During a television interview last month, Rory Stewart, a foreign policy expert who has argued strenuously that President Obama should cut rather than increase the size of the American force in Afghanistan, used an arresting metaphor to describe what it was like to advise the American government on Afghan policy.
Mr. Stewart, who acquired his knowledge of Afghanistan the really old-fashioned way — by walking across it — told Lynn Sherr on PBS that he had spoken to both Secretary of State Hillary Clinton and the special representative to the region, Richard C. Holbrooke, this year, even as the American military presence has steadily expanded. Asked to characterize these discussions, Mr. Stewart said this:
They listen politely, but in the end, of course, basically the policy decision is made. What they would like is a little advice on some small bit. I mean, the analogy that one of my colleagues used recently is this: It’s as though they come to you and they say, “We’re planning to drive our car off a cliff. Do we wear a seatbelt or not?” And we say, “Don’t drive your car off the cliff.” And they say, “No, no, no. That decision’s already made. The question is should we wear our seat belts?” And you say, “Why by all means wear a seat belt.” And they say, “O.K., we consulted with policy expert, Rory Stewart,” etc.
Mr. Stewart’s metaphor is strikingly similar to something Mr. Obama used to say about the decision to invade Iraq. On The Daily Show in November 2005, then-Senator Obama said: “Iraq is sort of a situation where you’ve got a guy who drove the bus into the ditch. You know, you obviously have to get the bus out of the ditch and that’s not easy to do — although you probably should fire the driver.”
The Daily Show With Jon Stewart | Mon - Thurs 11p / 10c | |||
Barack Obama | ||||
|