Rational Irrationality

The News from New Hampshire

by John Cassidy
I would offer the perhaps heretical suggestion that political journalism, far from having gone into a terminal decline, is in better shape now than it was in the nineteen-sixties and seventies, which some hold up as a golden age…
New Hampshire Voters Head To The Polls For State's Primary

Latest News

Daily Comment

The G.O.P., Abortion, and Privacy

by Jeffrey Toobin

Republican Presidential nominees have opposed Roe v. Wade since Reagan. But this year’s candidates are taking more extreme steps…

Photograph by Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images

Twitter

Mitt Romney

News Desk

Romney's Rough Win

by Alex Koppelman

A candidate who should be raising his arms in unalloyed triumph—he’s officially the first modern Republican who’s not already President to win both Iowa and New Hampshire—is instead battered and bleeding…

Mitt Romney, Chris Christie

The Lizza List

Five to Blame for Mitt

by Ryan Lizza

Cheri Daniels, Anthony Kennedy, and three others to point a finger at…

twitter

The Players

G.O.P. Candidates

Back before his hair turned whiter than the Republican base, Newt Gingrich used to call Democrats “the enemy of normal Americans.” If so, then where, oh where in the G.O.P. field is there a normal American for a Dem to be enemies with? O.K., Huntsman seems fairly normal. But Romney, the dog-on-car guy? Santorum, the man-on-dog dude? Pistol-packin’ Perry, who guns down canines while jogging?  Ron Paul?

Granted, the exit of Bachmann—who, despite being told to run by dog spelled backwards, was the first of the seven who made it to the voting stage to quit—precipitated a slight rise in the overall normalcy quotient. Who will join her among the departed after New Hampshire and South Carolina? Click on the drawings, right, by Tom Bachtell, to see the candidates’ ratings.

—Hendrik Hertzberg

The Pacers
Fighting for the honor of being the candidate Republicans hate least.
  • Illustration by Tom Bachtell
    Rick Santorum

    > Rating: Family Guy.
    > Why?  His wife and children are his favorite talking points, even though they’re not unborn.
    > How’s it going? When other Christianists faltered, Santorum went from “Who he?” to “How about that nice young man?” It’s too bad he’s already a Catholic. If he were a mainline Protestant, like Republicans used to be, he could: 1. Become an Episcopal priest like ex-Senator John Danforth. 2. Convert. 3. Join the Catholic clergy while staying married under a recent loophole. 4. Switch his office-seeking target from Washington to Rome. 5. Puff of white smoke!
    > Read More: Tie goes to Santorum 
    Santorum and abortion
    Latest coverage

  • Illustration by Tom Bachtell
    Ron Paul

    > Rating: Paleoprophet 
    > Why?  In the future, everyone gets to be not Mitt Romney for fifteen minutes, but in the Iowa Bowl, little Ron was QB Mitt’s beefiest lineman, throwing a key block on Newt to prevent the sack.
    > How’s it going?  Alas, Republicans want a Santa, not an elf. But still: he’s so cute! He says the darndest things! Forget all that bigoted stuff. That’s yesterday’s newsletters! Spry, sassy Ron’s the Occupy-pacifist-anarchist left’s favorite Republican! The Fox News ward bosses are correct that he can’t be nominated, but so what? On his plane of existence, squalid considerations like “winning” and “losing” do not apply. You can’t kill a dream.
    > Read More: Ron Paul, spoiler?
    Nicholas Lemann: Enemy of the State
    Latest coverage

  • Illustration by Tom Bachtell
    Mitt Romney

    > Rating: Hillary, 2008 B.B.O.
    > Why? The inevitable nominee. The inevitable nominee. The inevitable nominee. Everybody said so then, everybody says so now, but even a stopped conventional wisdom is right once in a while. Is he “likable enough,” though? If not, does it matter?
    > How’s it going?  Quite well, actually. These things are relative, you see. For Mitt to blow it, somebody else has to do less badly, and not just for a week or a month but consistently.
    > Read More: Eight Was Enough
    The Mittster And The Job Figures
    Latest coverage

The Stragglers
At this point, they’re just hoping not to embarrass themselves. Further.
  • Illustration by Tom Bachtell
    Jon Huntsman

    > Rating: Vote Huntsman 2016!
    > Why? The plan, at least as seen from the outside: 1. Use 2012 to polish campaigning skills, build name recognition, become a press darling, make some friends and not too many enemies, get a rep as a non-crazy, relatively moderate conservative. 2. Wait for whoever gets the G.O.P. nod to blow a sure thing by being too right-wing. 3. Get elected in 2016.
    > How’s it going?  Losing was always an essential part of the plan. Not losing this badly, though.
    > Read More: The Huntsman Girls
    Evan Osnos interviews Huntsman
    Latest coverage

  • Illustration by Tom Bachtell
    Newt Gingrich

    > Rating: Once and Futurist Has-Been.
    > Why? Many Republican voters were too young or too ignorant to know about Newt’s excellent adventures of the seventies, eighties, and nineties, but the Republican establishment made it its business to educate them. The elephant remembers.
    > How’s it going? Newt’s in kamikaze mode, and he’s aimed himself directly at Mitt Romney. But he’ll come out all right. As he has reminded us, Newt was “selling speeches” for sixty grand apiece when he was in the “private sector.”
    > Read More: Kelefa Sanneh on Gingrich
    Hertzberg: “Alt-Newt” 
    Latest coverage

  • Illustration by Tom Bachtell
    Rick Perry

    > Rating: Oops.
    > Why? It’s not just what he said when he forgot the name of the third department he’d like to eliminate.  It’s how he ought to feel about his decision to jump into the race to begin with. (Embarrassed Texans feel it for him.) After Iowa, he had to choose between withdrawal and denial. He’s goin’ with denial.
    > How’s it going? In a dog whistle to evangelicals, Perry likened himself to Denver Broncos quarterback Tim Tebow. The flaw in the comparison: when Tebow ostentatiously goes down on one knee to pray, he’s already in the end zone.
    > Links: Why Perry’s no Tebow
    Perry and Texas
    Latest coverage

The Departed
It was fun while it lasted; and then came the votes.
  • Illustration by Tom Bachtell
    Michele Bachmann

    > Rating: The Lady Vanishes.
    > Why?  The Lord moves in mysterious ways. He was just leading her on when He whispered in her ear that He wanted her in the White House. Turns out He’s not a member of the Promise Keepers.
    > How’s it going?  What didn’t happen in Iowa won’t even get a chance to not happen in New Hampshire.
    > Read More: Ryan Lizza on Bachmann’s rise
    Bachmann Exits
    Latest coverage

This is where the archive will go - when there is enough content for an archive.

Video & Podcasts

Campaign Ads

Huntsman vs. Paul

January 06, 2012

On television in New Hampshire, the fight for the libertarian anti-war vote takes an interesting turn.

  • Huntsman vs. Paul
    Huntsman vs. Paul
    The fight for the libertarian vote.
  • Final Arguments
    Closing Arguments
    The candidates' final ads in Iowa.
  • "Primary"
    J.F.K., 1960
    “Primary,” a campaign documentary.
  • Photograph by Mark Wilson/AFP/Getty Images
    Great Debates
    The best and worst G.O.P. moments.
    videos in the news

The Political Scene Podcast

120109_newt-gingrich_g290

Top Dollars

Host: Dorothy Wickenden | January 05, 2012

Hendrik Hertzberg, Jane Mayer, and Ryan Lizza on the power of the new Super PACs.

  • 120109_newt-gingrich_g290

    The Political Scene Podcast

    Top Dollars
    Hendrik Hertzberg, Jane Mayer, and Ryan Lizza on Super PACs.
  • Photograph: Getty Images

    The Political Scene Podcast

    One Man’s Plan
    Senator Alan Simpson lets loose on Washington, with Ryan Lizza.
  • Photograph by Scott Olson/Getty Images

    The Political Scene Podcast

    Iowa and Beyond
    Ryan Lizza, John Cassidy, and Jeffrey Toobin on the G.O.P. field.
  • Photograph: Getty Images

    The Political Scene Podcast

    Barney, Being Frank
    The Congressman’s exit interview, with George Packer.
    more podcasts
  • The Political Scene Podcast

    Top Dollars
    Hendrik Hertzberg, Jane Mayer, and Ryan Lizza on Super PACs.
  • The Political Scene Podcast

    One Man’s Plan
    Senator Alan Simpson lets loose on Washington, with Ryan Lizza.
  • The Political Scene Podcast

    Iowa and Beyond
    Ryan Lizza, John Cassidy, and Jeffrey Toobin on the G.O.P. field.
  • The Political Scene Podcast

    Barney, Being Frank
    The Congressman’s exit interview, with George Packer.

Maps, Etc.

Click each graphic to expand

Final Map1.1.7

Who Votes When?

What’s next on the road to Super Tuesday.

Final Map2.1.7

Electoral College Math

It takes two hundred and seventy to win. How much is each state worth?

Final Map3.1.7

How Obama Won

A blue-red breakdown of the 2008 Presidential election.

Must Read

Then and Now

Stories about campaigns past and politics from our archives.

Photograph by Alfred Eisenstaedt/Time & Life Pictures/Getty Images

Romney, Sr.

by Richard H. Rovere | April 22, 1967

A Harris Survey released this week reports that in an election held now with George Romney at the head of the Republican ticket, Romney would win with fifty-three per cent of the popular vote. Such findings establish the approximate extent of the President’s vulnerability; they cannot be taken as a measure of the problems that face Romney or any other Republican candidate…

Reading List

Recommendations from The New Yorker’s writers and editors.


  • “The Right Nation”

    John Micklethwait and Adrian Wooldridge, two Brits, explain the roots of radical conservatism in America. Published in 2005, but anticipates the problems both of Obama and of the Tea Partiers.

    “Back to Work”

    Bill Clinton’s talking points about the need for “smart government,” for Democrats who have been cowed into silence or confusion. Also, inevitably, an exercise in Presidential one-upmanship.

    “The Mirage”

    You think post-partisanship is a good idea? Princeton historian Sean Wilentz may change your mind. He argues in The New Republic that Presidents who have been averse to party politics invariably have invited “political defeat and even catastrophe.”

    Dorothy Wickenden

  • “Unequal Democracy”

    Larry M. Bartels explains the link between growing income inequality and our dysfunctional political system. (Turns out that, in the last fifty years, low-income white voters have become more Democratic, not less.)

    “Romney at Bain”

    Key quote from this Wall Street Journal piece: “The rate at which the firms Bain invested in ran into trouble appears to be higher than experienced by some rival buyout firms during the era.”

    “The Big Sort”

    The gridlock in D.C. has sent me searching through the literature on the polarization of American politics. Bill Bishop’s 2008 book offers an insight on every page.

    Ryan Lizza

  • “Pakistan: A Hard Country”

    A carefully researched work by London-based scholar Anatol Lieven; he lays out the ground-level case that Pakistan is not quite as frail and doomed as is commonly declared in the West.

    “The Korean War”

    Bruce Cumings’s book is a well-argued narrative that insists upon greater understanding of North Korea’s originating pathologies.

    “Tell Newt To Shut Up”

    Beyond its enviable title, David Maraniss and Michael Weisskopf’s 1996 book is a definitive, deeply reported account of the original Gingrich Wave, which changed Congress and Washington’s political assumptions.

    Steve Coll

Cartoons

How funny are elections? Find out with our political cartoon of the day. Plus: Presidential cartoons!

Cartoon

Cartoon by Leo Cullum | November 10, 2008
Cartoon
Cartoon
Cartoon
cartoon
Cartoon
Cartoon
Cartoon
Cartoon
Cartoon
Cartoon
cartoon
cartoon
cartoon
Cartoon
Cartoon