FDA/Center for Food Safety and Applied Nutrition
USDA/Food Safety and Inspection Service
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
September 2003


Quantitative Assessment of Relative Risk to Public Health
from Foodborne Listeria monocytogenes
Among Selected Categories of Ready-to-Eat Foods

Table of Contents

Appendix 7: Contamination Data Sets, Part 1

(Also available in PDF)

 



Smoked Seafood Food Category: Contamination Data
ReferenceFoodGeographic Region1CountryPub. Date2Sample Collection3Number of Samples (values in cfu/g units)
Total # of Samples from the reference<0.04is greater than or equal to0.04 >0.01-0.1>0.1-1<0.30.3-<10<10is greater than or equal to10 10-100<2020-100<100>100100-10001E2- 1E4<200200-500200-1000<500>10001E3-1E4>1E41E4-1E5>1E51E5-1E6>1E6
Aguado et al., 2001Salmon, smoked1Spain3R523616                                                
Baek et al., 2000Mussels, frozen & smoked1Korea3R68653                                                
Cortesi et al., 1997Salmon, smoked1Italy2P100808        11                          1          
Cortesi et al., 1997Salmon, smoked1Italy2P65536        2  2        1            1          
Dauphin et al., 2001Coalfish, smoked 1France3P101                                                
Dauphin et al., 2001Salmon, fresh & smoked 1France3P11011                                                
Dauphin et al., 2001Salmon Skin, smoked 1France3P21E4            1                                  
Dauphin et al., 2001Salmon, smoked1France3P21192                                                
Dauphin et al., 2001Tuna, smoked1France3P101                                                
Dillon et al., 1994Fin-fish, hot/cold-smoked1Canada2?25824612                                                
Dominguez et al., 2001Salmon, cold-smoked1Spain3R170132E                  18  18            2          
Eklund et al., 1995Salmon, cold-smoked1USA2P6113E                  48                            
Ericsson et al., 1997Trout, smoked1Sweden2P&R96E                  3                            
Farber, 1991bSalmon, cold-smoked1Canada/etc1P322210                                                
Garland, 1995Salmon, cold-smoked1Australia2P2852841                                                
Guyer and Jemmi, 1990Salmon, cold-smoked1Switzer-land1P64604                                                
Hartemink and Georgsson, 1991Fish, smoked1Iceland1P/R31301                                                
Heinitz and Johnson, 1998Fish, smoked 1USA1P1080929151                                                
Hudson et al., 1992Mussels, smoked1New Zealand1R1495                                                
Hudson et al., 1992 Salmon, smoked1New Zealand1R1248                                                
Inoue et al., 2000Salmon, smoked1Japan3R9287E    4  1                                      
Jemmi, 1990Fin-fish, cold-smoked1Switzer-land1R32428044                                                
Jemmi, 1990Fin-fish, hot-smoked1Switzer-land1R49645244                                                
Jørgensen and Huss, 1998Halibut, cold-smoked1Denmark2P2011E        9                                      
Jørgensen and Huss, 1998Halibut, cold-smoked1Denmark2P208E        6  2        3          1            
Jørgensen and Huss, 1998Salmon, cold-smoked1Denmark2P190126E        53  9        2                        
Jørgensen and Huss, 1998Salmon, cold-smoked1Denmark2P11569E        11  23        10          2            
Jørgensen and Huss, 1998Salmon, cold-smoked1Denmark2P7543E        17  11        2          2            
Hatakka et al., 2001Smoked, cold & vacuum-packed1Finland3R232222E                  10                            
Miettinen, H., et al., 2001Fish, cold-smoked1Finland3P12102                                                
Miettinen, H., et al., 2001Fish, hot-smoked 1Finland3P13121                                                
NFPA, 2002Seafood, smoked1USA-CA3R13631292E445    11  5        4            1      1  
NFPA, 2002Seafood, smoked1USA-MD3R13241281E236    8  3        2                    1  
Ng and Seah, 1995Mussels, smoked1Singapore2R211                                                
Norton et al., 2000Fish, cold-smoked1USA3P38326                                                
Norton et al., 2001Fish, cold-smoked1USA3P968511                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Cod, smoked1USA3R550                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Halibut,smoked1USA3R330                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Oysters, smoked1USA3R220                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Salmon, smoked1USA3R1301291                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Seafood, smoked1USA3R440                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Shad, smoked1USA3R220                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Snapper, smoked1USA3R220                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Sockeye, smoked1USA3R330                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Sturgeon, smoked1USA3R10100                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Trout, smoked1USA3R770                                                
Scoglio et al., 2000Salmon, smoked1Italy3R21183                                                
Teufel and Bendzulla, 1993Fish, smoked1Germany1R?71665                                                
Teufel and Bendzulla, 1993Fish, smoked1Germany1R?309287E                  14    4            4        
Vogel et al., 2001aSalmon, cold-smoked1Denmark3P32423193                                                
Vogel et al., 2001bSalmon, cold-smoked1Denmark3P20065135                                                
Yamazaki et al., 2000Herring, smoked1Japan3R101                                                
Yamazaki et al., 2000Salmon, smoked1Japan3R12102                                                
Total=7855684458967114  129  56    93  424        554    2  
1 Group 1 includes North America including the United States, Canada, Mexico, EU countries, Japan, Australia, New Zealand. Other countries were also included in group 1 on a case-by-case basis if they import the product to the United States. Group 2 includes any country not in group 1.
2 1 = time period pre-1993 to 1993; 2 = time period 1994 to 1998; 3 = time period 1999 to present.
3 R = sample collected at retail; P = sample collected at plant/ manufacturer; ? = location of sample collection unknown.
4 E = samples is greater than or equal to 0.04 cfu/g that were enumerated.


Raw Seafood Food Category: Contamination Data
ReferenceFoodGeographic Region1CountryPub. Date2Sample Collection3Number of Samples (values in cfu/g units)
Total # of Samples from the reference<0.04is greater than or equal to0.04 >0.01-0.1>0.1-1<0.30.3-<10<10is greater than or equal to10 10-100<2020-100<100>100100-10001E2- 1E4<200200-500200-1000<500>10001E3-1E4>1E4 1E4-1E5>1E51E5-1E6>1E6
Adesiyun, 1993Fish & shrimp, raw2Trinidad1R1021002                                                
Anderson and Nørrung, 1995Fish, raw1Denmark2R232199E4        26  6      1                          
Baek et al., 2000Halibut, raw1Korea3R45450                                                
Baek et al., 2000Shellfish1Korea3R2502473                                                
Berry et al., 1994Shrimp, imported & frozen1USA2R30282                                                
Buchanan et al., 1989Catfish, fresh1USA1R110                                                
Buchanan et al., 1989Clam, raw1USA1R110                                                
Buchanan et al., 1989Fin-fish, fresh1USA1R422                                                
Buchanan et al., 1989Oysters, uncooked1USA1R220                                                
Buchanan et al., 1989Scallops, raw1USA1R110                                                
Buchanan et al., 1989Shrimp, raw & frozen1USA1R440                                                
Buchanan et al., 1989 Surimi, crab1USA1R110                                                
Colburn et al., 1990Oysters, live1USA1P35350                                                
Dauphin et al., 2001Fillet, coalfish1France3P202                                                
Dauphin et al., 2001Fillet, cod1France3P404                                                
Dauphin et al., 2001Salmon, cut & raw1France3P101                                                
Dauphin et al., 2001Herring, frozen1France3P 505                                                
Dauphin et al., 2001Surfaces, raw salmon (filets)1France3P817                                                
Dauphin et al., 2001Surfaces, raw salmon (whole)1France3P716                                                
Dauphin et al., 2001Surfaces, raw salmon1France3P18162                                                
Davies et al. 2001Plaice/raw food1Great Britain3R550                                                
Davies et al. 2001Salmon/raw seafood1Great Britain3R550                                                
Davies et al. 2001Sardine/raw seafood1Portugal3R10100                                                
Davies et al. 2001Trout/raw seafood1Great Britain3R20182                                                
Davies et al. 2001Trout/raw seafood1Portugal3R10100                                                
Davies et al. 2001Whiting/raw seafood1France3R26260                                                
de Simon et al., 1992Molluscs, bivalve, mussels1Spain1R40373                                                
Decastelli et al., 1993Mussels, depurated1Italy1P1101100                                                
Decastelli et al., 1993Mussels,1Italy1P1751750                                                
Degnan et al., 1994Meat, blue crab1Australia2R431                                                
Draughon et al., 1999 Trout, rainbow1USA3R7436E              308                              
El-Shenawy and El-Shenawy, 1995Clam, fresh2Egypt2R431                                                
El-Shenawy and El-Shenawy, 1995Coquina, fresh2Egypt2R651                                                
El-Shenawy and El-Shenawy, 1995Crab2Egypt2R550                                                
El-Shenawy and El-Shenawy, 1995Fin-fish, fresh2Egypt2R39345                                                
El-Shenawy and El-Shenawy, 1995Fin-fish, frozen2Egypt2R17161                      &nbs p;                        
El-Shenawy and El-Shenawy, 1995Oysters, raw2Egypt2R220                                                
El-Shenawy and El-Shenawy, 1995Shrimp2Egypt2R541                                                
Farber, 1991bShrimp, retail1Canada1R20164                                                
Farber, 1991bSurimi, etc1Canada1R46451                                                
Ferrer and de Simón, 1993Mussels, fresh1Spain1R35323                                                
Ferrer and de Simón, 1993Oysters, fresh1Spain1R40391                                                
Fuchs and Surendran, 1989Clam, raw1India1R110                                                
Fuchs and Surendran, 1989Fish, fresh2India1R990                                                
Fuchs and Surendran, 1989Fish, frozen2India1R14140                                                
Hartemink and Georgsson, 1991Fish, other1Iceland1P or R541                                                
Hartemink and Georgsson, 1991Trout, fresh1Iceland1P or R220                                                
Heinitz, 1999Fin-fish/shellfish 1USA3P94958791704                                                
Hofer and Ribeiro, 1990Shrimp, frozen1Brazil1P45414                                                
Hudson et al, 1992Ready-to-eat seafood1New Zealand1R503713                                                
Iida et al., 1998Fin-fish & non-fin-fish1Japan2R78177110                                                
Inoue et al., 2000Seafood, raw1Japan3R213206E    112  2      1                          
Jeyasekaran et al., 1996Fin-fish, tropical2India2P or R29245                                                
Jeyasekaran et al., 1996Shellfish, tropical1India2P or R36324                                                
Kamat and Nair, 1994Anchovy2India2R220                                                
Kamat and Nair, 1994Duck-fish, Bombay2India2< /td>R220                                                
Kamat and Nair, 1994Crab1India2R220                                                
Kamat and Nair, 1994Fish, Doma-local2India2R330                                                
Kamat and Nair, 1994Anchovy, Golden2 India2R220                                                
Kamat and Nair, 1994Salmon, Indian2India2R110                                                
Kamat and Nair, 1994Mackeral2India2R330                                                
Kamat and Nair, 1994Pom fret2India2R220                                                
Kamat and Nair, 1994Shrimp, raw1India2R550                                                
Kamat and Nair, 1994Fin, thread2India2R330                                                
Karpiskova et al., 2000Fish, raw1Czech Republic3R1201182                                                
Karunasagar et al., 1992Fish2India1P2002000                                                
Manoj et al., 1991Fin-fish, fresh2India1P or R51510                                                
Manoj et al., 1991Shrimp, raw/process1India1P or R19190                                                
Masuda et al., 1992Fin-fish, fresh1Japan1R3823739                                                
Masuda et al., 1992Shellfish, non-oyster1Japan1R1471452                                                
Masuda et al., 1992Oysters, raw1Japan1R84840                                                
McLauchlin and Gilbert, 1990Fish & fish products1UK 1?462917                                                
Miettinen et al., 2001Fish, raw1Finland3P18162                                                
Miettinen et al., 2001Roe1Finland3P550                                                
Monfort et al., 1998Shellfish1France1P12010911                                      &n bsp;        
Motes, 1991Oysters, live1USA1P75750                                                
Motes, 1991Shrimp, live1USA1P74668                                                
Ng and Seah, 1995Crabmeat/scallops1Singapore2P or R16160                                                
Ng and Seah, 1995Fish cakes, fingers2Singapore2P or R16133                                                
Ng and Seah, 1995Tuna2Singapore2P or R550                                                
Norton et al., 2000Fish, raw1USA3P43403                                                
Norton et al., 2001Fish, raw1USA3P102939                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Butterfish1USA3R660                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Cod1USA3R402218                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Crab1USA3R39337518                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Halibut1USA3R606                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Fillets, ocean cats1USA 3R660                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Perch1USA3R17170                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Seafood, raw1USA3R402812                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Surimi, raw1USA3R321                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Fish, rock1USA3R29227                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Roe1USA3R880                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Sable1USA3R660                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Salmon1USA3R880                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Shrimp1USA3R106997                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Snapper1USA3R12120                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Sole1USA3R543519                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Sushi-with & without rice1USA3R42411                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Fillets, turbot1USA3R660                                                
Pullela et al., 1998Fin-fish, aquaculture1USA1P1401400                                                
Ravomanana et al., 1993Shrimp, raw & fresh1France1R?17152                                                
Rorvik and Yndestad, 1991Fin-fish, minced1Norway1P871                                                
Ryu et al., 1992Fish, other1Japan1R660                                                
Ryu et al., 1992Fish, salt sushi1Japan1R10100                                                
Ryu et al., 1992Fish, sushi1Japan1R18153                                                
Ryu et al., 1992Prawn, raw, 'sushi'1Japan1R38371                                                
Ryu et al., 1992Tuna, minced sushi1Japan1R37343                                                
Scoglio et al., 2000Shellfish, raw1Italy3R23230                                                
Scoglio et al., 2000Shrimp, raw1Italy3R17 170                                                
Soriano et al.,2001Hake, raw1Spain3R440                                                
Soriano et al.,2001Salmon, raw1Spain3R440                                                
Soriano et al.,2001 Sole, raw1Spain3R660                                                
Teufel and Bendzulla, 1993Crustacean/shellfish1Germany1R?3232E                                                
Teufel and Bendzulla, 1993Crustacean/shellfish1Germany1R?80800              &n bsp;                                
Teufel and Bendzulla, 1993Fish & fish parts1Germany1R?3533E                  1    1                      
Teufel and Bendzulla, 1993Fish & fish parts1Germany1R?2382326                                                
Vogel et al., 2001aSalmon, raw1Denmark3P92902                                                
Weagant et al., 1988Fin-fish, frozen1USA1R or P40391                                                
Weagant et al., 1988Lobster tail, frozen1USA1R or P20191                                                
Weagant et al., 1988Oysters, frozen 1USA1R or P10100                                                
Weagant et al., 1988Scallops, frozen1USA1R or P18180                                                
Weagant et al., 1988Shrimp, raw & frozen1USA1R or P706010                                                
Weagant et al., 1988Squid, langostinos, frozen1USA1R or P20200                                                
Weagant et al., 1988Surimi, frozen1USA1R or P664620                                                
Wong et al., 1990Fish & non-fish, local frozen and refrigerated2Taiwan1R57516                                                
Yamazaki et al., 2000Finfish, raw1Japan3R10100                                                
Yamazaki et al., 2000Octopus, raw, squid, trepang1Japan3R770                                                
Yamazaki et al., 2000Salmon, raw1Japan3R12111                                                
Yamazaki et al., 2000Shellfish, raw1Japan3R10100                                                
Yamazaki et al., 2000Shrimp, raw1Japan3R10100                                                
Yamazaki et al., 2000Seafood, surimi and minced1Japan3R10100                                                
Yamazaki et al., 2000Seafood,1Japan3R880                                                
Total=15634145411013    1128  830812  1                      
1 Group 1 includes North America including the United States, Canada, Mexico, EU countries, Japan, Australia, New Zealand. Other countries were also included in group 1 on a case-by-case basis if they import the product to the United States. Group 2 includes any country not in group 1.
2 1 = time period pre-1993 to 1993; 2 = time period 1994 to 1998; 3 = time period 1999 to present.
3 R = sample collected at retail; P = sample collected at plant/ manufacturer; ? = location of sample collection unknown.
4 E = samples is greater than or equal to 0.04 cfu/g that were enumerated.


Preserved Fish Food Category: Contamination Data
ReferenceFoodGeographic Region1CountryPub. Date2Sample Collection3Number of Samples (values in cfu/g units)
Total # of Samples from the reference<0.04is greater than or equal to0.04 >0.01-0.1>0.1-1<0.30.3-<10<10is greater than or equal to10 10-100<2020-100<100>100100-10001E2- 1E4<200200-500200-1000<500>10001E3-1E4>1E4 1E4-1E5>1E51E5-1E6>1E6
Anderson and Nørrung, 1995Fish, preserved1Denmark2R335300E4        18  11      6                          
Baek et al., 2000Dried shrimp, squid & mussels1Korea3R12120                                                
Choi et al.,2001Dried squid & mussels1Korea3R20200                                                
El-Shenawy and El-Shenawy, 1995Fin-fish, smoke & salted2Egypt2R11101                                                
Ericsson et al, 1997Trout, gravad1Sweden2P/R83E                  3  1                      1
Fuchs and Sirvas, 1991Ceviche1Peru1R32293                                                
Fuchs and Surendran, 1989Fish, dried & salted2India1R11110                                                
Hartemink and Georgsson, 1991Gravad1Iceland1P or R23176                                                
Hartemink and Georgsson, 1991Haddock, dried1Iceland1P or R550                                                
Jemmi, 1990Fin-fish, pickled1Switzer-land1R896623                                                
Jorgensen and Huss, 1998Fish, gravad1Denmark2P9168E        5  10        5          3            
Kamat and Nair, 1994Anchovy, dried2India2R330                                                
Kamat and Nair, 1994Anchovy, Golden dried2India2R220                                                
Kamat and Nair, 1994Dried fish "Bombay Duck"2India2R330                                                
Kamat and Nair, 1994Mackeral, dried2India2R220                                                
Kamat and Nair, 1994Shrimp, dried1India2R330                                                
Loncarevic et al, 1996Fish, gravad1Sweden2R584612                                                
Hatakka et al, 2001Fish, cold-salted & vacuum-packed1Finland3R8277E                  5                            
McLauchlin & Gilbert, 1990Cooked fish & fish products1UK1?34633412                                                
Miettinen et al, 2001Fish, cold & salted1Finland3P1082                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Clams, salted1USA3R220                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Salmon, salted1USA3R440                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Anchovies, seasoned1USA3R110                                                
Rorvik and Yndestad, 1991Shrimp, brined1Norway1P16133                                                
Teufel and Bendzulla, 1993Fish, processed1Germany1R?186185E                  1                            
Teufel and Bendzulla, 1993Fish, processed1Germany1R?11910613                                                
Yamazaki et al, 2000Dried squid, salmon, shishamo smelt 1Japan3R440                                                
Yamazaki et al, 2000Seafood, fermented1Japan3R770                                                
Yamazaki et al, 2000Sushi flatfish, fermented1Japan3R101                                                
Yamazaki et al, 2000Salad, marinated seafood1Japan3R880                                                
Yamazaki et al, 2000Sushi sandfish, fermented1Japan3R101                                                
Total=1495134977        23  21    966          3          1
1 Group 1 includes North America including the United States, Canada, Mexico, EU countries, Japan, Australia, New Zealand. Other countries were also included in group 1 on a case-by-case basis if they import the product to the United States. Group 2 includes any country not in group 1.
2 1 = time period pre-1993 to 1993; 2 = time period 1994 to 1998; 3 = time period 1999 to present.
3 R = sample collected at retail; P = sample collected at plant/ manufacturer; ? = location of sample collection unknown.
4 E = samples is greater than or equal to 0.04 cfu/g that were enumerated


Ready-to-eat Crustacean Food Category: Contamination Data
ReferenceFoodGeographic Region1CountryPub. Date2Sample Collection3Number of Samples (values in cfu/g units)
Total # of Samples from the reference<0.04is greater than or equal to0.04 >0.01-0.1>0.1-1<0.30.3-<10<10is greater than or equal to10 10-100<2020-100<100>100100-10001E2- 1E4<200200-500200-1000<500>10001E3-1E4>1E4 1E4-1E5>1E51E5-1E6>1E6
Dauphin et al, 2001Mussels, shelled cooked1France3P202                                                
Degnan et al, 1994Crab1USA2R412            1                                  
Farber, 1991bShrimp, wholesale1Canada1R49451    1  2                                      
Hartemink and Georgsson, 1991Shellfish, cooked1Iceland1P or R11110                                                
Hartemink and Georgsson, 1991Shrimp, cooked & processed1Iceland1P or R11101                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Crab, cooked1USA3R95905                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Shrimp, cooked1USA3R2362342                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Crab, imitation1USA3R24240                                                
Ravomanana et al, 1993Shrimp, cooked1France1R?35314                                                
Rawles et al, 1995Crab1USA2P126116E4        1  8                      1          
Richmond, 1990Miscellany, cooked1UK1R40400                                                
Valdimarsson, et al, 1998Shrimp, cooked & frozen1Iceland2P3331325972                                                
Weagant et al, 1988Crab, cooked1USA1R or P24177                                                
Weagant et al, 1988Shrimp, cooked1USA1R or P862                                                
Yamazaki et al, 2000Seafood, boiled1Japan3R880                                                
Total=4004389298    1  3  9                      1          
1 Group 1 includes North America including the United States, Canada, Mexico, EU countries, Japan, Australia, New Zealand. Other countries were also included in group 1 on a case-by-case basis if they import the product to the United States. Group 2 includes any country not in group 1.
2 1 = time period pre-1993 to 1993; 2 = time period 1994 to 1998; 3 = time period 1999 to present.
3 R = sample collected at retail; P = sample collected at plant/ manufacturer; ? = location of sample collection unknown.
4 E = samples is greater than or equal to 0.04 cfu/g that were enumerated


Vegetables Food Category: Contamination Data
ReferenceFoodGeographic Region1CountryPub. Date2Sample Collection3Number of Samples (values in cfu/g units)
Total # of Samples from the reference<0.04is greater than or equal to0.04 >0.01-0.1>0.1-1<0.30.3-<10<10is greater than or equal to10 10-100<2020-100<100>100100-10001E2- 1E4<200200-500200-1000<500>10001E3-1E4>1E4 1E4-1E5>1E51E5-1E6>1E6
Beckers et al, 1987Vegetables, fresh & cut1Nether-lands1?2514E4                  11                            
Benezet et al., 2001Celery,1Spain3P330                                                
Benezet et al., 2001Cilantro1Spain3P110                                                
Benezet et al., 2001Onion, 1Spain3P330                                                
Benezet et al., 2001Laurel1Spain3P110                                                
Benezet et al., 2001Parsley1Spain3P110                                                
Benezet et al., 2001Thyme1Spain3P110                                                
Benezet et al., 2001Winter sweet1Spain3P220                                                
Breer, 1988Salads1Switzer-land1R64613                                                
Breer, 1988Vegetables1Switzer-land1R27270                                                
Choi et al.,2001Vegetables, raw2Korea3R2052050                                                
Daley et al., 1999Vegetables1Canada3R25250                                                
de Simon et al., 1992Vegetables, fresh1Spain1R103958                                                
Farber et al., 1989Celery1Canada1R30300                                                
Farber et al., 1989Lettuce1Canada1R50500                                                
Farber et al., 1989Radishes1Canada1R10100                                                
Farber et al., 1989Tomatoes1Canada1R20200                                                
Garcia-Gimeno et al., 1996Salads1Spain2P704921                                                
Hartung, 2000bSalads, minimally processed fresh vegetables1Germany3R59581                                                
Hartung, 2001 Vegetable foods, other1Germany3R?6766715                                                
Hartung, 2001Vegetable foods, other1Germany3R?672667E                  5                            
Hartung, 1999Salad 1Germany3R23203                                                
Heinitz, 1999Salads, vegetable1USA3P36134120                                                
Heisick et al., 1989Cabbage1USA1R92911                                                
Heisick et al., 1989Cucumbers1USA1R92902                                                
Heisick et al., 1989Lettuce1USA1R92920                                                
Heisick et al., 1989Mushrooms1USA1R92920                                                
Heisick et al., 1989Radishes1USA1R13211319                                                
Inoue et al., 2000Vegetables1Japan3R2852850                                                
Karpiskova et al., 2000Vegetables1Czech Republic3R1561524                                                
Lin et al., 1996Salads, vegetable1USA2R58571                                                
Marranzano et al., 1996Celery1Italy2R20182                                                
Marranzano et al., 1996Fennel1Italy2R31301                                                
Marranzano et al., 1996Lettuce1Italy2R32311                                                
McLauchlin and Gilbert, 1990Vegetables & salads, 1UK 1?56749569                                    3          
McLauchlin and Gilbert, 1990Vegetables & salads, 1UK 1?27925524                                                
Monge and Arias, 1996Cabbage salad1Costa Rica2R504010                                                
NFPA, 2002Salad, leafy bagged & precut 1USA-CA3R15151501E121        1                                  
NFPA, 2002Salad, leafy bagged & precut 1USA-MD3R14481440E5      1  1        1                        
Odumeru et al., 1997Broccoli florets1Canada2P1513E                    2                          
Odumeru et al., 1997Broccoli florets1Canada2P2020E                                                
Odumeru et al., 1997Coleslawmix1Canada2P1514E                    1                          
Odumeru et al., 1997Coleslawmix1Canada2P2020E                                                
Odumeru et al., 1997Green peppers1Canada2P2020E                                                
Odumeru et al., 1997Green peppers1Canada2P1514E                  1                            
Odumeru et al., 1997Lettuce, chopped1Canada2P2422E                  2                            
Odumeru et al., 1997Lettuce, chopped1Canada2P1512E                  21                          
Odumeru et al., 1997Salad mix1Canada2P159E                  24                          
Odumeru et al., 1997Salad mix1Canada2P2421E                  21                          
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Broccoli1USA3R330                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Cabbage1USA3R220                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Celery1USA3R220                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Cilentro1USA3R110                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Green Beans1USA3R110                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Jalapeno1USA3R110                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Kelp1USA3R11101                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Kidney, Mung. Bean1USA3R33330                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Lettuce1USA3R15150                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Salad, mixed vegetable1USA3R49472                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Mushroom1USA3R660                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Onion 1USA3R660                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Pea1USA3R660                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Potato1USA3R14140                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Radish1USA3R550                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Spinach1USA3R321                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Sprouts1USA3R1091090                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Tomato1USA3R550                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Vegetable1USA3R12120                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Yam1USA3R220                                                
Pingulkar et al., 2001Root, beet2India3R440                                                
Pingulkar et al., 2001Cabbage2India3R431                                                
Pingulkar et al., 2001Carrot2India3R440                                                
Pingulkar et al., 2001Coriander1India3R1091                                                
Pingulkar et al., 2001Cucumber2India3R440                                                
Pingulkar et al., 2001Lettuce2India3R440                                                
Pingulkar et al., 2001Leaves, math vegetable2India3R440                                                
Pingulkar et al., 2001Roots, math2India3R440                                                
Pingulkar et al., 2001Leaves, radish2India3R440                                                
Pingulkar et al., 2001Roots, radish2India3R440                                                
Pingulkar et al., 2001Salads, ready-to-eat 2India3R12120                                                
Pingulkar et al., 2001Capsicum2India3R431                                                
Porto et al., 2001Cabbage2Brazil3R50500                                                
Porto et al., 2001Lettuce2Brazil3R100962      2                                        
Porto et al., 2001Parsley1Brazil3R50482                                                
Porto et al., 2001Watercress1Brazil3R50482                                                
Salamah, 1993Cabbage2Saudi Arabia1R70682                                                
Salamah, 1993Carrot2Saudi Arabia1R12010416                                                
Salamah, 1993Cucumber2Saudi Arabia1R1101064                                                
Salamah, 1993Lettuce2Saudi Arabia1R80791                                                
Sizmur and Walker, 1988Vegetables, mixed1UK1R60564                                                
Soriano et al.,2001Lettuce1Spain3R1091                                                
Soriano et al.,2001Lettuce, 1Spain3R1091                                                
Soriano et al.,2001Spinach1Spain3R10100                                                
Soriano et al.,2001Spinach 1Spain3R10100                                                
Szabo et al.,2000Lettuce1Australia3R60591                                                
Szabo et al.,2000Lettuce1Australia3P60582                                                
Teufel and Bendzulla, 1993Legumes1Germany1R?13121                                                
Teufel and Bendzulla, 1993Mushrooms1Germany1R?880                                                
Teufel and Bendzulla, 1993Vegetables, fresh1Germany1R?660                                                
Velani and Roberts, 1991Individual salad ingredients (bean sprouts, cabbage, carrot, celery, cress, cucumber, lettuce, mushroom, peppers, radish, spring onions, tomato, vegetables, watercress)1UK1R108106E                          2                    
Velani and Roberts, 1991Salads, mixed & prepacked1UK1R4234E                          8                    
West and North Yorkshire Joint Working Group, 1991Salad, raw vegetables1UK1R2372242              53    2          1            
Wong et al., 1990Vegetables2Taiwan1R49436                                                
Total=92238892249171  21  2532593  10      13          
1 Group 1 includes North America including the United States, Canada, Mexico, EU countries, Japan, Australia, New Zealand. Other countries were also included in group 1 on a case-by-case basis if they import the product to the United States. Group 2 includes any country not in group 1.
2 1 = time period pre-1993 to 1993; 2 = time period 1994 to 1998; 3 = time period 1999 to present.
3 R = sample collected at retail; P = sample collected at plant/ manufacturer; ? = location of sample collection unknown.
4 E = samples is greater than or equal to 0.04 cfu/g that were enumerated


Fruit Food Category: Contamination Data
ReferenceFoodGeographic Region1CountryPub. Date2Sample Collection3Number of Samples (values in cfu/g units)
Total # of Samples from the reference<0.04is greater than or equal to0.04 >0.01-0.1>0.1-1<0.30.3-<10<10is greater than or equal to10 10-100<2020-100<100>100100-10001E2- 1E4<200200-500200-1000<500>10001E3-1E4>1E4 1E4-1E5>1E51E5-1E6>1E6
Heinitz, 1999Fruit products1USA3P1178928                                                
Karpiskova et al., 2000Fruit, dried1Czech Republic3R12120                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Apples1USA3R12120                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Blueberries1USA3R642                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Cantalope1USA3R880                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Salad, fruit1USA3R23230                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Fruit, various1USA3R17170                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Gelatin dessert with fruit1USA3R220                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Melons1USA3R880                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Pears1USA3R35350                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Pineapples1USA3R220                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Watermelons1USA3R440                                                
Teufel and Bendzulla, 1993Fruit, fresh1Germany1R?770                                                
Teufel and Bendzulla, 1993Fruit, product1Germany1R?110                                                
Total=25422430                                                
1 Group 1 includes North America including the United States, Canada, Mexico, EU countries, Japan, Australia, New Zealand. Other countries were also included in group 1 on a case-by-case basis if they import the product to the United States. Group 2 includes any country not in group 1.
2 1 = time period pre-1993 to 1993; 2 = time period 1994 to 1998; 3 = time period 1999 to present.
3 R = sample collected at retail; P = sample collected at plant/ manufacturer; ? = location of sample collection unknown.


Fresh Soft Cheese Food Category: Contamination Data
ReferenceFoodGeographic Region1CountryPub. Date2Sample Collection3Number of Samples (values in cfu/g units)
Total # of Samples from the reference<0.04is greater than or equal to0.04 >0.01-0.1>0.1-1<0.30.3-<10<10is greater than or equal to10 10-100<2020-100<100>100100-10001E2- 1E4<200200-500200-1000<500>10001E3-1E4>1E4 1E4-1E5>1E51E5-1E6>1E6
Frye, 2000Queso Fresco1USA3R1724167846                                                
Frye, 2000Queso Fresco1USA3R22202                                                
Gelosa, 1990Cheese, fresh (fornaggio fresco)1Italy1R17170                                                
NFPA, 2002Cheese, Hispanic style1USA-CA3R14821481E4            1                                  
NFPA, 2002Cheese, Hispanic style1USA-MD3R14541450E2          2                                  
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Queso Fresco1USA3R13112                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Panela1USA3R110                                                
Saltijeral et al., 1999Panellá1Mexico3R40346                                                
Ubach et al., 1991Quesofresco, requesoy1Spain1R?91847                                                
Weber et al., 1988Cheese, fresh cow & goat milk1Germany1?22202                                                
Total=48664796652          3                                  
1 Group 1 includes North America including the United States, Canada, Mexico, EU countries, Japan, Australia, New Zealand. Other countries were also included in group 1 on a case-by-case basis if they import the product to the United States. Group 2 includes any country not in group 1.
2 1 = time period pre-1993 to 1993; 2 = time period 1994 to 1998; 3 = time period 1999 to present.
3 R = sample collected at retail; P = sample collected at plant/ manufacturer; ? = location of sample collection unknown.
4 E = samples is greater than or equal to 0.04 cfu/g that were enumerated


Soft Unripened Cheese Food Category: Contamination Data
ReferenceFoodGeographic Region1CountryPub. Date2Sample Collection3Number of Samples (values in cfu/g units)
Total # of Samples from the reference<0.04is greater than or equal to0.04 >0.01-0.1>0.1-1<0.30.3-<10<10is greater than or equal to10 10-100<2020-100<100>100100-10001E2- 1E4<200200-500200-1000<500>10001E3-1E4>1E4 1E4-1E5>1E51E5-1E6>1E6
Copes et al., 2000Cheeses, soft paste2Argentina3R35314                                                
Frye, 2000 Cheese, farmer1USA3R18180                                                
Frye, 2000Gournay1USA3R110                                                
Frye, 2000Cheese, fresh port1USA3R84831                                                
Frye, 2000Quark1USA3R110                                                
Frye, 2000Cheese, sheep milk 1USA3R110                                                
Greenwood et al., 1991Cheese, unripened1UK1R366362E4                                4              
McLauchlin and Gilbert, 1990Cheese, cottage1UK 1?1371370                                                
McLauchlin et al., 1990Anari1UK1R/P239E        10                                    4
McLauchlin et al., 1990Halloumi1UK1R/P113E        8                                      
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Cheese, cottage1USA3R12120                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Cheese, cream1USA3R550                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Creme Mexicana1USA3R440                                                
Teufel and Bendzulla, 1993Spieisequark1Germany1R2221E                  1                            
Teufel and Bendzulla, 1993Spieisequark-quargel1Germany1R20200                                                
West and North Yorkshire Joint Working Group, 1991Cheese, cottage1UK1R74740                                                
Total=8147825        18        1            4            4
1 Group 1 includes North America including the United States, Canada, Mexico, EU countries, Japan, Australia, New Zealand. Other countries were also included in group 1 on a case-by-case basis if they import the product to the United States. Group 2 includes any country not in group 1.
2 1 = time period pre-1993 to 1993; 2 = time period 1994 to 1998; 3 = time period 1999 to present.
3 R = sample collected at retail; P = sample collected at plant/ manufacturer; ? = location of sample collection unknown.
4 E = samples is greater than or equal to 0.04 cfu/g that were enumerated


Soft Ripened Cheese Food Category: Contamination Data
ReferenceFoodGeographic Region1CountryPub. Date2Sample Collection3Number of Samples (values in cfu/g units)
Total # of Samples from the reference<0.04is greater than or equal to0.04 >0.01-0.1>0.1-1<0.30.3-<10<10is greater than or equal to10 10-100<2020-100<100>100100-10001E2- 1E4<200200-500200-1000<500>10001E3-1E4>1E4 1E4-1E5>1E51E5-1E6>1E6
Beckers et al, 1987Brie/ Camembert (from pasteurized milk)1Nether-lands1?51510                                                
Beckers et al, 1987Brie/ Camembert (from raw milk)1Nether-lands1?1880                                  10            
Botarelli et al., 1999Feta/cheese, soft & short-ripened1Italy3R15150                                                
Botarelli et al., 1999Brie/cheese, soft & short-ripened1Italy3R15150                                                
Botarelli et al., 1999Crescenza/ cheese, soft & short-ripened1Italy3R15150                                                
Botarelli et al., 1999Taleggio/ cheese, soft, short-ripened1Italy3R15150                                                
Breer and Schopfer, 1989Cheese, white mold1Switzer-land1?2612547                                                
Delgado da Silva et al., 1998Minas frescal chomemadel, Brazilian soft cheese eaten fresh2Brazil2R17107                                                
Frye, 2000Cheese, feta1USA3R34340                                                
Frye, 2000Brie1USA3R20200                                                
Frye, 2000Camambert1USA3R12120                                                
Frye, 2000Mozzarella1USA3R17170                                                
Hartung, 2000a. soft, mold-ripened cheese 1Germany3R2342304                                                
Hartung, 2001soft, mold-ripened cheese 1Germany3?62593                                                
Hartung, 2001soft, mold-ripened cheese 1Germany3?4139E4                  1                  1        
Hartung, 1999soft, mold-ripened cheese 1Germany3R82748                                                
Loncarevic et al., 1995soft, mold-ripened cheese 1Europe Sweden2R3118E                  9  1            2      1  
McLauchlin et al., 1990Feta1UK1R330                                                
NFPA, 2002Cheese, soft mold ripened1USA3R13471333E12      2                                      
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Cheese, Camembert1USA3R110                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Cheese, pyramid goat1USA3R10100                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Cheese, feta goat1USA3R990                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Mozzarella1USA3R220                                                
Pinto and Reali, 1996Taleggio1Italy2R45450                                                
Pinto and Reali, 1996Mozzarella1UK 2R29254                                                
Rudolf et al., 2001Cheese, soft1Europe3P or R19218012                                                
Sanchez-Rey et al., 1993La Serena cheese, from raw ewes milk1Spain1P15105                                                
Teufel and Bendzulla, 1993Hartz mountain cheese Harzerkase1Germany1R1919E                                                
Teufel and Bendzulla, 1993Hartz mountain cheese Harzerkase1Germany1R?19145                                                
Teufel and Bendzulla, 1993Cheese, Sauermulchkase-sour milk hand1Germany1R53485                                                
Teufel and Bendzulla, 1993Cheese, Sauermulchkase-sour milk hand1Germany1R6964E                  2    3                      
Teufel and Bendzulla, 1993Romadur1Germany1R2318E                  5                            
Weber et al., 1988Cheese, soft1Germany1?22220                                                
Weber et al., 1988Cheese, soft cow1Germany1?3072998                                                
Weber et al., 1988Cheese, soft goat & sheep1Germany1?440                                                
Total=310929926812      2        17  13        1021    1  
1 Group 1 includes North America including the United States, Canada, Mexico, EU countries, Japan, Australia, New Zealand. Other countries were also included in group 1 on a case-by-case basis if they import the product to the United States. Group 2 includes any country not in group 1.
2 1 = time period pre-1993 to 1993; 2 = time period 1994 to 1998; 3 = time period 1999 to present.
3 R = sample collected at retail; P = sample collected at plant/ manufacturer; ? = location of sample collection unknown.
4 E = samples is greater than or equal to 0.04 cfu/g that were enumerated


Semi-Soft Cheese Food Category: Contamination Data
ReferenceFoodGeographic Region1CountryPub. Date2Sample Collection3Number of Samples (values in cfu/g units)
Total # of Samples from the reference<0.04is greater than or equal to0.04 >0.01-0.1>0.1-1<0.30.3-<10<10is greater than or equal to10 10-100<2020-100<100>100100-10001E2- 1E4<200200-500200-1000<500>10001E3-1E4>1E4 1E4-1E5>1E51E5-1E6>1E6
Botarelli et al., 1999Gorgonzola/ cheese1Italy3R4038E4                            2                  
Breer and Schopfer, 1989Cheese, semi-soft1Switzer-land1?2052014                                                
de Boer and Kuik, 1987 Cheese, blue-veined1Nether-lands1R20182                                                
Frye, 2000Cheese, blue1USA3R22220                                                
Frye, 2000Butter cheese1USA3R110                                                
Frye, 2000Gorgonzola1USA3R220                                                
Frye, 2000Cheese, Gouda1USA3R39390                                                
Frye, 2000Cheese, Gouda1USA3R110                                                
Frye, 2000Havarti1USA3R440                                                
Frye, 2000Cheese, Jack1USA3R220                                                
Frye, 2000Limburger1USA3R770                                                
Frye, 2000Pinna Ricotta1USA3R523                                                
Frye, 2000Roquefort1USA3R220                                                
Frye, 2000Cheese, semi-soft1USA3R1351350                                                
Frye, 2000Cheese, semi-soft1USA3R660                                                
Frye, 2000Cheese, string1USA3R440                                                
NFPA, 2001Cheese, blue-veined soft1USA3R16231600E183    1  1                                  
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Cheese, blue1USA3R21210                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Cheese, Monterey Jack1USA3R54540                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Muenster1USA3R110                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Cheese, semi-soft goat1USA3R660                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Cheese, string1USA3R220                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Cheese, Swiss 1USA3R12120                                                
Pinto and Reali, 1996Gorgonzola1UK 2R58553                                                
Rudolf and Scherer, 2001Cheese, semi-soft1Europe3P or R92857                                                
Saltijeral et al., 1999Manchego1Mexico3R40400                                                
Teufel and Bendzulla, 1993Edam1Germany1R31E                  2                            
Teufel and Bendzulla, 1993Edam1Germany1R990                                                
Teufel and Bendzulla, 1993Limburger1Germany1R2119E                  1    1                      
Teufel and Bendzulla, 1993Limburger1Germany1R110                                                
Teufel and Bendzulla, 1993Muenster1Germany1R505                                                
Teufel and Bendzulla, 1993Muenster1Germany1R80E                  1    6            1        
Teufel and Bendzulla, 1993Stangenkase, Limburger type1Germany1R330                                                
Teufel and Bendzulla, 1993Stangenkase, Limburger type1Germany1R1110E                        1                      
Weber et al., 1988Cheese, semi-soft1Germany1?14412519                                                
Weber et al., 1988Cheese, sheep semi-soft1Germany1?660                                                
Total=2615253443183    1  1    4    8  2        1        
1 Group 1 includes North America including the United States, Canada, Mexico, EU countries, Japan, Australia, New Zealand. Other countries were also included in group 1 on a case-by-case basis if they import the product to the United States. Group 2 includes any country not in group 1.
2 1 = time period pre-1993 to 1993; 2 = time period 1994 to 1998; 3 = time period 1999 to present.
3 R = sample collected at retail; P = sample collected at plant/ manufacturer; ? = location of sample collection unknown.
4 E = samples is greater than or equal to 0.04 cfu/g that were enumerated


Hard Cheese Food Category: Contamination Data
ReferenceFoodGeographic Region1CountryPub. Date2Sample Collection3Number of Samples (values in cfu/g units)
Total # of Samples from the reference<0.04is greater than or equal to0.04 >0.01-0.1>0.1-1<0.30.3-<10<10is greater than or equal to10 10-100<2020-100<100>100100-10001E2- 1E4<200200-500200-1000<500>10001E3-1E4>1E4 1E4-1E5>1E51E5-1E6>1E6
Breer and Schopfer, 1989Cheese, hardHartkase1Switzerland1?88880                                                
Delgado da Silva et al., 1998Cheese, Cheddar2Brazil2R220                                                
Frye, 2000Cacique Asadero1USA3R110                                                
Frye, 2000Cheese, Colby Jack semi-soft1USA3R110                                                
Frye, 2000Cheese, Parmesan1USA3R220                                                
Frye, 2000Cheese, Provolone1USA3R110                                                
Frye, 2000Queso Anejo1USA3R110                                                
Greenwood et al., 1991Cheese, hard1UK1R6665E4                                1              
Lanciotti et al., 1999Cheese, hard ripened1Italy3P45450                                                
McLauchlin and Gilbert, 1990Cheese, hard1UK 1?4484426                                                
McLauchlin et al., 1990Cheese, Cheddar goat1UK1R/P84E        2                                  11
McLauchlin et al., 1990Gjestost1UK1R10E        1                                      
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Cheese, Cheddar1USA3R65650                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Cheese, Cheddar 1USA3R19190                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Cheese, Colby Jack 1USA3R990                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Cheese, hard1USA3R48480                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Quesco Cotija1USA3R550                                                
Rudolf and Scherer, 2001Cheese, hard1Europe3P or R45432                                                
Saltijeral et al., 1999Chihuahua1Mexico3R40400                                                
Weber et al., 1988Cheese, hard1Germany1?440                                                
West and North Yorkshire Joint Working Group, 1991Cheese, hard1UK1R74740                                                
Total=9739598        3                      1          11
1 Group 1 includes North America including the United States, Canada, Mexico, EU countries, Japan, Australia, New Zealand. Other countries were also included in group 1 on a case-by-case basis if they import the product to the United States. Group 2 includes any country not in group 1.
2 1 = time period pre-1993 to 1993; 2 = time period 1994 to 1998; 3 = time period 1999 to present.
3 R = sample collected at retail; P = sample collected at plant/ manufacturer; ? = location of sample collection unknown.
4 E = samples is greater than or equal to 0.04 cfu/g that were enumerated


Processed Cheese Food Category: Contamination Data
ReferenceFoodGeographic Region1CountryPub. Date2Sample Collection3Number of Samples (values in cfu/g units)
Total # of Samples from the reference<0.04is greater than or equal to0.04 >0.01-0.1>0.1-1<0.30.3-<10<10is greater than or equal to10 10-100<2020-100<100>100100-10001E2- 1E4<200200-500200-1000<500>10001E3-1E4>1E4 1E4-1E5>1E51E5-1E6>1E6
Baek et al., 2000Cheese, pasturized & processed2Korea3R45450                                                
Ng and Seah, 1995Cheese & spreads2Singapore2P/R1031030                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Cheese, processed1USA3R440                                                
Teufel and Bendzulla, 1993Cheese, Schnittkase-sliced1Germany1R96951                                                
Teufel and Bendzulla, 1993Cheese, Schnittkase-sliced1Germany1R7775E4                  2                            
Total=3253221                  2                            
1 Group 1 includes North America including the United States, Canada, Mexico, EU countries, Japan, Australia, New Zealand. Other countries were also included in group 1 on a case-by-case basis if they import the product to the United States. Group 2 includes any country not in group 1.
2 1 = time period pre-1993 to 1993; 2 = time period 1994 to 1998; 3 = time period 1999 to present.
3 R = sample collected at retail; P = sample collected at plant/ manufacturer; ? = location of sample collection unknown.
4 E = samples is greater than or equal to 0.04 cfu/g that were enumerated


Pasteurized Milk Food Category: Contamination Data
ReferenceFoodGeographic Region1CountryPub. Date2Sample Collection3Number of Samples (values in cfu/g units)
Total # of Samples from the reference<0.04is greater than or equal to0.04 >0.01-0.1>0.1-1<0.30.3-<10<10is greater than or equal to10 10-100<2020-100<100>100100-10001E2- 1E4<200200-500200-1000<500>10001E3-1E4>1E4 1E4-1E5>1E51E5-1E6>1E6
Ahrabi et al., 1997Milk, cow's2Turkey2R20191                                                
Arnold and Coble, 1995Milk, cow's1Australia2R33330                                                
Baek et al., 2000Milk, pasteurized2Korea3R26260                                                
Beckers et al, 1987Milk, cow's1Nether-lands1?41410                                                
Casarotti et al., 1994Milk, cow's2Brazil2R20200                                                
Farber et al., 1989Milk, cow's1Canada1R14140                                                
Fernandez Garayzabal et al., 1986Milk, cow's1Spain1P28226                                                
Gelosa, 1990 Milk, cow's1Italy1R770                                                
Gohil et al., 1995Milk, cow's2UA Emirates2R1821820                                                
Greenaway and Drew, 1990 Milk, cow's1Australia1P77770                                                
Greenwood et al., 1991Milk, cow's1UK1R1039102811                                                
Hartung, M. 2000bMilk, pasteurized1Germany3R6516510                                                
Hartung, 2001Milk, pasteurized1Germany3R14521451E4                  1                            
Hartung, M., 1999Milk, UHT 1Germany3R28280                                                
Hartung, M., 1999Pasteurized milk 1Germany3R6906900                                                
Harvey and Gilmour, 1992Milk, cow's1Northern Ireland1  95941                                                
Ibrahim et al., 1992Milk, cow's1Hungary1R1001000                                                
Ibrahim et al., 1992Milk, cow's1Hungary1R60537                                                
Frye/IDFA, 2000bMilk, cow's whole1USA3R189718970                                                
Frye/IDFA,2000bMilk, cow's skim1USA3R184618451                                                
Frye/IDFA, 2000bMilk, cow's Chocolate1USA3R166916690                                                
Frey/IDFA, 2000bMilk, cow's reduced fat1USA3R1071070                                                
Frye/IDFA, 2000bMilk, cow's 1USA3R2852850                                                
Kozak et al., 1996Milk, chocolate1USA1P 4154105                                                
Kozak et al., 1996Milk, lowfat1USA1P 2822820                                                
Kozak et al., 1996Milk, skim1USA1P 98980                                                
Kozak et al., 1996Milk, whole1USA1P 3503482                                                
Laciar et al., 1999 Milk, cow's2Argentina3P80800                                                
McLaughlin and Gilbert, 1990Milk, cow's1UK 1?4694690                                                
Mickova, 1991Milk, cow's1Czecho-slovakia1P30300                                                
Moura et al., 1993Milk, cow's2Brazil1P2202200                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Milk, chocolate1USA3R770                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Milk, cow's1USA3R39390                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Milk, goat's1USA3R110                                                
Rola, 1994 Milk, cow's1Poland1?73730                                                
Roy, 1992Milk, cow's1Scotland1?1151114                                                
Sharif and Tunail, 1991 Milk, cow's2Turkey1R22220                                                
Teufel and Bendzulla, 1993Milk, cow's1Germany1R?4434421                                                
Teufel and Bendzulla, 1993Milk, treated1Germany1R?4139E                  2                            
Tiscione et al., 1994Milk, cow's1Italy2P50500                                                
Venables, 1989 Milk, cow's1Australia1P2062051                                                
West and North Yorkshire Joint Working Group, 1991Milk, cow's1UK1R6665E              1                                
Total=124071236340              1  3                            
1 Group 1 includes North America including the United States, Canada, Mexico, EU countries, Japan, Australia, New Zealand. Other countries were also included in group 1 on a case-by-case basis if they import the product to the United States. Group 2 includes any country not in group 1.
2 1 = time period pre-1993 to 1993; 2 = time period 1994 to 1998; 3 = time period 1999 to present.
3 R = sample collected at retail; P = sample collected at plant/ manufacturer; ? = location of sample collection unknown.
4 E = samples is greater than or equal to 0.04 cfu/g that were enumerated


Non-pasteurized Milk Food Category: Contamination Data
ReferenceFoodGeographic Region1CountryPub. Date2Sample Collection3Number of Samples (values in cfu/g units)
Total # of Samples from the reference<0.04is greater than or equal to0.04 >0.01-0.1>0.1-1<0.30.3-<10<10is greater than or equal to10 10-100<2020-100<100>100100-10001E2- 1E4<200200-500200-1000<500>10001E3-1E4>1E4 1E4-1E5>1E51E5-1E6>1E6
Abou-Eleinin et al., 2000Milk, raw goat1USA3P45043317                                                
Anonymous, 1989Cows' milk1France1?1409132485                                                
Arias et al., 1994Cows' milk2Costa Rica2P2202200                                                
Baek et al., 2000Milk, raw2Korea3R45432                                                
Beckers et al., 1987Cows' milk1Nether-lands1?137131E4                  6                            
Casarotti et al., 1994Cows' milk2Brazil2R20200                                                
Davidson et al., 1989Cows' milk1Canada1P2562524                                                
Desmasures et al., 1997Cows' milk1France2P69654                                                
Dominguez Rodrigues et al., 1985Cows' milk1Spain1P955243                                                
Donnelly et al., 1988Cows' milk1USA1P93992415                                                
Doyle and Schoeni, 1986Cows' milk1USA1P50500                                                
El Marrakchi et al., 1993Cows' milk2Morocco1R30273                                                
El-Leboudy and Fayad, 1992 Cows' milk2Egypt1P2362297                                                
Farber et al., 1988 Cows' milk1Canada1P4454396                                                
Fedio and Jackson, 1990Cows' milk1Canada1P36351                                                
Fedio and Jackson, 1990Cows' milk1Canada1P36324                                                
Fedio and Jackson, 1990Cows' milk1Canada1P4264188                                                
Fenlon and Wilson, 1989Cows' milk1Scotland1P 54052614                                                
Fenlon et al., 1995Cows' milk1Scotland2P 72763844        32  13                                  
Fernandez Garayzabul et al., 1987Cows' milk1Spain1P673730                                                
Frye/IDFA, 2000Milk, raw goat1USA3R65641                                                
Frye/IDFA, 2000Milk, raw1USA3R1941931                                                
Gledel, 1986Milk, cow's1France1?514110                                                
Gledel, 1986 Milk, cow's1France1?33732314                                                
Greenwood et al., 1991 Milk, cow's1UK1P36134813                                                
Hartung, 2000a. Raw milk for sale (raw milk off farm) 1Germany3R1871843                                                
Hartung, 2000a. Milk, untreated (bulk raw milk)1Germany3R9649559                                                
Hartung, 2000a. Milk, certified raw1Germany3R4154150                                                
Hartung, 1999Raw milk for sale (raw milk off farm) 1Germany3R1661651                                                
Hartung, 1999Milk, untreated (bulk raw milk)1Germany3R1273126310                                                
Hartung, 1999Milk, certified & raw1Germany3R4394390                                                
Harvey and Gilmour, 1992Milk, cow's1N. Ireland1P17614927                                                
Laciar et al., 1999 Milk, cow's2Argentina3P?2082071                                                
Liewen and Plautz, 1988Milk, cow's1USA1P2001928                                                
Lovett et al., 1987Milk, cow's1USA1P65062327                                                
Luisjuan-Morales et al., 1995Milk, cow's1Mexico2R1001000                                                
Lund et al., 1991Milk, cow's1USA1P3002919                                                
McLauchlin and Gilbert, 1990Milk, cow's1UK 1?3313238                                                
McLauchlin and Gilbert, 1990Non-bovine1UK 1?4124120                                                
McLauchlin et al., 1990Milk, goat's1UK1P770                                                
Moura et al., 1993Milk, cow's2Brazil1P22019921                                                
Oni et al., 1989Milk, cow's2Nigeria1P1501491                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Milk, cow's1USA3R3853841                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Milk, goat's1USA3R1711710                                                
Patterson et al., 1989Milk, cow's1USA1P12120                                                
Razavi-Rohani and Hedaiatinia, 1990 Milk, cow's2Iran1P/R1901864                                                
Rea et al., 1992Milk, cow's1Ireland1P58956029                                                
Rodler and Köerbler, 1989Milk, cow's1Hungary1P80773                                                
Rohrbach et al., 1992Milk, cow's1USA1P29228012                                                
Slade and Collins-Thompson, 1988Milk, cow's1Canada1P31529817                                                
Steele et al., 1997Milk, cow's (farm bulk tank)1Canada2P1720167347                                                
Stone, 1987Milk, cow's1New Zealand1P71710                                                
Takai et al., 1990Milk, cow's1Japan1P1201200                                                
Teufel and Bendzulla, 1993Milk, cow's1Germany1R?9793E                  4                            
Teufel and Bendzulla, 1993Milk, cow's1Germany1R?2562560                                                
Teufel and Bendzulla, 1993Non-bovine1Germany1R?39390                                                
Teufel and Bendzulla, 1993Non-bovine1Germany1R?440                                                
Vázquez-Salinas et al. 2001Milk, raw1Mexico3P13001138162                                                
Total=1908018299726        32  13    10                            
1 Group 1 includes North America including the United States, Canada, Mexico, EU countries, Japan, Australia, New Zealand. Other countries were also included in group 1 on a case-by-case basis if they import the product to the United States. Group 2 includes any country not in group 1.
2 1 = time period pre-1993 to 1993; 2 = time period 1994 to 1998; 3 = time period 1999 to present.
3 R = sample collected at retail; P = sample collected at plant/ manufacturer; ? = location of sample collection unknown.
4 E = samples is greater than or equal to 0.04 cfu/g that were enumerated


Frozen Dairy Products Food Category: Contamination Data
ReferenceFoodGeographic Region1CountryPub. Date2Sample Collection3Number of Samples (values in cfu/g units)
Total # of Samples from the reference<0.04is greater than or equal to0.04 >0.01-0.1>0.1-1<0.30.3-<10<10is greater than or equal to10 10-100<2020-100<100>100100-10001E2- 1E4<200200-500200-1000<500>10001E3-1E4>1E4 1E4-1E5>1E51E5-1E6>1E6
Arnold and Coble, 1995 Ice cream1Australia2R16614323                                                
Baek et al., 2000Ice cream2Korea3R1321248                                                
Choi et al.,2001Ice cream2Korea3R25250                                                
Ciftcioglu et al., 1992 Ice cream2Turkey1?50455                                                
Farber et al., 1989Ice cream, novelty1Canada1P51501                                                
Farber et al., 1989Ice cream1Canada1P3943931                                                
Farber et al., 1989Ice cream mix1Canada1P85850                                                
Frye, 2000Frozen dairy products1USA3R69654                                                
Greenwood et al., 1991Ice cream1UK1R1501473                                                
Hartung, 2000a. Ice cream =speiseeis 1Germany3R249024891                                                
Hartung, 2001Speiseeis =icecream1Germany3R169416922                                                
Hartung, 2001 Speiseeis =icecream1Germany3R16961694E4                  2                            
Hartung, 1999Ice cream =speiseeis 1Germany3R262826253                                                
Heinitz, 1999Ice cream1USA3P29427024                                                
IDFA, 1999 Ice cream, novelties1USA3R1227119631                                                
IDFA, 1999 Ice cream, novelties (0.01 detection limit)1USA3R19320193119                                                
IDFA, 1999 Ice cream/ frozen yogurt1USA3R5175170                                                
Kozak et al., 1996Ice cream, novelty1USA2P35132130                                                
Kozak et al., 1996Ice cream1USA2P71668828                                                
Kozak et al., 1996Ice milk1USA2P42420                                                
Maifreni et al., 1993Ice cream1Germany1R3963960                                                
McLauchlin and Gilbert, 1990Ice cream1UK 1?27425717                                                
Monge et al., 1994Ice cream1Costa Rica2R50491                                                
Monge et al., 1994 Ice cream1Costa Rica2R50491                                                
Ng and Seah, 1995Ice cream2Singapore2P/R61610                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Frozen yogurt1USA3R31310                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Ice cream1USA3R1061060                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Ice cream mix1USA3R57570                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Ice cream, novelty1USA3R220                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Ice milk1USA3R82820                                                
Teufel and Bendzulla, 1993Ice cream, iced products1Germany1R?63630                                                
Teufel and Bendzulla, 1993Ice cream, iced products1Germany1R?550                                                
Unilever, 2000Ice cream 2Oceania/ Asia/ Africa3P21416214133                                                
Unilever, 2000Ice cream 1America3P16387163825                                                
Unilever, 2000Ice cream 1Europe3P992169916056                                                
Warke et al., 2000Ice creams2India3R30291                                                
West and North Yorkshire Joint Working Group, 1991Ice cream1UK1R68652              1                                
Total=170391170129259              1  2                            
1 Group 1 includes North America including the United States, Canada, Mexico, EU countries, Japan, Australia, New Zealand. Other countries were also included in group 1 on a case-by-case basis if they import the product to the United States. Group 2 includes any country not in group 1.
2 1 = time period pre-1993 to 1993; 2 = time period 1994 to 1998; 3 = time period 1999 to present.
3 R = sample collected at retail; P = sample collected at plant/ manufacturer; ? = location of sample collection unknown.
4 E = samples is greater than or equal to 0.04 cfu/g that were enumerated


Cultured Milk Products Category: Contamination Data
ReferenceFoodGeographic Region1CountryPub. Date2Sample Collection3Number of Samples (values in cfu/g units)
Total # of Samples from the reference<0.04is greater than or equal to0.04 >0.01-0.1>0.1-1<0.30.3-<10<10is greater than or equal to10 10-100<2020-100<100>100100-10001E2- 1E4<200200-500200-1000<500>10001E3-1E4>1E4 1E4-1E5>1E51E5-1E6>1E6
Greenwood et al., 1991Yogurt1UK1R?1801763                                    1          
McLauchlin and Gilbert, 1990Yogurt1UK 1?2092090                                                
McLauchlin et al., 1990Yogurt1UK1R220                                                
Ng and Seah, 1995Yogurt2Singapore2P/R40400                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Buttermilk1USA3R550                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Sour cream1USA3R550                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Yogurt1USA3R440                                                
West and North Yorkshire Joint Working Group, 1991Yogurt1UK1R45450                                                
Total=4904863                                    1          
1 Group 1 includes North America including the United States, Canada, Mexico, EU countries, Japan, Australia, New Zealand. Other countries were also included in group 1 on a case-by-case basis if they import the product to the United States. Group 2 includes any country not in group 1.
2 1 = time period pre-1993 to 1993; 2 = time period 1994 to 1998; 3 = time period 1999 to present.
3 R = sample collected at retail; P = sample collected at plant/ manufacturer; ? = location of sample collection unknown.


High Fat and Other Dairy Products: Contamination Data
ReferenceFoodGeographic Region1CountryPub. Date2Sample Collection3Number of Samples (values in cfu/g units)
Total # of Samples from the reference<0.04is greater than or equal to0.04 >0.01-0.1>0.1-1<0.30.3-<10<10is greater than or equal to10 10-100<2020-100<100>100100-10001E2- 1E4<200200-500200-1000<500>10001E3-1E4>1E4 1E4-1E5>1E51E5-1E6>1E6
Frye, 2000Butter1USA3R23230                                                
Greenwood et al., 1991Cream, pasteurized1UK1R 40400                                                
Hartung, 2000a. milk products 1Germany3R9589562                                                
Hartung, 2000a. milk products, 1Germany3R6567653829                                                
Hartung, 2001milk products, 1Germany3R2662642                                                
Hartung, 2001milk products, 1Germany3R537533E4                  4                            
Hartung, 1999milk products 1Germany3R45450                                                
Hartung, 1999milk products, 1Germany3R87328552180                                                
Heinitz, 1999milk product1USA3P32320                                                
Heinitz, 1999Milk products (not cheese or ice cream)1USA3P2712674                                                
Karpiskova et al., 2000Dairy products1Czech Republic3R2092072                                                
Kozak et al., 1996Butter1USA2P 30300                                                
Kozak et al., 1996Cream1USA2P 52520                                                
Kozak et al., 1996Cream half & half1USA2P 42420                                                
McLauchlin and Gilbert, 1990Cream1UK 1?1161160                                                
Ng and Seah, 1995cream2Singapore2P/R17170                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Pudding, chocolate1USA3R220                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Egg nog1USA3R440                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Half & half1USA3R770                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Milkshake1USA3R55550                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Dip1USA3R42402                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Whipping cream1USA3R660                                                
Teufel and Bendzulla, 1993Butter1Germany1R?1914E                  5                            
Teufel and Bendzulla, 1993Butter1Germany1R?97970                                                
Total=1816917939221                  9                            
1 Group 1 includes North America including the United States, Canada, Mexico, EU countries, Japan, Australia, New Zealand. Other countries were also included in group 1 on a case-by-case basis if they import the product to the United States. Group 2 includes any country not in group 1.
2 1 = time period pre-1993 to 1993; 2 = time period 1994 to 1998; 3 = time period 1999 to present.
3 R = sample collected at retail; P = sample collected at plant/ manufacturer; ? = location of sample collection unknown.
4 E = samples is greater than or equal to 0.04 cfu/g that were enumerated


Frankfurter Food Category: Contamination Data
ReferenceFoodGeographic Region1CountryPub. Date2Sample Collection3Number of Samples (values in cfu/g units)
Total # of Samples from the reference<0.04is greater than or equal to0.04 >0.01-0.1>0.1-1<0.30.3-<10<10is greater than or equal to10 10-100<2020-100<100>100100-10001E2- 1E4<200200-500200-1000<500>10001E3-1E4>1E4 1E4-1E5>1E51E5-1E6>1E6
Hayes et al., 1992Hotdogs1USA1R4028E4    9  1  2                                  
Levine, 2000Hotdogs1USA3P1593151677                                                
Levine, 2001Hotdogs1USA3P1800176634                                                
Ng and Seah, 1995Franks, chicken & pork2Singapore2P/R78735                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Hotdog1USA3R11110                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Hotdogs, beef1USA3R330                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Hotdogs, turkey1USA3R330                                                
Qvist and Liberski, 1991Frankfurter1Sweden?1R64568                                                
Samelis and Metaxopoulos, 1999Frankfurter, sausage type1Greece3P880                                                
Wang and Muriana, 1994Hotdogs1USA2R1179316        8                                      
Wenger et al., 1990Wieners, turkey1USA1P462521                                                
Total=37633582161    9  9  2                                  
1 Group 1 includes North America including the United States, Canada, Mexico, EU countries, Japan, Australia, New Zealand. Other countries were also included in group 1 on a case-by-case basis if they import the product to the United States. Group 2 includes any country not in group 1.
2 1 = time period pre-1993 to 1993; 2 = time period 1994 to 1998; 3 = time period 1999 to present.
3 R = sample collected at retail; P = sample collected at plant/ manufacturer; ? = location of sample collection unknown.
4 E = samples is greater than or equal to 0.04 cfu/g that were enumerated


Dry/Semi-dry Sausage Food Category: Contamination Data
ReferenceFoodGeographic Region1CountryPub. Date2Sample Collection3Number of Samples (values in cfu/g units)
Total # of Samples from the reference<0.04is greater than or equal to0.04 >0.01-0.1>0.1-1<0.30.3-<10<10is greater than or equal to10 10-100<2020-100<100>100100-10001E2- 1E4<200200-500200-1000<500>10001E3-1E4>1E4 1E4-1E5>1E51E5-1E6>1E6
Breer and Schopfer, 1989Salami1Australia1?63594                                                
Buncic, 1991Sausage, fermented1Yugo-slavia1R21174                                                
Cantoni et al., 1988Salami & pork, seasoned meat products1Italy?1R?2252196                                                
Choi et al.,2001Sausage, fermented2Korea3R15132                                                
Farber et al., 1989Sausages, fermented1Canada1R 30246                                                
Gomez-Campillo et al., 1999Cured chorizo1Spain3R20191                                                
Lahellec et al., 1996Sausage, dry1France2?1168333                                                
Lahellec et al., 1996Sausage, smoked1France2?45396                                                
Levine, 2000Sausages, fermented1USA3P35233517                                                
Levine, 2001Sausage, dry & semi-dry fermented1USA3P85684115                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Beef Stick1USA3R330                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Ag, 2001Pepperoni1USA3R761                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Salami1USA3R550                                                
Samelis and Metaxopoulos, 1999Sausage, dry & fermented1Greece3P440                                                
Teufel and Bendzulla, 1993Sausage1Germany1R?85080644                                                
Teufel and Bendzulla, 1993Sausage, cooked & cured1Germany1R?338314E4                  21    3                      
Trüssel, 1989Beef, salami & mettwurst1Germany1P9995E              4                                
Uyttendaele et al., 1999 Sausage, raw & fermented1Belgium3R30825936          13                                    
Total=33573141175          13  4  21    3                      
1 Group 1 includes North America including the United States, Canada, Mexico, EU countries, Japan, Australia, New Zealand. Other countries were also included in group 1 on a case-by-case basis if they import the product to the United States. Group 2 includes any country not in group 1.
2 1 = time period pre-1993 to 1993; 2 = time period 1994 to 1998; 3 = time period 1999 to present.
3 R = sample collected at retail; P = sample collected at plant/ manufacturer; ? = location of sample collection unknown.
4 E = samples is greater than or equal to 0.04 cfu/g that were enumerated


Deli Meats Food Category: Contamination Data
ReferenceFoodGeographic Region1CountryPub. Date2Sample Collection3Number of Samples (values in cfu/g units)
Total # of Samples from the reference<0.04is greater than or equal to0.04 >0.01-0.1>0.1-1<0.30.3-<10<10is greater than or equal to10 10-100<2020-100<100>100100-10001E2- 1E4<200200-500200-1000<500>10001E3-1E4>1E4 1E4-1E5>1E51E5-1E6>1E6
Aguado et al., 2001Deli meats1Spain3R36933534                                                
Baek et al., 2000Ham2Korea3R50500                                                
Bersot et al, 2001Mortadella2Brazil3R30228                                                
Daley et al., 1999Meats, ready-to-eat1Canada3R19181                                                
Gillespie et al., 2000Deli meats1UK3R34553442E4                  8  5                        
Gomez-Campillo et al., 1999Cold cuts1Spain3R20200                                                
Kamat and Nair, 1994Ham, cooked 2India2R220                                                
Lahellec et al., 1996Ham1France2?45441                                                
Levine, 2000Corned beef, roast and cooked1USA3P2587252364                                                
Levine, 2000Ham and luncheon meats, sliced1USA3P97893048                                                
Levine, 2000Poultry, cooked1USA3P4125403689                                                
Levine, 2000Sausage, large diameter cooked 1USA3P2174214826                                                
Levine, 2001Corned beef, roast cooked 1USA3P1939189247                                                
Levine, 2001Ham-sliced/sliced luncheon1USA3P2048197177                                                
Levine, 2001Poultry, cooked1USA3P2325229431                                                
Levine, 2001Sausage, large diameter cooked1USA3P2725271213                                                
Miettinen, et al., 2001Broiler products, ready-to-eat1Finland3P25250                                                
NFPA, 2002Deli meats1USA-CA3R46004572E108    6  1        2            1          
NFPA, 2002Deli meats1USA-MD3R45994545E3212    4  1        5                        
Ng and Seah, 1995Ham/salami/bacon/ luncheon meat2Singapore2R17143                                                
Ojeniyi et al., 2000Turkey breast, smoked1Denmark3P220                                                
Ojeniyi et al., 2000Turkey breast, cooked smoked 1Denmark3P18180                                                
Ojeniyi et al., 2000Turkey cuvette, smoked 1Denmark3P17170                                                
Ojeniyi et al., 2000Turkey fillet, smoked & ready-to-eat1Denmark3P14113                                                
Ojeniyi et al., 2000Turkey parts1Denmark3P110                                                
Ojeniyi et al., 2000Turkey wings1Denmark3P101                                                
Ojeniyi et al., 2000Turkey, cooked & smoked & diced1Denmark3P220                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Beef, barbecue 1USA3R11110                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Chicken, barbecue 1USA3R440                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Meat, barbecue 1USA3R110                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Pork, barbecue 1USA3R550                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Beef1USA3R110                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Bologna1USA3R440                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Chicken, breaded1USA3R22220                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Chicken, ready-to-eat 1USA3R74722                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Corned beef1USA3R660                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Ham1USA3R56560                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Olive loaf1USA3R440                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Pastrami1USA3R14140                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Pork1USA3R312                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Beef, roast1USA3R1081080                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Turkey breast, sliced1USA3R1181180                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Turkey ham1USA3R880                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Turkey pastrami1USA3R871                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Turkey, ready-to-eat1USA3R440                                                
Qvist and Liberski, 1991Ham1Sweden?1R80728                                                
Qvist and Liberski, 1991Pork loin1Sweden?1R806218                                                
Qvist and Liberski, 1991Sausages1Sweden?1R80728                                                
Samelis and Metaxopoulos, 1999Bacon1Greece3P440                                                
Samelis and Metaxopoulos, 1999Ham like products1Greece3P431                                                
Samelis and Metaxopoulos, 1999Ham, sliced & vacuum-packed1Greece3P651                                                
Samelis and Metaxopoulos, 1999Mortadella1Greece3P440                                                
Samelis and Metaxopoulos, 1999Pariza1Greece3P220                                                
Samelis and Metaxopoulos, 1999Pork shoulder, sliced & vacuum-packed1Greece3P660                                                
Samelis and Metaxopoulos, 1999Sausage, country type 1Greece3P1091                                                
Samelis and Metaxopoulos, 1999Sausage, Emulsion type 1Greece3P12120                                                
Samelis and Metaxopoulos, 1999Turkey breast, smoked 1Greece3P440                                                
Soriano et al., 2001Beef, ready-to-eat1Spain3R550                                                
Soriano et al., 2001Chicken, ready-to-eat 1Spain3R550                                                
Soriano et al., 2001Pork, ready-to-eat1Spain3R550                                                
Uyttendaele et al., 1999 Ham, cooked sliced1Belgium3R87981754          8                                    
Total=33824331795424220    1082    8  12            1          
1 Group 1 includes North America including the United States, Canada, Mexico, EU countries, Japan, Australia, New Zealand. Other countries were also included in group 1 on a case-by-case basis if they import the product to the United States. Group 2 includes any country not in group 1.
2 1 = time period pre-1993 to 1993; 2 = time period 1994 to 1998; 3 = time period 1999 to present.
3 R = sample collected at retail; P = sample collected at plant/ manufacturer; ? = location of sample collection unknown.
4 E = samples is greater than or equal to 0.04 cfu/g that were enumerated


Pâté and Meat Spreads Food Category: Contamination Data
ReferenceFoodGeographic Region1CountryPub. Date2Sample Collection3Number of Samples (values in cfu/g units)
Total # of Samples from the reference<0.04is greater than or equal to0.04 >0.01-0.1>0.1-1<0.30.3-<10<10is greater than or equal to10 10-100<2020-100<100>100100-10001E2- 1E4<200200-500200-1000<500>10001E3-1E4>1E4 1E4-1E5>1E51E5-1E6>1E6
Anderson and Nørrung, 1995Pâté1Denmark2R3413336            1        1                        
Dominguez et al., 2001Pâté1Spain3R182172E4                  9  1                        
Gomez-Campillo et al., 1999Pâté1Spain3R20200                                                
Lahellec et al., 1996Pâté1France2?1109614                                                
Levine, 2000Meat spreads1USA3P26425410                                                
Levine, 2000Pâté1USA3P2492445                                                
Levine, 2001Meat spreads1USA3P1051032                                                
Levine, 2001Pâté1USA3P1031030                                                
McLauchlin and Gilbert, 1990Pâté1UK 1?69658099                                  17            
Morris and Ribeiro, 1989Pâté1UK1R7336E              185    4            3  43    
Morris and Ribeiro, 1991Pâté1UK1R2161416              426    7            410        
Nichols et al., 1998Pâté, fish & seafood1UK2R1221131                          6  2                
Nichols et al., 1998Pâté, meat-based1UK2R180417671                          29  1    2  2    2
Nichols et al., 1998Pâté, poultry-based1UK2R528511E                          11  2    1  2  1  
Nichols et al., 1998Pâté, undefined1UK2R380369E                          9            1    1
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Ham spread1USA3R110                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Pâté, salmon1USA3R770                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Pâté, shrimp1USA3R110                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Pâté, tuna1USA3R110                                                
Uyttendaele et al., 1999 Aspic mince, prepacked, cooked1Belgium3R48434          1                                    
Uyttendaele et al., 1999 Aspic mince, unprepackaged & cooked1Belgium3R67661                                                
Uyttendaele et al., 1999 Pâté mince, prepacked & cooked1Belgium3R2172116                                                
Uyttendaele et al., 1999 Pâté mince, unprepackaged & cooked1Belgium3R1301236          1                                    
Total=56655295161          2160119  13  55  5  1710109313
1 Group 1 includes North America including the United States, Canada, Mexico, EU countries, Japan, Australia, New Zealand. Other countries were also included in group 1 on a case-by-case basis if they import the product to the United States. Group 2 includes any country not in group 1.
2 1 = time period pre-1993 to 1993; 2 = time period 1994 to 1998; 3 = time period 1999 to present.
3 R = sample collected at retail; P = sample collected at plant/ manufacturer; ? = location of sample collection unknown.
4 E = samples is greater than or equal to 0.04 cfu/g that were enumerated


Deli-type Salad Food Category: Contamination Data
ReferenceFoodGeographic Region1CountryPub. Date2Sample Collection3Number of Samples (values in cfu/g units)
Total # of Samples from the reference<0.04is greater than or equal to0.04 >0.01-0.1>0.1-1<0.30.3-<10<10is greater than or equal to10 10-100<2020-100<100>100100-10001E2- 1E4<200200-500200-1000<500>10001E3-1E4>1E4 1E4-1E5>1E51E5-1E6>1E6
Buchanan et al., 1989Salad, seafood1USA1R220                                                
Hartemink and Georgsson 1991Salads, seafood1Iceland1P/R37316                                                
Hartung, 2000a. Delicatessen salads, other1Germany3R4854796                                                
Hartung, 2001Delicatessen salads, other1Germany3R26251                                                
Hartung, 2001Delicatessen salads, other1Germany3R389374E4                  15                            
Hartung, 1999Delicatessensalads, unspecified1Germany3R3543513                                                
Levine, 2000Various meat & poultry salads1USA3P 1645159451                                                
Levine, 2001Salads, deli1USA3P6306237                                                
Lin et al., 1996Salads(2 egg, 2 cheese, 1dressing)1USA2R55                                                  
NFPA, 2002Salads, deli1USA-CA3R42564157E7814    4  2                      1          
NFPA, 2002Salad, seafood1USA-CA3R12481221E261                                            
NFPA, 2002Salads, deli1USA-MD3R42934190E8414    5                                      
NFPA, 2002Salad, seafood1USA-MD3R13131225E5618    10  2        2                        
Ng and Seah, 1995Cole slaw/vegetable salad2Singapore2R50482                                                
Ng and Seah, 1995Fish, tuna salad2Singapore2R550                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Antipasto1USA3R330                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Salad, broccoli & cheese1USA3R50500                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Caesar salad1USA3R220                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Chef salad1USA3R31310                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Salad, chicken1USA3R2222184                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Cole slaw1USA3R1611592                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Salad, crab1USA3R990                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Creamy Fruit1USA3R550                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Salad, egg1USA3R770                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Salad, Greek1USA3R880                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Salad, ham1USA3R770                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Salad, macaroni with cheese1USA3R1941931                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Salad, meat1USA3R17170                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Salad, pasta1USA3R1151150                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Salad, pea1USA3R45423                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Salad, potato1USA3R3023020                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Salad, salmon1USA3R220                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Salad, seafood1USA3R2112110                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Salad, shrimp1USA3R48480                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Salad, tortellini1USA3R14140                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Salad, tuna1USA3R16160                                                
Oregon  State  Dept of Agriculture, 2001Salad, turkey1USA3R22220                                                
Ryu et al., 1992Salad, potato1Japan1R330                                                
Scoglio et al., 2000Fish marinate & seafood salad1Italy3R550                                                
Teufel and Bendzulla 1993Salad, meat & egg1Germany1R?25224111                                                
Teufel and Bendzulla 1993Deli, mayonnaise1Germany1R?360333E                  24    3                      
Uyttendaele et al., 1999 Salad, chicken1Belgium3R15211041          1                                    
Uyttendaele et al., 1999 Salad, fish & shrimp1Belgium3R36224999          14                                    
Uyttendaele et al., 1999 Salad, ham1Belgium3R15912133          5                                    
Uyttendaele et al., 1999 Other salad (veg) with mayonnaise1Belgium3R20118613          2                                    
West and North Yorkshire Joint Working Group, 1991Salad, egg/egg mayonnaise1UK1R10183E              26                10            
West and North Yorkshire Joint Working Group, 1991Salad, fish1UK1R3332E              1                                
West and North Yorkshire Joint Working Group, 1991Salad, meat/egg1UK1R1513E              11                              
West and North Yorkshire Joint Working Group, 1991Salad, fruit/nut1UK1R4342E              1                                
Total=179151722928324447    192245739  23        101          
1 Group 1 includes North America including the United States, Canada, Mexico, EU countries, Japan, Australia, New Zealand. Other countries were also included in group 1 on a case-by-case basis if they import the product to the United States. Group 2 includes any country not in group 1.
2 1 = time period pre-1993 to 1993; 2 = time period 1994 to 1998; 3 = time period 1999 to present.
3 R = sample collected at retail; P = sample collected at plant/ manufacturer; ? = location of sample collection unknown.
4 E = samples is greater than or equal to 0.04 cfu/g that were enumerated


National Food Safety Programs | CFSAN Home | FSIS Home | CDC Home
www.FoodSafety.gov | Search/Subject Index | Disclaimers & Privacy Policy | Accessibility

Hypertext updated by dms 2005-OCT-08