[Constitution, Jefferson's Manual, and the Rules of the House of Representatives, 105th Congress] [105th Congress] [House Document 104-272] [Jeffersons Manual of ParliamentaryPractice] [Pages 244-247] [From the U.S. Government Printing Office, www.gpo.gov] sec. xxxviii.--equivalent questions.
Sec. 484. Former practice as to rejection and second reading of bills. | If, on a question for rejection, a bill be retained, it passes, of course, to its next reading. Hakew., 141; Scob., 42. And a question for a second reading, determined negatively, is a rejection without further question. 4 Grey, 149. And see Elsynge's Memor., 42, in what case questions are to be taken for rejection. |
Sec. 485. Equivalent questions in general. | Where questions are perfectly equivalent, so that the negative of the one amounts to the affirmative of the |
Sec. 486. Equivalent questions on amendments between the Houses. | A bill originating in one House is passed by the other with an amendment. A motion in the originating House to agree to the amendment is negatived. Does there result from this a vote of disagreement, or must the question on disagreement be expressly voted? The question respecting amendments from another House are--1st, to agree; 2d, disagree; 3d, recede; 4th, insist; 5th, adhere. |
Sec. 487. The motions to agree and disagree as related to motions to amend. | 1st. To agree; 2d. To disagree.--Either of these concludes the other necessarily, for the positive of either is exactly the equivalent to the negative of the other, and no other alternative remains. On either motion amendments to the amendment may be proposed; e.g., if it be moved to disagree, those who are for the amendment have a right to propose amendments, and to make it as perfect as they can, before the question of disagreeing is put. |
Sec. 488. No equivalent questions on motions to recede, insist, and adhere. | 3d. To recede.--You may then either insist or adhere. 4th. To insist.--You may then either recede or adhere. |