Accessibility Skip to Top Navigation Skip to Main Content Home  |  Change Text Size  |  Contact IRS  |  About IRS  |  Site Map  |  Español  |  Help  

8.1.1  Appeals Operating Directives and Guidelines

8.1.1.1  (10-23-2007)
Accomplishing the Appeals Mission

  1. The Appeals Mission is to resolve tax controversies, without litigation, on a basis which is fair and impartial to both the Government and the taxpayer and in a manner that will enhance voluntary compliance and public confidence in the integrity and efficiency of the Service.

  2. Appeals accomplishes this mission by considering protested cases, holding conferences, and negotiating settlements in a manner which ensures the following:

    1. A prompt conference is held and a prompt decision made so the taxpayer knows the final amount of tax liability or settlement of issues, and the additional revenue gets into the Treasury at the earliest practicable date.

    2. A high-quality decision is made representing judicious application of Service policy and sound legal principles.

    3. As many non-docketed cases as possible are closed while in non-docketed status, and as many docketed cases as possible are closed without trial.

  3. Schedule conferences on dates and/or at locations that are reasonably convenient to taxpayers, representatives and Appeals. If more convenient, settle cases by telephone conference, and/or correspondence.

  4. Appeals provides multilingual services to taxpayers who speak limited English, especially Spanish, to resolve tax controversies in an effective and informative manner. Bilingual employees provide the services, either those on a bilingual position description or those who volunteer.

  5. Generally, definitions of terms used in the Manual are with the material where the term is discussed. See Exhibit 8.1.1-1. for a list and the definitions of the common terms used in Appeals.

8.1.1.2  (10-23-2007)
Appeals Delegation Orders and Policy Statements

  1. Appeals is the Internal Revenue Service’s dispute resolution forum. The Commissioner granted Appeals authority to consider and negotiate settlements of Internal Revenue Service controversies. See Delegation Order No. 66, as revised, in IRM 1.2.47, Delegation of Authorities for the Appeals Process, and Policy Statement P–8–47 in IRM 1.2.1, Policies of the Internal Revenue Service.

  2. Delegations of Authority, more commonly referred to as Delegation Orders, place authority in the position(s) where actual operational responsibility resides. This frees officials from having to consider issues which can be handled at lower levels. Time and resources are saved when matters are forwarded directly to the designated office rather than to Heads of Office for action.

  3. See Exhibit 8.1.1-2. for Delegation Orders applicable to the Appeals' functional authority. See IRM 1.2.2, Delegations of Authority, for an explanation of the renumbering of delegations of authority and a complete listing of delegation orders broken down by IRM section and business process.

  4. Service Policies, commonly referred to as Policy Statements, are major decisions of the Commissioner, Deputy Commissioners, Chiefs and Directors directly reporting to the Commissioner and Deputy Commissioners, Division Commissioners and/or the National Taxpayer Advocate, within the framework of basic tax administrative policies of Treasury and Congress. These "Service Policies" govern and guide Service personnel in the administration of internal revenue laws and do not directly relate to time schedules or the allocation of funds, staffing, equipment or other resources.

8.1.1.2.1  (10-23-2007)
Some Exceptions to Appeals Authority

  1. There are certain issues or cases where Appeals may defer action or decline to settle:

    1. Appeals considers controlled issues subject to the decision of Service officials assigned nationwide responsibility for specific issues. There is currently one controlled issue. The LMSB Director, Natural Resources, has nationwide jurisdiction for the issues related to pricing and shipment of foreign produced crude oil and by products. See IRM 8.7.3.8.1 in IRM 8.7.3, Technical Guidance Programs and Delegation Order 153 as revised.

    2. Appeals does not settle ISP or other issues designated for litigation by the appropriate Associate Chief Counsel. Generally the designation for litigation does not preclude settlement of other cases involving the issue or the non-designated issues in the designated case. See IRM 8.7.3.5, Designation of Coordinated Issue for Litigation.

    3. Appeals does not settle cases contrary to technical advice memoranda issued by the National Office where the technical advice memoranda are favorable to the taxpayer, where they concern an organization’s exempt status or private foundation classification, or where they concern an employee plan’s qualification. See IRM 8.6.3, Appeals Rulings.

    4. Once the National Office and the taxpayer agree to terms for a change in accounting method and enter into a consent agreement, Appeals will not change those terms. Only Chief Counsel's office can revoke or modify a consent agreement in the year of change. If the facts or law changes in a subsequent year, Appeals can change the taxpayer's method to a different method.

8.1.1.3  (10-23-2007)
Examination Cases Under Appeals Jurisdiction

  1. The Internal Revenue Service is responsible for administering tax laws enacted by Congress. In carrying out this duty, Compliance examines selected tax returns in Field and Campus offices.

  2. The following table shows a chronological listing of what happens once Compliance examines the taxpayer's return.

    If ... Then ...
    Compliance examines selected tax returns usually a preliminary (30 or 60 day) letter is issued.
    Taxpayer does not agree with proposed adjustments by Compliance he/she may request an Appeals conference.
    Taxpayer does not agree with Compliance's proposed adjustments AND does not request an appeal generally a notice of deficiency (90 or 150 day letter) or other final notice or letter providing U.S. Tax Court rights is issued.
    No petition is filed in response to the notice or letter Compliance makes a default assessment based upon the findings in the notice or letter.
    A petition is filed the case is routed from Compliance through Appeals to Area Counsel to file an answer in response to the petition.
    The petition is answered Counsel returns case to Appeals for settlement consideration.
    No settlement is reached Appeals returns case to Counsel for trial preparation.

  3. Appeals also receives Exempt Organization cases where adverse action is proposed on an organization's exempt status or private foundation classification, and Employee Plans cases involving an employee plan's qualification.

  4. Appeals jurisdiction includes, but is not limited to, cases subject to notice of deficiency procedures or cases involving a tax liability.

  5. In most cases, a preliminary (30 or 60 day) letter is issued to the taxpayer by the Compliance Area Director or Campus Director.

  6. In general, taxpayers request an Appeals conference and, when required, file a protest against the proposed deficiency, overassessment, or determination (See IRM 8.6.1, Conference and Issue Resolution).

8.1.1.3.1  (10-23-2007)
No Appeals Conference or Concession on Certain Arguments

  1. As provided in 26 CFR 601.106(b), Statement of Procedural Rules, the administrative appeal procedures do not extend to cases solely involving the failure or refusal to comply with the tax laws because of moral, religious, political, constitutional, conscientious, or similar grounds. Such arguments are given no weight in settlement.

8.1.1.3.2  (10-23-2007)
"No Immediate Tax Consequence" Cases

  1. Generally, cases considered by Appeals involve a disputed tax liability. However, in some cases there is no tax liability in dispute for the period under consideration. These cases are called "No Immediate Tax Consequence" cases.

  2. Where required by law, IRS policy, regulation, ruling or procedure, Appeals considers cases that do not have an immediate tax consequence. This situation most frequently occurs when adjustments result in a potential deficiency or an overassessment but because of a net operating loss (NOL) carryback, no deficiency or overassessment results; or, adjustments are made to an NOL carryforward and the carryforward year has not been examined. Other examples of cases with no immediate tax consequences are estate tax IRC 6166 cases and employee plans determination cases.

  3. As the Internal Revenue Service’s dispute resolution forum, Appeals grants consideration of these cases when requested by the taxpayer. (Exam IRM provisions discuss the procedures followed in forwarding these cases to Appeals for consideration.)

  4. Taxpayers requesting an Appeals conference under the provisions of this section must file a protest addressing the proposed adjustment. See IRM 8.6.1, Conference and Issue Resolution, for protest requirements.

  5. Once this type case is accepted in Appeals, it can be transferred from one office to another under the provisions of this chapter. Procedures for transferring cases are found in IRM 8.20.6, Appeals Case Processing Manual, Interim Actions - Remittances, Partials, Transfers, and Returns.

  6. If a conference is held on a "no immediate tax consequence" case and a settlement is reached, follow normal closing procedures, including preparing an Appeals Transmittal and Case Memo, Form 5402. Identify the case on Form 5402, item 2 - Special Features, as one involving the settlement of a "no immediate tax consequence" case. When appropriate, secure a closing agreement on all agreed cases. Close agreed cases using closing code 03.

  7. If settlement is not reached, include a statement on Form 5402 stating no agreement was reached. Identify the case as one involving the settlement of a "no immediate tax consequence" case on Form 5402, item 2 - Special Features. Close the case as an unagreed case using closing code 13 (unagreed pre-90).

  8. Policy Statement P-8-3 (formerly P-8-50) governs reopening "no immediate tax consequence" cases.

  9. Send a copy of the Appeals Case Memo (ACM) and closing agreement, if applicable, to the appropriate function in the Area or Campus.

8.1.1.4  (10-23-2007)
Collection Cases under Appeals Jurisdiction

  1. Collection Due Process - The IRS Restructuring and Reform Act of 1998 (RRA 98) gives taxpayers the right to a Collection Due Process (CDP) hearing with Appeals when they receive one of the following notices:

    1. Notice of Federal Tax Lien Filing and Your Right to A Hearing Under IRC 6320,

    2. Final Notice - Notice of Intent to Levy and Notice of Your Right To A Hearing,

    3. Notice of Jeopardy Levy and Right of Appeal,

    4. Notice of Levy on Your State Tax Refund - Notice of Your Right to a Hearing.

  2. IRC 6320 requires the taxpayer be given notice after the filing of a Notice of Federal Tax Lien (NFTL). IRC 6330 requires the taxpayer be given notice of a right to a hearing before taking levy action. The purpose of CDP hearings under IRC 6320 and IRC 6330 is to give the taxpayer an opportunity early in the collection process to work with an independent hearing officer to resolve the collection of the taxpayer's liability. After a CDP hearing and determination by Appeals, taxpayers have the right to challenge Appeals' determination in court.

  3. Equivalent Hearing (EH) - If a taxpayer did not timely request a CDP hearing with Appeals, the taxpayer has the right to request an "Equivalent Hearing" . However, the taxpayer must specifically state he or she wants an Equivalent Hearing. In an Equivalent Hearing, the taxpayer may raise and Appeals will consider all issues raised in CDP, however, the taxpayer does not have the right to seek judicial review of Appeals' decision.

  4. Offer-in-Compromise - An Offer in Compromise (OIC) is an agreement between a taxpayer and the government to settle a tax liability in exchange for payment of less than the full amount owed. Appeals has jurisdiction to make decisions on OIC cases in the following circumstances:

    1. Offers appealed after being rejected by Collection.

    2. Offers based wholly or in part on doubt as to liability after being rejected by Examination, or if the liability was previously determined by Appeals.

    3. Offers submitted directly to Appeals as an alternative to the proposed collection in a CDP or EH case.

    4. Offers being evaluated by Collection when a Notice of Federal Tax Lien is filed and the taxpayer requests a CDP hearing or Equivalent hearing.

  5. Collection Appeal Program - Collection Appeal Program (CAP) is an administrative appeal for certain collection actions. A taxpayer, or a third party whose property is subject to a collection action, may appeal the following actions under CAP:

    1. Levy or seizure action that was or will be taken.

    2. Notice of Federal Tax Lien that was or will be filed.

    3. Filing of a Notice of Federal Tax Lien against an alter-ego or nominee's property.

    4. Denials to issue lien certificates; such as subordination, withdrawal, discharge or non-attachment.

    5. Rejected, proposed for termination or terminated installment agreements.

    6. Disallowance of taxpayer's request to return levied property under IRC 6343(d).

    7. Disallowance of property owner's claim to return property under IRC 6343(b).

    CAP decisions by Appeals are binding on the taxpayers and the Collection functions.

  6. Trust Fund Recovery Penalty - Trust Fund Recovery Penalty (TFRP) is a penalty against any person who willfully fails to collect, account for, and pay over taxes held in trust. The TFRP is imposed for:

    1. Willful failure to collect tax.

    2. Willful failure to account for and pay over tax.

    3. Willful attempt in any manner to evade or defeat tax or the payment thereof.

    TFRP under IRC 6672 is equal to the total amount of tax evaded, not collected, or not accounted and paid for. The Collection function is solely responsible for recommending assertion of the TFRP. Before assessing a TFRP, a 60-day notice of proposed assessment is sent or given to the taxpayers, along with their right to an Appeal. The taxpayer has 60 calendar days to file a timely protest (75 calendar days if the letter is addressed outside of the United States). When the taxpayer files a timely protest, the case is sent to Appeals. Appeals is responsible for determining if the party is willful and responsible for the TFRP. Only Appeals can make the final administrative determination with respect to the taxpayer's protest.

  7. Trust Fund Recovery Penalty Claims - The IRS must provide for an appeal of a Form 843, Claim for Refund and Request for Abatement. When the IRS assesses the TFRP, the taxpayer has a right to pay the appropriate amount of the assessment and file a refund claim with the IRS. If Collection denies the taxpayer's claim, Collection sends the taxpayer a letter notifying them of the 60-day time period to file a timely administrative appeal. If a timely administrative appeal is received, the case is heard in Appeals.

8.1.1.5  (10-23-2007)
Appeals Miscellaneous Responsibilities

  1. Appeals employees perform miscellaneous duties often involving communications with other IRS functions, and outside accounting and/or tax groups. These duties include providing feedback to Compliance, making presentations on Appeals practices and procedures, writing articles for publication, testifying in court cases, and producing records requested by taxpayers.

  2. The following subsections provide specific guidelines to use when performing these miscellaneous duties.

8.1.1.5.1  (10-23-2007)
Feedback Procedures to Collection and Examination

  1. Appeals Field Operations Area Directors often become aware of problem areas and trends through review of work units assigned within their areas. When the need arises, discuss these concerns with Compliance management officials. Quarterly meetings between Appeals and Compliance are encouraged.

  2. By providing meaningful feedback to Compliance functions, Appeals assists local management in their effort to achieve a better work product.

  3. When feedback is warranted, the Appeals Team Manager (ATM) or Appeals Team Case Leader (ATCL) prepares a clear, concise, objective memorandum to the appropriate Compliance function. Favorable comments by memorandum are encouraged.

8.1.1.5.2  (10-23-2007)
Public Speeches and Articles for Publication

  1. To avoid controversy or disclosure, the subject matter of all speeches and articles should be Appeals practices and procedure. As a matter of policy and to avoid disclosure penalties, do not discuss cases.

  2. When the subject of a speech or article is not directly related to Internal Revenue Service or Treasury matters, clearance is not required, provided there is no conflict with the policies of the Internal Revenue Service or Department of Treasury. Further, it must be made clear that the speaker or author does not represent the Internal Revenue Service or Department of Treasury.

  3. Speeches and/or articles must not cover any of the following:

    • pending legislation;

    • specific cases awaiting final disposition by the Service;

    • proposed regulations, procedures and policies which have not been finally and officially announced;

    • legally or administratively restricted information;

  4. Discuss doubtful issues and questions on jurisdiction with your Appeals Public Affairs Specialist.

8.1.1.5.3  (10-23-2007)
Testimony by Appeals Employees in IRS Tax Cases

  1. Internal Revenue Service tax cases are cases referred by or on behalf of the IRS to the Department of Justice or Office of the U.S. Attorney for defense or prosecution or other affirmative action, as well as U.S. Tax Court cases. These cases include, but are not limited to, the following:

    1. criminal tax;

    2. refund litigation;

    3. summons enforcement;

    4. wrongful levies;

    5. foreclosure of tax liens;

    6. bankruptcies;

    7. actions affecting personal rights of employees or former employees of the IRS;

    8. Federal tort claims litigation involving IRS employees;

    9. Freedom of Information and Privacy Act litigation;

    10. TIGTA cases.

  2. Use of an Appeals employee as a Government witness in IRS tax cases to produce documents or testify on matters discussed during the Appeals Conference, or as an expert witness for the Government, is discouraged. The requesting organization must justify the need by stating the special circumstances involved. The request must be submitted to and approved by the appropriate Appeals Area Director. For additional information, see IRM 11.3, Disclosure of Official Information.

  3. Use of an Appeals employee as an expert witness for the Government should be limited to those instances where no other qualified Service employee is available.

8.1.1.5.4  (10-23-2007)
Requests for Appeals to Produce Records

  1. Upon receipt of a request, subpoena, notice, or other order to testify or to produce or disclose Service records in cases other than those specified in the above paragraph, refer to the procedures in IRM 11.3, Disclosure of Official Information and consult with the local Disclosure Officer.

  2. Appeals case memos may also be requested by taxpayers either informally or pursuant to the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA). They are not exempt in their entirety from disclosure. Due to the sensitive nature of these documents, coordinate all taxpayer requests for Appeals case memos with both Area Counsel and the local Disclosure Officer. Refer to IRM 37.1.2, Chief Counsel Directives Manual - Disclosure of Information and IRM 11.3, Disclosure of Official Information, for guidance.

8.1.1.6  (10-23-2007)
Programs of Interest to Appeals

  1. The following chart lists the miscellaneous IRS programs, offices, and IRM references, applicable to the Appeals organization.

    Reference Topic Description
    IRM 1.16.2 Safety & Security-Manager's Security Appeals managers are required to comply with any standards relevant to the operation of an Appeals Office.
    IRM 5.1.3 Potentially Dangerous Taxpayer (PDT) System This system identifies taxpayers who pose a threat to the safety of IRS employees whose official duties may require personal contact with such taxpayers. Appeals employees should refer to the procedures in IRM 5.1.3.
    IRM 5.8 and IRM 5.14 Accounts Receivable Dollar Inventory (ARDI) Appeals is committed to the reduction of the outstanding accounts receivable of the Service. Appeals Officers or Settlement Officers can assist in this reduction by soliciting advance payments, using offer in compromise and installment agreement procedures, and quickly resolving problems with incorrect assessments.
    IRM 11.3 Privacy Act & Disclosure IRC 7213 provides for criminal penalties and IRC 7431 provides for civil damages for unauthorized disclosures of confidential tax information. All personnel should refer to IRM 1.3 for the procedures regarding disclosure of tax returns and returns information under IRC 6103. For additional assistance regarding disclosure matters, consult your Disclosure Officer.
    IRM 13.1 Taxpayer Advocate Service Appeals is an unusual function within the Service. Part of its authority is derived from the Commissioner and another part is derived from the Chief Counsel. Authority on cases that are docketed in the Tax Court comes from the Chief Counsel, while authority on non-docketed cases comes from the Commissioner. TAS involvement is limited to non-docketed cases where Appeals authority is received from the Commissioner. Of course, if there is a problem on a docketed case which could be resolved with TAS assistance, Appeals employees are encouraged to request TAS assistance.
    IRM 13.1.7 Taxpayer Assistance Orders- Limitations As with regular TAS cases, Appeals ATAO/TAO involvement is limited to non-docketed cases, where Appeals authority is received from the Commissioner.
    IRM 25.16 Natural Disasters & Emergencies This IRM sets forth the procedures in designated disaster/emergency areas. Appeals must be sensitive to taxpayer needs in situations that involve natural disasters and/or emergencies.

Exhibit 8.1.1-1  (10-23-2007)
Common Terms Used in Appeals

Generally, definitions of terms used in the IRM are with the material where the term is discussed. Some common terms used in IRM Part 8 are as follows:

Term Definition
90-day letter Term includes the 150-day letter.
Administrative File A file consisting of one or more examined tax returns of a taxpayer, the report of examination, and all papers, correspondence, and other documents relative to the taxpayer's liability for the year or years involved. An administrative file may also consist of collection related documents such as history, correspondence, financial information, and other documents related to collection action taken on the taxpayer and the relevant tax periods.
AO Refers to an Appeals Officer and includes Appeals Officers, Settlement Officers and Collection Resolution Specialists.
APS Refers to Appeals Processing Services, the unit responsible for processing cases in Appeals.
ATCL Refers to Appeals Team Case Leader.
ATS Refers to Appeals Tax Specialist, a campus employee who works campus generated post assessment penalty cases.
Audit Statement A settlement computation which gives effect to the decision of Appeals or Counsel showing proposed adjustments, computation of revised tax liability, and deficiency or overassessment. It concerns examination issues and accompanies Appeals case memos. Referred to as Settlement Computations in IRM Part 8.
EP/EO Refers to Employee Plans and Exempt Organizations, functional units within the Tax Exempt and Government Entities (TE/GE) Operation Division.
IRC Refers to the Internal Revenue Code of 1986.
IRM Refers to the Internal Revenue Manual.
Non-docketed Case A protested case in which the taxpayer has not filed a petition with the United States Tax Court.
Notices of deficiency (90-day letters) References include those issued by the Operating Divisions and Functional Divisions of the Internal Revenue Service.
Pre-90 Day Cases Term includes the pre-150 day cases.
Preliminary Letter 30-day and 60-day letters.
Protest The taxpayer's statement of disagreement with the adjustments proposed by Compliance.
Reference Return Return which is associated with a case solely for the purpose of providing information.
Service Policy IRS policy as expressed in a policy statement approved by the Commissioner.

Exhibit 8.1.1-2  (10-23-2007)
Delegation Orders Applicable to Appeals Function Authority

Delegation Order Subject
4-8* Authority to Issue or Execute Agreement to Rescind Notices of Deficiency
4-19* Authority to Sign the Notice to Partners and Shareholders of the Beginning of an Administrative Proceeding at the Partnership or S Corporation Level With Respect to Partnership and Subchapter S Items
5-1* Authority to Accept, Reject, Return, Terminate or Acknowledge Withdrawals of Offers in Compromise
  8* Authority To Sign Agreements as to Liability for Personal Holding Company Tax
8-2* Appeals Review of Penalty Cases
8-5* Authority to Decide Appeals of Participation Denial and Sanctions in the Internal Revenue Service e-file Program
11-2* Authority to Permit Disclosure of Tax Information and to Permit Testimony or the Production of Documents
 14* Granting Extension of Time for Filing Statements in Accordance with 26 CFR 1.534–2
 35* Agreements as Determinations under Section 1313(a)(4) of the Internal Revenue Code of 1954
 42* Authority to Execute Consents Fixing the Period of Limitations on Assessment or Collection Under Provisions of the 1939 and 1954, and 1986 Internal Revenue Codes
 60* 26 CFR 601.106: Appeals Functions. Settlement of Cases Docketed in the United States Tax Court
 66* Authority of Appeals in Protested and Tax Court Cases
 93* Authority to Consent to a Redetermination of Aggregations by a Taxpayer in the Case of Invalid Basic Aggregations or Invalid Additions
 97* Closing Agreements Concerning Internal Revenue Tax Liability
107* Authority to Determine that Certain "Savings Institutions" do not intend to Avoid Taxes by Paying Dividends or Interest for Periods Representing More than 12 Months
112* Authority to Issue Determination and Revocation Letters, to Allow Amendment of Employee Plans After the Expiration of the Remedial Amendment Period and to Issue Examination Reports Relating to Employee Plans
113* Authority to Issue Exempt Organization Determination Letters
136* Authority to Sign Agreements Under Rev. Proc. 74-6 with Respect to Exercise by Trustee of Administrative and Investment Powers
139* Authority to Extend the Correction Period and the Allowable Distribution Period Relating to Private Foundation and Employee Plans Matters
160* Authority of Appeals in Termination of Income Tax and Jeopardy Assessments
171* Authority of Appeals Under 26 CFR 301.6511 and 26 CFR 301.6532
179* Coordination of Certain Issues Before Approval of Settlement or Other Disposition in Appeals
231* Authority to Abate Interest on Erroneous Refunds under IRC 6404(e)(2)
* As revised and updated.

More Internal Revenue Manual