|
Assessing Stream Channel Stability at Bridges in Physiographic Regions FHWA-HRT-05-072
PDF version (3.47 MB)
The objective of this study was to expand and improve a rapid channel stability assessment method developed previously by Johnson et al. to include additional factors, such as major physiographic units across the United States, a greater range of bank materials and complexities, critical bank heights, stream types and processes, sand bed streams, and in-channel bars or lack of bars. (1) Another goal of this study was to tailor Thorne's reconnaissance method for bridge inspection and stability assessment needs. (2) Stream-bridge intersections were observed across the United States to develop and test the stability assessment method. Site visits were conducted at 57 stream-bridge intersections in 14 physiographic regions and subregions. Data collected and included in the report include locations and global positioning system (GPS) coordinates of the bridges, the physiographic Province, land use, stream classification, bed and bar material, percent of sand in the bed material, controls in the banks or on the bed, bank vegetation, bank material, bank height, and any erosion-related characteristics. Variability in stream types and common characteristics within each of the physiographic regions also were described. Thirteen indicators were identified for the stability assessment method. For each indicator, a rating of poor, fair, good, or excellent was assigned. An overall rank was obtained by summing the 13 ratings. To address sensitivities of various stream types to the indicators and rankings, the appropriate ranges of rankings were determined for three categories of stream channels. Each of the 57 stream-bridge intersections also was described in terms of lateral and vertical stability. Finally, a simplified version of Thorne's stream reconnaissance field sheets is presented for collecting data for the stream stability assessment and to provide a record of conditions at each visit. (2)
Gary L. Henderson Director, Office of Infrastructure Research and Development
NOTICE
This document is disseminated under the sponsorship of the U.S. Department of Transportation in the interest of information exchange. The U.S. Government assumes no liability for its contents or use thereof. This report does not constitute a standard, specification, or regulation.
The U.S. Government does not endorse products or manufacturers. Trade and manufacturers' names appear in this report only because they are considered essential to the object of the document.
QUALITY ASSURANCE STATEMENT
The Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) provides high-quality information to serve Government, industry, and the public in a manner that promotes public understanding. Standards and policies are used to ensure and maximize the quality, objectivity, utility, and integrity of its information. FHWA periodically reviews quality issues and adjusts its programs and processes to ensure continuous quality improvement.
Technical Report Documentation Page
1. Report No. FHWA-HRT-05-072 |
2. Government Accession No. |
3. Recipient's Catalog No. |
4. Title and Subtitle Assessing Stream Channel Stability at bridges in Physiographic Regions |
5. Report Date July 2006 |
6. Performing Organization Code |
7. Author(s) Peggy A. Johnson |
8. Performing Organization Report No. |
9. Performing Organization Name and Address Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering Pennsylvania State University University Park, PA 16802 |
10. Work Unit No. (TRAIS) |
11. Contract or Grant No. DTFH61-03-P-00353 |
12. Sponsoring Agency Name and Address Office of Infrastructure Research and Development Federal Highway Administration Turner-Fairbank Highway Research Center 6300 Georgetown Pike McLean, VA 22101 |
13. Type of Report and Period Covered Final Report, August 2003 to August 2004 |
14. Sponsoring Agency Code |
15. Supplementary Notes Contracting Officer's Technical Representative - J. Sterling Jones, HRDI-07; cosponsored by Jorge Pagan, Office of Bridge Technology |
16. Abstract
The objective of this study was to expand and improve a rapid channel stability assessment method developed previously by Johnson et al. to include additional factors, such as major physiographic units across the United States, a greater range of bank materials and complexities, critical bank heights, stream types and processes, sand bed streams, and in-channel bars or lack of bars. (1) Another goal of this study was to tailor Thorne's reconnaissance method for bridge inspection and stability assessment needs. (2) Stream-bridge intersections were observed across the United States to develop and test the stability assessment method. Site visits were conducted at 57 stream-bridge intersections in 14 physiographic regions and subregions. Data collected and included in the report include locations and global positioning system (GPS) coordinates of the bridges, the physiographic Province, land use, stream classification, bed and bar material, percent of sand in the bed material, controls in the banks or on the bed, bank vegetation, bank material, bank height, and any erosion-related characteristics. Variability in stream types and common characteristics within each of the physiographic regions also were described. Thirteen indicators were identified for the stability assessment method. For each indicator, a rating of poor, fair, good, or excellent was assigned. An overall rank was obtained by summing the 13 ratings. To address sensitivities of various stream types to the indicators and rankings, the appropriate ranges of rankings were determined for three categories of stream channels. Each of the 57 stream-bridge intersections also was described in terms of lateral and vertical stability. Finally, a simplified version of Thorne's stream reconnaissance field sheets is presented for collecting data for the stream stability assessment and to provide a record of conditions at each visit. (2)
|
17. Key Words Bridge scour, stream stability, inspection, bridge maintenance, hydraulics |
18. Distribution Statement |
19. Security Classification (of this report) Unclassified |
20. Security Classification (of this page) Unclassified |
21. No. of Pages 157 |
22. Price N/A |
Form DOT F 1700.7 (8-72) Reproduction of completed page authorized
Metric Conversion Chart
TABLE OF CONTENTS
- INTRODUCTION
- BACKGROUND AND LITERATURE REVIEW
- FIELD OBSERVATIONS
- ASSESSING CHANNEL STABILITY
- MODIFICATIONS OF THORNE'S RECONNAISSANCE SHEETS
- EXAMPLES
- CONCLUSIONS
LIST OF FIGURES
- Figure 1. Stable stream in central Pennsylvania.
- Figure 2. Unstable stream in western Pennsylvania
- Figure 3. Variation of channel width over medium timeframe about the stable mean (after reference 14)
- Figure 4. Critical bank height and angle
- Figure 5. USACE10 stream classification system
- Figure 6. Physiographic map of the United States (after reference 66)
- Figure 7. Failing banks in the Central Lowlands
- Figure 8. Failing banks in the Interior Lowlands
- Figure 9. Stream impacts due to disturbances, including hoof damage, vegetation removal, and channel straightening
- Figure 10. Impacts of disturbances at bridge (from figure 9)
- Figure 11. Wooded land upstream of bridge
- Figure 12. Downstream of figure 11, vegetation removed
- Figure 13. Mojave River, CA
- Figure 14. Meander migration affecting right abutment, Hammond Branch, MD
- Figure 15. Single-span bridge over unstable channel
- Figure 16. Riprap stabilization wall along Roaring Run, PA
- Figure 17. Cross vane downstream of bridge over Potter Run,
- Figure 18. Simplified and revised reconnaissance sheets based on Thorne, sheet 1
- Figure 19. Simplified and revised reconnaissance sheets based on Thorne, sheet 2
- Figure 20. Simplified and revised reconnaissance sheets based on Thorne, sheet 3
- Figure 21. Dry Creek, Pacific Coastal - upstream from bridge
- Figure 22. Dry Creek, Pacific Coastal - downstream from bridge
- Figure 23. Dry Creek, Pacific Coastal - upstream under bridge, photo 1
- Figure 24. Dry Creek, Pacific Coastal - upstream under bridge, photo 2
- Figure 25. Dutch Bill Creek, Pacific Coastal - upstream from under bridge
- Figure 26. Dutch Bill Creek, Pacific Coastal - downstream at bridge
- Figure 27. Dutch Bill Creek, Pacific Coastal - downstream from under bridge
- Figure 28. Dutch Bill Creek, Pacific Coastal - upstream through bridge
- Figure 29. Buena Vista Creek, Pacific Coastal - upstream from bridge
- Figure 30. Buena Vista Creek, Pacific Coastal - downstream from bridge
- Figure 31. Buena Vista Creek, Pacific Coastal - downstream under bridge
- Figure 32. Buena Vista Creek, Pacific Coastal - upstream from under bridge
- Figure 33. Jacalitos Creek, Pacific Coastal - downstream from bridge
- Figure 34. Jacalitos Creek, Pacific Coastal - upstream from bridge
- Figure 35. Jacalitos Creek, Pacific Coastal - looking downstream at bridge
- Figure 36. Jacalitos Creek, Pacific Coastal - downstream from under bridge
- Figure 37. Murietta Creek, Pacific Coastal - downstream from bridge
- Figure 38. Murietta Creek, Pacific Coastal - upstream from bridge
- Figure 39. Murietta Creek, Pacific Coastal - upstream toward bridge
- Figure 40. Murietta Creek, Pacific Coastal - looking upstream at bridge
- Figure 41. Mojave River, Basin and Range - upstream from bridge, photo 1
- Figure 42. Mojave River, Basin and Range - upstream from bridge, photo 2
- Figure 43. Mojave River, Basin and Range - looking downstream at bridge
- Figure 44. Mojave River, Basin and Range - downstream from bridge
- Figure 45. Rt. 66 Wash, Basin and Range - upstream from bridge
- Figure 46. Rt. 66 Wash, Basin and Range - downstream from bridge
- Figure 47. Rt. 66 Wash, Basin and Range - looking downstream at bridge
- Figure 48. Rt. 66 Wash, Basin and Range - looking upstream at bridge
- Figure 49. Sacramento Wash, Basin and Range - upstream under bridge
- Figure 50. Sacramento Wash, Basin and Range - downstream from bridge
- Figure 51. Sacramento Wash, Basin and Range - downstream under bridge
- Figure 52. Sacramento Wash, Basin and Range - looking downstream at bridge
- Figure 53. Rio Puerco, Trans Pecos - downstream from bridge
- Figure 54. Rio Puerco, Trans Pecos - upstream from bridge.
- Figure 55. Rio Puerco, Trans Pecos - looking upstream at bridge
- Figure 56. Rio Puerco, Trans Pecos - looking downstream at bridge
- Figure 57. Rio San Jose, Trans Pecos - upstream from bridge
- Figure 58. Rio San Jose, Trans Pecos - downstream from bridge
- Figure 59. Rio San Jose, Trans Pecos - looking upstream at bridge
- Figure 60. Rio San Jose, Trans Pecos - looking downstream at bridge
- Figure 61. Arkansas River, Rocky Mountains - looking downstream at bridge
- Figure 62. Arkansas River, Rocky Mountains - upstream from bridge
- Figure 63. Arkansas River, Rocky Mountains - downstream from bridge
- Figure 64. Arkansas River, Rocky Mountains - bridge #2 downstream from other bridge
- Figure 65. Cochetopa Creek, Rocky Mountains - downstream from bridge
- Figure 66. Cochetopa Creek, Rocky Mountains - looking downstream at bridge
- Figure 67. Cochetopa Creek, Rocky Mountains - upstream from bridge
- Figure 68. North Rush Creek, Great Plains - upstream of bridge
- Figure 69. North Rush Creek, Great Plains - upstream from bridge
- Figure 70. North Rush Creek, Great Plains - downstream from bridge
- Figure 71. Saline River, Great Plains - upstream under bridge
- Figure 72. Saline River, Great Plains - downstream from bridge
- Figure 73. Saline River, Great Plains - looking downstream at bridge
- Figure 74. South Fork Solomon River, Great Plains - looking downstream at bridge, photo 1
- Figure 75. South Fork Solomon River, Great Plains - looking downstream at bridge, photo 2
- Figure 76. South Fork Solomon River, Great Plains - left bank
- Figure 77. South Fork Solomon River, Great Plains - downstream
- Figure 78. West Elk Creek, Central Plains - looking downstream at bridge, photo 1
- Figure 79. West Elk Creek, Central Plains - looking downstream at bridge, photo 2
- Figure 80. West Elk Creek, Central Plains - upstream from bridge
- Figure 81. West Elk Creek, Central Plains - downstream from bridge
- Figure 82. Beaver Creek, Central Plains - upstream from bridge
- Figure 83. Beaver Creek, Central Plains - downstream from bridge
- Figure 84. Beaver Creek, Central Plains - facing upstream under bridge
- Figure 85. Beaver Creek, Central Plains - facing downstream under bridge
- Figure 86. Brush Creek, Central Plains - upstream from bridge
- Figure 87. Brush Creek, Central Plains - downstream from bridge
- Figure 88. Brush Creek, Central Plains - downstream under bridge
- Figure 89. Unnamed creek (N 19), Central Plains - downstream from bridge
- Figure 90. Unnamed creek (N 19), Central Plains - upstream from bridge
- Figure 91. Unnamed creek (N 19), Central Plains - upstream under bridge
- Figure 92. Unnamed creek (N 19), Central Plains - downstream under bridge
- Figure 93. East Fork, Interior Low Plateau - upstream from bridge
- Figure 94. East Fork, Interior Low Plateau - looking downstream at second bridge
- Figure 95. East Fork, Interior Low Plateau - looking upstream at bridge
- Figure 96. East Fork, Interior Low Plateau - looking downstream at bridge
- Figure 97. Honey Run, Interior Low Plateau - upstream from bridge
- Figure 98. Honey Run, Interior Low Plateau - downstream from bridge
- Figure 99. Honey Run, Interior Low Plateau - looking upstream at bridge
- Figure 100. Honey Run, Interior Low Plateau - looking downstream at bridge
- Figure 101. Unnamed creek (N 28), Interior Low Plateau - upstream from bridge
- Figure 102. Unnamed creek (N 28), Interior Low Plateau - downstream from bridge
- Figure 103. Unnamed creek (N 28), Interior Low Plateau - downstream under bridge
- Figure 104. Unnamed creek (N 28), Interior Low Plateau - rocky bank material
- Figure 105. South Fork, Interior Low Plateau - downstream from bridge
- Figure 106. South Fork, Interior Low Plateau - upstream from bridge
- Figure 107. South Fork, Interior Low Plateau - looking upstream at bridge
- Figure 108. South Fork, Interior Low Plateau - looking downstream at bridge
- Figure 109. Little Skin Creek, Ozark-Ouachita Highlands - downstream from bridge
- Figure 110. Little Skin Creek, Ozark-Ouachita Highlands - upstream from bridge
- Figure 111. Little Skin Creek, Ozark-Ouachita Highlands - looking downstream at bridge (left)
- Figure 112. Little Skin Creek, Ozark-Ouachita Highlands - looking downstream at bridge (right)
- Figure 113. Unnamed creek (N 21), Ozark-Ouachita Highlands - downstream from bridge
- Figure 114. Unnamed creek (N 21), Ozark-Ouachita Highlands - upstream from bridge
- Figure 115. Unnamed creek (N 21), Ozark-Ouachita Highlands - looking downstream at bridge
- Figure 116. Unnamed creek (N 21), Ozark-Ouachita Highlands - looking upstream at bridge
- Figure 117. Little Cypress Creek, Atlantic Coastal Plain - downstream from bridge
- Figure 118. Little Cypress Creek, Atlantic Coastal Plain - upstream from bridge
- Figure 119. Little Cypress Creek, Atlantic Coastal Plain - looking downstream at bridge
- Figure 120. Little Cypress Creek, Atlantic Coastal Plain - looking upstream at bridge
- Figure 121. Unnamed creek (N 23), Atlantic Coastal Plain - downstream from bridge
- Figure 122. Unnamed creek (N 23), Atlantic Coastal Plain - upstream from bridge
- Figure 123. Unnamed creek (N 23), Atlantic Coastal Plain - looking downstream at bridge
- Figure 124. Unnamed creek (N 23), Atlantic Coastal Plain - looking upstream at bridge
- Figure 125. Unnamed creek (N 24), Atlantic Coastal Plain - upstream from bridge
- Figure 126. Unnamed creek (N 24), Atlantic Coastal Plain - downstream from bridge
- Figure 127. Unnamed creek (N 24), Atlantic Coastal Plain - looking upstream at bridge
- Figure 128. Unnamed creek (N 24), Atlantic Coastal Plain - looking downstream at bridge
- Figure 129. Peace River, Atlantic Coastal Plain - upstream from bridge at old pedestrian bridge
- Figure 130. Peace River, Atlantic Coastal Plain - looking downstream at bridge
- Figure 131. Peace River, Atlantic Coastal Plain - downstream under bridge, right bank
- Figure 132. Peace River, Atlantic Coastal Plain - upstream from old pedestrian bridge
- Figure 133. Alligator Creek, Atlantic Coastal Plain - downstream from bridge
- Figure 134. Alligator Creek, Atlantic Coastal Plain - looking downstream at bridge
- Figure 135. Alligator Creek, Atlantic Coastal Plain - looking upstream at bridge
- Figure 136. Alligator Creek, Atlantic Coastal Plain - upstream from bridge
- Figure 137. Stocketts Run, Atlantic Coastal Plain - upstream from bridge
- Figure 138. Stocketts Run, Atlantic Coastal Plain - downstream from bridge
- Figure 139. Stocketts Run, Atlantic Coastal Plain - looking downstream at bridge
- Figure 140. Stocketts Run, Atlantic Coastal Plain - looking upstream at bridge
- Figure 141. Mill Stream Branch, Atlantic Coastal Plain - upstream from bridge
- Figure 142. Mill Stream Branch, Atlantic Coastal Plain - downstream from bridge
- Figure 143. Mill Stream Branch, Atlantic Coastal Plain - looking downstream at bridge
- Figure 144. Mill Stream Branch, Atlantic Coastal Plain - looking upstream at bridge
- Figure 145. Kent County Tributary, Atlantic Coastal Plain - downstream from bridge
- Figure 146. Kent County Tributary, Atlantic Coastal Plain - upstream from bridge
- Figure 147. Kent County Tributary, Atlantic Coastal Plain - looking downstream at bridge
- Figure 148. Kent County Tributary, Atlantic Coastal Plain - looking upstream at bridge
- Figure 149. Morgan Creek, Atlantic Coastal Plain - upstream from bridge
- Figure 150. Morgan Creek, Atlantic Coastal Plain - downstream from bridge
- Figure 151. Morgan Creek, Atlantic Coastal Plain - looking upstream at bridge
- Figure 152. Morgan Creek, Atlantic Coastal Plain - looking downstream at bridge
- Figure 153. Hammond Branch, Atlantic Coastal Plain - upstream from bridge
- Figure 154. Hammond Branch, Atlantic Coastal Plain - downstream from bridge
- Figure 155. Hammond Branch, Atlantic Coastal Plain - looking downstream at bridge
- Figure 156. Hammond Branch, Atlantic Coastal Plain - looking upstream at bridge
- Figure 157. Pootatuck River, New England - downstream from bridge
- Figure 158. Pootatuck River, New England - upstream from bridge
- Figure 159. Pootatuck River, New England - looking downstream at bridge
- Figure 160. Pootatuck River, New England - looking upstream at bridge
- Figure 161. Mill River, New England - upstream from bridge
- Figure 162. Mill River, New England - downstream from bridge
- Figure 163. Mill River, New England - looking upstream at bridge
- Figure 164. Mill River, New England - looking downstream at bridge
- Figure 165. Aspetuck River, New England - upstream from bridge
- Figure 166. Aspetuck River, New England - downstream from bridge
- Figure 167. Aspetuck River, New England - looking upstream at bridge
- Figure 168. Aspetuck River, New England - looking downstream at bridge
- Figure 169. West Branch Saugatuck River, New England - downstream from bridge
- Figure 170. West Branch Saugatuck River, New England - upstream from bridge
- Figure 171. West Branch Saugatuck River, New England - looking downstream at bridge (bridge in foreground is the pedestrian bridge)
- Figure 172. West Branch Saugatuck River, New England - looking upstream at bridge
- Figure 173. Mianus River, New England - upstream from bridge
- Figure 174. Mianus River, New England - downstream from bridge. Note weir
- Figure 175. Mianus River, New England - looking downstream at bridge
- Figure 176. Mianus River, New England - looking upstream at bridge
- Figure 177. McKnown Creek, Appalachian Plateau - upstream from bridge
- Figure 178. McKnown Creek, Appalachian Plateau - downstream from bridge
- Figure 179. McKnown Creek, Appalachian Plateau - looking downstream at bridge
- Figure 180. McKnown Creek, Appalachian Plateau - looking upstream at bridge
- Figure 181. Wolf Run, Appalachian Plateau - upstream from bridge
- Figure 182. Wolf Run, Appalachian Plateau - downstream from bridge
- Figure 183. Wolf Run, Appalachian Plateau - looking upstream at bridge
- Figure 184. Wolf Run, Appalachian Plateau - upstream face of bridge
- Figure 185. Unnamed creek (N 48), Appalachian Plateau - upstream from bridge
- Figure 186. Unnamed creek (N 48), Appalachian Plateau - downstream from bridge
- Figure 187. Unnamed creek (N 48), Appalachian Plateau - looking downstream at bridge
- Figure 188. Unnamed creek (N 48), Appalachian Plateau - looking upstream through bridge
- Figure 189. Reids Run, Appalachian Plateau - upstream from bridge
- Figure 190. Reids Run, Appalachian Plateau - downstream from bridge
- Figure 191. Reids Run, Appalachian Plateau - looking downstream at bridge
- Figure 192. Reids Run, Appalachian Plateau - looking upstream at bridge
- Figure 193. Piney Creek, Appalachian Plateau - downstream from bridge
- Figure 194. Piney Creek, Appalachian Plateau - upstream from bridge
- Figure 195. Piney Creek, Appalachian Plateau - looking downstream at bridge
- Figure 196. Piney Creek, Appalachian Plateau - looking upstream at bridge
- Figure 197. Sandy Creek, Appalachian Plateau - upstream from bridge
- Figure 198. Sandy Creek, Appalachian Plateau - downstream from bridge
- Figure 199. Sandy Creek, Appalachian Plateau - looking downstream at bridge
- Figure 200. Sandy Creek, Appalachian Plateau - looking upstream at bridge
- Figure 201. Trout Run, Appalachian Plateau - upstream from bridge
- Figure 202. Trout Run, Appalachian Plateau - downstream from bridge
- Figure 203. Trout Run, Appalachian Plateau - looking upstream at bridge
- Figure 204. Trout Run, Appalachian Plateau - upstream face of bridge
- Figure 205. Blackrock Run, Piedmont - upstream from bridge
- Figure 206. Blackrock Run, Piedmont - downstream from bridge
- Figure 207. Blackrock Run, Piedmont - looking downstream at bridge
- Figure 208. Blackrock Run, Piedmont - looking upstream at bridge
- Figure 209. Indian Run, Piedmont - upstream from bridge
- Figure 210. Indian Run, Piedmont - downstream from bridge
- Figure 211. Indian Run, Piedmont - looking downstream at bridge
- Figure 212. Indian Run, Piedmont - looking upstream at bridge
- Figure 213. Middle Patuxent River, Piedmont - upstream from bridge
- Figure 214. Middle Patuxent River, Piedmont - downstream from bridge
- Figure 215. Middle Patuxent River, Piedmont - looking downstream at bridge
- Figure 216. Middle Patuxent River, Piedmont - looking upstream at bridge
- Figure 217. Atherton Tributary, Piedmont - upstream from bridge
- Figure 218. Atherton Tributary, Piedmont - downstream from bridge
- Figure 219. Atherton Tributary, Piedmont - looking upstream at bridge
- Figure 220. Atherton Tributary, Piedmont - looking downstream at bridge
- Figure 221. Little Elk Creek, Piedmont - upstream from bridge
- Figure 222. Little Elk Creek, Piedmont - downstream from bridge
- Figure 223. Little Elk Creek, Piedmont - looking upstream at bridge
- Figure 224. Little Elk Creek, Piedmont - looking downstream at bridge
- Figure 225. Big Beaver Creek, Piedmont - upstream from bridge
- Figure 226. Big Beaver Creek, Piedmont - downstream from bridge
- Figure 227. Big Beaver Creek, Piedmont - looking downstream at bridge
- Figure 228. Big Beaver Creek, Piedmont - looking upstream at bridge
- Figure 229. Buffalo Run, Valley and Ridge - upstream from bridge
- Figure 230. Buffalo Run, Valley and Ridge - downstream from bridge
- Figure 231. Buffalo Run, Valley and Ridge - looking downstream at bridge
- Figure 232. Buffalo Run, Valley and Ridge - looking upstream at bridge
- Figure 233. Roaring Run, Valley and Ridge - downstream from bridge
- Figure 234. Roaring Run, Valley and Ridge - upstream from bridge
- Figure 235. Roaring Run, Valley and Ridge - looking downstream at bridge
- Figure 236. Roaring Run, Valley and Ridge - looking upstream at bridge
- Figure 237. Potter Run, Valley and Ridge - downstream from bridge
- Figure 238. Potter Run, Valley and Ridge - upstream from bridge
- Figure 239. Potter Run, Valley and Ridge - looking downstream at bridge
- Figure 240. Potter Run, Valley and Ridge - looking upstream at bridge
List of Tables
|
|