Administrative Law Judge D. Michael Chappell, Filed on December 5, 2011 (Redacted Public Version)
- News Release
December 27, 2011
- Complaint Counsel's Appeal Brief
- Respondent's Appeal Brief
September 30, 2011
- Complaint Counsel's Post-trial Reply Brief
- Complaint Counsel's Reply Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
September 29, 2011
- Respondent ProMedica Health System, Inc's Replies to Complaint Counsel's Post-trial Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
- Respondent ProMedica Health System, Inc.’s Post-trial Reply Brief
September 20, 2011
- Complaint Counsel’s Post-Trial Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law
- Complaint Counsel’s Post-Trial Brief
- Respondent ProMedica Health System, Inc.'s Proposed Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, and Order - Revised
September 16, 2011
-
Administrative Law Judge’s Order Granting Non-Party Ambac Assurance Corporation's Motion For In Camera Treatment of Hearing Transcript
September 15, 2011
-
Respondent ProMedica Health System, Inc.'s Post-Trial Brief
-
Respondent ProMedica Health System, Inc.'s Proposed Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, and Order
September 7, 2011
- Administrative Law Judge’s Order Setting Closing Arguments
September 2, 2011
- Motion of Non-Party Ambac Assurance Corporation for In Camera Treatment of Hearing Transcript and Declaration of Stephen P. Rochford in Support of Motion [Redacted Public Version]
August 29, 2011
- Notice of Appearance Filed by Counsel for Respondents
August 26, 2011
- Administrative Law Judge’s Order Granting Respondent's Supplemental Motion for in Camera Treatment
August 25, 2011
- Administrative Law Judge’s Order Granting Non-party Ambac Assurance Corporation's Motion for Provisional in Camera Treatment of Hearing Testimony
August 24, 2011
- Respondent ProMedica Health System, Inc.'s Unopposed Supplemental Motion for in Camera Treatment of New Trial Exhibits
- Motion of Non-party Ambac Assurance Corporation for Provisional in Camera Treatment of Hearing Testimony
- Notice of Appearance Filed by Counsel for Non-Party Ambac Assurance Corporation
August 22, 2011
-
Joint Stipulated Motion to Admit Additional Exhibits Into Evidence
-
Statement of Parties Regarding Meet and Confer
August 12, 2011
- Respondent ProMedica Health System Inc.’s Motion for Leave to File Substitute Hearing Exhibit
August 9, 2011
- Administrative Law Judge’s Order Summarizing Bench Ruling on Respondent’s Motion for Leave to File Substitute Hearing Exhibit
June 3, 2011
- Complaint Counsel's Pre-trial Brief
- Administrative Law Judge’s Order Granting Respondent's Supplemental Motion for in Camera Treatment of New Trial Exhibits
- Respondent Promedica Health System, Inc.’s Notice of Filing of Proposed Order
June 2, 2011
- Administrative Law Judge’s Order on Non-parties' Motions for in Camera Treatment
- Administrative Law Judge’s Order on Respondent's Supplemental Motion for in Camera Treatment
June 1, 2011
- Non-parties UnitedHealthcare, Inc. and UnitedHealthcare of Ohio Inc.’s Motion for Leave to File Supplemental Motion for in Camera Treatment of Proposed Evidence
- Respondent ProMedica Health System, Inc.'s Unopposed Supplemental Motion for in Camera Treatment of New Trial Exhibits
- Respondent ProMedica Health System, Inc.'s Pre-trial Brief
- Respondent ProMedica Health System, Inc.'s Notice of Withdrawal of its Motion in Limine to Exclude Employer and Physician Declarations
- Non-parties UnitedHealthcare, Inc. and UnitedHealthcare of Ohio Inc.’s Supplemental Motion for in Camera Treatment of Proposed Evidence
May 27, 2011
- Administrative Law Judge’s Order Granting Respondent's Renewed Motion for in Camera Treatment of Trial Exhibits
- Non-party Aetna Inc.'s Motion for ·in Camera Treatment of Proposed Evidence
May 26, 2011
- Respondent ProMedica Health System, Inc.?s Notice of Filing of Proposed Order
May 25, 2011
- Administrative Law Judge?s Order Granting Complaint Counsel?s Motion for in Camera Treatment
- Administrative Law Judge?s Order on Non-Parties? Motions for in Camera Treatment
- Administrative Law Judge?s Order on Respondent?s Renewed Motion for in Camera Treatment
- Complaint Counsel's Unopposed Motion to Replace Witness With Equivalent Witness From the Same Organization on Complaint Counsel's Proposed Final Witness List
- Notice of Appearance by Counsel Supporting the Complaint
- Complaint Counsel’s and Respondent’s Joint Stipulations of Law and Fact
- Complaint Counsel’s Opposition to Respondent’s Motion in Limine to Exclude Employer and Physician Declarations
May 24, 2011
- Notice of Appearance Filed by Counsel for MDA Engineering, Inc.
- Administrative Law Judge?s Order Granting Complaint Counsel?s Unopposed Motion to Replace Witness with Equivalent Witness from Same Organization on Complaint Counsel?s Witness List
May 23, 2011
- Complaint Counsel?s Opposition to Respondent's Renewed Motion for in Camera Treatment of Trial Exhibits
May 20, 2011
- Non-Party Aetna Inc.’s Supplemental Motion for in Camera Treatment of Proposed Evidence
- MDA Engineering, Inc. Motion for in Camera Treatment of Hearing Exhibits
May 18, 2011
- Notice of Appearance Filed by Counsel Supporting the Complaint
- Respondent Promedica Health System Inc.?s Renewed Motion for in Camera Treatment of Trial Exhibits
May 16, 2011
- Non-Parties UnitedHealthcare, Inc. and UnitedHealthcare of Ohio Inc.’s Amended Motion for in Camera Treatment of Proposed Evidence
- Notice of Appearance Filed by Counsel Supporting the Complaint
May 13, 2011
- Respondent ProMedica Health System Inc.’s Motion in Limine to Exclude Employer and Physician Declarations
- Administrative Law Judge?s Order on Respondent?s Motion for in Camera Treatment
- Unopposed Motion of Third Party Fulton County Health Center for in Camera Treatment of Exhibits and Underlying Data
May 12, 2011
- Non-Party The University of Toledo?s Motion for in Camera Treatment of Hearing Exhibits Designated by Complaint and Defense Counsel
- Non-Party Mercy Health Partners? Motion for in Camera Treatment of Confidential Materials
- Complaint Counsel’s Opposition to Respondent’s Motions For in Camera Treatment of Trial Exhibits
- Notice of Appearance Filed by Counsel for Non-Party Mercy Health Partners
May 11, 2011
- Non-Party Wood County Hospital?s Motion for in Camera Treatment of Confidential Data Designated by Complaint Counsel
- Non-Party Wellpoint, Inc.'s Unopposed Motion for in Camera Treatment of Trial Exhibits
- Counsel for Non-Party Wellpoint, Inc.'s Statement Regarding Meet and Confer
- Respondent ProMedica Health System, Inc.'s Supplemental Motion for in Camera Treatment of Trial Exhibits
- Respondent Promedica Health System, Inc.'s Motion for Leave to File a Supplemental Motion for in Camera Treatment of Certain Trial Exhibits
- Administrative Law Judge’s Order Shortening Time to File Response to Motions for in Camera Treatment Filed after May 5, 2011
May 10, 2011
- Administrative Law Judge’s Order on Motion of Non-Party MDA Engineering, Inc. for Extension of Time to Move for in Camera Treatment
- Non-Party MDA Engineering, Inc's Motion for Extension of Time
May 9, 2011
- Notice of Appearance Filed by Counsel for Non-Party Humana Inc.
May 6, 2011
- Notice of Appearance Filed by Counsel for Third-Party Michigan Health & Hospital Association Service Corporation
- Notice of Appearance Filed by Counsel for the Ohio Hospital Association
- Non-Party Humana Inc.'s Motion for in Camera Treatment of Proposed Evidence
- Non-Party FrontPath Health Coalition's Motion for in Camera Treatment of Proposed Evidence
- Notice of Appearance Filed by Counsel for Non-Party FrontPath Health Coalition
- Notice of Appearance Filed by Counsel Supporting the Complaint
- Administrative Law Judge’s Order Granting Unopposed Motion of Non-Party University of Toledo Medical Center for Extension of Time to Move for in Camera Treatment
May 5, 2011
- Motion by Nonparties United Healthcare, Inc., and United Healthcare of Ohio, Inc. For in Camera Treatment of Proposed Evidence
- Notice of Appearance by Counsel for Non-Party Aetna, Inc.
- Complaint Counsel’s Unopposed Motion for in Camera Treatment of Hearing Exhibits
- Motion of Third-Party Michigan Health & Hospital Association Service Corporation for in Camera Treatment of Records
- Non-Party The University of Toledo's Unopposed Motion For Extension of Time to Move for in Camera Treatment of Hearing Exhibits Designated by Complaint and Defense Counsel
- Notice of Appearance Filed by Counsel for Non-Party The University of Toledo
- Administrative Law Judge’s Order Granting Unopposed Motion of Non-Party Connecticut General Life Insurance Co. For Extension of Time to Move for in Camera Treatment
- Non-Party Connecticut General Life Insurance Co.'s Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time to Move for in Camera Treatment of Certain Records, Testimony and Electronic Patient Claims Data Designated by Complaint Counsel and Respondent's Counsel
- Notice of Appearance Filed by Counsel for Non-Party Connecticut General Life Insurance Co. (CIGNA)
- Non-Party Aetna Inc.'s Motion for in Camera Treatment of Proposed Evidence
- Respondent ProMedica Health System, Inc.'s Motion for in Camera Treatment of Trial Exhibits
- Non-Party the Ohio Hospital Association's Motion for in Camera Treatment of Proposed Evidence
- Non-Party Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan's Motion for in Camera Treatment of Proposed Evidence
- Notice of Appearance Filed by Counsel for Non-Party Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan
- Non-Party Medical Mutual of Ohio's Motion for in Camera Treatment of Confidential Materials
- Notice of Appearance Filed by Counsel for Non-Party Medical Mutual of Ohio
- Notice of Appearance Filed by Counsel for Non-Parties UnitedHealthcare, Inc. and UnitedHealthcare of Ohio, Inc.
- Motion of Non-Party Ambac Assurance Corporation for in Camera Treatment of Proposed Evidence
May 4, 2011
- Administrative Law Judge?s Order Granting Unopposed Motion of Non-Party Mercy Health Partners for Extension of Time to Move for in Camera
- Non-Party Mercy Health Partners's Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time to Move for in Camera Treatment of Confidential Materials
- Non-Party Findley Davies, Inc,'s Motion for in Camera Treatment of Proposed Evidence
- Notice of Appearance Filed by Counsel for Non-Party Findley Davies, Inc.
- Administrative Law Judge’s Order Granting Unopposed Motion of Non-Party Wood County Hospital for Extension of Time to Move for in Camera Treatment
- Non-Party Wood County Hospital's Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time to Move for in Camera Treatment of Confidential Data Designated by Complaint Counsel
May 3, 2011
- Notice of Appearance Filed by Counsel for Non-Party Fulton County Health Center
- Notice of Appearance Filed by Counsel for Non-Party Wood County Hospital
- Administrative Law Judge’s Order Granting Consent Motion of Non-Party Wellpoint, Inc. for Extension of Time to Move for in Camera Treatment
- Non-Party Wellpoint, Inc.'s Consented to Motion for Extension of Time to Move for in Camera Treatment of Hearing Exhibits Designated By Complaint Counsel and by Respondent's Counsel
- Notice of Appearance Filed by Counsel for Non-Party Wellpoint, Inc.
- Administrative Law Judge’s Order Granting Unopposed Motion of Non-Party Fulton County Health Center for Extension of Time to Move for in Camera Treatment
- Unopposed Motion of Non-Party Fulton County Health Center For Extension of Time to Move for in Camera Treatment of Exhibits Designated by Complaint Counsel
- Administrative Law Judge’s Order Granting Consent Motion for Joint Scheduling Conference
May 2, 2011
- Consent Motion for Joint Scheduling Conference and Memorandum in Support Thereof
April 8, 2011
- Commission Order Regarding Scheduling
March 29, 2011
- Administrative Law Judge’s Order Denying Respondent's Motion to Set Hearing Location
March 16, 2011
- Complaint Counsel’s Opposition to Respondent’s Motion to Set Hearing Location
March 10, 2011
- Respondent Promedica Health System, Inc.'s Response to Complaint Counsel's Requests for Admission
March 7, 2011
- Respondent ProMedica Health System, Inc.'s Motion to Set Hearing Location
March 3, 2011
- Administrative Law Judge’s Order Revising Scheduling Order
February 25, 2011
February 24, 2011
February 9, 2011
- Respondent ProMedica Health System Inc.'s Notice of Withdrawal of its Unopposed Motion to Modify Protective Order
February 7, 2011
February 3, 2011
- Administrative Law Judge's Order Granting Respondent's Unopposed Motion to Place Answer on the Public Record
January 31, 2011
- Respondent ProMedica Health System Inc.'s Unopposed Motion to Modify Protective Order
- Respondent ProMedica Health System, Inc.'s Unopposed Motion to Place Answer on the Public Record
January 26, 2011
- Administrative Law Judge’s Order Setting Scheduling Conference
- Complaint Counsel's Notice of Appearance
January 25, 2011
- Respondent ProMedica Health System, Inc.'s Answer to Complaint (Redacted Public Version)
- Administrative Law Judge’s Order Granting Complaint Counsel's Unopposed Motion To Place Complaint on the Public Record
January 24, 2011
- Complaint Counsel's Notice of Appearance
- Complaint Counsel's Unopposed Motion to Place Complaint on the Public Record
January 12, 2011
- Notice of Appearance Filed by Counsel for the Respondents
January 10, 2011
- Notice of Appearance Filed by Counsel for the Respondent
January 6, 2011
- Protective Order Governing Discovery Material
- Order Designating Administrative Law Judge
- Administrative Complaint [Redacted Public Version]
- News Release