<< Back to Safety and Health Information Bulletins - Table of Contents by Year
Safety and Health Information Bulletin
SHIB 05-01-2006
Purpose The purpose of this Safety and Health Information Bulletin (SHIB) is:
Background OSHA's Toledo, Ohio, Area Office investigated a fatal accident involving the collapse, during a launch sequence, of an overhead launching gantry crane used during segmental bridge construction. The equipment involved was an overhead truss with a self-launching under-bridge (overhead launching gantry) manufactured by Paola De Nicola of Italy for the construction of the Maumee River Crossing in Toledo, Ohio (see Figures 1 and 2). ![]() Figure 1: General Configuration of the Overhead Launching Gantry Manufactured by Paola De Nicola for the Maumee River Crossing For problems with accessibility in using figures and illustrations in this document, please contact the Directorate of Science, Technology and Medicine at (202) 693-2300. ![]() Figure 2: Two Launching Gantries Side-by-side For problems with accessibility in using figures and illustrations in this document, please contact the Directorate of Science, Technology and Medicine at (202) 693-2300. The launching gantry is used to place concrete bridge and pier segments for elevated roadways and bridges by spanning the distance between a finished road segment and the next roadway pier or column. While spanning this distance, the launching gantry picks up each bridge segment and suspends the segments from beneath the overhead truss moving the segments into place. The segments are then epoxied together and post-tensioned into place. Following the successful placement of the roadway segments beneath the overhead truss, the entire launching gantry is then moved forward to the next span along its previously launched under-bridge. The under-bridge provides a temporary bridge over the span for the front leg of the launching gantry to travel and position the structure over the next span. (See Figure 3) ![]() Figure 3: Launching Gantry with Suspended Segments For problems with accessibility in using figures and illustrations in this document, please contact the Directorate of Science, Technology and Medicine at (202) 693-2300. For this particular design, the manufacturer required the use of four anchoring bars for each of the four rear legs (sixteen total anchoring bars) and two anchoring bars for each of the two telescoping front legs (four anchoring bars total). The anchoring bars in the rear were designed to be pre-stressed to 600 kilo-Newton's per bar (approximately 135,000 pounds of force per bar) to provide resistance to the longitudinal and transversal forces primarily during the launching of the under-bridge. The front leg anchors were to be pre-stressed to resist transversal forces, such as those created by wind. Accident Investigation The accident investigation revealed that the employer had not designed the pier segments to accommodate each of the anchoring locations, reportedly because of congestion in the segments with other items such as stressing cables. It was further determined that the employer used only a few anchoring bars during the initial launches and as work progressed began using fewer and fewer anchoring bars. On the day of the accident, there were no anchoring bars for the four rear leg and only one anchoring bar in each of the front legs. Additionally, the front leg anchors had not been stressed to the appropriate force and were only tightened with a wrench. A few months prior to the collapse of the launching gantry, the employer had experienced a movement of about 2 centimeters at the rear legs during a launch when using a total of only two rear-leg anchoring bars. The manufacturer's instructions provided that such movement could lead to a collapse of a launching gantry. ![]() Figure 4: View of the Launching Gantries after the Accident For problems with accessibility in using figures and illustrations in this document, please contact the Directorate of Science, Technology and Medicine at (202) 693-2300. Conclusion
29 CFR 1926.550(a)(1) - The employer shall comply with the manufacturer's specifications and limitations applicable to the operation of any and all cranes and derricks. Where manufacturer's specifications are not available, the limitations assigned to the equipment shall be based on the determinations of a qualified engineer competent in this field and such determinations will be appropriately documented and recorded. Attachments used with cranes shall not exceed the capacity, rating, or scope recommended by the manufacturer. |