Scottish independence: Britain faces 'constitutional crisis' at next election
Polls show MPs from north of the border could sweep Labour to power in 2015 – even if Scotland has already voted to become an independent country
Andrew Grice
Andrew Grice has been Political Editor of The Independent since 1998. He was previously Political Editor of The Sunday Times, where he worked for 10 years, and he has been a Westminster-based journalist since 1982. His column, Inside Politics, appears in The Independent each Saturday.
Tuesday 09 September 2014
Ministers are under pressure to explain how they would respond if Scots vote for independence, as it emerged that Labour is on course to win the general election only because of its strong support in Scotland.
The latest “poll of polls” for The Independent suggests that Ed Miliband will win an overall majority of 32 next May. But if Scottish MPs are excluded, there would be a hung parliament, with Labour three seats short of a majority.
“Scotland is potentially critical to Labour’s ability to win an overall majority,” said John Curtice, professor of politics at Strathclyde University, who compiled the data. At present, Labour holds 41 of the 59 Scottish seats at Westminster and could land another five if the latest polls are reflected next May. Labour is on 35 per cent, the Conservatives 31 per cent, Ukip 13 per cent and the Liberal Democrats nine per cent.
Some Conservative MPs want Scottish voters excluded from the general election if the country decides to break away. The Scottish National Party has called for the election to be postponed so it did not disrupt negotiations before “independence day” in March 2016.
Whitehall sources said that delaying an election for the first time since the Second World War has not been discussed by ministers. But one official admitted: “It is too sensitive before the referendum, but we couldn’t duck it any longer if there were a Yes vote.”
Senior MPs in the three main parties said postponing the election would be “very unlikely”. They fear it would be condemned as “anti-democratic” and a “constitutional outrage”, and would be a gift for Ukip.
John Redwood, the former Tory Cabinet minister, said Scots should not participate in next year’s election if they vote to leave the UK. He argued the election should take place as normal elsewhere, with existing Scottish MPs allowed to remain until independence.
The Scottish flag flutters next to the Union flag over Downing Street in London (Getty)
“Scottish MPs would only serve for less than a year and should not take an active part in non-Scottish matters. That seems to me the neatest solution,” he said.
Peter Riddell, director of the Institute for Government think tank, said the position would be “dangerous and unsustainable” if Mr Miliband won an overall majority due to Scottish MPs, presenting Labour with a “hellish” dilemma.
But Graham Allen, Labour chairman of the Select Committee on Political and Constitutional Reform, insisted that Labour would simply move from having an overall majority to requiring the support of other parties. “The numbers in the House of Commons would decide who the Government is,” he said.
David Cameron, Ed Miliband and Nick Clegg will all hit the campaign trail in Scotland tomorrow, instead of appearing at Prime Minister’s Questions in an attempt to arrest the slide in support for a No vote. After the idea was suggested by Mr Miliband, Mr Cameron agreed to tear up his diary. The three leaders will travel separately and campaign in different parts of Scotland but their message will be the same: “We want you to stay.”
Alex Salmond, the First Minister, said: “The message of this extraordinary, last-minute reaction is that the Westminster elite are in a state of absolute panic as the ground in Scotland shifts under their feet.”
Today Gordon Brown spoke movingly as he vowed to "nail the SNP lie" that Scotland's health service is at risk of privatisation. Addressing activists in Glasgow, his voice wavered slightly as he spoke about his baby daughter Jennifer Jane, who died from a brain haemorrhage in 2002, and how his sight was saved after a rugby accident left him blind in one eye at the age of 16.
The former Prime Minister said: "I love Scotland, I love the NHS. When my daughter died it was as the result of not being able to do anything to save her life, and my respect for the NHS grew as a result of the experience that Sarah and I had.”
First Minister Alex Salmond, with Scots and other European citizens, supporting the 'Yes' vote in Glasgow (Getty)
Mr Cameron ordered the Scottish saltire to be flown over Downing Street until next week’s referendum. But his gesture of solidarity with Scotland got off to an inauspicious start as the flag fell down the first time that workmen tried to run it up the flagpole.
* Writing in Wednesday's Daily Mail, Mr Cameron tells the Scottish people: "The choice for you is clear: a leap into the dark with a Yes vote, or a brighter future for Scotland by voting No. You can have the best of both worlds in the UK. You can have more powers in Scotland."
The Prime Minister says: "The UK is a precious and special country. That is what is at stake. So let no-one in Scotland be in any doubt: we desperately want you to stay; we do not want this family of nations to be ripped apart."
He adds: "If we pull together, we can keep on building a better future for our children. We can make sure our destiny matches our history, because there really will be no second chances. If the UK breaks apart, it breaks apart forever."
Presenter hits back at rumours of sacking after racism complaints
Dutch student Skyped her parents after mocking up a Thai hotel room
Couples hit hardest by economic downturn more likely to break up
First look at the vehicle ahead of Batman v Superman release in 2016
- 1 Pilot rescues baby elephant who survived massacre - by flying it home in four-seater plane
- 2 Queen tried to use state poverty fund to heat Buckingham Palace
- 3 ‘Extreme’ solar storm is heading straight for Earth following ‘giant magnetic explosion’ on the Sun
- 4 A bottle of wine a day is not bad for you and abstaining is worse than drinking, scientist claims
- 5 Life under Isis: Captured teenage girl tells story of horrendous abuse at hands of Islamic State militants
-
Sean O'Haire dead: Former WWE and WCW wrestler dies in apparent suicide
-
‘Extreme’ solar storm is heading straight for Earth following ‘giant magnetic explosion’ on the Sun
-
Male Japanese porn stars rarer than Bengal tigers - according to Japan's porn king Shimiken
-
Jennifer Lawrence and Kate Upton nude photos exhibition cancelled after artist concedes images were 'stolen property'
-
Jennifer Lawrence 'naked sex video' will be leaked next, threatens 4Chan celebrity photo hacker
-
Scottish independence: What happens if Scotland votes yes at the referendum?
-
Scottish independence: George Osborne offers Scotland fresh powers, but says no chance of sharing the pound
-
Scottish independence: 'Yes' vote takes the lead for first time in shock poll
-
Scottish independence: Britain faces 'constitutional crisis' at next election
-
Salmond accused of laughing off national debt with ‘what are they going to do: invade?’ joke
-
Scottish independence: Alex Salmond opens up war of words with BBC over RBS 'leak'
i100: A single mother on benefits who became one of the world's most successful authors
11 rags-to-riches underdog success stories
Visit Kent with Simon Calder
Simon Calder explores the delights of England’s Garden in the south-easternmost corner of Britain, now only a swift rail ride away. Watch the video here.
Visit Essex with Simon Calder
Simon Calder gets acquainted with the grassy hills, crinkled coastline and picture-perfect market towns of this dreamy rural haven. Watch the video here.
Forget top summer reads
here are our top five summer listens
Update your holiday wardrobe
Update your holiday wardrobe with tropical prints, the perfect pair of sandals and some seriously stylish swimwear to make a splash in. Bon voyage.
Get Reddy
For a hint of autumnal elegance opt for boozy hues of tomato, rouge and claret. Get reddy says Melanie Wilkinson
Get the look. See the trends.
Westfield and Snapfashion team up to create a new digital styling tool. Create a style board or browse this season's trends. #editme.
Jake Bugg: "I’m the one I have to answer to…"
Fresh out of his teenage years, singer-songwriter Jake Bugg has achieved the kind of success that most aspiring musicians can merely dream of.
Enter the latest Independent competitions
Win anything from gadgets to five-star holidays on our competitions and offers page.
Business videos from commercial thought leaders
Watch the best in the business world give their insights into the world of business.
Independent Dating
iJobs General
Cover Supervisor
£60 - £90 per day: Randstad Education Leeds: The JobSeveral cover supervisors ...
Maths Teacher
£100 - £150 per day: Randstad Education Sheffield: My Client is looking for a ...
SQL DBA (SSIS, ETL) - London, £60k
£60000 per annum: Ashdown Group: SQL DBA (SSIS, ETL) - London, £60,000 London ...
Qualified Secondary Teachers
£121 - £130 per day: Randstad Education Luton: SECONDARY TEACHERS in Hitchin a...