Statement on Development of and Schedule for MOBILE6 August 21, 1996 Planning the timing of updates to guidance for the estimating of mobile source emissions always requires EPA to balance a number of competing considerations. The Office of Mobile Sources (OMS) wants to allow sufficient time for the development of a scientifically sound, error-free, and user- friendly emission factor estimation tool for our customers. We also want to inform them of significant new facts and other information in time for their decisions and selections of control options to be based on the best information available, rather than on "old" estimates that have been modified by new data or insights. We want to avoid situations in which an honest dialog about new data and tentative insights distracts attention from State technical work and related decision-making. Finally, as is always true, the States want assurances that their State Implementation Plans (SIPs) will be reviewed for approval by EPA under the same guidance that was applicable during their development. After consultation with the Office of Air Quality Planning and Standards (OAQPS), OMS has determined that an appropriate window for final release of MOBILE6 would be the Summer of 1998. Release of the final version of MOBILE6 in Summer 1998 implies that significant portions of the proposed content of the model would be provided (in non-software form) for stakeholder and peer review comments beginning late this year or early in 1997. Draft, or "beta version," software for MOBILE6 would be made available approximately March 1998. Following is a summary of some of the major areas of revision planned for MOBILE6, and a brief description of the expanded process planned for stakeholder and peer review of the model. Aspects of MOBILE being reexamined and likely to be revised. MOBILE6 is planned as an extensive update and reworking of the model, and there are a large number of areas in which we plan to make changes. This list is not exhaustive, and covers only some of the more important issues. In the realm of exhaust emissions, we will be examining non- FTP (so called "off-cycle") driving behaviors and frequencies of occurrence, and the effects of such driving on emissions. This is a very important area and is likely to substantially change in-use emission estimates for all pollutants and all vehicle types. The work of the In-Use Deterioration Work Group, part of the FACA Mobile Source Technical Advisory Subcommittee, will be used in our efforts to refine and improve estimates of in-use deterioration of emissions. We plan to expand the emission factor calculations for heavy-duty diesel vehicles (HDDVs), providing emission factors by subcategory (e.g., light, medium, heavy, buses) as is now done in the mobile source particulate emission factor model. Heavy-duty conversion factors (g/bhp-hr to g/mi) will be updated. We would like to separate start-related and running (stabilized) emissions for gasoline-fueled vehicle categories. The effects of onboard diagnostic systems (OBD II) on exhaust emissions will be reconsidered. If possible, we intend to update and improve estimates of idle emission factors, and to look at interactions of various correction factors (temperature, fuel volatility, average speed). More extensive work based on development of, and testing of vehicles over, new driving cycles based on newer data and specific to highway facility types (limited access, major arterial, etc.) is also planned. For non-exhaust (evaporative) emissions, we will be incorporating real-time diurnal emissions estimates and the effects of the new, more stringent evaporative emission test procedure, and updating estimates of hot soak, resting loss, and running loss emissions. Trip characteristics (e.g., trip frequencies, average trip lengths) will be revised on the basis of newer data. The effects of OBD II systems on evaporative emissions will be considered. Analysis of new data on rates of functional purge/pressure test failures and associated emission impacts will be reflected. In the area of modeling inspection and maintenance (I/M) program effects, we will be incorporating credits for remote sensing (RSD) programs, supporting additional emissions cutpoints in estimating of program benefits, and including provisions for other-than-50% credit discounts for test-and-repair programs. The effects of OBD II systems in conjunction with I/M programs will be evaluated and modeled. To the extent permitted by time and availability of data, we would like to model the effects of I/M programs applicable to heavy-duty vehicles. Fuels effects to be updated include impact of in-use sulfur levels on emissions, updated effects of oxygenates on exhaust emissions, and possibly including the "complex model" used in support of the reformulated gasoline (RFG) rules in MOBILE. Fleet characterization data (registration distributions and average annual mileage accumulation rates by vehicle type) will be revised on the basis of more recent information. A number of other changes are planned to make the model more user-friendly and to "clean up" sections of the code that have become obsolete or superceded by later revisions. As can be seen from the number and scope of areas being reexamined and revised, along with the fact that considerable testing will be performed over the next 12 months or so to obtain additional data for use in the model, it is not possible for us to estimate the overall changes in emission factors that are likely to be seen in MOBILE6. It is quite possible that these changes will be significant, particularly for calendar years of evaluation of 2000 and beyond; yet at this time it is not possible for us to estimate with any confidence where these results will lead. Many of our final decisions on how to revise aspects of the model will be affected by vehicle testing and data analysis work to be performed between now and next summer. Expanded opportunities for stakeholder and peer review of proposed model revisions. In addition to the many changes discussed above, we have worked with the Modeling Work Group of the Mobile Source Technical Advisory Subcommittee to develop recommendations for obtaining significantly more outside input and review during the development of MOBILE6. In consideration of the practical problems posed by attempting a outside review of a full finished product, we are planning to have an ongoing process in place by this fall and continuing throughout the development period for MOBILE6 in which ample opportunity is provided to all interested parties to comment on work as it is completed. The exact details of the process are still not final, but it appears that the central mechanism will be establishment of a specific electronic forum in which OMS will post analyses, test program proposals, documentation, and other model-related work, and invite review and comment from outside parties. We anticipate that this will result not only in a better product, but also one that when released in final form should face less criticism than has sometimes been the case for past releases. Of course, allowing time for comment, EPA response to comments, and changes necessitated or suggested by commenters, will require more time to implement properly, and this is accounted for in the schedule that we have proposed for MOBILE6. Once we are ready to release MOBILE6 in final form, EPA will have to articulate clear guidance regarding its use. We generally support the "no late hits" philosophy when it comes to changes being made in EPA guidance to the States, but feel that we should postpone specific decisions until we have a better understanding of how MOBILE6 emission factors will differ from those estimated using MOBILE5a, and are cognizant of the status that various related planning activities have reached by that time.