Afghanistan 2011 versus A
where the experts come to talk
This month in
NATO Review
Afghanistan 2011 versus Afghanistan 2001: the same country?
Afghanistan. A country that suffers from a murderous group of religious fanatics. From endemic poverty. And from lack of infrastructure or development. But is this description of 2001 Afghanistan still apt for 2011 Afghanistan?
Coming up next in
NATO Review
Don't miss it!
Optimized
for iPhone

2014: New Afghanistan's year zero?
2014 promises to be one of the most important years for Afghanistan in decades. As the country prepares to take the full lead for its own security following the draw down of international forces, NATO Review asks three experts about how pivotal they see the year.

Where now for Afghanistan? Interview with Ahmed Rashid
Pakistani journalist and best-selling author, Ahmed Rashid, shares his views on the Afghan economy, corruption, the perceptions of Afghans on the year 2014, and the way ahead.

Was it worth investing in Afghanistan?
Can we compare an Afghanistan of beheadings and torture to today’s? Mr. Shafiq Hamdam looks at the Afghanistan he has seen. He concedes it’s not yet perfect. But concludes that it’s come a long way.

Afghanistan: 10 years of missed opportunities?
Nelofer Pazira has seen the many faces of Afghanistan. And while there has been progress, she feels that the country is yet to escape its cycle of suffering. Here she charts her experiences and impressions, from living there in the turbulent 1980s to visiting today’s Afghanistan.

Afghanistan: what’s gone right, what’s gone wrong
Dr. Sima Samar was the Minister of Women's Affairs of Afghanistan from 2002 to 2003. The fact that the job even existed showed the difference in Afghanistan from Taliban rule. But how successful have other initiatives been during the last 10 years?

Imagine being an Afghan-American in September and October 2001. Both your countries were attacked. One by the other. How did Afghan-Americans react? Where were their allegiances? And what could they do to help both countries? We asked an Afghan-American how he dealt with this dilemma.
In 2008, NATO Review asked award-winning Afghan blogger Nasim Fekrat to illustrate how he saw his country. This month, as the country marks the 10th anniversary of the start of operations to oust the Taliban, we ask him what the biggest changes have been in the Afghanistan he knows.
Afghanistan is a photojournalist's paradise. The light and colours make for great photos. The people make for engaging subjects. And the country's stories make for a gripping tale. Here, we publish some of the most striking images.
Trainers play the central role in transition to Afghans leading Afghan security. Lieutenant General William Caldwell was the first man to head up the training mission designed to give Afghan trainers the skills they need. As he prepares to leave his post, he gives an assessment of what's been achieved - and what remains to be done.
New to NATO Review?

Most people can remember where they were on 9/11. Far fewer have the same clear memories of the start of operations against Afghanistan.

But that date marked the beginning of the longest war in the history of the United States. Longer than Korea, Vietnam or Iraq. It also led to NATO's longest ever operation.

Most people can remember where they were on 9/11. Far fewer have the same clear memories of the start of operations in Afghanistan.

But that date marked the beginning of the longest war in the history of the United States. Longer than Korea, Vietnam or Iraq. It also led to NATO's longest ever operation.

10 years ago, there was an alternative on the table. US President Bush asked the Taliban to hand over the al-Qaeda leaders in Afghanistan who had planned and funded the 9/11 attacks. They refused. So, while the Taliban had not been the original target, they now fell foul of President Bush's 'with us or against us' approach. The Taliban effectively decided to fight this war.

For Afghanistan, this was just another war in a history studded with wars. The Afghans had already seen off the British at the height of their empire; the Soviets when they controlled large parts of Europe and Asia. Now it would be America and its allies.

But few could have predicted how unpredictable this war would be. That it would move from a security-based issue to practically helping one of the world's poorest countries become a master of its own destiny at last.

In this edition of NATO Review, we look at how Afghans assess the last 10 years of their country. We also ask experts if what has been achieved is enough. And we look at how Afghanistan is approaching 2014, when it takes the full lead for its security.

Some have alleged that Afghanistan was neglected twice in recent years. The first time was after the defeat of the Soviet forces. The second was following the invasion of Iraq. Whatever other lessons are drawn from the last 10 years, one of the clearest is that we neglect Afghanistan again at our peril.

Paul King, Editor

quotes
Ahmad Shah Masood
Resistance leader and Afghan national hero
Newsletter
Make sure you don't miss a thing
We will not be a pawn in someone else's game,
we will always be Afghanistan!
About NATO Review
Go to
NATO A to Z
NATO Multimedia Library
NATO Channel
Share this
Facebook
Facebook
Twitter
Twitter
Delicious
Delicious
Google Buzz
Google Buzz
diggIt
Digg It
RSS
RSS
You Tube
You Tube