Volume 2: Attachments
This volume shows sociograms for the networks of individuals Centers for Education and Research on Therapeutics (CERTs) as well as the CERTS Coordinating Center. Abt used Social Network Analysis (SNA) techniques. A detailed description of the network relationships for each CERT is found in Chapter 3, and an overview of the social network analysis (SNA) measures is provided in Exhibit 5. Each sociogram has central points (the CERT and the CERT Coordinating Center) with lines radiating out from the central point to every organization they are partnered with and the CERT network as a whole. A key to the abbreviation for each organization listed as a network point is shown below the sociogram.
Contents
Attachment 1. HMO Network Sociogram
Attachment 2. Duke Sociogram
Attachment 3. UNC Sociogram
Attachment 4. Vanderbilt Sociogram
Attachment 5. Arizona Sociogram
Attachment 6. Penn Sociogram
Attachment 7. Alabama Sociogram
Attachment 8. Coordinating Center (Now) Sociogram
Attachment 9. Coordinating Center (Now) Sociogram
Attachment 10. Preferred Partners Sociogram
Attachment 11. Final Collaboration Network Sociogram
Attachment 12. Appreciative Inquiry Workshop And Stakeholder Discussion Guides
Attachment 1: HMO Network
![This figure is a sociogram of the HMO Network CERT that displays the network relationships between the CERT and organizations associated with it. The HMO Network is one central point, with the CERT Coordinating Center the other point. The list of organizations that work with the HMO Network CERT are displayed in a table below.](attachfig1.gif)
Note: For an in-depth analysis, please refer to Section 3.1.2 of Volume 1.
Key to Organization Abbreviations
Full Name of Organization |
Abbreviation in Sociogram |
CERT Harvard |
CERTH |
CERT Alabama |
CERTA |
CERT University of North Carolina |
CERTUNC |
Brigham and Women's |
BW |
Centers for Disease Control |
CDC |
Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services |
CMS |
Channing Laboratory |
CL |
Drug Industry |
DIND |
Duke University |
DUKE |
Fallon |
FALLON |
Fallon Community Health Plan |
FCHP |
Fallon Healthcare/Umass |
FHUM |
Fallon/Umass |
FUM |
UMASS |
UMASS |
Group Health Cooperative |
GHC |
Group Health Cooperative of Puget Sound |
GHCPS |
Harvard HMO |
HHMO |
Harvard Medical School |
HMS |
Harvard Pilgrim Research Foundation |
HPRF |
Harvard School of Public Health |
HSPH |
Harvard Vanguard |
HVAN |
HealthPartners Research Foundation |
HPRF |
Henry Ford Health Sciences Center |
HFHSC |
Henry Ford Health System |
HFHS |
HMO Research Network |
HMORN |
HPHC |
HPHC |
Hugh H. Tilson, MD, DrPH, Steering Committee Chair |
CERTSCChair |
Kaiser Foundation Colorado |
KFC |
Kaiser Foundation Health Plan Colorado |
KFHPC |
Kaiser Foundation Research Institute |
KFRI |
Kaiser Permanente |
KP |
Kaiser Permanente Hawaii Region? |
KPHR |
Kaiser Permanente North Carolina |
KPNC |
Kaiser Permanente Northern California |
KPNCAL |
Kaiser Permanente of Colorado |
KPC |
Kaiser Permanente of Georgia |
KPG |
Kaiser Permanente of Northwest |
KPNW |
Kaiser Permanente Southern California |
KPSC |
Lovelace Clinic Foundation |
LCF |
Lovelace Health Systems |
LHS |
Marshfield Clinic Research Foundation |
MCRF |
Meyers Primary Care, Fallon, Umass |
MPCFUM |
Meyers Primary Care/Umass |
MPCUM |
Scott and White Health System |
SWHS |
St. Vincent's, Umass |
STVUM |
US Department of Health and Human Services |
HHS |
CERT Project Partners |
CERTPP |
CERT Steering Committee |
CERTSC |
CERT PENN |
CERTP |
CERT Arizona |
CERTAZ |
CERT Duke |
CERTDUKE |
Coordinating Center |
CERTCC |
CERT Vanderbilt |
CERTV |
Food and Drug Administration |
FDA |
Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality |
AHRQ |
Outside Experts |
OUTEXP |
Physicians |
MDS |
Media/Journals |
MEDIA |
Grantees |
GRANT |
Return to Contents
Attachment 2: Duke
![This figure is a sociogram of the Duke Network CERT that displays the network relationships between the CERT and organizations associated with it. The Duke Network is one central point, with the CERT Coordinating Center the other central point with organizations radiating out of it. The list of organizations that work with the Duke CERT are displayed in a table below.](attachfig2.gif)
Note: For an in-depth analysis, please refer to Section 3.1.3 of Volume 1.
Key to Organization Abbreviations
Full Name of Organization |
Abbreviation in Sociogram |
CERT Duke |
CERTDUKE |
Duke Clinical Research Institute |
DCRI |
Duke University System Community |
DUKEUS |
American College of Cardiologists |
ACC |
American Heart Association |
AHA |
Coalition for Affordable Healthcare Quality |
CAHQ |
American Academy of Healthcare Physicians |
AAHP |
National Committee for Quality Assurance |
NCQA |
Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services |
CMS |
CERT Coordinating Center |
CERTCC |
Food and Drug Administration |
FDA |
CERT Steering Committee |
CERTSC |
CERT Harvard |
CERTH |
Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality |
AHRQ |
National Institutes of Health |
NIH |
CERT University of North Carolina |
CERTUNC |
CERT Alabama |
CERTA |
Healthcare Stakeholders |
HS |
CERT Cornell University |
CERTCU |
CERT Iowa |
CERTIU |
Kaiser Permanente Northern California |
KaiserCA |
Media/Journals |
MEDIA |
CERT Project Partners |
CERTPP |
Return to Contents
Attachment 3: UNC
![This figure is a sociogram of the UNC Network CERT that displays the network relationships between the CERT and organizations associated with it. The UNC Network is one central point, with the CERT Coordinating Center the other central point with organizations radiating out of it. The list of organizations that work with the UNC CERT are displayed in a table below.](attachfig3.gif)
Note: For an in-depth analysis, please refer to Section 3.1.4 of Volume 1.
Key to Organization Abbreviations
Full Name of Organization |
Abbreviation in Sociogram |
CERT University of North Carolina |
CERTUNC |
UNC Chapel Hill |
UNCCH |
Research Triangle Institute |
RTI |
American Board of Pediatric Medicine |
ABPM |
North Carolina WIC |
NCWIC |
American Academy of Pediatrics |
AAP |
Institute of Health Medicine |
IHM |
UNC Children's Hospital |
UNCCH |
US Pharmacopoeia |
USP |
National Institute for Children's Healthcare Quality |
NICHQ |
Medtronic Company |
Medtronic |
Beckinson, Dickinson, & Co. |
BD |
Texas A&M |
A&M |
KB Reynolds Foundation |
KBRF |
North Carolina Medicaid |
NCMA |
CERT Harvard |
CERTH |
CERT Duke |
CERTDUK |
CERT Penn |
CERTP |
Glaxo Smith Kline |
GLAXO |
Community Care Network of North Carolina |
CCNNC |
National Institute of Child Health& Human Development |
NICHD |
North Carolina Access Care |
NCAC |
Duke Hospital |
DH |
Piedmont Health Clinic |
PHC |
Cincinnati Children's Hospital |
CCH |
CERT Vanderbilt |
CERTV |
CERT Arizonian |
CERTAZ |
CERT Alabama |
CERTA |
CERT Steering Committee |
CERTSC |
Kaiser Permanente Northern California |
KAISERNC |
CERT Coordinating Center |
CERTCC |
Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality |
AHRQ |
National Institutes of Health |
NIH |
Food and Drug Administration |
FDA |
Media/Journals |
MEDIA |
CERT Project Partners |
CERTPP |
Healthcare Stakeholders |
HS |
Return to Contents
Attachment 4: Vanderbilt
![This figure is a sociogram of the Vanderbilt Network CERT that displays the network relationships between the CERT and organizations associated with it. The Vanderbilt Network is one central point, with the CERT Coordinating Center the other central point with organizations radiating out of it. The list of organizations that work with the Vanderbilt CERT are displayed in a table below.](attachfig4.gif)
Note: For an in-depth analysis, please refer to Section 3.1.5 of Volume 1.
Key to Organization Abbreviations
Full Name of Organization |
Abbreviation in Sociogram |
CERT Vanderbilt |
CERTV |
Vanderbilt University Medical Center |
VUMC |
TENNCARE Program |
TENNCARE |
Veterans Administration |
VA |
State of Tennessee Health Department |
TENNHD |
Geriatric Research Education Center and Clinical Care Center |
GRECC |
Institute of Health Medicine |
IHM |
CERT Harvard |
CERTH |
University of Washington |
UW |
Harvard School of Public Health |
HSPH |
DECIDE Network |
DECIDE |
CERT Steering Committee |
CERTSC |
CERT Coordinating Center |
CERTCC |
Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality |
AHRQ |
National Institutes of Health |
NIH |
Food and Drug Administration |
FDA |
Media/Journals |
MEDIA |
CERT Project Partners |
CERTPP |
Healthcare Stakeholders |
HS |
Return to Contents
Attachment 5: Arizona
![This figure is a sociogram of the Arizona Network CERT that displays the network relationships between the CERT and organizations associated with it. The Arizona Network is one central point, with the CERT Coordinating Center the other central point with organizations radiating out of it. The list of organizations that work with the Arizona CERT are displayed in a table below.](attachfig5.gif)
Note: For an in-depth analysis, please refer to Section 3.1.6 of Volume 1.
Key to Organization Abbreviations
Full Name of Organization |
Abbreviation in Sociogram |
CERT Arizona |
CERTAZ |
University of Arizona |
UAZ |
Advanced PCS |
APCS |
National Institutes of Health |
NIH |
NIH Center Of Excellence in Women's Healthcare |
NIHCEWH |
Food and Drug Administration |
FDA |
Walgreens |
WALLGREENS |
General Clinical Research Center |
GCRC |
United Mine Workers |
UMWA |
CERT Penn State |
CERTP |
Wellpoint |
WELLPOINT |
Medtronic Company |
MC |
Express Script |
ES |
University of Arizona Health Sciences |
UAZHS |
Acuscan |
AS |
LaFrontiera HealthCenter |
LHC |
Critical Path Institute |
CPI |
Integrate Pain Center |
IPC |
Hope Center |
HC |
CERT Harvard |
CERTH |
CERT Duke |
CERTDUKE |
CDC |
CDC |
CERT Steering Committee |
CERTSC |
CERT Coordinating Center |
CERTCC |
Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality |
AHRQ |
Media/Journals |
MEDIA |
CERT Project Partners |
CERTPP |
Healthcare Stakeholders |
HS |
Return to Contents
Attachment 6: Penn
![This figure is a sociogram of the Penn Network CERT that displays the network relationships between the CERT and organizations associated with it. The Penn Network is one central point, with the CERT Coordinating Center the other central point with organizations radiating out of it. The list of organizations that work with the Penn CERT are displayed in a table below.](attachfig6.gif)
Note: For an in-depth analysis, please refer to Section 3.1.7 of Volume 1.
Key to Organization Abbreviations
Full Name of Organization |
Abbreviation in Sociogram |
CERT Alabama |
CERTA |
CERT Penn |
CERTP |
CERT Duke |
CERTDUKE |
CERT Harvard |
CERTH |
CERT Steering Committee |
CERTSC |
CERT Arizona |
CERTAZ |
CERT Project Partners |
CERTPP |
CERT Steering Committee |
CERTSC |
Food and Drug Administration |
FDA |
Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality |
AHRQ |
Department of Veterans Affairs |
DVA |
National Institutes of Health |
NIH |
FDA |
FDA |
DHHS |
DHHS |
Congress |
CONGRESS |
Center for Clinical Epidemiology and Biostatistics |
CCEB |
The Leonard Davis Institute of Health Economics |
LDIHE |
Healthcare Stakeholders |
HS |
The Center for Experimental Therapeutics |
CET |
General Clinical Research Center |
GCRC |
The University of Pennsylvania Health System |
UPHS |
The University of Pennsylvania |
UPENN |
Media/Journals |
MEDIA |
Outside Experts |
OUTEXP |
Pennsylvania State Department of Health |
PSDH |
Penn CERTS Public-Private Partnerships |
PCPPP |
Agouron Pharmaceuticals, Inc. |
AGOURON |
Amgen |
AMGEN |
Aventis |
AVENTIS |
Bayer |
BAYER |
Berlex |
BERLEX |
Centocor, Inc. |
CENTO |
Dupont Pharmaceuticals Company |
DUPONT |
Genetech |
GENET |
GlaxoSmithKline |
GLAXO |
Institute on Medicine |
IOM |
Johnson & Johnson |
JJ |
Juvenile Diabetes Research Foundation Int'l |
JDRF |
Knoll Pharmaceutical Company |
KPC |
McNeil |
MCNEIL |
Nanogen |
NANO |
Infectious Disease Society of America |
IDSA |
Pfizer Inc. |
PFIZER |
Pharmacia & Upjohn Company |
PUC |
Provantage Health Systems |
PHS |
Robert Wood Johnson Foundation |
RWJF |
SmithKline Beecham |
SB |
U of PA Health System |
UPHS |
VAMC |
VAMC |
Whitehall-Robins Healthcare |
WRH |
Wistar Institute |
WISTAR |
Wyeth-Ayerst Research |
WAR |
Prescription Pharmaceutical Assistance Contract for the Elderly |
PACE |
Government of Botswana |
BOTSWANA |
University of British Columbia |
UBC |
Centers for Disease Control |
CDC |
State Health Dept |
SHD |
Academy of Thoracic Surgeons |
ATS |
Return to Contents
Attachment 7: Alabama
![This figure is a sociogram of the Alabama Network CERT that displays the network relationships between the CERT and organizations associated with it. The Alabama Network is one central point, with the CERT Coordinating Center the other central point with organizations radiating out of it. The list of organizations that work with the Alabama CERT are displayed in a table below.](attachfig7.gif)
Note: For an in-depth analysis, please refer to Section 3.1.8 of Volume 1.
Key to Organization Abbreviations
Full Name of Organization |
Abbreviation in Sociogram |
Duke University Center for Aging |
DUCA |
Aetna U.S. Healthcare |
AETNA |
U.S. Quality Algorithms |
USQA |
Arthritis Foundation-Maryland Chapter |
AFMC |
American Academy of Pediatrics |
AAP |
UnitedHealth Group |
UHG |
Duke University Medical Center |
DUMC |
Medtronic Company |
Medtronic |
TAP Pharmaceutical Products, Inc. |
TAP |
National Institutes of Health |
NIH |
Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality |
AHRQ |
National Institute of Arthritis and Musculoskeletal and Skin Diseases |
NIAMS |
CERT Harvard (HMO Research Network) |
CERTH |
CERT Duke |
CERTDUKE |
CERT Penn |
CERTP |
CERT Arizona |
CERTAZ |
Aventis |
AVENTIS |
Southeast Regional Osteoporosis Board |
SROB |
P&G |
P&G |
North Carolina Access Care |
NCAC |
Eli Lilly and Company |
ELC |
Alacare Network |
ALNET |
BCBS of Alabama |
BCBSAB |
Food and Drug Administration |
FDA |
Lincoln Technologies |
LT |
United Mine Workers of America Health |
UMWA |
CERT Coordinating Center |
CERTCC |
University of North Carolina |
UNC |
CERT Steering Committee |
CERTSC |
Media/Journals |
MEDIA |
CERT Project Partners |
CERTPP |
Return to Contents
Attachment 8: Coordinating Center Now
![This figure is a sociogram of the CERT Coordinating Center network as it currently operates. There are two central points, one with the CERTs Coordinating Center and CERT Penn, and the other central point with the CERTs Steering Committee and CERT Harvard. The other CERTs are connected to these central points.](attachfig8.gif)
Note: For an in-depth analysis, please refer to Section 3.1.9 of Volume 1.
Key to Organization Abbreviations
Full Name of Organization |
Abbreviation in Sociogram |
Coordinating Center |
CERTCC |
CERT PENN |
CERTP |
CERT Arizona |
CERTAZ |
CERT Duke |
CERTDUKE |
CERT Harvard |
CERTH |
CERT University of North Carolina |
CERTUNC |
CERT Vanderbilt |
CERTV |
CERT Alabama |
CERTA |
CERT Arizona |
CERTAZ |
CERT Project Partners |
CERTPP |
CERT Steering Committee |
CERTSC |
Food and Drug Administration |
FDA |
Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality |
AHRQ |
National Institutes of Health |
NIH |
DHHS |
DHHS |
Media |
MEDIA |
Outside Experts |
OUTEXP |
Duke University |
DUKE |
Return to Contents
Attachment 9: Coordinating Centers Future
![This figure is a sociogram with a projection of the CERT Coordinating Center in the future.](attachfig9.gif)
Note: For an in-depth analysis, please refer to Section 3.1.9 of Volume 1.
Key to Organization Abbreviations
Full Name of Organization |
Abbreviation in Sociogram |
Coordinating Center |
CERTCC |
CERT PENN |
CERTP |
CERT Arizona |
CERTAZ |
CERT Duke |
CERTDUKE |
CERT Harvard |
CERTH |
CERT University of North Carolina |
CERTUNC |
CERT Vanderbilt |
CERTV |
CERT Alabama |
CERTA |
CERT Arizona |
CERTAZ |
CERT Project Partners |
CERTPP |
CERT Steering Committee |
CERTSC |
Food and Drug Administration |
FDA |
Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality |
AHRQ |
National Institutes of Health |
NIH |
DHHS |
DHHS |
Media |
MEDIA |
Outside Experts |
OUTEXP |
Duke University |
DUKE |
Return to Contents
Attachment 10: Preferred Partners
![This is a graphical portrayal of the preferred partners of the CERTs centers. These preferred partners were determined to be connections garnered and maintained by the CERTs Coordinating Center. There is no key to the abbreviations in this diagram.](attachfig10.gif)
This is a graphical portrayal of the preferred partners of the CERTs centers. These preferred partners were determined to be connections garnered and maintained by the CERTs Coordinating Center. There is no key to the abbreviations in this diagram. For more analysis, please refer to Section 3.1.2 of Volume 9.
Return to Contents
Attachment 11: Final Collaboration Network
![This is a graphical portrayal of the networking between CERTs and its partners. It shows a set of points with lines intersecting between them and numbers estimating the number of authors for the different partners next to the points.](attachfig11.gif)
Description of Sociogram: This is a graphical portrayal of the networking between CERTs and its partners. It shows a set of points with lines intersecting between them and numbers estimating the number of authors for the different partners next to the points.
Return to Contents
Return to Pharmaceutical Portfolio Contents
Proceed to Next Section