Accessibility Skip to Top Navigation Skip to Main Content Home  |  Change Text Size  |  Contact IRS  |  About IRS  |  Site Map  |  Español  |  Help  

4.90.4  Penalties

4.90.4.1  (05-31-2006)
Overview

  1. This section provides general information about penalties, preparing an information return penalty package, and backup withholding.

4.90.4.2  (02-01-2008)
Penalty Overview

  1. In the interest of equitable treatment of the taxpayer and effective tax administration, the non-assertion or abatement of civil penalties based on reasonable cause or other relief provisions provided in the IRM must be made in a consistent manner and should conform with the considerations specified in the Internal Revenue Code (IRC), Regulations, Policy Statements, and IRM 20.1, Penalty Handbook.

  2. Penalty Policy Statement 20-1 provides that the IRS administers a penalty system that is designed to:

    1. Enhance voluntary compliance

    2. Promote consistency in the application of penalties compared to similar cases

    3. Promote unbiased analysis of the facts in each case

    4. Promote the proper application of the law to the facts of the case

    5. Approve a reduction of otherwise applicable penalties or penalty waiver for a group or class of taxpayers as part of a Servicewide resolution strategy to encourage efficient and prompt resolution of cases of noncompliant taxpayers

    6. Ensure that penalties are used for their proper purpose and not as bargaining points in developing or processing cases

  3. To ensure consistency, the Service prescribes and uses a single set of guidelines set out within the Penalty Handbook, IRM 20.1, which is to be followed by all operational and processing functions.

  4. Policy Statement 2-4 provides that penalties will not be assessed against Federal agencies; therefore, if errors are found during an examination of a Federal agency, the Specialist should focus attention on assisting in the correction of the errors and gaining future compliance. Strong consideration should also be given to assessing backup withholding (which is not a penalty) when issues arise related to failure to file or furnish Forms 1099.

4.90.4.2.1  (02-01-2008)
Assessment of Penalties

  1. FSLG will only assess penalties during examinations. If delinquent returns are secured during a customer assistance contact or a compliance check, then the Specialist may assist the customer by explaining reasonable cause criteria and assisting with the preparation of explanation for filing a late return.

  2. Reasonable cause must be considered and developed when issues arise during the examination concerning the assessment of penalties. Reasonable cause has replaced due diligence as the standard for abatement of a penalty. Reasonable cause is discussed in depth in IRM 20.1.1.

  3. If the taxpayer provides a valid reasonable cause argument, the Specialist must document his or her position and should not proceed with assessment of the penalty.

  4. If the Specialist determines that reasonable cause does not exist, then he or she should assess the applicable penalties. The Specialist’s consideration of reasonable cause must be fully documented in the case file and a penalty package must be prepared for closure.

  5. The Specialist should also focus on educating the entity about the errors and on gaining future compliance. FSLG maintains an ongoing effort to develop, monitor, and revise programs designed to assist taxpayers in complying with legal requirements, and thus avoid penalties.

4.90.4.2.2  (02-01-2008)
Information Return Penalties

  1. IRC Section 6721 provides for a penalty when an information return or statement is not correctly filed by the due date of the return. Penalties assessed under this section for returns due after 1989 are based on a time-sensitive penalty rate, as follows:

    1. $15 per failure, not to exceed an annual maximum of $75,000 for returns filed correctly within 30 days of the due date

    2. $30 per failure, not to exceed an annual maximum of $150,000 for returns filed correctly after 30 days but on or before August 1

    3. $50 per failure, not to exceed an annual maximum of $250,000 for returns filed after August 1

    4. The correction must be made in the year the information return was required to be filed.

  2. IRC section 6722 provides for a penalty of $50 for each failure, not to exceed $100,000, to timely and correctly furnish payee statements. If the failure is due to intentional disregard, the penalty may be increased to $100 or greater for each failure.

  3. IRC section 6723 provides for a penalty of $50 for each failure, not to exceed $100,000, to comply with other specified information reporting requirements.

  4. IRC section 6724 addresses waiver/definitions and special rules. This section provides that penalties will not be assessed if the taxpayer has "reasonable cause" for failing to comply.

  5. In addition to the information contained in the Penalty Handbook, IRM 4.23.9, Employment Tax Penalty and Fraud Procedures, provides a good explanation of penalties that apply to employment taxes. IRM 4.23.9.12 specifically discusses Information Return Penalties.

  6. See the discussion in IRM 4.23.14 regarding statutes on Information Return Penalties.

4.90.4.2.3  (05-31-2006)
Trust Fund Recovery Penalty

  1. The trust fund recovery penalty may apply when income, social security and Medicare taxes that should have been withheld were not withheld, or were withheld but were not paid over to the IRS. Under this penalty, certain officers or employees of an organization may be held personally liable for the unpaid trust fund taxes (one-half of the social security and Medicare taxes and all the Federal income tax) and are assessed an amount equal to the unpaid taxes. This penalty may be applicable when these unpaid taxes cannot be immediately collected from the organization. The trust fund recovery penalty may be imposed on all persons who are determined to be responsible for collecting, accounting for and paying over these taxes, and who acted willfully in not doing so.

  2. IRM 4.23.9 provides additional information about the trust fund recovery penalty and procedures that the Specialist should follow to make a referral to the Small Business and Self-Employed (SB/SE) operating division collection function when this penalty is applicable.

4.90.4.2.4  (02-01-2008)
Preparer/Promoter Penalties

  1. The return preparer penalty provisions were amended by the Small Business and Work Opportunity Act of 2007. The new law amended several provisions of the Internal Revenue Code to extend the return preparer penalties under IRC 6694 to preparers of all tax returns, including employment tax returns. See Notice 2007-54 for transitional penalty relief provided to employment tax return preparers. See IRM 20.1.6 for information about preparer penalties, preparer penalty cases, and referrals to the Office of Professional Responsibility (OPR).

  2. Procedures related to return preparer/promoter penalties are currently being developed.

4.90.4.3  (05-31-2006)
Compliance and Program Management (CPM) IRP Classification Process

  1. A significant part of FSLG's compliance program is to ensure that government entities comply with wage and information return reporting requirements. This subsection provides information about this compliance program.

4.90.4.3.1  (02-01-2008)
Wage Reporting Compliance Program for Government Entities

  1. Per Section 6051(a) (Receipts for Employees) of the Code and Section 31.6051-1(a) and (b) of the Employment Tax Regulations, employers must furnish the tax return copy and the employee’s copy of Form W-2, Wage and Tax Statement, to employees for remuneration paid during the calendar year. The Form W-2 must show, among other information, the total amount of wages paid subject to withholding of income tax, the total amount of wages paid subject to FICA tax, and the total amounts of income tax and FICA tax deducted and withheld. The deadline for furnishing the forms to each employee, in most cases, is on or before January 31 of the succeeding year. Refer to IRM 4.23.9.12.

  2. In addition, the employer must file a copy of each form, along with the transmittal Form W-3, with the Social Security Administration. Generally, the deadline for this filing is on or before the last day of February following the calendar year for which the payments are made. Refer to IRM 4.23.9.12.

  3. The correct and timely reporting of employment taxes is the key to our voluntary compliance system as well as the cornerstone of the Social Security system. "Employment taxes" include income tax withholding, social security and Medicare taxes under the Federal Insurance Contribution Act, and unemployment taxes under the Federal Unemployment Tax Act (FUTA). Studies also show that the issuance of a Form W-2 greatly increases the likelihood that the income will be reported. Significant benefits can be gained from working with Federal, state, local and quasi-governmental agencies to understand problems and practices unique to governments. Voluntary compliance will usually improve once the customer understands his or her tax obligations.

4.90.4.3.2  (02-01-2008)
Information Return Reporting Compliance Program for Government Entities

  1. Studies conducted by the Internal Revenue Service indicate there is widespread non-compliance by governmental entities that are required to file information returns. Studies also show that the issuance of a Form 1099 greatly increases the likelihood that the income will be reported. In 1996 legislation was passed that required Federal agencies to issue Form 1099-MISC to corporations for services.

  2. When Form 1099 is issued, it is included in the Information Reporting Program (IRP) matching process, thus facilitating verification that the income was reported and identifying taxpayers that fail to file Forms 1040. Information returns are an integral part of ensuring voluntary compliance.

4.90.4.4  (02-01-2008)
Information Return Examinations

  1. CPM may assign "information return examinations" that are limited in scope to a government's compliance with Form W-2 and/or Form 1099 requirements. Information return examinations will involve examination of the taxpayer's records related to compliance with information returns only; Form 941 will not be examined. Issues related to worker classification will not be addressed. (These examinations can be expanded to include Form 941 with managerial approval.)

  2. Information return examinations will be used, for example, when auditing a Federal or state agency that files Forms 1099 and/or W-2, but Form 941 is filed by a common paymaster.

  3. CPM will establish information return examinations on the TE/GE Reporting and Electronic Examination System (TREES) using activity code 520 and Exempt Organization Inventory Control (EOIC) using MFT 99 and activity code 520.

  4. Examination opening procedures apply to information return examinations. However, the Specialist must specify in the opening letter that the scope of the examination will be limited to examination of the information returns, but may be expanded to Form 941 at a later date.

  5. An information return penalty case is prepared for these cases. See IRM 4.90.4.5.

  6. If the taxpayer failed to file Forms 1099 and/or W-2, delinquent returns should be secured and processed following procedures outlined in IRM 4.90.12.11.3.

  7. To close the case, the Specialist will draft a closing letter to share the audit findings. It should also state that the examination was limited to examination of the information returns.

  8. If the examination is expanded to an examination of Forms 941 or 945, then the Specialist will submit Form 5597 to establish the appropriate quarters and notify the taxpayer that Forms 941/945 are under examination and complete the establishment on TREES.

4.90.4.5  (05-31-2006)
Information Return Penalty Case (Civil Penalty Case)

  1. This subsection discusses the computation of information return penalties and the preparation of an information return penalty case, sometimes referred to as a civil penalty case. This procedure applies when a Specialist is auditing Form 941 and determines that information return penalties should be applied, as well as when a Specialist is conducting an information returns examination discussed in IRM 4.90.4.4.

4.90.4.5.1  (02-01-2008)
Computation of Information Return Penalty

  1. To compute the appropriate information return penalty as it relates to IRC section 6721, 6722 or 6723, multiply the number of violations in each penalty category by the dollar amount associated with the appropriate category:

    1. Standard ($50)

    2. Reduced ($15 or $30) IRC section 6721 only, or

    3. Intentional Disregard (see IRM 20.1.7)

    Note:

    Assess only one penalty per return or payee statement. Assess the largest penalty applicable to that return or statement. When appropriate, use the penalty reference number that identifies all violations that apply to the return.

4.90.4.5.2  (02-01-2008)
Information Return Penalty Case Processing Procedures

  1. During an employment tax return examination, as soon as a Specialist determines that information return penalties should be applied, the Specialist must prepare an Information Return Penalty Package. The Specialist will complete the ESTABLISH steps to establish a new activity on TREES using activity code 520 and source code 45 and submit to manager for approval. In addition, the Specialist will prepare Form 5597 to establish the information return penalty case controls on EOIC using source code 45, MFT 99 and activity code 520. It is not controlled on AIMS, only on TREES and EOIC.

  2. The information return penalty case will be entered on ETS using activity code 520. The time spent reviewing books and records to determine whether taxpayers are in compliance with various filing requirements should be charged to the key case. Time spent calculating and preparing the penalty case will be charged to the penalty case.

  3. Instructions on completing and assembling an information return penalty case can be found in IRM 4.23.8.11.

  4. The information return penalty case will be maintained in a separate case file from the related employment tax case file. It will generally be closed concurrently with the employment tax case. The Field Manager (or MA) will close the information return penalty case on the EOIC using disposal code 03 if the penalty is paid and 99 if the penalty has not been paid. On TREES the case be closed using disposal 303 if paid and 801 if the penalty is not paid.

  5. The information return penalty case file will be closed out of the group and submitted to CPM via TREES and an EOIC generated Form 3210, Document Transmittal. CPM will then forward the case to TE/GE closing unit for closure as needed. Information return penalty cases in which no penalties are assessed will be maintained by CPM according to record retention standards.

  6. If there is more than one type of information return, prepare separate transmittals for each type of information return.

  7. Payments of information return penalties that are secured will be processed in the same way as other advance payments. See IRM 4.90.12.11.4. The original Form 3244-A with the payment should be forwarded via a separate Form 3210 for processing. A copy of the Form 3244-A should be included in the case file.

  8. The statute of limitations related to information returns normally ends February 28 rather than April 15. See IRM 4.23.14 and IRM 25.6.10 for discussions regarding statutes on information return penalties.

4.90.4.6  (02-01-2008)
Backup Withholding

  1. IRC Section 3406 requires beginning in 2003, a payer to withhold 28% from reportable payments to recipients if:

    1. The payee fails to furnish a TIN to the payer in the manner required;

    2. The Secretary notifies the payer that the TIN furnished by the payee is incorrect;

    3. There has been a notified payee underreporting, described in IRC 3406(c); or

    4. There has been a payee certification failure, described in IRC 3406(d).

  2. Payers will be held liable for the payment of any backup withholding required to be deducted and withheld under IRC 3406. In rare cases, the Trust Fund Recovery Penalty would apply to backup withholding adjustments. Federal agencies and instrumentalities of the Federal government are not exempt from backup withholding since it is not a penalty.

  3. When a Specialist discovers failures of the backup withholding rules during an examination, he or she should discuss the findings with the customer to encourage self-correction. However, if the entity does not agree to self-correct, the Specialist should consider expanding the scope of the exam. Step by step procedures to assess backup withholding can be found in IRM 4.23.8.13.


More Internal Revenue Manual