Could Iran’s Ancient Democratic Tradition Resurface?

Recently the U.S. government – for the first time ever – imposed sanctions on individuals inside Iran for human rights abuses.  Noting the human rights abuses revolving around Iran’s disputed 2009 presidential election and Iranian protestors, the White House said the United States “will always stand with those in Iran who aspire to have their voices heard.”

That there are many Iranians who are risking their lives to speak out against injustice, suggests that there is a deep and strong desire for freedom and, perhaps, a democratic government.

Several years ago, I interviewed a well-known Iranian blogger who believed democracy – Iranian style – could develop in the land of his birth.  Arash Sigarchi pointed out to me that some 2,500 years ago, King Cyrus the Great of the Achaemenid Empire, which included much of modern Iran, issued the first charter for human rights.

“Even though democracy and human rights can hardly be imagined coming from a king, many kings in Iran’s past history have done this,” Sigarchi said.

There is little memory of a remotely democratic Iran among most Westerners, but there are a host of scholars who believe it is possible.  And Iranians themselves look for information on forming democratic societies: online courses such as Tavaana cater to this demand.

Iranian youth do in fact desire democracy, if Farbod Khoshtinat, award winning Democracy Is… video producer is to be believed.  The artist and self-proclaimed “freedom fighter” says his people are “all in the quest for democracy.”

¿Por qué hablar acerca de los niños en el conflicto? / Why talk about children in the conflict?

Today’s guest author is Colombian Juan Pablo Patiño Arévalo, winner of the 2010 Democracy Video Challenge. You can read his entry in either Spanish or English, and you can watch his award-winning video, “Democracy is the right of life,” on the Democracy Video Challenge website.

Para construir memoria es necesario ser concientes de nuestra realidad. Este proyecto se puede entender como una crítica a la vinculación de niños al conflicto armado en el mundo, empezando por Colombia, país donde nace mi documental Osos Abandonados.

De otro lado, es importante que este proyecto se enmarque como un proceso artístico. De acuerdo con Susan Sontag, “el arte del presente ha de ser empleado como un nuevo instrumento –como un instrumento para la modificación de la conciencia y para el desarrollo de nuevas formas de sensibilidad” (SONTAG, 1980, p.288). Es decir, valerse del arte como un mecanismo de sensibilidad e instrumento modificador de la conciencia.

Debo mencionar la existencia de normativas legales y estatutos vigentes de protección, que son tenidos en cuenta por distintos gobiernos, como es el caso de Colombia. Sin embargo, se hace necesaria la presencia de diferentes mecanismos de observancia externos para garantizar su cumplimiento.

El 20 de noviembre de 1999 UNICEF realizó la convención por los derechos de los niños, en la que definió el concepto de niño de la siguiente manera: “La Convención define como “niño” o “niña” a toda persona menor de 18 años, a menos que las leyes de un determinado país reconozcan antes la mayoría de edad. En algunos casos, los Estados tienen que ser coherentes a la hora de definir las edades para trabajar y para hacer parte del sistema educativo. La Convención es estricta en casos como la condena a pena de muerte estableciendo la prohibición para menores de 18 años”. (Unicef, 1999)

Esta Convención presenta normas que contemplan que los niños son seres humanos, individuos miembros de una familia y una comunidad, con derechos y responsabilidades apropiados para su edad. Esto permite tenerlos en cuenta como seres integrarles cuyos derechos son fundamentales.

Pero estas normas parecen no ser conocidas por los actores del conflicto. Los problemas del manejo de la información han llevado también a que no existan cifras consolidadas sobre el tema en Colombia. Organizaciones como Crin y Human Rights Watch sostienen lo siguiente:

“En Colombia no existen cifras verificables sobre la cantidad de niños que hacen parte de los grupos armados que toman parte en las hostilidades; sin embargo, los datos más conservadores afirman que pueden estar entre 8.000 y 13.000. Se cree que al menos uno de cada cuatro combatientes es menor de 18 años y, en ocasiones, esta población puede llegar a ser más del 30% en ciertas unidades armadas. Sus edades de vinculación oscilan entre los 7 y los 17 años, con un promedio de edad de ingreso de los 13,8 años”. (ORGANIZACIÓN CRIN, 2007)

“En nuestra opinión, la cifra total de niños combatientes en Colombia supera probablemente los 11.000, siendo este un cálculo conservador que puede subestimar significativamente la cantidad real”. (HUMAN RIGHTS WATCH, 2004)

Teniendo en cuenta esta breve introducción ¿por qué no trabajar por una niñez que está en peligro? Nosotros podemos cambiar el mundo y debemos actuar.

Citas:

• SONTAG, S. (1980). Die Enheit der Kultur und die neue Erlebnisweise. (One Culture and the new sensibility). En Kunst and Antikunst. Munchen, Alemania.
• UNICEF. (1999). Unicef. From Unicef: http://www.unicef.org.co/10-temas.htm
• ORGANIZACIÓN CRIN. (13 de Julio de 2007). Child Rights Information Network. Retrieved 2008 from CRIN: http://www.crin.org/resources/infodetail.asp?id=14012
• HUMAN RIGHTS WATCH. (2004). Aprenderás a no llorar. Bogotá, Colombia: Editorial Gente Nueva.

To build consciousness, we must first be aware of our reality. My work takes a critical look at the conscription of children into armed conflict worldwide, starting with Colombia, where my documentary, Osos Abandonados (Lost Innocence), was created.

This project is also an artistic process. According to Susan Sontag, “Art today must be used as a new instrument, an instrument for modifying consciousness and developing new forms of sensitivity” (Sontag, 1980, p.288). That is to say, we should use art as a sensitizing mechanism and awareness-raising tool.

I should mention that legal regulations and statutes have been established to protect children during times of conflict, and these laws are acknowledged by governments, as is the case in Colombia. However, these regulations require external monitoring in order to ensure compliance.

On November 20, 1999, UNICEF held the convention for the rights of children, which defined the notion of children as follows: “The Convention defines “boy” or “girl” as any person under the age of 18, unless the laws of a specific country recognize adulthood at an earlier age. In some cases, states must be consistent in defining the age to work and become part of the education system. The Convention is stricter in cases such as the death penalty, prohibiting its infliction on anyone under 18″. (UNICEF, 1999)

This Convention affirms that children are human beings, individual members of a family and community, with rights and responsibilities appropriate to their age. This allows them to be counted as integral beings with fundamental rights.

But these rules seem to be unknown to the actors of the conflict. Problems with information management mean there are no firm data about the situation in Colombia. However, organizations like Crin and Human Rights Watch contend that,

“In Colombia there are no verifiable figures on the number of children who are part of armed groups taking part in hostilities, however, the most conservative data suggest that it could be between 8,000 and 13,000. It is believed that at least one in every four combatants is under 18 and that at times this percentage may grow to more than 30% in certain armed units. Their conscription ages range from 7 to 17, with an average conscription age of 13.8.” (CRIN ORGANIZATION, 2007)

“In our opinion, the total number of child combatants in Colombia likely exceeds 11,000, this being a conservative estimate that may significantly underestimate the actual amount”. (HUMAN RIGHTS WATCH, 2004)

Given this brief introduction, why not work for children at risk? We can change the world and we must act.

Bibliography:

• SONTAG, S. (1980). Die Enheit der Kultur und die neue Erlebnisweise. (One Culture and the new sensibility). En Kunst and Antikunst. Munchen, Alemania.
• UNICEF. (1999). Unicef. From Unicef: http://www.unicef.org.co/10-temas.htm
• ORGANIZACIÓN CRIN. (13 de Julio de 2007). Child Rights Information Network. Retrieved 2008 from CRIN: http://www.crin.org/resources/infodetail.asp?id=14012
• HUMAN RIGHTS WATCH. (2004). Aprenderás a no llorar. Bogotá, Colombia: Editorial Gente Nueva.

Child Soldiers – It Impacts All of Us

The use of children as soldiers is most prevalent in countries torn by conflict in Africa, as well as in Afghanistan, Burma and Colombia, according to the United Nations, but it’s a human rights violation that affects all of us, as I learned while researching a series of stories I did on the topic.

The children themselves – and there are hundreds of thousands of them, by some estimates – are, of course, a primary concern.  Forced into service most frequently by militias, they are frequently killed or injured during combat and universally brutalized by their leaders.

Even after the conflict is over, they have a hard time being reintegrated into their home communities.  The special needs of child soldiers, who usually represent the poorest of the poor, are a real burden to the families and communities to which they return. Girl soldiers — and there are a surprising high number of them — have an especially hard time adjusting to normal life, especially if they have children by the men who conscripted them.

But the issue of child soldiers is a global security concern as well, according to Peter Warren Singer, who has written a book about the topic.  According to Singer, the use of child soldiers makes conflicts easier to start, harder to end and peace agreements more difficult to maintain.

Nations need to have a “hard interest” in stopping the use of child soldiers, Singer told me in an interview, because doing so provides the mechanism to shrink the pool of failed states and areas terrorists can exploit.

Democracy Video Challenge winner Juan Pablo has provided his personal take on child soldiers.  What are your thoughts on how the issue affects you?

This week on By the People we will be featuring blog entries and information related to the issue of child soldiers.  Check back tomorrow for a guest entry from Democracy Video Challenge winner Juan Pablo on this topic.  It will be available in English and in Spanish.

Ask the Democracy Video Challenge Winners a Question

The winners of the Democracy Video Challenge

After meeting Secretary Clinton in Washington, DC and traveling to New York City, the six winners of this year’s Democracy Video Challenge are now heading across the country to Los Angeles.  Among their many stops on the west coast will be a panel discussion on engaging global audiences through social media with Dr. Nancy Snow Associate Professor of communications at California State University, and Democracy Video Challenge representative Rudy Gharib from the US Department of State.

But they need your help!  Leave a question for the winners (Or a specific winner – Yared Shumete, Ethiopia; Adhyatmika, Indonesia; Joel Marsden, Spain; Farbod Khoshtinat, Iran; Anup Poudel, Nepal; Juan Pablo Patiño Arévalo, Colombia) in the comments section of this blog post.  We’ll select a few of your questions to ask the winners during the Q&A portion of their panel discussion. 

The panel event will take place tomorrow, September 21, 2010 from 6:00pm – 7:00pm Los Angeles time at the University of Southern California’s Davidson Conference Center (3415 South Figueroa Street, Los Angeles, CA 90089).  You can also watch the panel on U-stream as well as on the Democracy Video Challenge Facebook Page.  The panel is part of Social Media Week.  See their website for more information.  

So, what do you want to ask the Democracy Video Challenge winners?

Secretary Clinton Meets with Democracy Video Challenge Winners

Last Friday at the State Department in Washington, D.C., the six winners of this year’s Democracy Video Challenge received their awards and met with Secretary of State Hillary Clinton. A crowd of State Department officials and representatives of the winning countries gathered to watch the ceremony.

Speaking about the winners, who come from Colombia, Ethiopia, Indonesia, Iran, Nepal, and Spain, Secretary Clinton said they are “giving voice to millions of others.” Their videos, she added, “capture essential truths about democracy around the world.”

The Democracy Video Challenge asks filmmakers to create a short video that completes the phrase, “Democracy is…” A panel of experts selected the finalists and the public voted for the winners on YouTube.

What’s next for our six winners? Today they head to New York City, where they will show their films at the United Nations, meet with representatives from New York University’s film school, and enjoy some free time to explore the Big Apple. Then they go to Los Angeles to meet with representatives from Hollywood’s film and television industries, participate in a panel discussion as part of the Social Media Week program, and screen their films at the Director’s Guild of America.

Video of the awards ceremony:

[video href="http://www.america.gov/multimedia/video.html?videoId=607796035001"]

What Do You Think Democracy Is?

David Shelby is the director of the State Department’s Office of Member Communities, which uses social media to engage overseas audiences.

When an unlikely group of partners set out two years ago to take the global pulse on democracy, we had no idea what sort of response we’d get. The group, which included everything from Hollywood filmmakers to democracy advocates to the U.S. government, asked the world to tell us what “Democracy is…” Thousands of videos and photos and tweets later, the one thing we can say for certain is that there are a lot of opinions on the matter. And while it was kind of cool that Kurdish Prime Minister Barham Salih participated in our Twitter contest, the thing I find most inspiring about the “Democracy is…” project is the response we’ve received from young people.

Thousands of young people from more than 130 countries around the world have answered our question. And the answers are as varied as the places they come from. Some talk about the benefits of democracy in their societies. Some talk about the flaws in their political systems. Others, from closed societies, talk about their aspirations to experience rights and freedoms they’ve only heard about.

This year’s winners run the spectrum. The winners from Nepal and Ethiopia talk about the ideals of democracy – diversity and fairness. The winner from Spain proposes a single worldwide democracy where everyone gets a vote. The winner from Indonesia takes an ironic and amusing look at the imperfections in his own democracy.

But the two I find the most haunting are those that explore life where democracy is curtailed. Juan Pablo Patiño from Colombia shows us the wrenching experience of a child whose life is torn apart by a senseless guerrilla war, and Farbod Khoshtinat from Iran paints a stunning portrait of what he and a whole generation of young Iranians are demanding of their government.

[video href="http://www.america.gov/multimedia/video.html?videoId=97110197001"]

And as inspiring as these videos are, there are hundreds more. You should check out all the finalists and semifinalists. It’s great to see that young people around the world have so much to say. And if you want to hear more about their opinions, you can follow the conversation on our Facebook page. We’d love to hear what you have to say, too!

Democracy Video Challenge 2010 Winner: Adhyatmika

Adhyatmika

Adhyatmika

Adhyatmika sees film as a medium that transcends geography, race and age.

Born in Jakarta, Adhyatmika is a graduate of the Puttnam School of Film, Lasalle College of The Arts in Singapore. He developed a passion for filmmaking while still in high school and his work has since been featured at international film festivals.

Intrigued by the Democracy Video Challenge topic, Adhyatmika said democracy is a subjective term that is not easily defined. He “played around” with the idea and “created a rather surreal satirical comedy about democratic life in Indonesia….Democracy is not a thing,” he said, “it’s a process.”

Watch Adhyatmika’s video.

Democracy Video Challenge Winner: Juan Pablo Patiño Arévalo

Juan Pablo Patiño Arévalo

Juan Pablo Patiño Arévalo

Juan Pablo Patiño Arévalo is a visual arts professional at the Javeriana University of Bogotá who has studied at the School of Cinema and Television in Cuba and the National University of Bogotá.

His works include Los Fantasmas Del Palacio (The Ghosts Of The Justice) (2007) about the takeover of the Justice Palace in Colombia by the guerrilla group M19, Justos X Pecadores (Just For Sinners) (2008) about animal rights in Colombia, and Osos Abandonados (Lost Innocence) (2009) about war children in Colombia.

His documentaries have been screened at film festivals in Colombia, Brazil and the Czech Republic.

Watch Democracy is the Right of Life, his video entry for the 2010 Democracy Video Challenge.

Democracy Video Challenge 2010 Winner: Anup Poudel

Anup Poudel

Anup Poudel

Anup Poudel is the son of a politician from Kathmandu, Nepal. He credits his father’s involvement in three democratic movements in Nepal with inspiring him to create his entry for the 2010 Democracy Video Challenge.

“The internal conflict in Nepal, political instability and several crises have degraded the sovereignty of the people. Therefore, I used this video to unite the people for this mutual goal,” he says.

The 20-year-old Poudel says he has always had a passion for film and arts. “Filmmaking gives me two wings to fly through my imagination,” he says.

Poudel is currently working on a bachelor’s degree in film studies and has made a number of other films, including a prize-winning one on climate change called My Green Home.

Watch Poudel’s video entry for the 2010 Democracy Video Challenge.

Democracy Video Challenge 2010 Winner: Joel Marsden

Joel Marsden is a writer, producer and director who has worked on television and film projects in the United States, South America, Europe, the Middle East, Asia and Africa.

Joel Marsden

Joel Marsden

His works include the feature film Ill-Gotten Gains, about an uprising aboard an illegal American slave ship in 1869, and the feature documentary film World Vote Now, which deals with the construction of the first global democratic system.

“For the last eight years I have been actively collaborating with an international team of democracy activists with the goal of constructing the first World Vote, where every man and every woman on the planet can have an equal voice. The Democracy Video Challenge offers a great opportunity to spread our message of global democracy,” he says.

Watch Marsden’s video entry for the 2010 Democracy Video Challenge.