Guardian Global Development

Should the UK cut aid to India? | Poll

UK development secretary Justine Greening is working on plans to cut back British aid to India. Is she right?

  • theguardian.com,
  • Jump to comments ()
A fruit vendor struggles to cross a road with his cart in the rain in Bangalore, India.
A fruit vendor struggles to cross a road with his cart in the rain in Bangalore, India. Photograph: Aijaz Rahi/AP

The UK government is firming up plans to make substantial cuts to British aid to India, worth £280m a year. International development secretary Justine Greening says it's better to refocus Britain's relations with India on trade.

UK aid to India has long been contentious. In 2011 a group of British MPs said that despite its huge economic growth India should receive aid until 2015 to ensure it meets the millennium development goals.

Yet many have questioned whether UK aid is working. Pranab Mukherjee, then the Indian finance minister, said in February that Delhi did not need UK aid but had agreed to accept it under pressure from Britain.

What do you think? Vote in our poll and join the conversation in the comment thread below.

Should the UK cut aid to India?

  Yes India is a rapidly growing economy with its own space programme; the UK can no longer justify spending aid there
  No India is still grappling with major development issues and is home to many of the world's poor people
  Maybe Aid to India is a political tool and supports Britain's strategic interests. It must be considered alongside all other UK policies involving the country
  Partially UK aid should be cut back, better targeted to achieve results, and only eliminated gradually with an 'exit strategy'

This poll is now closed

Today's best video

;