--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

REPORT OF INVESTIGATION OF
ENRON CORPORATION AND RELATED ENTITIES
REGARDING FEDERAL TAX AND COMPENSATION ISSUES,
AND POLICY RECOMMENDATIONS
VOLUME III:  APPENDICES C & D

By the Staff
of the
JOINT COMMITTEE ON TAXATION

At the Request of
Senator Max Baucus
and
Senator Charles E. Grassley
of the
SENATE COMMITTEE ON FINANCE

February 2003

JCS-3-03

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

You will need the Adobe Acrobat Reader installed on your computer to view these PDF files.  Get Acrobat Reader

[VOLUME I:  REPORT]   [VOLUME II:  APPENDICES A & B]  

VOLUME III:  APPENDIX C
CONTENTS

Title Page
 
PRELIMINARY PAGES
[ Title Page, Committee Members, Table of Contents ]
Preliminary Pages
 
I. PROJECT TANYA C-3
  Letter from Arthur Andersen, L.L.P. to Robert J. Hermann, Vice President Tax, Enron Corporation (with appendices) (December 21, 1995) C-4
 
II. PROJECT VALOR C-29
  Letter from Arthur Andersen, L.L.P. to Deborah Culver, Assistant General Counsel, and Jordan Mintz, Vice President, and Tax Counsel, Enron Capital and Trade Resources Corporation (with appendices) (December 27, 1996) C-30
 
III. PROJECT STEELE C-76
  Letter from Akin, Gump, Strauss, Hauer & Feld L.L.P. to R. Davis Maxey, Esquire, Enron Corporation (December 16, 1997) C-77
  Unsigned letter from Akin, Gump, Strauss, Hauer & Feld L.L.P. to R. Davis Maxey, Esquire, Enron Corporation (December 16, 1997) C-115
 
IV. PROJECT COCHISE C-127
  Letter from William S. McKee and James D. Bridgeman, McKee Nelson, Ernest & Young L.L.P. to R. Davis Maxey, Vice President Tax Research and Planning, Enron Corporation (March 21, 2001) C-128
  Letter from King & Spalding, to Enron Corporation, Maliseet Properties, Inc. (May 14, 2001) C-213
 
V. PROJECT TERESA C-217
  Memorandum from William S. McKee and Susan Jewett, King & Spalding to R. Davis Maxey, Director, Tax Research, Enron Corporation (February 20, 1997) C-218
  Draft letter from William S. McKee and Abraham N.M. Shashy, Jr., King & Spalding, to R. Davis Maxey, Esquire, Senior Director, Tax Research Corporate Tax, Enron Corporation (May 14, 1997) C-297
  Abraham N.M. Shashy, Jr., (for himself and William S. McKee), King & Spalding to R. Davis Maxey, Esquire, Senior Director, Tax Research, Corporate Tax, Enron Corporation (July 29, 1997) C-326
  Letter from King & Spalding to Enron Corporation (October 2, 2000) with an attachment letter from R. Davis Maxey, Vice President, Tax Planning, Enron Corporation to King & Spalding (September 27, 2000) C-371
  Letter from Vinson & Elkins L.L.P. to Enron Leasing Partners, L.L.P. (July 17, 1997) C-391
  Letter from Kevin A. Duvall, Partner, Ernest & Young L.L.P. to R. Davis Maxey, Vice President, Tax Planning, Enron Corporation (November 16, 1999) C-417
 
VI. PROJECT TOMAS C-424
  Letter from Akin, Gump, Strauss, Hauer & Feld, L.L.P. to Enron Corporation (November 23, 1998) C-425
 
VII. PROJECT CONDOR C-488
  Draft letter from Vinson & Elkins L.L.P. to Enron Corporation (attention: R. Davis Maxey) (March 17, 2000) C-489
 
VIII. PROJECT TAMMY I C-499
  Letter from Vinson & Elkins L.L.P. to Enron Corporation (attention: R. Davis Maxey) (February 9, 2001) C-500
 
IX. PROJECT APACHE C-524
  Letter from Shearman & Sterling to Enron Corporation (May 28, 1999) C-525
  Letter from Shearman & Sterling to Enron Corporation (May 28, 1999) C-569
 
X. PROJECT NOLy C-584
  Letter from Vinson & Elkins L.L.P. to Enron Corporation (February 26, 2001) C-585
  Draft letter from Vinson & Elkins L.L.P. to Enron Corporation (December 17, 2001) C-591
 
XI. PROJECT VALHALLA C-601
  Letter from Jutta Schneider, Clifford Chance Pünder to Enron Corporation (May 2, 2000) C-602
  Letter from Vinson & Elkins L.L.P. to Enron Corporation (September 12, 2000) C-617

VOLUME III:  APPENDIX D
CONTENTS

Title Page
 
PRELIMINARY PAGES
[ Table of Contents ]
Preliminary Pages
 
I. MATERIALS RELATING TO THE DUTIES OF THE ADMINISTRATIVE COMMITTEE FOR THE ENRON QUALIFIED PLANS D-5
  Memorandum from Patrick Mackin to Administrative Committees of Enron Corp. Tax Qualified Pension Plans Regarding Fiduciary Duties of Members of Committees (December 2, 1996) (Attachment II to the Minutes of the December 5, 1996, Administrative Committee Meeting) D-6
  Presentation by Patrick Mackin to the Administrative Committee regarding Administration of the ESOP, Cash Balance and Savings Plans (Attachment I to the Minutes of the March 9, 2000, Administrative Committee Meeting) D-11
 
II. MATERIALS RELATING TO CHANGES TO THE ENRON ESOP AND CASH BALANCE PLANS D-36
  Enron Corp. Interoffice Memorandum Regarding Retirement Plan Changes and ESOP Access Questions and Answers (January 31, 1995) D-37
  The Enron Retirement Program Guide D-58
  Cash Balance Plan Benefit Examples D-85
  Enron Corp. Retirement Plan Estimated Cash Contribution 1994-2002 (November 16, 1994) D-94
 
III. MATERIALS RELATING TO THE BLACKOUT PERIOD FOR THE ENRON SAVINGS PLAN D-95
  Timeline Regarding the Change in the Recordkeeper under the Enron Savings Plan (Presented at the November 20, 2001, Administrative Committee Meeting) D-96
  Enron Corp. Savings Plan Changes, "Money in Motion" D-104
  Electronic Mail to Employees with Blackout Reminders (October 16, 2001, 11:10 pm) D-110
  Electronic Mail to Employees with Blackout Reminders (October 22, 2001, 10:28 pm) D-111
  Electronic Mail to Employees with Blackout Reminders (October 25, 2001, 11:44 pm) D-112
  Electronic Mail to Employees with Final Reminder of Blackout Date (October 26, 2001, 11:58 am) D-113
  Electronic Mail to Enron Employees Notifying Them that the Blackout Had Ended on November 13 (November 14, 2001, 9:07 pm) D-114
 
IV. EXECUTIVE COMPENSATION "WHITE PAPERS" D-115
  Enron Executive Compensation Program "White Paper" (Updated January, 1998) D-116
  Enron Corp. Executive Compensation Program Brochure D-123
 
V. MATERIALS PROVIDED TO ENRON BY OUTSIDE CONSULTANTS REGARDING EXECUTIVE COMPENSATION D-127
  Letter from Towers Perrin to Dr. Charles A. LeMaistre dated December 3, 2001 (regarding competitiveness of Enron executive compensation programs) D-128
  Letter from Towers Perrin to Dr. Charles A. LeMaistre dated November 14, 2001 (regarding bonus and other compensation decisions during period before proposed merger with Dynegy) (letter was included as an attachment to the Towers Perrin letter dated December 3, 2001) D-134
  Enron Corp. Executive Compensation Stress Test Findings (April 20, 2001) Prepared by Towers Perrin and Presented to the Compensation Committee on May 1, 2001 D-141
  Letter from Towers Perrin to Ms. Pam Butler, Director, Compensation, dated November 16, 2000 (regarding marketplace compensation analysis for Mr. Lay and Mr. Skilling) D-195
  Letter from Towers Perrin to Dr. Charles A. LeMaistre dated January 18, 2001 (regarding alternative compensation arrangements for Mr. Lay due to his changed responsibilities upon the appointment of Mr. Skilling as Chief Executive Officer) D-205
 
VI. COMPENSATION OF THE TOP-200 MOST HIGHLY COMPENSATED EMPLOYEES (1998, 1999, and 2000 and 2001) D-209
 
VII. MATERIALS RELATING TO PRE-BANKRUPTCY BONUSES D-228
  List of Recipients of Bonuses, Including Name, Job Title, and Amount Received D-229
  Information Regarding Individuals Who Terminated Employment with Enron Before Completing 90-Day Service Requirement D-241
  Sample Agreements Relating to Pre-Bankruptcy Bonuses D-246
  Minutes of Board of Directors and Compensation Committee Meetings Relating to Pre-Bankruptcy Bonuses (October 24, 2001; November 16, 2001; November 18, 2001; November 25, 2001; November 28, 2001; and November 29, 2001) D-248
 
VIII. MATERIALS RELATING TO NONQUALIFIED DEFERRED COMPENSATION D-299
  Pre-Bankruptcy Early Withdrawals from the 1994 Deferral Plan and the Expat Deferral Plan D-300
 
IX. MATERIALS RELATING TO SALE OF OPTIONS TAX SHELTER D-309
  Sale of Executive Options Technique--Advantages and Disadvantages D-310
  Diagrams of Sale of Executive Options Technique D-314
  Draft Opinion Letter (undated, to "Client") D-317
 
X. MATERIALS RELATING TO EXECUTIVE LOANS D-346
  Enron Corp. Account Reconciliation, Officers’ Loans (1997-2001) D-347
  Mr. Lay Line of Credit, Recent Transactions (2001) D-352
  Enron Line of Credit, Mr. Frevert (2001) D-353
 
XI. MATERIALS RELATING TO PURCHASE AND RECONVEYANCE OF MR. LAY’S ANNUITY CONTRACTS D-354
  Ken Lay Insurance Swap Analysis (presented at September 14, 2001, Compensation Committee meeting) D-355
  Letter from Towers Perrin to Dr. Charles A. LeMaistre dated November 2, 2001 D-357
 
XII. SPLIT DOLLAR LIFE INSURANCE ARRANGEMENTS D-359
  Kenneth L. Lay Split Dollar Life Insurance Agreement Effective April 22, 1994 D-360
  Kenneth L. Lay Collateral Agreement Effective April 22, 1994 D-365
  Kenneth L. Lay Split Dollar Agreement Effective December 13, 1996 D-367
  Jeffrey K. Skilling Split Dollar Agreement Effective May 23, 1997 D-374
  Jeffrey K. Skilling Assignment of Life Insurance Policy as Collateral, Effective May 23, 1997 D-381
  Jeffrey K. Skilling Split Dollar Premium Payment Schedule D-385
 

[VOLUME I:  REPORT]   [VOLUME II:  APPENDICES B & C]  

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Questions or comments regarding this service? Contact the GPO Access User Support Team by Internet e-mail at gpoaccess@gpo.gov;
by telephone at (202) 512-1530 or toll free at (888) 293-6498; by fax at (202) 512-1262.

[ BACK ] [ GPO HOME ] [ GPO INET Services ]

Page #/congress/joint/jcs-3-03/vol3/index.html March 28, 2003