WSJ: The Cap and Tax Fiction
Democrats off-loading economics to pass climate change bill |
|
JUNE 25, 2009
House Speaker Nancy Pelosi has put cap-and-trade legislation on a forced march through the House, and the bill may get a full vote as early as Friday. It looks as if the Democrats will have to destroy the discipline of economics to get it done. Despite House Energy and Commerce Chairman Henry Waxman's many payoffs to Members, rural and Blue Dog Democrats remain wary of voting for a bill that will impose crushing costs on their home-district businesses and consumers. The leadership's solution to this problem is to simply claim the bill defies the laws of economics.
Their gambit got a boost this week, when the Congressional Budget Office did an analysis of what has come to be known as the Waxman-Markey bill. According to the CBO, the climate legislation would cost the average household only $175 a year by 2020. Edward Markey, Mr. Waxman's co-author, instantly set to crowing that the cost of upending the entire energy economy would be no more than a postage stamp a day for the average household. Amazing. A closer look at the CBO analysis finds that it contains so many caveats as to render it useless.
For starters, the CBO estimate is a one-year snapshot of taxes that will extend to infinity. Under a cap-and-trade system, government sets a cap on the total amount of carbon that can be emitted nationally; companies then buy or sell permits to emit CO2. The cap gets cranked down over time to reduce total carbon emissions.
To get support for his bill, Mr. Waxman was forced to water down the cap in early years to please rural Democrats, and then severely ratchet it up in later years to please liberal Democrats. The CBO's analysis looks solely at the year 2020, before most of the tough restrictions kick in. As the cap is tightened and companies are stripped of initial opportunities to "offset" their emissions, the price of permits will skyrocket beyond the CBO estimate of $28 per ton of carbon. The corporate costs of buying these expensive permits will be passed to consumers.
The biggest doozy in the CBO analysis was its extraordinary decision to look only at the day-to-day costs of operating a trading program, rather than the wider consequences energy restriction would have on the economy. The CBO acknowledges this in a footnote: "The resource cost does not indicate the potential decrease in gross domestic product (GDP) that could result from the cap."
The hit to GDP is the real threat in this bill. The whole point of cap and trade is to hike the price of electricity and gas so that Americans will use less. These higher prices will show up not just in electricity bills or at the gas station but in every manufactured good, from food to cars. Consumers will cut back on spending, which in turn will cut back on production, which results in fewer jobs created or higher unemployment. Some companies will instead move their operations overseas, with the same result.
When the Heritage Foundation did its analysis of Waxman-Markey, it broadly compared the economy with and without the carbon tax. Under this more comprehensive scenario, it found Waxman-Markey would cost the economy $161 billion in 2020, which is $1,870 for a family of four. As the bill's restrictions kick in, that number rises to $6,800 for a family of four by 2035.
Note also that the CBO analysis is an average for the country as a whole. It doesn't take into account the fact that certain regions and populations will be more severely hit than others -- manufacturing states more than service states; coal producing states more than states that rely on hydro or natural gas. Low-income Americans, who devote more of their disposable income to energy, have more to lose than high-income families.
Even as Democrats have promised that this cap-and-trade legislation won't pinch wallets, behind the scenes they've acknowledged the energy price tsunami that is coming. During the brief few days in which the bill was debated in the House Energy Committee, Republicans offered three amendments: one to suspend the program if gas hit $5 a gallon; one to suspend the program if electricity prices rose 10% over 2009; and one to suspend the program if unemployment rates hit 15%. Democrats defeated all of them.
The reality is that cost estimates for climate legislation are as unreliable as the models predicting climate change. What comes out of the computer is a function of what politicians type in. A better indicator might be what other countries are already experiencing. Britain's Taxpayer Alliance estimates the average family there is paying nearly $1,300 a year in green taxes for carbon-cutting programs in effect only a few years.
Americans should know that those Members who vote for this climate bill are voting for what is likely to be the biggest tax in American history. Even Democrats can't repeal that reality.
Note: To view this article online, click here.
Related Documents
August 24, 2009
The House Republican Conference has compiled new data that has become available since the House passed the national energy tax...
July 27, 2009
Truth #20: Lights off in Homes, but Lights on for ArtWhat the bill does: Mandates that light fixtures, intended to...
July 24, 2009
Truth #19: Federal Government: If It Works, We’ll Replace ItWhat the bill does: Provides taxpayer resources, $1.8 billion between 2011...
July 22, 2009
Truth #17: Taxpayer Sponsored InfomercialsWhat the bill does: Authorizes taxpayer money to be used by the Secretary of Energy to...
July 21, 2009
Truth #16: Taxpayer-Funded “Carbon Content” LabelsWhat the bill does: Authorizes $25 million of taxpayers’ money each year, for the next...
July 20, 2009
Truth #15: Subsidizes Studies on Human BehaviorWhat the bill does: Authorizes “such sums as may be necessary” to research American...
July 17, 2009
Truth #14: No Household Appliance is Safe from Government RegulationWhat the bill does: The bill authorizes taxpayer dollars to subsidize...
July 16, 2009
Truth #13: Higher Energy Rates to Pay for Bike Paths in SenegalWhat the bill does: The federal government will provide...
July 15, 2009
Truth #12: Attempts to save trees in the Congo while forcing Americans to pay more for energyWhat the bill does:...
July 14, 2009
Truth #11: Liberal Democrats Tell Real Estate Appraisers How to do Their JobsWhat the bill does: Mandates federal standards for...
July 13, 2009
Truth #10: Raises Electricity Prices and Kills JobsWhat the bill does: The bill mandates a “cap” on carbon emissions, while...
July 10, 2009
Truth #9: Taxpayer Dollars to Help Developing Countries “Adapt” to Climate ChangeWhat the bill does: Requires the Secretary of State,...
July 09, 2009
Truth #8: Increases Utility Rates on America’s Families and BusinessesWhat the bill does: Mandates a Renewable Electricity Standard, or RES,...
July 08, 2009
Truth #7: Yet Another Taxpayer-Funded Giveaway to ACORNWhat the bill does: The bill allocates taxpayer funds to groups like ACORN,...
July 07, 2009
Truth #6: Uses American Tax Dollars to Plant TreesWhat the bill does: Authorizes such “sums as may be necessary” to...
July 06, 2009
Truth #5: Taxpayer-Funded Mobile HomesWhat the bill does: The Democrats’ national energy tax requires electricity providers and gasoline distributers to...
July 03, 2009
Truth #4: Promotes “Green Banks” At a Time of Record Job LossesWhat the bill does: Requires federal banking agencies and the...
July 02, 2009
Truth #3: Creates the Largest Welfare Program in Our Nation’s HistoryWhat the bill does: The bill (H.R. 2454) requires the...
July 01, 2009
Truth #2: Democrats Want Fannie and Freddie to do to our National Energy Policy what They Have Done to the...
June 30, 2009
Truth # 1- Federal Government Intrusion: The Federal Government Wants to Tell You How to Build Your HouseWhat the bill...
June 26, 2009
Washington, DC - U.S. Congressman Mike Pence, Chairman of the House Republican Conference, made the following statement on the floor...
June 26, 2009
To view this clip on Bloomberg with Mark Crumpton, click here.Transcript below:Mark Crumpton: For more let's go to Capitol Hill...
June 18, 2009
Based on the allowance allocation formula in H.R. 2454 for electricity consumers, the red states will not have enough allowances...
June 11, 2009
Washington, DC - U.S. Congressman Mike Pence, Chairman of the House Republican Conference, made the following statement on the floor...
June 11, 2009
"‘I'm just estimating the number of votes that will be against this,' Peterson said. ‘I suspect that the list has...
June 11, 2009
The Wall Street JournalThe GOP's Energy AlternativeWe need more nuclear power.By Mike Pence, John Shimkus and Fred UptonWhile the price...
June 10, 2009
House GOP Brings Back 'All of the Above' as Response to Dems' Energy AgendaBy Alex Kaplun, E&E reporterHouse Republicans today...
June 10, 2009
House Republicans Introduce Alternative to Speaker Pelosi's National Energy TaxGuest blog post by Rep. Mike PenceDemocrats' national energy tax wages...
June 10, 2009
Transcript below:MIKA BRZEZINSKI: With us now Republican Representative from Indiana and Chairman of the House Republican Conference, Congressman Mike Pence....
June 10, 2009
New York Times: House Republicans Draft Energy Bill With Heavy Focus on Nuclear PowerAmerican Energy Solutions Group Chairman Mike Pence's...
June 10, 2009
The New York TimesJune 10, 2009 House Republicans Draft Energy Bill With Heavy Focus on Nuclear PowerBy JOHN M. BRODERWASHINGTON -...
June 10, 2009
House Republicans recognize that as gas prices and home utility bills rise, American families are dealt an even greater economic...
June 10, 2009
"Today House Republicans are introducing the American Energy Act, an ‘all of the above' plan that offers energy independence, more...
May 26, 2009
The House of Representatives isn't usually known for its shipbuilding skills. Nevertheless, thirty-six Members of the body have spent the...
May 21, 2009
As Democrats push forward with a $646 billion national energy tax, Henry Waxman, chairman of the Energy and Commerce Committee...
May 14, 2009
Democrat Charlie Rangel, Chairman, House Ways and Means Committee, was quoted in this evening's Congress Daily as saying: "Whether you...
May 05, 2009
As prepared for delivery:U.S. Congressman Mike Pence, Chairman of the House Republican Conference, and Chair of the American Energy Solutions...
May 01, 2009
Pence: Cap-and-Trade 'Declaration of War,' to Cost US Families $3,100/Year...Cap and Trade a ‘Declaration of War,' Say RepublicansBy Josiah Ryan,...
April 29, 2009
The Democrat's cap and tax plan is nothing more than a national energy tax.The truth behind the Democrat's cap and...
April 28, 2009
Rep. Kevin McCarthy (CA) and Rep. Steve Scalise (LA) spoke with bloggers today about the cap and tax energy bill...
April 27, 2009
After three days of hearing on the cap and tax global warming legislation last week, Republicans are billing it a...
April 24, 2009
Washington, DC - U.S. Congressman Mike Pence, Chairman of the House Republican Conference, made the following statement today in response...
April 24, 2009
Chairman Emeritus of Energy and Commerce Committee, John Dingell (D-MI), calls cap and trade as it is: “Nobody in this...
April 23, 2009
*This post originally published on Townhall.comby Rep. Steve Scalise (LA)President Obama is proposing a “cap and trade” energy tax that...
April 23, 2009
Washington, DC – U.S. Congressman Mike Pence, Chairman of the House Republican Conference, made the following statement on the House...
April 22, 2009
SummaryBoth Presidents Clinton and Obama called for a sweeping national energy tax in their inaugural budget submissions. In 1993, Clinton...
April 22, 2009
By John McCormack Weekly Standard April 22, 2009 It's just another inconvenient truth: If Americans want any of the government remedies...
April 22, 2009
6:52 p.m. The Democrat Energy PlanCap and Trade: Caps Economic Growth and Trades Jobs Overseas6:25 p.m.Rep. Michael Burgess on the...
April 21, 2009
STATUSOn March 31, 2009, House Energy and Commerce Chairman Waxman (D-CA) and Energy and Environment Subcommittee Chairman Markey (D-MA) released...
April 20, 2009
House Leader John Boehner appeared yesterday on "This Week" with George Stephanopoulos, saying legislators should beware of "trillion dollar deficits...
March 20, 2009
Rep. Virginia Foxx (NC) has been stirring the pot lately, with her explosive House floor ventures and determined messages on...
March 17, 2009
Taxing Too Much: The President's "Cap and Tax" ProposalMarch 17, 2009 Under my plan of a cap and trade system electricity...
|
|