Anderson: Biologists refining attack on Asian carp

  • Article by: DENNISANDERSON , Star Tribune
  • Updated: August 22, 2012 - 7:55 AM
hide

An Asian silver carp

Photo: Ramin Rahimian, Star Tribune

CameraStar Tribune photo galleries

Cameraview larger

  • share

    email

A federal research fish biologist specializing in Asian carp, Duane Chapman is in the Twin Cities this week attending the American Fisheries Society gathering in St. Paul.

Chapman works for the U.S. Geological Survey in Columbia, Mo., and is at the forefront of the nation's fight against Asian carp. He and other federal scientists, as well as those from various states and academia, are attempting to find the Achilles' heel of bighead, silver and other, similar evil critters.

"Asian carp are not magical,'' Chapman said. "These fish can be controlled. But it won't be easy. And there likely will be ecological and economic consequences to controlling them, when we figure out how to do it.''

In an attempt to understand which types of rivers are suitable for Asian carp spawning, Chapman and his colleagues raise these fish in their Missouri laboratory.

"In the U.S., Asian carp live mostly in rivers,'' he said, "but they actually prefer lakes when they're not spawning.''

Silver, bighead, grass and black carp generally require highly turbulent water for spawning.

"Turbulent waters are needed because if the eggs sink to the bottom, they can die,'' Chapman said. He and other USGS scientists are studying which U.S. rivers not already infested might be vulnerable to carp expansion.

"We're also trying to develop [chemicals] that will be toxic only to Asian carp,'' he said.

Because Asian carp are very long-lived, they can experience back-to-back poor spawning years and still multiply their numbers.

"We'd like to be able to control their big year classes of reproduction,'' Chapman said. "We have some ideas how to do that. But we need to go out and test them.''

Asian carp seem particularly vulnerable when they are young and measure only between 1 and 10 centimeters long.

"That's a bottleneck for these fish, most years,'' Chapman said.

So attacking them at that early life juncture might be best. Is eradication of Asian carp possible in the U.S.?

Perhaps not, Chapman said.

Restricting their expansion might be the best we can hope for, because controlling them once their populations are established will "take a long time and a lot of willpower.

"And it won't be free.''

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions
  • share

    email

ADVERTISEMENT

Atlanta 92 4th Qtr 11:00
Orlando 56
San Antonio 74 4th Qtr 11:38
Cleveland 75
Charlotte 54 3rd Qtr 3:17
Indiana 63
Chicago 36 3rd Qtr
Boston 35
Denver 57 3rd Qtr
Brooklyn 62
Washington 45 3rd Qtr
Detroit 44
Toronto 37 3rd Qtr
New York 42
Philadelphia 42 2nd Qtr 6:06
Milwaukee 29
Portland 16 2nd Qtr 6:17
New Orleans 26
Utah 26 2nd Qtr 5:15
Minnesota 25
Sacramento 10 1st Qtr 7:08
Dallas 14
Houston 9:30 PM
LA Clippers
Ottawa 2 3rd Prd
Pittsburgh 2
St. Louis 3 2nd Prd 11:03
Detroit 2
Dallas 8:30 PM
Calgary
Western Mich 52 2nd Half 3:35
Bowling Green 62
Toledo 54 2nd Half 0:56
Buffalo 74
Wake Forest 59 2nd Half 4:40
Boston College 56
Syracuse 49 2nd Half 3:33
Connecticut 59
Radford 65 2nd Half 5:47
Va Military 63
Rice 67 2nd Half 0:21
Marshall 71
Richmond 52 2nd Half 5:05
Saint Josephs 53
Nebraska 43 2nd Half 3:15
Indiana 68
UNC-Wilmington 80 2nd Half 1:29
William & Mary 85
Ohio 82 2nd Half 0:39
Central Mich 61
Oklahoma State 87 2nd Half 5:09
Texas Tech 60
Akron 61 2nd Half 2:50
Eastern Mich 52
UMBC 62 2nd Half 4:54
New Hampshire 62
Miami-Florida 57 2nd Half 6:55
Florida State 53
Ole Miss 61 2nd Half 3:43
Texas A&M 65
La Salle 57 2nd Half 2:10
St Bonaventure 57
Liberty 67 2nd Half 7:15
Campbell 56
Army 81 2nd Half 3:55
Lafayette 56
UAB 61 FINAL
East Carolina 74
Fordham 51 2nd Half 5:03
Xavier 61
Gardner-Webb 58 2nd Half 4:07
UNC-Asheville 60
High Point 75 2nd Half 2:37
Longwood 49
Coastal Carolina 56 2nd Half 0:56
Presbyterian 48
Colgate 60 2nd Half 0:19
Bucknell 68
Dayton 59 2nd Half 4:00
Rhode Island 65
DePaul 66 2nd Half 0:52
Notre Dame 66
Char Southern 36 2nd Half 7:09
Winthrop 49
Charlotte 60 2nd Half 2:59
Butler 53
Delaware 64 2nd Half 3:20
Northeastern 65
Hofstra 35 2nd Half 7:12
Georgia State 48
Miami-Ohio 65 2nd Half 2:45
Kent State 84
American Univ 47 FINAL
Lehigh 60
Hartford 35 2nd Half 17:59
Maine 30
Arizona State 22 2nd Half
Utah 29
Ball State 28 1st Half 2:56
Northern Ill 19
Missouri 34 1st Half 1:31
Miss State 10
Iowa State 32 1st Half 1:53
Texas 29
Tennessee 40 2nd Half
Vanderbilt 28
Tulane 21 2nd Half
Southern Miss 31
Texas-El Paso 28 1st Half 1:33
Houston 38
UCF 30 1st Half 2:50
Memphis 34
Drake 16 1st Half 1:08
Wichita State 27
Creighton 22 1st Half 3:25
Northern Iowa 27
Evansville 20 1st Half 3:52
Southern Ill 28
Bradley 31 2nd Half
Illinois State 32
West Virginia 8:00 PM
Baylor
Nevada 8:00 PM
Wyoming
UNLV 8:00 PM
Air Force
Providence 8:00 PM
South Florida
Purdue 8:00 PM
Illinois
North Carolina 8:00 PM
Duke
Arkansas 8:00 PM
Auburn
Oregon State 9:00 PM
Washington St
New Mexico 9:00 PM
Fresno State
San Diego St 9:00 PM
Colorado State
UC Riverside 9:00 PM
UC Irvine
Cal State Fullerton 10:00 PM
Long Beach State
Oregon 10:00 PM
Washington
George Washington 56 FINAL
Fordham 66
Saint Louis 46 FINAL
La Salle 49
Rhode Island 45 FINAL
Temple 56
St Johns 65 FINAL
South Florida 59
Western Ky 62 2nd Half 0:14
Florida Atlantic 61
Holy Cross 35 FINAL
Navy 59
Lehigh 62 2nd Half 4:00
American Univ 54
Lafayette 54 2nd Half 0:39
Army 66
Bucknell 49 2nd Half 0:38
Colgate 55
Quinnipiac 60 2nd Half 1:35
Central Conn St 50
(25) Oklahoma St 57 2nd Half 3:20
West Virginia 52
Villanova 63 FINAL
Seton Hall 34
Butler 49 FINAL
Charlotte 59
New Hampshire 47 2nd Half 0:39
UMBC 56
Wright State 66 2nd Half 0:12
Detroit 73
Georgia Southern 52 FINAL
Western Carolina 63
Marquette 52 2nd Half 1:22
Cincinnati 49
Stony Brook 53 2nd Half 8:30
Binghamton 46
Boston U 56 FINAL
Vermont 47
Maine 56 FINAL
Hartford 82
Indiana 42 FINAL
Michigan State 72
Saint Josephs 49 2nd Half 6:45
Duquesne 40
Kansas 25 1st Half 1:12
TCU 46
Texas 22 2nd Half
Kansas State 33
Valparaiso 25 2nd Half
Loyola-Chicago 34
Houston Baptist 26 2nd Half
Lamar 36
Louisiana 21 2nd Half
South Alabama 29
Ark-Little Rock 25 2nd Half
Arkansas State 23
Fresno State 8:00 PM
New Mexico
Wyoming 8:30 PM
Nevada
Air Force 9:00 PM
UNLV
Colorado State 9:00 PM
San Diego State

Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

question of the day

Poll: Do you favor Minnesota's managed wolf hunt?

Weekly Question
 
Close