Question and Answer: Medicare and the Republican Budget
APRIL 3, 2009
"The real problem with our long-term deficit actually has to do with our entitlement obligations...The big problem is Medicare, which is unsustainable." – President Obama, Interview with Washington Post editorial board, January 15, 2009 On April 2, 2009, the House of Representatives considered the Republican budget alternative, which failed by a vote of 137-293. The Republican Conference has compiled background on the Medicare reforms offered as part of the Republican budget alternative. According to one press account, the plan would “end Medicare.” This claim is flatly untrue. Does the Republican budget alternative end Medicare?No. For current Medicare beneficiaries—and those within ten years of Medicare eligibility—nothing in the current program will change, except that very high-income beneficiaries will have their government subsidies for prescription drug coverage reduced, as the President’s own budget proposed. When those who are currently aged 54 years and younger turn 65 and become eligible for Medicare, they will receive a premium subsidy from the government to purchase a Medicare-approved health plan of their choice—similar to how Members of Congress receive their health benefits. The amount of the premium subsidy will total 100% of current Medicare spending—rising annually according to inflation. Those with high health care costs, including older and sicker individuals, will receive higher subsidies. Low income seniors will also receive extra financial help. Additionally, for the first time in the program’s history, seniors will be protected from bankruptcy if they get sick as a result of a new cap on out-of-pocket expenses. Does the Republican budget alternative cut Medicare?No. Medicare spending will grow every year under the Republican budget. The Republican budget would simply slow the rate of growth of a program that is currently growing itself into extinction. Without action, is Medicare going bankrupt?Yes. The Hospital Insurance (HI) Trust Fund, which funds Medicare Part A, is currently paying out more in benefits than it is collecting through the payroll tax. As a result, the HI Trust Fund is expected to go bankrupt as early as 2016, just seven years from now. Last year’s Medicare trustees report found that the program faces overall shortfalls of $36 trillion—nearly three times current GDP levels. Government projections also indicate that by 2040, our country’s major entitlement programs—Social Security, Medicare, and Medicaid—will consume the entirety of today’s budget as they struggle to meet the cost of retiring Baby Boomers and the continued growth in cost of providing health care. Is there a broad consensus that Medicare needs to be reformed?Yes. The Federal Reserve, the Congressional Budget Office, the General Accountability Office, the Brookings Institution, and the Concord Coalition have all said Medicare must be reformed to slow its growth—a recognition that Medicare is the primary contributor to the federal budget’s long-term problems. Even President Obama has acknowledged the entitlement problem and admitted that Medicare is at its heart, as noted above. Is government health spending increasing faster than private health spending?Yes. Recent projections from government actuaries at the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) found that between 2007 and 2018, spending on both Medicare (7.3%) and Medicaid (8.4%) will significantly outpace private sector health spending growth of 5.3%. Thus some Members may believe that slowing the growth of health care costs alone will not address Medicare’s pending shortfalls; structural reforms are necessary as well. The current Medicare program is also subject to high rates of fraud and waste. The Government Accountability Office has put Medicare on its “high risk” list due to this problem. Has competition helped bring down Medicare spending, while increasing quality of care and choice of plans?Yes. As a result of the intense competition among plans offering Medicare prescription drug benefits, independent actuaries at CMS recently found that the Part D drug benefit is projected to cost less than $395 billion—nearly 40% lower than the $634 billion figure cited at the time the Medicare prescription drug plan became law in 2003. Does President Obama’s budget improve Medicare’s solvency?No—in fact, it undermines Medicare’s solvency by increasing overall Medicare spending. While the President’s budget includes some proposals to slow the growth of Medicare, they are more than offset by projected new spending. Moreover, all the purported efficiencies found within Medicare are re-directed to the health care “reserve fund” to pay for new entitlement spending. At a time when Medicare faces unfunded shortfalls totaling $36 trillion, some Members may question why the solvency of a program for vulnerable seniors is given short shrift in the Obama budget, in order to finance a new government-run health plan that will cause as many as 120 million Americans to lose their current coverage. What plans have Democrats brought forward to slow the growth of health care costs and restore Medicare’s solvency?None. The only “plans” put forward by Democrats have revolved around creating a new entitlement to government-run health care—financed in the President’s case by new tax increases. Many Members may question how creating a program that may cost as much as $1.5 trillion will slow the growth of health care costs, and whether creating a new government-run health plan, causing as many as 120 million Americans to lose their current health coverage, is the first step towards government rationing of benefits in order to contain cost growth. Staff ContactChris Jacobs, christopher.jacobs@mail.house.gov, (202) 226-2302
Related Documents
August 18, 2009
Even as President Obama campaigned on a platform of change and transparency, recent dealings between the pharmaceutical industry and the...
August 17, 2009
WASHINGTON, DC-U.S. Congressman Mike Pence, Chairman of the House Republican Conference, issued the following statement today regarding the six month...
August 10, 2009
If you are an anti-war protestor...According to the San Francisco Chronicle, after meeting with a group of anti-war protestors, Speaker...
August 10, 2009
Washington, DC - U.S. Congressman Mike Pence, Chairman of the House Republican Conference, responded today, on Fox News' America's Newsroom,...
August 06, 2009
The House Republican Conference released a new web video today in response to a recent White House video on "DISINFORMATION"...
August 06, 2009
In order to assist Members, staff, and interested parties seeking to read and review the health "reform" legislation (H.R. 3200)...
July 31, 2009
Washington, DC - U.S. Congressman Mike Pence, Chairman of the House Republican Conference, made the following statement today after last...
July 28, 2009
Participants:- Republican Leader John Boehner (R-OH)- Republican Whip Eric Cantor (R-VA)- Republican Conference Chairman Mike Pence (R-IN)- Republican Conference Vice...
July 23, 2009
"I'm always in favor of Congress sticking around long enough to get the right thing done but if the Democrats...
July 22, 2009
"The President of the United States may 'mean it' when he says a government takeover of health care won't add...
July 22, 2009
To view this clip, click here.Transcript below: [Clip of Hoyer on the House floor] MIKA BRZEZINSKI: Wow, ok then. Here with us...
July 21, 2009
Washington, DC - U.S. Congressman Mike Pence, Chairman of the House Republican Conference, made the following statement on the House...
July 17, 2009
During the worst recession in a generation Democrats propose a government takeover of health care that will lead to fewer...
July 14, 2009
Washington, DC - U.S. Congressman Mike Pence, Chairman of the House Republican Conference, made the following statement today after House...
July 08, 2009
WASHINGTON, DC - U.S. Congressman Mike Pence, Chairman of the House Republican Conference appeared on FOXNEWS this morning to react...
June 23, 2009
The Republican Conference has compiled a list of important numbers relevant to the House Democrats’ 1,018-page “America’s Affordable Health Choices...
June 22, 2009
BackgroundOn June 19, 2009, the Chairmen of the three House Committees with jurisdiction over health care legislation—Education and Labor Chairman...
May 21, 2009
Former DNC chair's government-run insurance program is sure to backfire. Just ask his wife the doctorBy Phil Gingrey, M.D.Posted May...
May 15, 2009
by Robert Pear, The New York TimesWASHINGTON - Hospitals and insurance companies said Thursday that President Obama had substantially overstated...
May 12, 2009
Washington, DC - U.S. Congressman Mike Pence, Chairman of the House Republican Conference, issued the following statement today in response...
May 11, 2009
As the American people struggle to make ends meet, too many also live with the challenge of affording basic health...
May 06, 2009
*This post originally appeared on Net Right Nation.by Rep. John Shadegg (AZ)Are you ready for health care rationing? Are you...
May 01, 2009
http://www.breitbart.tv/html/330913.htmlRep. Jan Schakowsky (D-IL): "And next to me was a guy from the insurance company, who then argued against the...
March 23, 2009
Rep. Jeff Flake (AZ) gets a few words in at the American Spectator this morning, offering insight from the mind...
March 23, 2009
Rep. Jeff Flake (AZ) gets a few words in at the American Spectator this morning, offering insight from the mind...
March 09, 2009
"What it's supposed to do for people doesn't get done in reality."The speaker criticizing this government program wasn't talking about...
March 05, 2009
President Obama said government-run health care was “extreme” and “wrong” but…Then-Candidate Obama said government- run health care was “extreme” and...
March 04, 2009
President Obama's budget proposal includes nearly $1 trillion in new health care spending-a $634 billion reserve fund as a "down...
February 26, 2009
President Obama's budget includes nearly $1 trillion in new health spending-a $634 billion reserve fund as a "down payment" for...
February 23, 2009
"We shouldn't have to do that, because they should know better."So said President Obama in explaining why the Treasury-quite rightly-forced...
February 10, 2009
In light of the inclusion of $1.1 billion in the Democrat "stimulus" legislation for the Agency for Healthcare Research and...
February 04, 2009
In anticipation of a potential vote to reauthorize and expand the State Children’s Health Insurance Program (SCHIP), the Republican Conference...
January 14, 2009
Congressman Mike Pence (R-IN), Chairman of the House Republican Conference, issued the following statement today regarding House consideration of a...
|
|