GOP rookies buck Grover Norquist
Grover’s grip may be loosening.
A small but increasingly vocal group of freshman Republicans are publicly rejecting the idea they are beholden to Grover Norquist’s Americans for Tax Reform pledge for their entire congressional careers.
Continue ReadingOne such member, Scott Rigell of Virginia, has openly rejected the pledge, explaining on his website that it would prevent Congress in some cases from eliminating corporate loopholes or government subsidies because those changes would have to be revenue-neutral. The math, he said, just doesn’t make sense.
And Reid Ribble (R-Wis.) told the Los Angeles Times he wouldn’t be signing the pledge again — or any pledge for that matter — not because he wants to raise taxes but because he wants to close certain loopholes to help pay down the deficit.
Rep. Allen West (R-Fla.) scoffed at the idea the pledge was some sort of blood oath. A number of other offices of freshman members told POLITICO their bosses had sworn oaths to do what was best for their districts, not Americans for Tax Reform.
“I signed that thing in the desert of Afghanistan,” West said in an interview. “I got home and they wanted me to sign again during my campaign, and I wouldn’t, and Grover started yelling at my campaign manager. Grover is a nice guy, but I think he’s a little misguided.”
“I don’t care if he has my name on his website, it’s meaningless,” West added. “I think my voting record speaks for itself.”
The tax pledge has long been a litmus test for any conservative who wants to be taken seriously in a Republican primary. That some newcomers are repudiating it lends support to critics who argue the document is more valuable as a campaign tool than a guidepost for governing.
Norquist insists he’s not bothered by any hedging on the part of the freshmen.
“I don’t lie awake at night thinking any of these characters are going to vote for a tax increase,” Norquist said. “The leadership is not going to bring it up. All but six Republicans in the House have signed the pledge and they have a 25-vote margin. It’s a moot point.”
But the slip in devotion, however slight, is notable considering how strong a hold the pledge has had over the GOP.
A handful of other freshman members privately told POLITICO they had been struggling with their ATR pledge signatures, as they felt it had become clear the pledge was a hindrance to certain tax reforms they’d like to see happen.
Some members aren’t backing off the pledge, but when asked about it, their offices didn’t glow with praise for Norquist.
Rep. Robert Dold (R-Ill.) pledged only “to do what’s best for his constituents back home,” said spokeswoman Stefani Zimmerman. And a spokesman for Rep. Trey Gowdy, one of the most conservative House freshmen, emphasized that, first and foremost, Gowdy has “taken an oath to uphold the Constitution,” though the congressman isn’t backing away from the pledge.
Make no mistake, these members are all opposed to tax increases. But many don’t seem to take much stock in the fact that Norquist has their signatures on a piece of paper.
Readers' Comments (85)
Wow did he really say "impure thoughts?" Looks like the GOP elitte is censoring thought now. Sound familiar?
How weak-minded would a politician have to be be influenced by this toad pimple of a human? They are so go-with-the-flow they get pushed into signing his ridiculous pledge? If I was one of politicians I'd tell him to go "f" himself, that I had better things to do with my time than cater to his losing concern.
If more republicans don't grow more backbones and throw this dude away, they are in for long-term failure.
These sheep wasted two years in government with a blood oath to Grover. I consider the House of tea party republicans as traitors to real Americans in the 99%.
These same sheep have no trouble protecting wall street banks, big oil/gas/coal subsidies, the koch boyz, rush the slut, and ill-advised bush cuts.
They are a disgrace. I have issues with the libertarians but at least they are true to their words and have America in mind not just some psychopathic corporations who are puppeteering the tea party republicans.
It is past time to throw this muslim sympathizer, Norquist, overboard. He is a mercenary with too much influence.
The Democratic message of who do you pledge to Glover or America is getting though.
Beside they have to be on their best behavior an election is coming up
Nobody wants to be a christine o'donnnell
Norquist is the epitome of the vile influence of lobbyists over DC.
The damage he has done in bringing about the destruction of the middle class, our debt worthiness, and the despair of the unenfranchised is inestimable. Grover should go straight to hell, he's diabolical and evil.
Grover Norquist sounds smug, like someone who knows he has the Republican Party by the short hairs.
The goal he once described is tantalizingly close, to shrink government so it can be drowned in a bathtub.
No noblesse oblige in Norquist's dog-eat-dog world.
If the elected officials now repudiating their signatures on Norquist's pledge don't return every cent of his campaign contributions, then they're not serious about standing up to him.
It's more likely they'll jump, again, the next time Norquist snaps his fingers as opposed to telling him to get lost.
That they put loyalty to Norquist's pledge above their sworn duty, taken with their Oath of Office, to uphold and defend the Constitution is a mark of shame they'll never be rid of.
Pledges are for Cub Scouts. The GOP Congressional boys are childish & spineless to being pledging allegence to the little toad Norquist.
My god, a conservative with a brain of his own? One that doesn't turn my stomach? Whats the world coming to?
I sent my Republican representative, Eric Paulsen, an email stating, "Any congress person who signed Grover Norquist's tax pledge should be voted out of office including you. You are supposed to represent your constituents not a lobbyist".
my goodness all the name calling, all the piling on.
yes grover may be all the things commenters allege here and by all means the pledge movement was a shallow, misguided and wildly successful movement.
but perhaps it would be better if we simply gave thanks for the first signs of responsibility being injected into this pledge signing silliness and keep an eye on these pledgers who have come to the light. their constituents at home have been sold the same tax rant bilgewater and the end goal of getting them to the light will require considerably more effort. just ask the koch brothers and rupert how much effort it takes to move that mountain.
your pledge is to your constituents, not some muppet looking character lobbying for the 1%.
Good for them because Norquist hates America. We have proof.
Grover Norquist is bosom buddies with the disgraced felon Jack Abramoff.
I don't really think that much more needs to be said.
Bad- Elected representatives signing a pledge to anything but the Constitution.
Worse- Said representatives later saying that their signing doesn't mean anything, thereby showing their word to be useless...
Bad- Elected representatives signing a pledge to anything but the Constitution.
Worse- Said representatives later saying that their signing doesn't mean anything, thereby showing their word to be useless...
Obama approved his bio for Harvard Law Review that stated he was born in Kenya.
Michelle Obama referred to Kenya as Obama's "home land"
And much more.
The time for playing games with this is over. The American People demand that congress investigate and hold official hearings.
Constitutional crisis.
It's that halarious! The CONSTITUENTS Grover, are the American people and the American people over whelmingly think that we need to raise taxes in order to have a balanced approach to our financial problems. So, NO! It's not a "promise to constituents" at all, it is a promise to YOU and those that YOU represent - the very wealthy.
You seem to think that the American public at large is quite ignorant - well, we are not and these people are finally realiziing that nothing can get done as long as our elected officials adhere to your "pledge". The only pledge these folks should be taking, as they are being paid with my tax dollars, is TO OUR COUNTRY!
You must be logged in to comment
Not yet a member?
Register Now