Arbitration Decision Examples
From eotcd
Contents |
Arbitration Decisions by Disagreement Category
Additional Author(s)
californiadesert.gov
| Who | Notes | Classification |
| SME | Interagency author not in list: California Desert Innovative Management Laboratory | D 101. - Army Department; D 201. - Navy Department; D 301. - Air Force Department; I 19. - Geological Survey; I 29. - National Park Service; I 49. - Fish and Wildlife Service; I 53. - Land Management Bureau |
| SME | I 53. - Land Management Bureau | |
| ARB | Desert Managers Group - interagency, no clear lead agency | In Scope: Unable to Classify |
invasivespecies.gov
| Who | Notes | Classification |
| SME | "The National Invasive Species Council (NISC) was established by Executive Order (EO) 13112 to ensure that Federal programs and activities to prevent and control invasive species are coordinated, effective and efficient. NISC members are the Secretaries and Administrators of 13 federal departments and agencies to provide high-level coordination on invasive species and is co-chaired by the Secretaries of Commerce, Agriculture, and the Interior (see NISC Organizational Chart)." | A - Agriculture Department; C - Commerce Department; I - Interior Department |
| SME | Subagency author not in list: National Invasive Species Council. Website maintained by National Agricultural Library. | A - Agriculture Department; A 17. - National Agricultural Library |
| ARB | A 17. - National Agricultural Library |
landimaging.gov
| Who | Notes | Classification |
| SME | see http://www.landimaging.gov/charter.html | I 19. - Geological Survey; NAS - National Aeronautics and Space Administration; PREX - Executive Office of the President; PREX 23. - Science and Technology Policy Office |
| SME | Subagency author not in list: Office of Science and Technology Policy | PREX - Executive Office of the President |
| ARB | "Science & Technology Council link goes to Office of Sci & Tech Policy (this means reviewing several other sites where this connection was not so direct) PREX seal prominent" | PREX 23. - Science and Technology Policy Office |
bionet.gov
| Who | Notes | Classification |
| SME | C 55. - National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration; D - Defense Department; E - Energy Department | |
| SME | "Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) and our strategic partners are working together to build a comprehensive incident management system for the near-real-time detection, identification, and assessment of chemical, biological, radiological, nuclear, and explosive (CBRNE) threats." Listed partners are civilian. Main page shows seals for Department of Defense and NOAA. | E - Energy Department |
| ARB | CGP assigns pubs from Oak Ridge NL to E1.2: | E - Energy Department |
firescience.gov
| Who | Notes | Classification |
| SME | Interagency author not in list: Joint Fire Science Program | A - Agriculture Department; I - Interior Department |
| SME | "The Joint Fire Science Program (JFSP) was created by Congress in 1998 as an interagency research, development, and applications partnership between the U.S. Department of the Interior and the U.S. Department of Agriculture." All contacts are at BLM. | I 53. - Land Management Bureau |
| ARB | A lot of the subordinate pages (about, logo, etc.) not archived. Would bet lead agency is Forest Service. | In Scope: Unable to Classify |
Classified v. In Scope - Unable to Classify
acquisition.gov
| Who | Notes | Classification |
| SME | "IAE is under the auspices of OMB's Office of Federal Procurement Policy and the Chief Acquisition Officers Council." | PREX 2. - Management and Budget Office |
| SME | Cannot determine responsibility for site | In Scope: Unable to Classify |
| ARB | "Most likely GSA, but nothing on the site to support this directly" | In Scope: Unable to Classify |
execsec.gov
| Who | Notes | Classification |
| SME | A - Agriculture Department | |
| SME | "This site is hosted on behalf of the Council of Federal Executive Secretariats by the US Department of Agriculture, a member of the Council. Site contains documents which may be from agencies other than USDA." | In Scope: Unable to Classify |
| ARB | other presidential/executive councils classed as PR - needs class stem | PR - President of the United States |
No Agreement
identitytheft.gov
| Who | Notes | Classification |
| SME | FT - Federal Trade Commission | |
| SME | "One publication in CGP, classed for Justice Dept. United States. President's Identity Theft Task Force." | J - Justice Department |
| ARB | "The President's Task Force on Identity Theft was established by Executive Order 13402 on May 10, 2006, launching ... Some URI confusion here; same content at idtheft.gov" | PREX - Executive Office of the President |
manufacturing.gov
| Who | Notes | Classification |
| SME | C - Commerce Department | |
| SME | C 13. - National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST); PREX 23. - Science and Technology Policy Office | |
| ARB | Manufacturing and Services (MAS) is a unit of the International Trade Administration, and is dedicated to enhancing the global ... | C 61. - International Trade Administration |
recovery.gov
| Who | Notes | Classification |
| SME | Specifically: PR 44.8/2: | PR - President of the United States |
| SME | T - Treasury Department | |
| ARB | CGP classes the Board at PR 44.8/2: | PR - President of the United States |
africanburialground.gov
| Who | Notes | Classification |
| SME | GS - General Services Administration | |
| SME | I 29. - National Park Service | |
| ARB | GS - General Services Administration; I 29. - National Park Service |
cfo.gov
| Who | Notes | Classification |
| SME | CGP classified other publications of this group under GSA | GS - General Services Administration |
| SME | plus a host of others--admin by gsa? | PREX 2. - Management and Budget Office; T - Treasury Department |
| ARB | Subjectively a better choice than GSA the site host. | PREX 2. - Management and Budget Office |
Parent v. Subordinate
airnow.gov
| Who | Notes | Classification |
| SME | EPA, NOAA, NPS, etc. | EP - Environmental Protection Agency |
| SME | The U.S. EPA, NOAA, NPS, tribal, state, and local agencies developed the AIRNow Web site to provide the public with easy access to national air quality information. | EP 4.50: - Office of Air Quality Planning and Standards |
| ARB | AQPS listed as contact; others listed as partners | C 55. - National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration; EP 4.50: - Office of Air Quality Planning and Standards; I 29. - National Park Service |
health.gov
| Who | Notes | Classification |
| SME | HE - Health and Human Services Department | |
| SME | This site is coordinated by the Office of Disease Prevention and Health Promotion, Office of Public Health and Science, Office of the Secretary, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. | HE 20. - Office of Public Health and Science |
| ARB | HE 20. - Office of Public Health and Science |
Classified v. Out of Scope - Unable to Classify
findyouthinfo.gov
| Who | Notes | Classification |
| SME | D - Defense Department ED - Education Department | |
| SME | "Based on log-in requests at top of page." | Out of Scope: Unable to Classify |
| ARB | Interagency. Privacy statement refers to HHS. Definitely not Defense. | In Scope: Unable to Classify |
dra.gov
| Who | Notes | Classification |
| SME | A - Agriculture Department | |
| SME | "The governors of Alabama, Arkansas, Illinois, Kentucky, Louisiana, Mississippi, Missouri and Tennessee -- along with federal co-chairman Pete Johnson -- welcome you to the Delta Regional Authority website. This is a multi-state group." | Out of Scope: Unable to Classify |
| ARB | Out of Scope: Unable to Classify |
housedemocrats.gov
| Who | Notes | Classification |
| SME | Y 1.2: - House of Representatives | |
| SME | Out of Scope: Unable to Classify | |
| ARB | not the official page of the agency (USHOR) but only some of the members | Out of Scope: Unable to Classify |
In scope - Unable to Classify v. Out of Scope - Unable to Classify
cdatribe-nsn.gov
| Who | Notes | Classification |
| SME | native american tribal site...general category needed? | In Scope: Unable to Classify |
| SME | "Copyright (c) 2006 The Coeur d'Alene Tribe" | Out of Scope: Unable to Classify |
| ARB | individual tribe; not govt agency | Out of Scope: Unable to Classify |
mitigationcommission.gov
| Who | Notes | Classification |
| SME | In Scope: Unable to Classify | |
| SME | Utah not federal government | Out of Scope: Unable to Classify |
| ARB | The Utah Reclamation Mitigation and Conservation Commission is an Executive branch agency of the federal government. The Commission was authorized under the Central Utah Project Completion Act of 1992. | Y 3. - Commissions, Committees, and Boards |
fcg.gov
| Who | Notes | Classification |
| SME | In Scope: Unable to Classify | |
| SME | Out of Scope: Unable to Classify | |
| ARB | "Website hosted by the U.S. Treasury Department, no other attribution." | In Scope: Unable to Classify |
