Astrobiology: Life in the Universe

NASA Astrobiology Institute (NAI)


  1. The Diversity of the Original Prebiotic Soup: Re-Analyzing the Original Miller-Urey Spark Discharge Experiments

    Project Investigators: Jeffrey Bada

    Other Project Members

    Adam Johnson (Doctoral Student)

    Summary

    Recently obtained samples from some of the original Stanley Miller spark discharge experiments have been reanalyzed using High Pressure Liquid Chromatography-Flame Detection and Liquid Chromatography-Flame Detection/Time of Flight-Mass Spectrometry in order to identify lesser constituents that would have been undetectable by analytical techniques 50 years ago. Results show the presence of several isoforms of aminobutyric acid, as well as several serine species, isomers of threonine, isovaline, valine, phenylalanine, ornithine, adipic acid, ethanolamine and other methylated and hydroxylated amino acids. Diversity and yield increased in experiments utilizing an aspirating device to increase the gas flow rates; this could be applied as a simulation of prebiotic chemistry during a volcanic eruption. The variety of products formed in these experiments is significantly greater than previously published and mimic the assortment of compounds detected in Murchison and CM meteorites.

    Astrobiology Roadmap Objectives:

    Project Progress

    Experiments were carried out to mimic the present Martian diurnal cycling of a Mg-Fe-Ca-Na-SO4 brine derived from acidic weathering of olivine-laden basalt. Experimental brines were laced with an enantiomeric excess of amino acids. Testing was done with and without exposure to the photolytic effects of UV radiation and utilizing a diurnal temperature cycle suitable for simulation of evaporation and sublimation processes in a Martian paleolake or permafrost system.

    Results indicate that iron containing brines in the presence of UV are prone to increased levels of amino acid degradation due to photo-Fenton oxidation reactions. In the absence of UV, iron-rich brines provide enhanced preservation, with half lives 200-300% longer than systems lacking iron. Racemization half lives are 30 and 50 times greater than corresponding degradation half lives in iron and non-iron samples, respectively. These initial results provide interesting scenarios in the preservation of organic matter on Mars; an iron-rich subsurface groundwater system, such as those attributed to hematite concretion formation, may provide increased organic matter preservation. Additionally, a limiting factor in life detection may not be the detection of an enantiomeric excess of amino acids but detecting a pool of amino acids at all.

    In addition to laboratory brines, we are studying a hydrologically closed basin system in southern California as a Mars analog environment. Samples from a long sediment core (30 meters) drilled at Soda Lake in the Carrizo Plain are being analyzed to determine the yield of enantiomeric excess of amino acids in lacustrine sediments dominated by interbedded clay- and sulfate-mineral assemblages. Obtained values will provide rates of amino acid racemization in environments dominated by seasonal to decadal cycles of evaporation and precipitation of sulfate and chloride minerals.


    Stanley Miller's PhD thesis at the University of Chicago was published in 1955. He used three different experimental configurations (A, B, C). One (A) was the classic Miller spark discharge apparatus; another (B) incorporated an aspirating nozzle to increase the gas flow rate through the apparatus and the third (C) incorporated the aspirator device, but in place of the spark discharge electrodes it used a silent discharge device.

    Mission Involvement

    MSL
    Detection of complex organic molecules, including amino acids and peptides, is a key goal of MSL. The Miller-Urey experimental products contain complex mixtures of organic molecules containing nitrogen. The Miller-Urey products are historically important and are scientifically important as analogs for abiotic organic matter delivered to Mars by meteorites or produced on Mars by hydrothermal reactions.