skip to page content
Office of Administrative Law Judges
USDOL/OALJ Reporter
Service Contract Act - ALJ Decisions

This library contains administrative law judge decisions relating to the Service Contract Act. Only decisions available in electronic form are included. For Secretary of Labor or Board of Service Contact Appeals decisions, see the "Service Contract Act Appeals Decisions: 1987 - Current" library. For Administrative Review Board decisions, see the ARB caselist.

Note: The case numbers assigned by the BSCA do not correspond to the OALJ case numbers, although the format is similar.

Note: CBV cases refer to collective bargaining variance proceeding arising under the McNamara-O?Hara Service Contract Act

Some documents in this database consist of files in Adobe Portable Document Format (PDF). Adobe software distributes a free Adobe Acrobat Reader at its web site.

Link to Adobe, Inc.

1982-SCA-127 MELTON SALES AND SERVICES, INC.
Decision & Order (ALJ Nov. 18, 1985) (Stuart A. Levin)HTML | PDF

1988-CBV-5 HYDE SECURITY SERVICES, INC.
Decision & Order (ALJ Sept. 19 1988)(Rudolf L. Jansen)PDF

2000-CBV-2 AKAL SECURITY, INCORPORATED
Decision & Order (ALJ Apr. 19, 2000)(Jeffrey Tureck)HTML

1989-SCA-56 U.S. DEPARTMENT OF LABOR v. IDAVOY, INC. d/b/a OLYMPIC CLEANING
Decision & Order (ALJ Aug. 10, 1994)(John C. Holmes)

1989-SCA-69 CATHY GETZFRIED
Order of Dismissal (ALJ Oct. 8, 1996)(John M. Vittone)HTML

1991-SCA-9 HOLLY GATES
Order of Dismissal (ALJ June 21, 1996)(John M. Vittone)HTML

1991-SCA-16 GARY W. STONE, D/B/A/ WHITE TAIL EXPRESS
Decision & Order Approving Consent Findings (ALJ xx)(David W. DiNardi)HTML

1991-SCA-30 HOUSTON BUILDING SERVICE, INC.
Decision & Order (ALJ Apr. 27, 1995)(Daniel J. Roketenetz)HTML

1991-SCA-41 UNITED INTERNATIONAL INVESTIGATIVE SERVICES, INC., AND WILLIAM J. GUIDICE
Decision & Order (ALJ Oct. 21, 1993)(Joan Huddy Rosenzweig)HTML

1991-SCA-71 JOSEPH L. SWILLEY d/b/a SWILLEY COMMERCIAL CLEANING and JOSEPH L. SWILLEY, INDIVIDUALLY
Decision & Order (ALJ Oct. 19, 1994)(Paul H. Teitler)HTML

1992-SCA-2 DALE JEFFREY GUENTHERMAN
Notice of Stipulation of Voluntary Dismissal (ALJ Oct. 6, 1995)(J. Michael O'Neill)HTML

1992-SCA-23 LEWIS & MICHAEL, INC. and THE SECURITY STORAGE COMPANY
Decision & Order (ALJ July 31, 1995)(J. Michael O'Neill)HTML

1992-SCA-36 STEINMANN TRANSPORTATION, INC.
Order to Show Cause Why Record Should Not Be Closed (ALJ Mar. 14, 1995)(Celement J. Kichuk)HTML
Decision & Order Accepting Consent Findings (ALJ Mar. 31, 1995)HTML

1992-SCA-40 HOUSTON BUILDING SERVICE, INC.
Decision & Order (ALJ Feb. 13, 1995)(Lee J. Romero, Jr.)HTML

1992-SCA-46 ANNA G. RICHARDSON, a/k/a GENEVIEVE RICHARDSON
Decision & Order Approving Consent Findings (ALJ 1997)(John M. Vittone)HTML

1992-SCA-49 SIDNEY STEWART, d/b/a PROFESSIONAL BUILDING SERVICES & MAINTENANCE
Order Partially Granting Motion for Summary Judgment (ALJ Aug. 7, 1996)HTML
Order Denying Summary Judgment (ALJ Nov. 8, 1996)HTML
Decision & Order (ALJ Feb. 18, 1998)(Jeffrey Tureck)HTML

1992-SCA-64 TECHNIX, INC.
Decision & Order (ALJ Feb. 23, 1995)(Samuel J. Smith)HTML

1992-SCA-65 ALVIN ALLEN COYNE, D/B/A FARMER'S TRUCKING COMPANY
Decision & Order (ALJ Nov. 29, 1994)(Robert L. Hillyard)HTML

1993-SCA-8 GAYLE RAYE JONES, d/b/a TROJAN STRIDING
Decision & Order of Default Judgment (ALJ Aug. 16, 1995)(Daniel L. Stewart)HTML

1993-SCA-26 DANTRAN, INC. and ROBERT HOLMES
Decision & Order (ALJ Dec. 4, 1995)(David W. Di Nardi)HTML

1993-SCA-39 DOMER TRUCKING, INC.

Decision & Order Approving Consent Findings (ALJ Aug. 1, 1994)(David W. Di Nardi)HTML

1993-SCA-49 J & J MERRICK'S ENTERPRISES, INC.

Decision & Order (ALJ June 13, 1994)(C. Richard Avery)HTML

1994-SCA-2 JOHN'S JANITORIAL SERVICE, INC.
Decision & Order (ALJ Sept. 8, 1995)(Joel F. Gardiner)HTML

1994-SCA-10 RYAN-WALSH, INC.
Decision & Order Approving Consent Findings (ALJ Oct. 12, 1994)(Paul H. Teitler)HTML

1994-SCA-31 SUMMITT INVESTIGATIVE SERVICE, INC.
Decision & Order (ALJ Sept. 25, 1995)(Robert D. Kaplan)HTML

1994-SCA-35 INTERNATIONAL RESOURCES CORP.
Decision & Order -- Assessing Damages & Debarment (ALJ Jan. 3, 1996)(George A. Fath)HTML
Decision & Order -- Assessing Damages & Debarment (ALJ June 26, 1996)(George A. Fath)(reissued decision as rehired annuitant)HTML

1994-SCA-46 COMMERCIAL LAUNDRY AND DRY CLEANING
Recommended Decision & Order (ALJ Mar. 15, 1996)(Lee J. Romero, Jr.)HTML

1994-SCA-47 SUPERVAN, INC.
Decision and Order Granting Motion to Compel, Denying Motion for Summary Judgment, and Denying Motion for Default Judgment (ALJ Nov. 24, 1998)(Daniel L. Stewart)HTML
Decision & Order Granting Partial Default Judgment(ALJ Apr. 29, 1999)HTML
Decision & Order Granting Default Judgment (ALJ Aug. 18, 1999)HTML
Order Denying Motion for Reconsideration (ALJ Oct. 12, 1999)HTML
Final Decision & Order (ARB Sept. 30, 2002)HTML
Errata (ARB Nov. 5, 2002)HTML

1995-SCA-1 CHENEY, INC. (a/k/a CHENEY'S OF MOTLEY, INC.)
Decision & Order ALJ Oct. 27, 1997)HTML

1995-SCA-15 AMERICAN SENTRY AND PATROL, INC. and JAMES L. MARTIN, JR.
Decision & Order (ALJ Dec. 4, 1996)(John M. Vittone)HTML

1995-SCA-26 [ARB No. 01-047] J.N. Moser Trucking, Inc.
Decision & Order (ALJ Dec. 1, 2000) (Daniel J. Roketenetz)PDF
Final Decision & Order (ARB May 30, 2003)HTML
J.N. Moser Trucking, Inc., __ F.Supp.2d __ (N.D. Ill. Feb. 27, 2004) (available at 2004 WL 405929) (vacating ARB order and remanding)PDF (image only)
Decision & Order on Remand (ALJ Aug. 5, 2004) (Daniel J. Roketenetz)PDF

1995-SCA-38 DONALD M. GLAUDE, d/b/a D'S NATIONWIDE INDUSTRIAL SERVICES
Order Vacating Decision and Order on Default (ALJ Sept. 26, 1996)(John M. Vittone)HTML
Decision & Order (ALJ Jan. 8, 1998)(Alexander Karst)HTML

1995-SCA-45 PONY EXPRESS COURIER CORPORATION
Decision & Order Granting Respondent's Motion for Summary Decision ↦ Dismissing Complaint (ALJ Feb. 29, 1996)(Daniel A. Sarno, Jr.)HTML
Decision & Order Denying Complainant's Motion for Reconsideration (ALJ Mar. 28, 1996)HTML

1996-SCA-1 LEROY WAINES d/b/a LEROY WAINES MAIL HAULER
Decision & Order (ALJ Nov. 6, 1997)HTML

1996-SCA-3 SECRETARY V. USOLTEFF
Decision & Order (ALJ )(Paul A. Mapes)HTML

1996-SCA-36 ELAINE'S CLEANING SERVICE
Elaine's Cleaning Service, Inc. v. USDOL, 106 F.3d 726 (6th Cir. 1997)HTML

1996-SCA-42 DONALD TOBIN and LAND BRIDGE TRANSPORTATION
Order of Dismissal (ALJ Mar. 21, 1997)HTML

1997-SCA-14 INTEGRATED RESOURCE MANAGEMENT, INC.
Decision & Order (ALJ Aug. 5, 1999)(Alfred Lindeman)HTML

1997-SCA-22 TEMPORARY EMPLOYMENT SERVICES and HARRY STEPHENSON
Decision & Order (ALJ Nov. 19, 1997)HTML

1997-SCA-35 NANTOM SERVICES, INC. and TOM WHITTAKER
Decision & Order (ALJ Dec. 22, 1998)(Larry W. Price)HTML

1998-SCA-6 BEN H. GRAVES, d/b/a BEN'S HOME CENTER
Order of Dismissal (ALJ Dec. 17, 1997)(John M. Vittone)HTML

1998-SCA-24 F & M ASSOCIATES OF JACKSONVILLE, INC.
Order Approving Consent Findings (ALJ Dec. 23, 1999)(Thomas M. Burke)HTML

1998-SCA-26 S.C. SECURITY, INC.
Order Concerning Discovery (ALJ June 29, 1999)(Pamela Lakes Wood)HTML

1999-SCA-2 WILLIAM T. CARR
Decision & Order (ALJ Jan. 4, 2000)(David W. Di Nardi)HTML

1999-SCA-10
Decision & Order (ALJ Feb. 6, 2002) (Pamela Lakes Wood)HTML
Erratum (ALJ Feb. 13, 2002)HTML

1999-SCA-17 MICHAEL RELYEA, INC.
Order Granting Motion for Default Judgement (ALJ Oct. 29, 1999)(David W. Di Nardi)HTML

1999-SCA-18 UNITED KLEENIST ORGANIZATION CORP.
Decision & Order (ALJ Jan. 10, 2000)(C. Richard Avery)HTML

2000-SCA-1 and 2 CM3 CORP., VGA ENTERPRISES
Decision & Order (ALJ Apr. 6, 2000) (Thomas M. Burke)HTML

2000-SCA-11 R & B TRUCKING COMPANY
Order Entering Default Judgment (ALJ Oct. 18, 2000) (Robert L. Hillyard)HTML

2001-SCA-17 ROOD TRUCKING COMPANY, INC.
Decision & Order (ALJ July 10, 2002) (Richard A. Morgan)HTML
Errata to Decision & Order (ALJ July 16, 2002)HTML
Supplement to Decision & Order (ALJ Aug. 20, 2002)HTML
Order Granting Administrator's Motion to Withdraw Petition for Review (ARB Oct. 7, 2002)HTML

2001-SCA-19 J.B.M. SERVICES, INC.
Decision & Order (ALJ Aug. 1, 2003) (Donald B. Jarvis)HTML

2001-SCA-22 USDOL v. GROBERG TRUCKING, INC.
Decision & Order (ALJ June 24, 2003) (Joseph E. Kane)HTML
Final Decision & Order (ARB Nov. 30, 2004) PDF

2002-SCA-3 COAST INDUSTRIES, INC. v. ADMINISTRATOR, WAGE & HOUR DIVISION, USDOL
Decision & Order (ALJ Aug. 30, 2003) (Jarvis)PDF
Final Decision & Order (ARB Feb. 28, 2005)PDF

2002-SCA-6 LAWN RESTORATION CORPORATION d/b/a LAWN RESTORATION SERVICE, INC., and LAWN RESTORATION SERVICES, INC.
Order Denying Motion for Protective Order (ALJ Nov. 7, 2002) (Stephen L. Purcell)HTML
Order Granting Agency's Motion to Compel & Denying Respondent's Motion for Protective Order (ALJ Dec. 9, 2002)HTML
Order Granting Agency's Second Motion to Compel (ALJ Jan. 17, 2003)HTML
Order Granting Agency's Motion for Partial Summary Judgment (ALJ Jan. 27, 2003)HTML
Decision & Order (ALJ Dec. 2, 2003)HTML

2002-SCA-7 USDOL v. CANTERBURY
Decision & Order - Granting Motions for Sanctions & Summary Judgment (ALJ July 8, 2003) (Daniel L. Leland)HTML
Final Decision & Order (ARB Dec. 29, 2004) PDF
Canterbury v. USDOL, No. Civ.A. 5:05-0028 (S.D. W.Va. Sept. 26, 2005) PDF

2002-SCA-13 USDOL v. BAKER
Order of Default Judgment on Motion for Relief From Default Judgment & on Order to Show Cause (ALJ Feb. 18, 2003) (Thomas F. Phalen, Jr.)PDF
United States v. Baker, No. 1-05-CV-685 (W.D.Mich. June 29, 2006) (affirming ALJ's default judgment)PDF

2002-SCA-16 USDOL v. MITCHEM TRANSPORTS, INC.
Order Granting Default Judgment (ALJ Apr. 29, 2003) (Clement J. Kennington)HTML
Decision & Order of Remand (ARB June 30, 2004)HTML | PDF

2003-SCA-2 USDOL v. LOSS PREVENTION, INC.
Decision & Order (ALJ Jan. 28, 2004) (Gerald M. Tierney)HTML
Order Granting Dismissal (ARB Nov. 29, 2006) PDF | HTML

2003-SCA-8 GONZALEZ FORESTRY
Decision & Order (ALJ Feb. 2, 2005) (Alexander Karst)PDF

2003-SCA-18 INTERNATIONAL SERVICES, INC. and OUSAMA KARAWIA
Decision & Order (ALJ July 6, 2005) (Ralph A. Romano)PDF
Final Decision & Order (ARB Dec. 21, 2007) PDF | HTM
 Order Denying Reconsideration (ARB May 30, 2008) PDF | HTML
 Karawia (International Services, Inc.) v. USDOL, No. 08-cv-05471 (S.D.N.Y. May 7, 2009) PDF | HTML

2003-SCA-24 R & W TRANSPORTATION, INC.
Decision & Order (ALJ December 21, 2005) (Daniel Solomon)PDF

2004-SCA-5 W/D ENTERPRISE, INC.
Decision & Order Ordering Debarment (ALJ Oct. 18, 2005) (Daniel F. Solomon)PDF
Final Decision and Order (ARB Jan. 31, 2008) PDF | HTML
Fields v. Chao, No. 08-1119-JTM (D. Kan. Feb. 19, 2009) PDF | HTML

2004-SCA-15 EDDIE JACKSON AND BETTY JACKSON
Decision & Order (ALJ May 25, 2005) (Clement J. Kennington)PDF

2005-SCA-15 CHARLOTTE HICKEY and AFFORDABLE DATA SERVICES, INC.
Decision & Order (ALJ May 22, 2007) (Pamela Lakes Wood)PDF

2005-SCA-24 PROGRESSIVE ENVIRONMENTAL LLC
Decision & Order (ALJ Mar. 23, 2007) (Russell D. Pulver)PDF

2006-SCA-7 RAY'S LAWN AND CLEANING SERVICES, INC.
Decision & Order (ALJ Apr. 25, 2006) (Richard K. Malamphy) PDF

2006-SCA-9 VGA INCORPORATED, d/b/a VGA, INC., and VINCE AKINS
Decision & Order (ALJ Feb. 12, 2009) (Pamela Lakes Wood) PDF
Final Decision and Order (ARB Sept. 29, 2011) PDF | HTM

2006-SCA-17 IN RE JAMES J. BEATTY, JR. d/b/a BEAR TRANSPORTATION SYSTEMS d/b/a BEATTY TRANSPORT SERVICE d/b/a JVB CONSOLIDATED d/b/a BTS
Decision & Order Granting Motion for Default Judgment (ALJ Dec. 21, 2006) (John M. Vittone) PDF

2006-SCA-20 KSC-TRI SYSTEMS USA, INC.
Decision & Order (ALJ Aug. 7, 2007) (Russell D. Pulver) PDF

2006-SCA-27 HHMT INC., a Corporation, and HAL D. HICKS, an Individual
Decision & Order (ALJ Aug. 4, 2010) (Merck) PDF

2006-CBV-1 AM-GARD, INC. AND THE UNITED GOVERNMENT SECURITY OFFICERS OF AMERICA, LOCAL NO. 50
Decision & Order (ALJ Jan., 19, 2006) (Russell D. Pulver)PDF
Final Decision and Order (ARB Apr. 24, 2006) PDF

2006-CBV-2 U. S. PROTECT, INC., AND THE UNITED GOVERNMENT SECURITY OFFICERS OF AMERICA (UGSOA) LOCAL NO. 52 UNDER A CONTRACT FOR SECURITY OFFICERS IN SAN DIEGO, CALIFORNIA
Decision & Order (ALJ Mar. 7, 2006) (Paul A. Mapes)PDF
 United Government Security Officers of America, Local No. 52 v. Chertoff, No. 07-173 (D.D.C. Nov. 24, 2008) PDF | HTML

2007-SCA-6 ROBERT GOMEZ d/b/a MAGIC BRITE JANITORIAL
Decision & Order (ALJ Dec. 7, 2006) (Russell D. Pulver) PDF

2008-SCA-11 SOUTHWEST SECURITY SERVICES, INC., and JESUS “JESSE” MORALES, JOSEPH MORALES, and ARCHIE GONZALES
Decision & Order (ALJ Sept. 9, 2011) (Romero) PDF

2008-SCA-16 FREDY BOWERS aka F & B ENTERPRISES
Summary Decision (ALJ July 12, 2010) (Levin) PDF

2008-SCA-17 ADMINISTRATOR, WAGE & HOUR DIVISION, USDOL v. TRI-COUNTY CONTRACTORS, INC.
Decision and Order (ALJ Oct. 28, 2010) (Avery) PDF
Final Decision and Order (ARB June 29, 2012) PDF | HTM

2009-SCA-1 CHARLES IGWE, and KSC TRI SYSTEMS, INC., USA, doing business as KSC-TRI SYSTEMS, TOTAL RESOURCE INDUSTRIES, TOTAL RESOURCES INDUSTRIES, TOTAL VOCATIONAL EDUCATION INSTITUTE, PREFERRED EDUCATIONAL DIAGNOSTICS AND TESTING CENTER, PREFERRED EDUCATIONAL DIAGNOSTICS TRAINING CENTER, PREFERRED EDUCATION AND DIAGNOSTIC CENTER, PREFERRED EDUCATIONAL & DIAGNOSTIC CENTER, TOTAL FIT-WELL GROUP, and TOTAL OUTSOURCING SPECIALISTS
Decision & Order Entering Default Judgment (ALJ Dec. 15, 2009) (Torkington) PDF

2009-SCA-9 ADMINISTRATOR, WAGE & HOUR DIVISION, USDOL v. J.N. MOSER ENTERPRISES, INC.
Decision and Order (ALJ June 5, 2012) (Johnson) PDF

2010-SCA-6 ADMINISTRATOR, WAGE & HOUR DIVISION, USDOL v. ARES GROUP, INC.
Decision and Order Granting Administrator's Motion for Summary Decision and Denying Respondent's Motion for Summary Decision (ALJ Oct. 28, 2010) (Avery) PDF

2010-SCA-23 CHAE S. MCFARLAND doing business as SK GATEWAY CLEANERS, and CHAE S. MCFARLAND Individually and Jointly
Decision and Order (ALJ Jan. 3, 2012) (Rosenow) PDF

2011-SCA-8 E & S DIVERSIFIED SERVICES, INC., MAYFIELD EVANS, BARRY EVANS, JACQUELINE EVANS, and WILLIE EVANS,
Decision and Order Debaring Respondents (ALJ Oct. 18, 2012) (Gee) PDF

2011-SCA-9 E & S DIVERSIFIED SERVICES, INC., MAYFIELD EVANS, BARRY EVANS, JACQUELINE EVANS, and WILLIE EVANS,
Decision and Order Debaring Respondents (ALJ Oct. 18, 2012) (Gee) PDF

2011-CBV-1 OCEAN SHIPHOLDINGS INC. AND AMERICAN MARITIME OFFICERS
Order Granting Motion of Ocean Ship, Inc. to Dismiss Claim of Marine Engineers' Beneficial Association, AFL-CIO (ALJ July 13, 2011)(Reilly)PDF
 Final Decision and Order (ARB Jan. 23, 2013) PDF | HTM

2011-CBV-2 NEVER QUIT ENTERPRISES, INC. (NQEI) and SERVICE EMPLOYEES INTERNATIONAL UNION/NATIONAL ASSOCATION OF GOVERNMENT EMPLOYEES (SEIU/NAGE), LOCAL 679
Decision and Order (ALJ Dec. 12, 2011)(Kirby)PDF

2011-CBV-3 INTEGRITY NATIONAL CORPORATION
Decision and Order (ALJ Dec. 15, 2011)(Avery) PDF

2012-CBV-1 BAE SYSTEMS, INC.
Decision and Order (ALJ Feb. 14, 2012)(Geraghty) PDF
2011-SCA-13 CHESTER VINCH d/b/aVINCH’S PI & SECURITY
Decision and Order (ALJ May 15, 2012) (Romano) PDF