Everything Butt the Girl

Is Kim Kardashian defying sexist beauty standards, or helping create new ones?
Paper Magazine

"We're officially in the era of the big booty," announced Vogue in September, two decades and change after Sir Mix-a-Lot first pledged his troth to the juicy double, the rump-o-smooth-skin, the healthy butt. "In music videos, in Instagram photos, and on today's most popular celebrities, the measure of sex appeal is inextricably linked to the prominence of a woman's behind."

The story was published six months after Kim Kardashian appeared on the cover of the April issue of Vogue with her fiancé, Kanye West. The reality TV star's behind, arguably responsible in large part for the recent ascendancy of the posterior in popular culture, didn't feature much in the accompanying shoot, which was styled by Grace Coddington and shot by Annie Leibovitz—two unfathomably brilliant female creative forces. Instead, Kardashian posed in wedding dresses facing the camera: walking hand-in-hand with West alongside a river, sitting on a private jet, clutching her daughter. In the lone image shot from behind, the train of the dress Kardashian wears dominates the picture, shrouding her figure in a cloud of feathers. The bustle disguises the butt. The butt might be in vogue, but it isn’t quite in Vogue, or not yet, anyway.

This week, the butt appears totally unadorned on the cover of Paper magazine, with all the texture and sheen of molten caramel. Obviously, Kardashian is wearing it, although the rest of her body is an afterthought; her face uncomfortably drawn to the camera behind her, her neck completely covered with a multi-strand pearl choker (itself a problematic metaphor, if you like dissecting the hidden subtext of jewelry). Although the eye isn’t exactly pulled toward her face, her eyebrows are slightly raised, and her teeth are visible. Unlike the other, self-captured images of Kardashian's rear end posted on Instagram, her face is totally exposed, as is her body (her hands are oddly covered, with black opera gloves). The words underneath the image read: Break the Internet. Kardashian's husband did his best to comply, tweeting a picture of it along with the accompanying hashtag #ALLDAY—perhaps suggesting that he could look at his wife's naked behind for the duration of a 24-hour-period without getting tired. The tweet has, as of this moment, been retweeted 57,000 times.

The Paper cover is obviously designed to attract public attention through creative manipulation of nudity in a way that renders it artistic rather than gratuitous, although how well it succeeds is open to interpretation. An accompanying image released by the magazine shows Kardashian, fully clothed this time in a Jessica Rabbit-esque sequined cocktail dress, resting a champagne glass on her buttocks and smiling with her mouth open as she grasps an exploding bottle of champagne. (The photo, by Jean Paul Goude, is a recreation of his controversial shot from 1976, in which a fully naked model poses in the same way.) Although Kardashian's backside is covered, it's still the focus of the photo: It's literally the foundation on which the fragile balancing act rests. She's grinning, this time, mouth ajar. Isn't this fun? she seems to say, teetering on a wooden box, bent sideways at a right angle.

Presented by

Sophie Gilbert is a senior editor at The Atlantic, where she oversees The Atlantic Weekly. She was previously the arts editor at The Washingtonian.

How to Photograph the Milky Way

A short film about the art and passion of astrophotography

Join the Discussion

After you comment, click Post. If you’re not already logged in you will be asked to log in or register.

blog comments powered by Disqus

Video

Playing An Actual Keyboard Cat

A music video transforms food, pets, and objects into extraordinary instruments.

Video

Stunning GoPro Footage of a Wildfire

In the field with America’s elite Native American firefighting crew

Video

The Man Who Built a Forest Larger Than Central Park

Since 1979, he has planted more than 1,300 acres of trees.

Video

How Long Do You Want to Live?

A conversation between James Hamblin and Dr. Zeke Emanuel

More in National

Just In