PHMSA Public Meetings and Documents
Time: 10/31/2016 11:57 PM

Managing Challenges with Pipeline Seam Welds

Final Summary Report

Final Summary Report: Here

Meeting Information
Status Completed
Starts Jul 20, 2011 at 8:00 EDT
Ends Jul 20, 2011 at 5:00 PM
Location The Westin Arlington Gateway
Purpose & Summary

Recent pipeline incidents involving seam weld anomalies are driving a stronger focus on better managing these challenges. PHMSA and the National Association of Pipeline Safety Representatives (NAPSR) are holding this important event after a careful and thorough review of inspection reporting and incident findings. In addition, this event is another measure in PHMSA's efforts to address the Secretary of Transportation's "Call to Action to Address Pipeline Infrastructure Risks, Drive for More Aggressive Safety Efforts and to Be More Transparent when executing these Safety Measures."

This event is designed to provide an open forum for exchanging information on the challenges associated with pipeline seam welds. Specifically the forum will facilitate individual, panel and working group discussions for the following objectives:

  1. Further determining "What is the nature and extent of the issue?" from industry and government data.
  2. Presenting perspectives on how anomalies in seam weld are identified and managed employing risk assessments, technology and standards or best practices.
  3. Presenting the scope of a recently awarded PHMSA research study on Seam Welds.
  4. Providing specifically designed working groups to further craft the scope for this PHMSA research study and other related topics.
Results

Final Agenda


Good Morning/Welcome

Event Moderator: Jeff Wiese, Associate Administrator for Pipeline Safety, DOT/PHMSA

Panel 1: What is the Nature/Extent of the Issue?

Panel Moderator: Alan Mayberry, Deputy Associate Administrator for Pipeline Field Operations, DOT/PHMSA

U.S. Federal Regulator: Jeff Gilliam, Director, Engineering and Research Division, DOT/PHMSA
U.S. State Regulator: Randy Vaughn, Program Specialist, Texas Railroad Commission
Canadian Federal Regulator: Joe Paviglianiti, Technical Leader, Engineering, National Energy Board
Liquid Pipelines: Peter Lidiak, Director, Pipeline Segment, American Petroleum Institute
Gas Transmission Pipelines: Terry D. Boss, Vice President, Environment, Safety & Operations, Interstate Natural Gas Association of America
Gas Trans/Distribution Pipelines: Bruce Paskett, Principal Compliance Engineer, NW Natural

Pipe Manufacturer: Alex Afaganis, Technical Sales Manager, EVRAZ Inc. NA

Panel 2: Identifying/Managing Seam Weld Challenges

Panel Moderator: Linda Daugherty, Deputy Associate Administrator for Pipeline Policy & Programs, DOT/PHMSA

Liquid Pipelines: Mike Palmer, Enterprise Products Partners (Q&A only no presentation)
Liquid Pipelines: Michael Pearson, Magellan Midstream Partners
Gas Transmission Pipelines: Sergio Limon, Mgr. Pipeline Integrity Group, Williams Pipeline
Gas Transmission Pipelines: Chris Whitney, Manager, Pipeline Services East, El Paso Pipeline Group
Pipe Manufacturer: Stephanie Sanders, Berg Steel Pipe

Independent Technology Expert: Marc Lamontagne, Lamontagne Pipeline Assessment Corporation

Presentation: Seam Weld Research Project and Input/ Refinement of this Targeted Research

Event Moderator: Jeff Wiese, Associate Administrator for Pipeline Safety, DOT/PHMSA

Researcher: Brian Leis, Battelle Memorial Institute

KMAP - Longitudinal Weld Threat Analysis - Noel Duckworth, Director, Integrity Management, Products Pipelines, Kinder Morgan Energy Partners

Working Group 1: Identifying Gaps in Risk Assessments (Concurrent Session)

WG Leader: Terry D. Boss, Vice President for Environment, Safety, and Operations, Interstate Natural Gas Association of America

Topics Most Likely Covered:
  • How do gaps in data impact risks with seam weld challenges?
  • How do you know you do not have remaining threats from seam welds?
  • Are there recommended practices that are relevant here or needed?

Working Group 2: Identifying Gaps in Technology

WG Leader: Mark Piazza, Senior Program Manager, Pipeline Programs, PRCI

Topics Most Likely Covered:
  • What technologies are available for detecting and characterizing seam weld threats?
  • What is the effectiveness and the limitations of current in-line inspection crack tools with respect to finding and characterizing ERW seam anomalies?
  • What suggested improvements can be made to the in-line inspection guidance tables in API 1160, NACE 0102, and ASME B31.8S?

Speaker 1: John Beavers, DNV
Speaker 2: Pat Vieth, BP

Speaker 3: Bruce Nestleroth, Battelle Memorial Institute

Working Group 3: Identifying Gaps with Assessment Methods

WG Leader: W. Kent Muhlbauer, WKM Consultancy

Topics Most Likely Covered:
  • How do you know which assessment method is the correct one to use?
  • What are the pro/cons for available assessment methods?
  • How can hydrostatic testing procedures (including "spike" tests) in API1110 or in 49 CFR192 and 49 CFR195 be improved to eliminate potentially growing small flaws before they grow large enough to fail in service?
  • How can improved modeling approaches better predict failure pressures when using ASME B31G, API 579, and NG-18 for mitigating selective seam corrosion pressure-cycle-induced fatigue?

Speaker 1: Doug Chabino, Magellan Midstream Partners
Speaker 2: David M. Wilson, ConocoPhillips Pipe Line Company
Speaker 3: Harvey Haines, Kiefner and Associates, Inc.
Speaker 4: Mark Stephens, C-FER Technologies

Speaker 5: Weixing Chen, University of Alberta


Feedback

Please feel free to email Robert Smith (robert.w.smith @ dot.gov) about how we can provide high quality events in the future.

Files
 File Type08/19/2011: Final Summary Report
FINAL_-_Seam_Weld_Event_Summary_Report.pdf (2,087 KB)
  [View]  [Download/Save...] [File #290]
 File Type07/17/2011: 
Seam_-_Agenda-Handout.pdf (100 KB)
  [View]  [Download/Save...] [File #245]
 File Type07/25/2011: 
Alex_Afaganis.pdf (849 KB)
  [View]  [Download/Save...] [File #280]
 File Type07/25/2011: 
Brian_Leis.pdf (92 KB)
  [View]  [Download/Save...] [File #279]
 File Type07/29/2011: 
Bruce_Nestleroth.pdf (1,749 KB)
  [View]  [Download/Save...] [File #287]
 File Type07/25/2011: 
Bruce_Paskett.pdf (551 KB)
  [View]  [Download/Save...] [File #278]
 File Type07/25/2011: 
Chris_Whitney.pdf (1,417 KB)
  [View]  [Download/Save...] [File #277]
 File Type07/28/2011: 
D_Chabino.pdf (559 KB)
  [View]  [Download/Save...] [File #285]
 File Type07/28/2011: 
D_Wilson.pdf (318 KB)
  [View]  [Download/Save...] [File #284]
 File Type07/28/2011: 
H_Haines.pdf (800 KB)
  [View]  [Download/Save...] [File #282]
 File Type07/25/2011: 
Jeff_Gilliam.pdf (781 KB)
  [View]  [Download/Save...] [File #276]
 File Type07/25/2011: 
Joe_Paviglianiti.pdf (945 KB)
  [View]  [Download/Save...] [File #275]
 File Type07/29/2011: 
John_Beavers.pdf (2,109 KB)
  [View]  [Download/Save...] [File #286]
 File Type07/28/2011: 
M_Stephens_.pdf (109 KB)
  [View]  [Download/Save...] [File #281]
 File Type07/25/2011: 
Marc_Lamontagne.pdf (232 KB)
  [View]  [Download/Save...] [File #274]
 File Type07/25/2011: 
Mike_Pearson.pdf (157 KB)
  [View]  [Download/Save...] [File #273]
 File Type07/25/2011: 
Noel_Duckworth.pdf (312 KB)
  [View]  [Download/Save...] [File #272]
 File Type07/29/2011: 
Patrick_H__Vieth.pdf (52 KB)
  [View]  [Download/Save...] [File #288]
 File Type07/25/2011: 
Peter_Lidiak.pdf (66 KB)
  [View]  [Download/Save...] [File #271]
 File Type07/25/2011: 
Randy_Vaughn.pdf (2,373 KB)
  [View]  [Download/Save...] [File #270]
 File Type07/25/2011: 
Sergio_Limon.pdf (495 KB)
  [View]  [Download/Save...] [File #269]
 File Type07/25/2011: 
Stephanie_Sanders.pdf (513 KB)
  [View]  [Download/Save...] [File #268]
 File Type07/25/2011: 
Terry_Boss.pdf (854 KB)
  [View]  [Download/Save...] [File #267]
 File Type07/28/2011: 
W_Chen.pdf (1,401 KB)
  [View]  [Download/Save...] [File #283]
 File Type07/25/2011: 
Wiese_Slides_-_Battelle.pdf (182 KB)
  [View]  [Download/Save...] [File #266]
 File Type07/25/2011: 
Wiese_Slides_-_Morning.pdf (192 KB)
  [View]  [Download/Save...] [File #265]
PHMSA Home | Pipeline Safety Website | Feedback | Privacy Policy | FOIA