USGS
South Florida Information Access
SOFIA home
Help
Projects
by Title
by Investigator
by Region
by Topic
by Program
Results
Publications
Meetings
South Florida Restoration Science Forum
Synthesis
Information
Personnel
About SOFIA
USGS Science Strategy
DOI Science Plan
Education
Upcoming Events
Data
Data Exchange
Metadata
publications > open file report > ofr 01-007 > results and discussion


Geochemistry of Sulfur in the Florida Everglades:
1994 through 1999

Open-File Report 01-007

Anne L. Bates, Willian H. Orem, Judson W. Harvey, and Elliott C. Spiker
U.S. Geological Survey, National Center, Reston, VA 20192

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

Solid Phase Sulfur Geochemistry | Dissolved Sulfate Concentrations and Isotopic Compositions

Home
Introduction
Study Area
Analytical Methods
Results and Discussion
- Solid Phase
- Dissolved Sulfate
Summary
References
Solid Phase Sulfur Geochemistry

Solid phase cores were collected in the EAA, WCA 2A, WCA 1A (Loxahatchee National Wildlife Refuge), Taylor Slough, and Lake Okeechobee (see Figures 1 & 2).

WCA 1A

WCA 1A is a "pristine" area protected from canal discharge. Two sediment cores were obtained from this area in April 1995, one near the Hillsboro Canal at site 1, and one away from the canal at site 7 (Fig. 1). Sulfur species contents for these sampling sites were obtained only on a percent by wet weight basis (Table 1 , Fig. 3). These data shows that sulfur contents are about the same at both sites except that organic sulfur is much higher at site 1. The delta symbol34S values are positive at both sites (Table1, Fig. 3), indicating freshwater levels of sulfate.

Loxahatchee Sediment Core C1
April 1995

graph of sulfur species in Loxahatchee sediment core C1, April 1995, percent wet weight
Loxahatchee Sediment Core C1
April 1995

graph of sulfur species in Loxahatchee sediment core C1, April 1995, delta34S
Loxahatchee Sediment Core C2
April 1995

graph of sulfur species in Loxahatchee sediment core C2, April 1995, percent wet weight
Loxahatchee Sediment Core C2
April 1995

graph of sulfur species in Loxahatchee sediment core C2, April 1995, delta34S
key for graphs
Figure 3.
Sulfur Species in Loxahatchee Sediment:
Percent Dry Weight and delta symbol34S Values

WCA 2A

Total sulfur content (percent dry weight) is similar in sediment collected in 1994 at two sites: one near the Hillsboro Canal (E1) and another far from the canal (U3) (Table 2, Fig. 4). At each site, total sulfur shows a significant increase in the upper part of the core, probably indicating an increase in sulfur loading in the marsh in recent times. Sulfur speciation analyses (Table 2 , Fig. 5) indicate that most of the sulfur is in the form of organic sulfur, probably due to iron limitation of sulfide fixation. Positive delta symbol34S values for the sulfur species (Table 2 , Fig. 5) show that there is a relatively restricted supply of sulfate for reduction to sulfide, although one negative delta symbol34S value for disufide sulfur (pyrite) at U3 could indicate an increase in sulfate availability at the time of fixation (Bates et al., 1998).

WCA 2A Sediment at Site E1, March 1994:
Total Sulfur, Percent Dry Weight
graph of total sulfur in WCA 2A sediment at site E1, March 1994, percent dry weight
WCA 2A Sediment at Site U3, March 1994:
Total Sulfur, Percent Dry Weight
graph of total sulfur in WCA 2A sediment at site U3, March 1994, percent dry weight
Figure 4. Total Sulfur in WCA 2A Sediment at Sites E1 and U3, March 1994:
Percent Dry Weight

WCA 2A Sediment at Site E1
March 1994
graph of sulfur species in WCA 2A sediment at site E1, March 1994, percent by dry weight
WCA 2A Sediment at Site E1
March 1994
graph of sulfur species in WCA 2A sediment at site E1, March 1994, delta34S
WCA 2A Sediment at Site U3
March 1994
graph of sulfur species in WCA 2A sediment at site U3, March 1994, percent by dry weight
WCA 2A Sediment at Site U3
March 1994
graph of sulfur species in WCA 2A sediment at site U3, March 1994, delta34S
key for graphs
Figure 5. Sulfur Species in WCA 2A Sediment at Sites E1 and U3
March 1994: Percent Dry Weight and delta symbol34S

Sediment collected in 1996 from site F1 (near the Hillsboro Canal) and from site ("new" U3--not the same as the site from 1994, see Fig. 1) has total sulfur content slightly lower than in the sediment collected in 1994 (Table 2 , Fig. 6). Because the core lengths were shorter in 1996 (only the top 15 cm of sediment), it is not possible to tell if there is a decrease with depth as there was in the sediment collected in 1994. Organic sulfur is the dominant species (Table 2 , Fig. 7) near the top of the sediment at F1 and U3, however, disulfides increase with depth. As in the sediment samples collected in 1994, the delta symbol34S values are positive (Table 2 , Fig. 7), indicating a limited supply of sulfate.

WCA 2A Sediment at Site F1
April 1996

graph of total sulfur in WCA 2A sediment at site F1, April 1996, percent dry weight
WCA 2A Sediment at Site U3 (new)
April 1996

graph of total sulfur in WCA 2A sediment at site U3 (new), April 1996, percent dry weight
Figure 6. Total Sulfur in WCA 2A Sediment at Sites F1 and U3 (new):
Percent Dry Weight

WCA 2A Sediment Core at F1
April 1996

graph of sulfur species in WCA 2A sediment at site F1, April 1996, percent dry weight
WCA 2A Sediment Core F1
April 1996

graph of sulfur species in WCA 2A sediment at site F1, April 1996, delta34S
WCA 2A Sediment Core U3
April 1996

graph of sulfur species in WCA 2A sediment at site U3, April 1996, percent dry weight
WCA 2A Sediment Core U3
April 1996

graph of sulfur species in WCA 2A sediment at site U3, April 1996, delta34S
key for graphs
Figure 7. Sulfur Species in WCA 2A Sediment at Sites F1 and U3, April 1996:
Percent Dry Weight and
delta symbol34S Values

Organic sulfur is the dominant sulfur species in another short core (top 15 cm) collected in WCA 2A in 1995 (Table 2 , Fig. 8), however the results are available only on a percentage wet weight basis. More positive delta symbol34S values for disulfide sulfur and organic sulfur are found in the near-surface sediment (top 3 cm) (Table 1 , Fig. 8) near the canal (F1) than far from the canal (U3new). This may be the result of higher rates of sulfate reduction near the canal.

WCA 2A Sediment Core F1
March 1995
graph of sulfur species in WCA 2A sediment at site F1, March 1995, percent wet weight
WCA 2A Sediment Core F1
March 1995
graph of sulfur species in WCA 2A sediment at site F1, March 1995, delta34S
WCA 2A Sediment Core U3 (new)
March 1995
graph of sulfur species in WCA 2A sediment at site U3(new), March 1995, percent wet weight
WCA 2A Sediment Core U3 (new)
March 1995
graph of sulfur species in WCA 2A sediment at site U3(new), March 1995, delta34S
key to graphs
Figure 8. Sulfur Species in WCA 2A Sediment at Sites F1 and U3 (new),
March 1995: Percent Wet Weight and delta symbol34S

Everglades Agricultural Area

Agricultural soil at the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) Research Center at Canal Point and at the University of Florida Agricultural Research Center was analyzed for total sulfur delta symbol34S values. These values fall in a range from 12.63 to 19.37, with higher values in the top 5 cm of the three cores sampled (Table 3 , Fig. 9). Total sulfur was determined only on a dry weight basis, and appears to increase with depth in the two meter core (Table 3 ).

Total Sulfur delta symbol34S Values at the U.S. Department of Agricultural Research Center at Canal Point, February 1994
graph of total sulfur delta34S values at the U.S. Department of Agricultural Research Center at Canal Point, February 1994
Total Sulfur delta symbol34S Values at the University of Florida Cane Field at Belle Glade, February 1994
graph of total sulfur delta34S values at the UF cane field at Belle Glade, February 1994
Total Sulfur delta symbol34S Values at the University of Florida Unused Field, February 1994
graph of total sulfur delta34S values at the UF unused field, February 1994
Figure 9

Lake Okeechobee

Total sulfur as a percent of dry weight was obtained for two cores from Lake Okeechobee, one from the center of the lake and the other from South Bay at the southern tip of the lake (Table 4 , Fig. 10). Total sulfur content is higher at the periphery of the lake than at the center, and both cores show a general decrease in sulfur content with depth.

graph of total sulfur content in the center of Lake Okeechobee cores, percent dry weight  graph of total sulfur content at the periphery of Lake Okeechobee cores, percent dry weight
Figure 10. Total sulfur content in Lake Okeechobee cores: Percent dry weight. Click for larger image.

Taylor Slough

Total sulfur contents (Table 5 , Fig. 11) are higher in the upper part of sediment collected at the head of Taylor Slough (Fig. 1) than in sediment collected in the middle part of the Slough (Fig. 1). This could be the result of the proximity of the head of the slough to agricultural fields and canal drainage (the head of the Slough also has higher total phosphorus levels in the sediment (Orem et al., 1999), possibly from agricultural runoff. Organic sulfur is the dominant sulfur species at both sites (Table 5 , Fig. 12). Sulfur species delta symbol34S values are positive at both sites (Table 5 , Fig. 12), indicating freshwater levels of sulfate. The delta symbol34S values of sulfate sulfur are quite high (approaching 30 per mil) near the top of the core at the head of the slough. This could be the result of a very restricted source of sulfate (not likely considering that the sulfur content is relatively high near the top of the core) or to high delta symbol34S values in the source sulfate.

Head of Taylor Slough at Site 3, May 1996:
Percent Dry Weight
graph of total sulfur content in sediment at the head of Taylor Slough at Site 3, May 1996, percent dry weight
Middle of Taylor Slough at Site 7, May 1996

graph of total sulfur content in sediment at the middle of Taylor Slough at Site 7, May 1996, percent dry weight

Figure 11. Total Sulfur Contents in Sediment from Taylor Slough, May 1996:
Percent Dry Weight

Head of Taylor Slough, Core 19
May 1996
graph of sulfur species at the head of Taylor Slough, Core 19, May 1996, percent dry weight
Head of Taylor Slough, Core 19
May 1996
graph of sulfur species at the head of Taylor Slough, Core 19, May 1996, delta34S
Middle of Taylor Slough, Site 3, Core 5
May 1996
graph of sulfur species at the middle of Taylor Slough, Core 5, May 1996, percent dry weight
Middle of Taylor Slough, Core 5, Site 3
May 1996
graph of sulfur species at the middle of Taylor Slough, Core 5, May 1996, delta34S
key to graphs
Figure 12. Species in Taylor Slough Sediment at Sites 3 and 7, May 1996:
Percent Dry Weight and delta symbol34S

Go back to Analytical Methods | Go ahead to Dissolved Sulfate




| Disclaimer | Privacy Statement | Accessibility |

U.S. Department of the Interior, U.S. Geological Survey
This page is: http://sofia.usgs.gov/publications/ofr/01-007/results.html
Comments and suggestions? Contact: Heather Henkel - Webmaster
Last updated: 29 November, 2004 @ 01:45 PM (KP)