FMCSA - Federal Motor Carrier Safety Adminstration

Search Google Appliance

National Trends

FMCSA relies on its State partners to provide crash and inspection data each month. Improving the quality of every State’s safety data will result in a more effective use of our Nation’s enforcement resources.

FMCSA & State users:

Data current as of September 23, 2016

National Trends: Crash Consistency Overriding Indicator

No Flag
49
Red Flag
2
Insuf Data
0
The national Crash Consistency Overriding indicator results show the number of States within each rating. A State’s consistency indicator is based on the estimated number of non-fatal crash records reported. The crashes evaluated occurred between 07/01/2015 and 06/30/2016. Learn how this rating is calculated.
info
Why this matters

It is important to ensure that all crash records are reported to FMCSA. Crash records are used by the SMS to assess carrier safety performance and prioritize carriers for interventions that pose the greatest safety risk. 

background arrow
What to do next
Make sure that you understand the Crash Consistency Overriding indicator and the rating.
  • Use the NFCC Tool.
  • Select another measure from the drop-down menu above.
  • Click on a measure within a State's pop-up window to view State-specific results.
  • Contact a FMCSA Data Quality Specialist to ask questions.

You can also explore other resources in the Help Center.

Crash Consistency Overriding Indicator: Percentage of State-Reported Non-Fatal Crash Records
State Rating Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Avg # Records Reported
over Previous 3 Years
Total # Records
Jul. 1, 2015 - Jun. 30, 2016
Estimate Reported for Current Year
Jul. 1, 2012 - Jun. 30, 2013 Jul. 1, 2013 - Jun. 30, 2014 Jul. 1, 2014 - Jun. 30, 2015
National N/A 139,305 156,345 161,046 152,233 163,662 108%
Alabama
Year 12,784
Year 23,594
Year 34,088
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years3,489
Total # Records4,256
Estimate Reported for Current Year122%
Alabama Green Circle - No Flag 2,784 3,594 4,088 3,489 4,256 122%
Alaska
Year 1104
Year 295
Year 3115
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years105
Total # Records81
Estimate Reported for Current Year77%
Alaska Green Circle - No Flag 104 95 115 105 81 77%
Arizona
Year 12,413
Year 22,593
Year 32,818
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years2,608
Total # Records3,217
Estimate Reported for Current Year123%
Arizona Green Circle - No Flag 2,413 2,593 2,818 2,608 3,217 123%
Arkansas
Year 12,268
Year 22,505
Year 32,560
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years2,444
Total # Records2,250
Estimate Reported for Current Year92%
Arkansas Green Circle - No Flag 2,268 2,505 2,560 2,444 2,250 92%
California
Year 110,437
Year 211,383
Year 312,581
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years11,467
Total # Records13,595
Estimate Reported for Current Year119%
California Green Circle - No Flag 10,437 11,383 12,581 11,467 13,595 119%
Colorado
Year 11,836
Year 22,110
Year 32,128
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years2,025
Total # Records1,798
Estimate Reported for Current Year89%
Colorado Green Circle - No Flag 1,836 2,110 2,128 2,025 1,798 89%
Connecticut
Year 1800
Year 2937
Year 31,089
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years942
Total # Records1,986
Estimate Reported for Current Year211%
Connecticut Green Circle - No Flag 800 937 1,089 942 1,986 211%
Delaware
Year 1485
Year 2590
Year 3588
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years554
Total # Records541
Estimate Reported for Current Year98%
Delaware Green Circle - No Flag 485 590 588 554 541 98%
District of Columbia
Year 1424
Year 2481
Year 3310
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years405
Total # Records148
Estimate Reported for Current Year37%
District of Columbia Red Flag 424 481 310 405 148 37%
Florida
Year 14,865
Year 26,745
Year 37,573
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years6,394
Total # Records8,596
Estimate Reported for Current Year134%
Florida Green Circle - No Flag 4,865 6,745 7,573 6,394 8,596 134%
Georgia
Year 15,147
Year 25,197
Year 34,693
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years5,012
Total # Records5,761
Estimate Reported for Current Year115%
Georgia Green Circle - No Flag 5,147 5,197 4,693 5,012 5,761 115%
Hawaii
Year 1185
Year 2159
Year 3192
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years179
Total # Records177
Estimate Reported for Current Year99%
Hawaii Green Circle - No Flag 185 159 192 179 177 99%
Idaho
Year 1683
Year 2589
Year 3686
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years653
Total # Records747
Estimate Reported for Current Year114%
Idaho Green Circle - No Flag 683 589 686 653 747 114%
Illinois
Year 15,520
Year 27,894
Year 37,385
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years6,933
Total # Records3,005
Estimate Reported for Current Year43%
Illinois Red Flag 5,520 7,894 7,385 6,933 3,005 43%
Indiana
Year 14,213
Year 25,136
Year 35,249
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years4,866
Total # Records5,427
Estimate Reported for Current Year112%
Indiana Green Circle - No Flag 4,213 5,136 5,249 4,866 5,427 112%
Iowa
Year 11,700
Year 22,062
Year 31,933
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years1,898
Total # Records2,085
Estimate Reported for Current Year110%
Iowa Green Circle - No Flag 1,700 2,062 1,933 1,898 2,085 110%
Kansas
Year 11,701
Year 21,710
Year 31,700
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years1,704
Total # Records1,666
Estimate Reported for Current Year98%
Kansas Green Circle - No Flag 1,701 1,710 1,700 1,704 1,666 98%
Kentucky
Year 12,894
Year 23,038
Year 33,291
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years3,074
Total # Records3,299
Estimate Reported for Current Year107%
Kentucky Green Circle - No Flag 2,894 3,038 3,291 3,074 3,299 107%
Louisiana
Year 13,529
Year 23,689
Year 33,893
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years3,704
Total # Records3,955
Estimate Reported for Current Year107%
Louisiana Green Circle - No Flag 3,529 3,689 3,893 3,704 3,955 107%
Maine
Year 1703
Year 2789
Year 3877
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years790
Total # Records753
Estimate Reported for Current Year95%
Maine Green Circle - No Flag 703 789 877 790 753 95%
Maryland
Year 12,267
Year 22,067
Year 32,326
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years2,220
Total # Records2,780
Estimate Reported for Current Year125%
Maryland Green Circle - No Flag 2,267 2,067 2,326 2,220 2,780 125%
Massachusetts
Year 12,584
Year 22,550
Year 31,194
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years2,109
Total # Records1,571
Estimate Reported for Current Year74%
Massachusetts Green Circle - No Flag 2,584 2,550 1,194 2,109 1,571 74%
Michigan
Year 14,265
Year 25,359
Year 35,215
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years4,946
Total # Records4,434
Estimate Reported for Current Year90%
Michigan Green Circle - No Flag 4,265 5,359 5,215 4,946 4,434 90%
Minnesota
Year 12,537
Year 23,036
Year 32,484
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years2,686
Total # Records2,385
Estimate Reported for Current Year89%
Minnesota Green Circle - No Flag 2,537 3,036 2,484 2,686 2,385 89%
Mississippi
Year 11,451
Year 21,649
Year 31,708
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years1,603
Total # Records1,860
Estimate Reported for Current Year116%
Mississippi Green Circle - No Flag 1,451 1,649 1,708 1,603 1,860 116%
Missouri
Year 13,475
Year 23,944
Year 34,120
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years3,846
Total # Records4,704
Estimate Reported for Current Year122%
Missouri Green Circle - No Flag 3,475 3,944 4,120 3,846 4,704 122%
Montana
Year 1654
Year 2696
Year 3629
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years660
Total # Records603
Estimate Reported for Current Year91%
Montana Green Circle - No Flag 654 696 629 660 603 91%
Nebraska
Year 11,130
Year 21,210
Year 31,198
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years1,179
Total # Records1,191
Estimate Reported for Current Year101%
Nebraska Green Circle - No Flag 1,130 1,210 1,198 1,179 1,191 101%
Nevada
Year 1425
Year 2387
Year 3370
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years394
Total # Records464
Estimate Reported for Current Year118%
Nevada Green Circle - No Flag 425 387 370 394 464 118%
New Hampshire
Year 1328
Year 2366
Year 3423
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years372
Total # Records422
Estimate Reported for Current Year113%
New Hampshire Green Circle - No Flag 328 366 423 372 422 113%
New Jersey
Year 15,975
Year 26,147
Year 36,062
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years6,061
Total # Records6,164
Estimate Reported for Current Year102%
New Jersey Green Circle - No Flag 5,975 6,147 6,062 6,061 6,164 102%
New Mexico
Year 1896
Year 2696
Year 3915
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years836
Total # Records658
Estimate Reported for Current Year79%
New Mexico Green Circle - No Flag 896 696 915 836 658 79%
New York
Year 14,480
Year 24,887
Year 35,591
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years4,986
Total # Records6,153
Estimate Reported for Current Year123%
New York Green Circle - No Flag 4,480 4,887 5,591 4,986 6,153 123%
North Carolina
Year 16,230
Year 26,625
Year 38,058
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years6,971
Total # Records9,572
Estimate Reported for Current Year137%
North Carolina Green Circle - No Flag 6,230 6,625 8,058 6,971 9,572 137%
North Dakota
Year 1767
Year 2762
Year 3790
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years773
Total # Records530
Estimate Reported for Current Year69%
North Dakota Green Circle - No Flag 767 762 790 773 530 69%
Ohio
Year 15,074
Year 26,720
Year 37,472
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years6,422
Total # Records7,180
Estimate Reported for Current Year112%
Ohio Green Circle - No Flag 5,074 6,720 7,472 6,422 7,180 112%
Oklahoma
Year 13,030
Year 23,359
Year 33,623
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years3,337
Total # Records3,206
Estimate Reported for Current Year96%
Oklahoma Green Circle - No Flag 3,030 3,359 3,623 3,337 3,206 96%
Oregon
Year 11,567
Year 21,577
Year 31,585
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years1,576
Total # Records1,726
Estimate Reported for Current Year110%
Oregon Green Circle - No Flag 1,567 1,577 1,585 1,576 1,726 110%
Pennsylvania
Year 14,521
Year 26,293
Year 37,530
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years6,115
Total # Records7,466
Estimate Reported for Current Year122%
Pennsylvania Green Circle - No Flag 4,521 6,293 7,530 6,115 7,466 122%
Rhode Island
Year 1199
Year 2226
Year 3240
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years222
Total # Records234
Estimate Reported for Current Year105%
Rhode Island Green Circle - No Flag 199 226 240 222 234 105%
South Carolina
Year 12,430
Year 22,743
Year 33,097
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years2,757
Total # Records2,867
Estimate Reported for Current Year104%
South Carolina Green Circle - No Flag 2,430 2,743 3,097 2,757 2,867 104%
South Dakota
Year 1361
Year 2378
Year 3314
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years351
Total # Records364
Estimate Reported for Current Year104%
South Dakota Green Circle - No Flag 361 378 314 351 364 104%
Tennessee
Year 13,483
Year 23,648
Year 33,558
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years3,563
Total # Records4,080
Estimate Reported for Current Year115%
Tennessee Green Circle - No Flag 3,483 3,648 3,558 3,563 4,080 115%
Texas
Year 116,932
Year 217,442
Year 316,557
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years16,977
Total # Records17,117
Estimate Reported for Current Year101%
Texas Green Circle - No Flag 16,932 17,442 16,557 16,977 17,117 101%
Utah
Year 11,388
Year 21,425
Year 31,447
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years1,420
Total # Records1,540
Estimate Reported for Current Year108%
Utah Green Circle - No Flag 1,388 1,425 1,447 1,420 1,540 108%
Vermont
Year 1208
Year 2228
Year 3260
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years232
Total # Records224
Estimate Reported for Current Year97%
Vermont Green Circle - No Flag 208 228 260 232 224 97%
Virginia
Year 13,971
Year 23,989
Year 34,191
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years4,050
Total # Records4,308
Estimate Reported for Current Year106%
Virginia Green Circle - No Flag 3,971 3,989 4,191 4,050 4,308 106%
Washington
Year 11,709
Year 21,786
Year 31,844
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years1,780
Total # Records2,139
Estimate Reported for Current Year120%
Washington Green Circle - No Flag 1,709 1,786 1,844 1,780 2,139 120%
West Virginia
Year 1981
Year 21,016
Year 31,108
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years1,035
Total # Records985
Estimate Reported for Current Year95%
West Virginia Green Circle - No Flag 981 1,016 1,108 1,035 985 95%
Wisconsin
Year 12,405
Year 22,740
Year 32,468
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years2,538
Total # Records2,446
Estimate Reported for Current Year96%
Wisconsin Green Circle - No Flag 2,405 2,740 2,468 2,538 2,446 96%
Wyoming
Year 1891
Year 21,098
Year 3920
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years970
Total # Records946
Estimate Reported for Current Year98%
Wyoming Green Circle - No Flag 891 1,098 920 970 946 98%

Good - Green CircleNo Flag

Estimated Reported is >= 50%

Poor - Red FlagRed Flag

Estimated Reported is < 50%

Insuf - Gray CircleInsufficient Data

State has < 15 records reported in current timeframe AND State has < 15 records reported in previous 3 year average AND Estimate Reported is <= 50%

Data Source: MCMIS non-fatal crash records for 12 months representing interstate, intrastate, and non-motor carriers, and includes large trucks and buses.
How this rating is calculatedClose Popup

The Crash Consistency Overriding Indicator evaluates 12 months of data to determine your State’s rating. A record is evaluated if the date of the crash event—not the date of upload to FMCSA—falls within that 12-month range. As shown below, the range begins 15 months before the evaluation month, but excludes the most recent three months of data. In the example below, the January 2015 evaluation looked at the 12-month event date range November 1, 2013, through October 31, 2014; crashes that occurred after October 31, 2014, were not included in the evaluation.

evaluation period

This indicator evaluates non-fatal crash records representing interstate, intrastate, and non-motor carriers, and includes large trucks and buses.

The rating percentage is determined by dividing the number of non-fatal crash records in the current evaluation period by the average number of non-fatal crash records in the previous 3 years. If the percentage of non-fatal crash records reported is

  • 50% or more, your State is NOT FLAGGED
  • Less than 50%, your State is RED-FLAGGED.
  • Less than 50%, AND there are fewer than 15 records in the current evaluation period, AND there are fewer than 15 records in the previous three year average, the rating is INSUFFICIENT DATA.

Note: States that have an obvious and significant decline in non-fatal crash record reporting will be categorized as Poor in the Overall State Rating and the Crash Rating, without regard to their rating in other measures.

Why this MattersClose Popup

Data Quality Improvement Resources

Use DataQs to request and track a review of Federal and State data issued by FMCSA that you believe may be incomplete or incorrect.

Connect with a Data Quality Specialist for insight on training and tools to understand and improve data quality.

Close Popup
Login Now FMCSA & State users

Complete data quality results are available to FMCSA and State users who are logged into A&I Online. Once logged in, you will have full access to reports and tools for improving safety data.

Continue to the FMCSA Portal to log in. Click on "A&I (SMS)" from the list of 'Available FMCSA Systems' and then on "Data Quality" to return to this module.