Archive for December, 2011

A casual consumer somewhat in a hurry

 

Sound familiar at Christmas time? ‘Tis the season when trade-marks play a critical role in millions of buying choices of millions of consumers. So where is the line between two marks that appear similar, for similar products? With all due respect, the Supreme Court of Canada is not known for being succinct, but I have to admit this quote from the top court does capture the issue, and in this context the term “provenance” refers to source, or which company the products come from:

  • “Trade-marks in Canada are an important tool to assist consumers and businesses. In the marketplace, a business marks its wares or services as an indication of provenance. This allows consumers to know, when they are considering a purchase, who stands behind those goods or services. In this way, trade-marks provide ashortcut to get consumers to where they want to go” […]  Where the trade-marks of different businesses are similar, a consumer may be unable to discern which company stands behind the wares or services. Confusion between trade-marks impairs the objective of providing consumers with a reliable indication of the expected source of wares or services. […] “

That is the essence of trade-mark law in Canada.

A recent case from the Federal Court (MÖVENPICK HOLDING AG v. EXXON MOBIL CORPORATION, 2011 FC 1397) has reiterated this concept, in a battle between the marks Marché Express for fast-food items sold at a convenience store, and Marché for restaurant services. The court stated that “The test to be applied is a matter of first impression in the mind of a casual consumer somewhat in a hurry who sees the [mark], at a time when he or she has no more than an imperfect recollection of the [prior] trade-marks …” Ultimately, the court decided that there was no confusion, partly since the term “Marché” was commonly used in this industry, indicating that consumers are accustomed to seeing the word and will use relatively small differences to distinguish between trade-marks.

ipblog.ca will be taking a break until January… So, for all those casual consumers somewhat in a hurry, slow down and have a great holiday!

Calgary - 07:00 MST

No comments

iPhone App Trips Over Copyright

 

Copyright complaints against apps are now common, and this one frames the issues nicely: In Shanti Deva Korpi v. Apple Inc. , 1:11-cv-00906- LY (U.S. District Court) a photographer who posts her photos to Flikr, has filed a lawsuit against Apple, claiming that two iOS apps - one of which was entitled “Unofficial Guide to Hipstamatic” - engaged in a practice of scraping and republishing her photos, without authorization or attribution. According to the claim, this is a violation of copyright.

In Canada, the recent decision of the B.C. Supreme Court in Century 21 Canada Ltd. Partnership v. Rogers Communications Inc., deals directly with this issue (see my commentary Coming to terms with online copyright published in the November 25, 2011 issue of the Lawyers Weekly). The B.C. case is not an app-related dispute, but the court makes it clear that copyright will be enforceable in situations where content (including images) is scraped off the internet, and is then repackaged and republished without authorization.

Calgary - 07:00 MST

No comments

Business Method Patents: Canadian Update

 

In September, 1998, Amazon applied to patent its 1-click check-out, an invention officially entitled “Method and System For Placing A Purchase Order Via A Communication Network” (Canadian Patent Application No. 2,246,933). In Canada, the patent office refused to grant the patent because it didn’t consider the invention to be patentable under the Canadian Patent Act. Amazon appealed that refusal and in 2010 the Federal Court reversed the patent office’s decision and effectively ordered the patent to be issued. The patent office still refused to grant the patent, and appealed the case up to the Federal Court of Appeal. In a decision in November 2011, the Federal Court of Appeal handed down its decision in Attorney General of Canada et al v Amazon.com, Inc., 2011 FCA 328. The appeal court has confirmed that business methods are patentable in Canada and there is no basis under Canadian law for excluding business methods from patentability in Canada.

Related Reading:

CIPO’s Software & Business Method Patent Guidelines

Business Method Patents in Canada

Calgary - 07:00 MST

1 comment

RIM’s BBX Trade-mark Woes

 

The BlackBerry maker can’t get a break these days. On December 6th, an American company obtained a Temporary Restraining Order, from a US court barring RIM from using the mark BBX in association with software. The lawsuit is based on the registered trade-mark BBX owned by BASIS International Ltd. This has caused an embarassing renaming of RIM’s new operating system to BlackBerry 10.

Lessons for business?

  • Trade-mark screening searches are critical when launching a new brand. Searches can be conducted country-by-country, and search services can screen top markets with quick “knock-out” searches to quickly determine availability.
  • Sure, RIM has been beat up a bit by the markets recently, but it’s still a global titan in the mobile devices and software industry… but that didn’t stop a rival software maker from taking on a trade-mark fight. That’s because BASIS had registered trade-marks in its arsenal.  Without the benefit of a trade-mark registration, this fight would have been much more costly and time-consuming and the outcome would have been much different.
  • Think about timing and territory - in this case, the preliminary injunction was rushed to court because of the BlackBerry Developer’s Conference in Asia on December 7 and 8, where the BBX mark would have been used extensively by RIM. Does a US court have jurisdiction to issue an order to a Canadian company regarding the use of its mark in Singapore? You might think the answer is no, but an American judge will have a different view. Faced with the US order, RIM decided to re-brand. 

Calgary - 07:00 MST

No comments

Copyright Week

 

For all the IP junkies out there, this is copyright week at the Supreme Court of Canada. Five copyright cases are being heard this week tackling such issues as the copyright in music contained within downloadable games, fair dealing exceptions, and streaming music online. Break out the popcorn, you can even watch the webcast!  

Calgary - 07:00 MST

No comments

Are Non-Competition Restrictions Enforceable?

This is the second in our 3-part employment law series.

Employees are often asked to sign a set of “restrictive covenants” as part of their employment agreement. This is the case in many competitive industries, and particularly in technology companies. These clauses can include non-competition restrictions, non-solicitation obligations, and other restrictions which bind the employee after termination. In Globex Foreign Exchange Corporation v. Kelcher , 2011 ABCA 240, the Alberta Court of Appeal reviewed the enforeability of these clauses. This case provides guidance for drafting and imposing restrictive covenants. Here is a summary of some of the court’s most important findings:

  • Restrictive covenants can fail due to the “lack of consideration”. The employee has to receive something of real benefit in exchange for agreeing to be bound to the restriction. An employer who wants to impose a restrictive covenant in the middle of the employment relationship must take special care, since continued employment alone does not provide sufficient consideration for a new restriction to be imposed during the term of employment. This is because the employer is already required to continue the employment until there are grounds for dismissal or reasonable notice of termination is given.
  • Non-solicitation and non-competition covenants are not enforceable unless they are reasonable. What’s reasonable will depend upon the circumstances of the industry, the employer and the employee. For one of the ex-employees in this case, the court found that the restriction was unreasonably wide, because it prevented him from soliciting any customer for a period of 18 months. In other words, this restriction was not limited to customers with whom the ex-employee had a relationship during employment. The employer in this case had no legitimate interest in protecting this category of customers from solicitation by the ex-employee.
  • An employer remains free to dismiss an employee at any time provided there is just cause, or there is reasonable notice of termination, or payment in lieu of notice. If none of these occurs, then the employee has been wrongfully dismissed, and wrongful termination renders the restrictive covenants unenforceable. In other words, an employee who is not terminated for just cause, or given reasonable notice or payment in lieu cannot be held to the non-competition or non-solicitation restrictions that appear in the employment agreement.

Lessons for business? Review your restrictive covenants with experienced counsel. Carefully consider the process of introducing new employment terms in the middle of an employment relationship. And handle terminations very carefully to avoid the problems of wrongful dismissal.

Calgary - 07:00 MST

No comments

Online Defamation: Injunctions Against Google in Canada

Courtesy of GoogleHow easy is it to get an injunction against Google? In Nazerali v. Mitchell, a man complained of online defamation, and obtained a preliminary injunction against the author of the allegedly defamatory content, the hosting company (Nozone, Inc.), the domain name registrar (GoDaddy) and Google. The Court ordered the injunction, which included the order prohibiting Google “from permitting the Google.com or Google.ca search engines from returning any search result from www.deepcapture.com.”  Essentially this results in shutting down the (allegedly) offending website, since the court considered it ”impossible surgically to eliminate just the offending phrases”. While this seems to be a dramatic result, considering it was obtained on an ex-parte basis (the other side did not appear at the hearing), it is not without precedent in Canada. 

In Canadian National Railway Company v. Google Inc., 2010 ONSC 3121 (CanLII), the court issued an interim injunction requiring Google to remove a blog hosted on Google’s Blogspot platform.

The injunction in Nazerali v. Mitchell was time-limited and is set to expire tomorrow (December 2).

Hat tip to Alan Macek for highlighting this case.

Calgary - 07:00 MST

No comments

buy no perscription Orlistat i want to buy prednisone without a perscription order prednisone free next day airprednisone on line buy Buspar without a rx what does Orlistat look like buy discount Crestor on line accutane no prescription overnigh Generic Cytotec tablets (Metformin espana|purchase Metformin|Metformin ohne rezept|Metformin pills|what is Metformin used for|price of Metformin|best buy Metformin|Metformin preis|medikament Metformin|what does Metformin look like|buy Metformin c o d|Metformin 1000 mg|generic Metformin online|Metformin purchase|best buy Metformin|buy Metformin usa|where to buy Metformin|Metformin rezept|Metformin mexico|buy Metformin with no prescription|buy Metformin canada|where to buy Metformin|buy Metformin cheap without prescription|comprare Metformin generico|discount Metformin|buy Metformin online no rx|Metformin purchase|pharmacy Metformin|comprar Metformin generico|uk Metformin generic|Metformin toronto|pharmacy Metformin|Metformin price|cheap Metformin online|buy Metformin without prescription|buy Metformin where|Metformin online purchase|buy Metformin online|online Metformin|online Metformin purchase|uk order Metformin|how to buy Metformin without a prescription|order Metformin withou buy Valtrex legally purchase Crestor without prescription needed I want a finasteride perscription buy Crestor cash on delivery pay cytotec cytotec no prescription with mastercard buy Premarin on line amex prednisone online pharmacy order Valtrex free next day airValtrex on line purchase Valtrex without a rx online buy Valtrex in the uk Buy accutane with visa buy cialis where can i purchase synthroid 200 mcg mastercard without a prescription buy Accutane 40mg where can i purchase zithromax online Flomax usa purchase Crestor overnight where to buy Xenical no prescription purchase rx Amitriptyline without buy Amitriptyline line how to buy finpecia online without a rx buy generic finpecia purchase Crestor free consultation buy genuine Buspar buy Crestor without prescription buy cheap generic Zithromax online buy cheap Zithromax with dr. prescription purchase Buspar no visa online without prescription cialis online now buy Cytotec online buy Atarax amex purchase cheap Atarax online online Atarax order buy Atarax online buying Cytotec online best Zovirax online pill purchase accutane online purchase Buspar without prescription to ship overnight 20 mg cialis cialis buy canada newyork generic cialis cialis no prescription usa cialis overnight Metformin to buy next day delivery on Xenical saturday purchasing Flomax online without prescription Premarin mexico purchase cheap prescription Valtrex buy generic Zovirax how to buy Valtrex without a prescription valtrex overnight Crestor fedex no prescription prednisone 40 mg online valtrex generic pharmacy iframe Metformin effects what is Metformin Buy Valtrex from usa without a perscription order cheap Zithromax online How to get a prednisone perscription buy Premarin pay cod order Premarin order amex Premarin buy Buspar no doctors prescription buy Crestor Online cheap Adobe Creative Suite 6 Master Collection Canada prednisone no perscription purchase prednisone money purchase Buy xenical overnight shipping Proscar buy next day delivery on Valtrex saturday i want to buy pregnizone without a prescription buy Xenical without prescription buy Flomax diet pills prescription xenical online buy cialis online 20 mg cialis buy 10 mg cialis order Accutane without a rx overnight shipping i want to order Accutane without a perscription purchase Valtrex without prescription to ship overnight buy Valtrex pills prezzo Orlistat purchase Flomax online without script buy cheap valtrex without prescription order prednisone pay pal online without rx generic nexium without a precsriptions cialis purchase no rx needed for purchasing finasteride purchasing Crestor online without prescription free fedex delivery Valacyclovir finasteride online prescriptions with no membership buy Amitriptyline 75 mg Zithromax overdose Zithromax online prescription buy Premarin paypal without rx order generic Proscar Crestor canada Orlistat 120 mg buy line Orlistat prednisone without a perscription order Zithromax online how to buy Proscar online without rx usa buy cialis buy cilais cheap cialis buy cialis no prescription buy cialis usa online generic cialis online usa buy cialis online 20mg purchase Prednisone online no membership buy Cytotec over the counter cod overnight buy cialis usa cialis no prescription order Valtrex no prescription cheap xenical no script no prescription required xenical buy Nizoral with no prescription Nizoral cash on delivery buy Buspar without a rx overnight delivery Cipro uk Buspar price Adobe Acrobat X Pro buy Microsoft Office 2010 Professional Plus canadian pharmacy no prescription prednisone buy cheap Prednisone buy nexium online 40 mg no prescription buy cheap generic valtrex online order Xenical without a prescription overnight shipping achat Flomax achat Finasteride ambien online purchase prednisone without prescription from us pharmacy order finasteride online from mexico generic 120mg Xenical online order Buspar free next day airBuspar on line Acomplia buy online buy Prednisone pills in toronto where to buy generic Prednisone online without a prescription buy xenical online without a prescription order generic xenical online no prescription Premarin toronto Buspar for pets prednisone to buy in canada nexium generic sale Valtrex drug order no prescription Valtrex generic Cytotec tablets Cipro capsule cheapest Acomplia available online Prednisone cod next day delivery buy Xenical sale Microsoft Windows 7 Ultimate purchasing Maxalt without a script buy Rosuvastatin cheap online wholesale Crestor cheap purchase cheap Orlistat cod free fedex cialis now buy cialis online