Official Site of the U.S. Air Force   Right Corner Banner
Join the Air Force

News > Commentary - Losing Your Future to Sexual Assault
Losing Your Future to Sexual Assault

Posted 9/6/2012   Updated 9/6/2012 Email story   Print story

    


Commentary by Col. Tom Posch
Air Force Legal Operations Agency


9/6/2012 - Joint Base Andrews, Md. (AFNS) -- "I knew the minute our eyes met that she was the 'one.' We exchanged numbers and set up a date. It was planned to perfection. She was the 'one.' And then she Googled me. . .and told me never to contact her again. That's life as a registered sex offender. My face, my name, my address...for the world to see: Sex Offender."

This is a very likely future for an Airman convicted of sexual assault. I know.
 
Since 1994, I've both prosecuted and represented Airmen charged in "Blue-on-Blue" crimes and all manner of sexual assaults. It happens that my memory of 9/11 was witnessing the attack on America and tragic loss of life on the news ... as I prepared my dress blues for the arraignment and trial of a client charged in the rape of a fellow Airman.

I've spent the better part of 18 years advising commanders, prosecuting cases, and representing Airmen charged with violating the Uniform Code of Military Justice. Currently, I am the chief appellate defense attorney in the Air Force. I lead a team of lawyers who defend Airmen after they've been convicted at a court-martial. It's our duty, as required by Article 70 of the UCMJ, to represent these Airmen, search for legal error in their cases, and advocate for their convictions to be overturned and their sentences set aside or reduced. This includes Airmen convicted of sexual assault, which I sadly say remains a large percentage of our docket.

As a matter of professional responsibility, it makes no difference to us whether or not our clients claim to be innocent or guilty -- our duty is to defend both equally well -- yes, even when they've confessed and pled guilty.

In plain speak, the Air Force is not our client, convicted Airmen are.

If you're concerned that my duties are in conflict with sexual assault prevention, don't be. In fact, the first thought I'll share with you is that there are not two sides to this problem. Yes, sides are taken in the courtroom, but nobody is "for" sexual assault or "against" accountability. "Zero tolerance" and potentially severe consequences for those who violate the law have been part of Air Force culture for many years. Accountability is the norm and not the exception. I see it every day at work and have for many years in different duties and settings.

Airmen convicted of a sexual offense face lifelong consequences. If the possibility of trial, conviction, jail, and a punitive discharge don't dissuade, consider the story at the beginning of this article. There's a high probability convicted Airmen will carry the label of "registered sex offender" for the rest of their lives. Sex offender registration allows federal and state law enforcement officers to monitor the location and activities of convicted sex offenders.

Airmen convicted of sexual assault at a court-martial are required to register in the state where they live, work, or attend school. Some states even require the offender to notify the registry if they are going on vacation in a different state. If the crime involved minors, state law may bar the offender from living or working near places where children frequent, such as a school, library, day-care center, or park.

Registration laws don't differentiate well between different types or degrees of sexual crimes, and some don't even try. Every state keeps a public registry of sex offenders. Many jurisdictions make this information available via a website or app, and may include the offender's full name, photograph and address.

These laws are designed as public-safety measures rather than additional punishment, but they can carry with them a substantial loss of freedom and liberty. After serving their sentences, Airmen often find it difficult to find a home or a job, and registration also impacts their freedom of association with families, friends and loved ones. What may not have been that big of a deal at age 19, can drastically alter your way of life when you're in your thirties and married with children. The consequences of a sexual assault conviction go far beyond the immediate sentence.

I share this perspective because prevention is better than prosecution. It's my hope that knowledge of the consequences may deter Airmen from a poor choice and a lifetime of regret. A sexual assault conviction is often just the beginning of a life of diminished freedom. Understanding the consequences today, may avert the sad outcome of this destructive crime and help our fellow Airmen before they fail or realize too late that such illegal conduct has lasting ramifications beyond the possibility of conviction, confinement, and a punitive discharge. It's important that Airmen think about the lifelong consequences of sexual assault now, not when having it explained to them by an attorney. This cannot be understated: sexual assault crimes last a lifetime for all involved.

Col. Tom Posch
Chief, Appellate Defense Counsel



tabComments
9/14/2012 5:08:56 AM ET
I have zero sympathy for convicted sex offenders. They leave scars - be it emotional or pysical- on their victims for the rest of their lives. If the sex offender has to suffer for the rest of their life too well that is only just.The military in general has done a rotten job of dealing with sexual assaults within the ranks. We treat anyone accused as automtically guilty while at the same time putting victims through the wringer - all while seemingly denying we have a problem. If nearly 1 in 5 women is assaulted in their career - yes we have a problem.Unfortunately opinions like Joe's in Arizona are seemingly common and don't help matters.
Karen, Undislosed Deployed
 
9/11/2012 2:46:09 PM ET
Notice the last paragraph people I share this perspective because prevention is better than prosecution. It's my hope that knowledge of the consequences may deter Airmen from a poor choice and a lifetime of regret.He is saying he would rather work to prevent the crime than have to deal with the results of the crime. Not just for the victims but also for the criminals. Most police organizations have crime prevention units. The author is pointing out more effort needs to be placed on letting Airmen know exactly what will happen once they commit the crime. This is the same method the Air Force has used sometimes with not so much success on DUI drug use and underage drinking.
Jerry, Oklahoma
 
9/11/2012 1:47:06 PM ET
Their crime doesn't last a lifetime, not in the least. Because they do not care, I had a supervisor come into my house over and over and even was trying to introduce his friends to me to get me into prostitution...and why because he didn't care. I am the one that lives in fear and nightmares since 1980... Why don't you try to help us? Yes I am a VET.
Veteran USAF, FL
 
9/10/2012 5:40:36 PM ET
Wow... some of you people really need to pay attention and comprehend before opening your mouths.
Brandon, Oklahoma
 
9/10/2012 3:59:00 PM ET
Then you get the people that scream rape or assault because they feel dirty after a night of consensual relations or have a dissagreement later on down the road and ruin the life of a perfectly innocent person. Not all of the people you're talking about are guilty sometimes it's the victim that should be getting the punishment. Our culture is so that whenever someone says rape its blindly believed that the offender is a freak and the worst kind of scum on the planet when this may not be the case at all. Hold your tongue and wait for the proof before you judge. Things arent always as they seem.
Joe, Arizona
 
9/9/2012 3:04:51 PM ET
Let me first say that I under no circumstances condone rape or the perpetrators. However I think this article hasn't been interpreted correctly. Obviously it brings a lot of emotion to the surface for victims and familyfriends of victims. If read entirely with emphasis on the last paragraph you would understand that the author is saying that if our airman werent just made knowledgable of reporting instructions but also the consequences that it might make an individual think twice before becoming a perpetrator. That if they knew the long term effects of the consequences that maybe it would deter a would be rapist. Which honestly makes sense to me but thats my perspective.
John Doe, Creech AFB NV
 
9/9/2012 12:14:07 AM ET
Wow. Just wow. I thought Air Force people were supposed to be smart Smart enough to read and comprehend Apparently not. The good colonel is attempting to lay out a fact based case -he's a lawyer after all- for why sexual assualt is bad. No glorification or excuse making for offenders just a breakdown of what the consequences can be. I'm guessing the target audience for this missive is that elite .01 percent of morons out there who don't already know sexual assualt is bad. Go back and re-read the 1st sentance of the last paragraph nice and s l o w so it sinks in.BTW if Col Posch was in my squadron his callsign would be Spice. Not relevant just saying.
Old Bear, Retired
 
9/8/2012 9:53:17 PM ET
Col Posch is not trying to pain anyone as a victim he is aiming for a 'scared straight' approach because right now the Air Force needs deterrents to sexual assault.
Sgt Whatshisface, not in jail
 
9/8/2012 3:04:53 PM ET
I think most of you are missing the point of the article he's not defending the actions he is trying to prevent people from doing it in the first place trying to get people to realize that when you commit this horrible crime it will affect your life as well as the victim. Read the last paragraph.
Grumpy, AK
 
9/8/2012 8:04:47 AM ET
I recognize this as an article simply warning airmen against committing the crime - a preventive law measure and not an attempt to victimize the perpetrator or create empathy. This is a good warning for those who are inclined to commit this heinous crime to think twice because these actions have far-reaching consequences.
AD Female Servicemember, USA
 
9/8/2012 8:03:51 AM ET
@Rob-- perhaps we should simply punish the accused without any type of investigation. Anything short of that will fail to satisfy you or the general public.
PeggedFunMeter, here
 
9/7/2012 4:26:44 PM ET
Obviously this is a very emotional issue and a horrible memory for a very long time for the victims. I believe it is unfair to attack the author as if he is supportive of heinous acts. His point was for all potential criminals to think before they act. I pray that God brings healing to all the victims.
Paul, SATX
 
9/7/2012 3:16:27 PM ET
It seems to me this story isn't calling for sympathy for the offenders but rather is meant to be a cautionary tale.
David, USA
 
9/7/2012 2:04:47 PM ET
There is no doubt a conviction via a courts martial will have huge consequences for an Airman. HOWEVER out of the over 3000 reported sexual assaults in 2011 LESS THAN 200 resulted in a conviction Source DoD. THIS IS UNACCEPTABLE A fancy article on the Air Force website is tough talk it is time for tough results.
Rob, USA
 
9/7/2012 1:18:19 PM ET
Col. Tom Posch As much as I understand your job and perspective from the offenders side I find your article insulting as a victim. Frankly as a victim I don't care how the offender is effected later in life. Have you ever talked to one of the victims later in life I am still a victim of my sexual assault at the hands of our acting 1st Sgt. during my AIT training in 1986. I have suffered from panic attack nightmares emotionally detached depressionfeeling hopeless can't sleep for fear of the nightmares distrust of everyone I avoid going place out of fear of being attacked I have trouble with male authority figures living in constant state of feeling isolated and disconnected from my boyfriend if 14 years because I can't trust enough to commit my children and the rest of my family. I have developed a eating disorder to make myself fat and unattractive to avoid drawing attention to myself. I live in a prison of fear on a daily basis a prison created b
Melissa Davis, Conroe Texas
 
9/7/2012 12:26:58 PM ET
Is this an Onion article or is this for real I'm so sorry the poor rapist has to register. What a hassle. Too bad his victim can't simply register every time he or she moves and deal with it in that manner. Too bad she has to think of the encounter every time there's a certain smell sight thought every second of every day. Perhaps an article focusing on teaching Airmen NOT to rape rather than teaching victims how not to get raped would be more appropriate. Shame on you. May you never have to face losing control of your will your life and your body. Shame on you.
Army Nurse, DC
 
9/7/2012 11:55:20 AM ET
thanks John Smith for your defense of the real victim. I have lived with the nightmare of what happened to me for over 30 years. I am a survivor so and person can never hurt me again.
JULIE HAMILTON, Washington
 
9/7/2012 11:16:45 AM ET
You mean the monsters that attacked a woman in the military are now playing victim I'm appalled.I have ZERO sympathy for rapists and those that attack our brave service members. They are torturers and should be treated like them by the justice system. Most of them re-offend after they get out of prison early on parole. I thought that the Air Force promised to improve their SAPRO program and do away with the victim is the rapist mentality This article is anti-Air Force and I am utterly ashamed.This man committed a crime against a member of the Air Force and I am suppose to have sympathy for him No way. Not a nice way to help a fellow airman by showing sympathy for her rapist. Sick.
Veteran, Arizona
 
9/7/2012 10:12:59 AM ET
I feel absolutely no remorse for people who commit the crime of rape sexual assault and sexual harassment. They have absolutely no remorse for how this affects their victims. They are sociopaths with no feelings for others. They manipulate everyone into thinking they are the victim. And quite frankly they made their bed and they need to sleep it in. This is what is wrong with the Air Force and all the other Armed Services. Empathy and sympathy for the perpetrator. I don't think they have a choice. They can't help themselves. That is why they are so dangerous. Prosecute discharge and warn society. That is a good thing.
Jennifer Norris, Maine
 
9/7/2012 9:18:24 AM ET
good i have no sympathy for a convicted sex offender. so it ruins their social life should have thought about it before they assaulted someone. this articles Summarizes what is wrong with this Air Force. when did the Offender became the victim personally i do not want them anywere near my children. imagine if that was your daughter that had been assaulted would you be ok with them trying to get a job and live a blue-colar life
John Smith, My TARDIS
 
Add a comment

 Inside AF.mil

ima cornerSearch

tabSubscribe AF.MIL
tabMore HeadlinesRSS feed 
Vandenberg launch unit 'small squadron with big responsibilities'

F-35A maintenance training on track

Intelligence collaboration focus of net-centric operations conference

Deployed Airmen build Azerbaijan partnership through mutual respect

AF joins NATO partners in Ramstein Rover 2012

National Guard vital to Africa Command mission

Airmen wrap up Winfly on the 'ice'

ACSC launches new distance learning program

Commanders share wing missions, kidney donation  1

Air Force continues pollution prevention efforts

First F-35 training commander: 'This jet is our future'

Security forces Airmen train with British counterparts

Safety at center of growing RPA requirement

Academy solar panels save taxpayers $800K in first year  11

tabCommentaryRSS feed 
Losing Your Future to Sexual Assault   20

Attacking Symptoms  7


Site Map      Contact Us     Questions     Security and Privacy notice     E-publishing