Ecosystem   Considerations  in  Fisheries  Management:
Linking Ecosystem Management Goals with Ecosystem Research
by  Patricia A. Livingston

click here for other contributors

Introduction

As fishery management organizations make progress in incorporating ecosystem-oriented thinking into management, there is a need to more clearly define the ecosystem-oriented management goals of the organization and the tools available to managers to attain those goals. Parallel to this must be an expansion of the scientific advice provided to management beyond traditional single-species stock assessment advice. There is a broad spectrum of ecosystem research currently being conducted that can provide useful advice to managers in this regard including GLOBEC and GLOBEC-like research efforts, habitat research, ongoing trophic interactions work, and long-term monitoring of non-commercial species. Although the ultimate goal is to have quantitative predictions from this research to guide management, these efforts already serve as indicators of ecosystem status and trends. These indicators can provide an early warning system for managers, signalling human or climate-induced changes that may warrant management action. They can also serve to track the success of previous ecosystem-oriented management efforts. The North Pacific Fishery Management Council (NPFMC) has started to include some of this ecosystem research information in an ecosystem considerations document that accompanies the traditional stock assessment reports. I outline here a proposed revision of this document that will include ecosystem status and trend information and link management actions with ecosystem observations.

 
Ecosystem-Oriented  Management  Goals:
Management goals with regard to the ecosystem must be explicitly stated in order to derive standards to measure and track the success of ecosystem-oriented management efforts.


Ecosystem Goals of the North Pacific Fishery Management Council
  1. Maintain biodiversity consistent with natural evolutionary and ecological processes, including dynamic change and variability.
  2. Maintain and restore habitats essential for fish and their prey.
  3. Maintain system sustainability and sustainable yields for human consumption and non-extractive uses.
  4. Maintain the concept that humans are components of the ecosystem.


Ecosystem  Management  Indicators:
Purpose:
Measure performance towards meeting the stated ecosystem management goals.

Advantages:

  1. Provides early signals of direct human effects on ecosystem components that might warrant management intervention
    (Figures 7, 9, 10)
  2. Provides evidence of the efficacy of previous management action (Figure 8)

Ecosystem  Status  Indicators:

Purpose:  Measure ecosystem status and trends.

Advantages:

  1. Brings the results of ecosystem research efforts to the attention of stock assessment scientists and fishery managers, which will provide stronger links between ecosystem research and fishery management (Figures 5, 6)
  2. Brings together many, diverse research efforts into one document, which will spur new understanding of the connections between ecosystem components and the possible role that climate, humans, or both may have on the system (Figures 1, 2, 3, 4)


graphic.jpg (171748 bytes)