United States Senate Committee on
Commerce, Science & Transportation
Home | Graphics On | Site Map | Text Size: A A A Search : + Advanced Search
 
Press Releases
For Immediate Release
06/24/09
Contact: Jena Longo - Democratic Deputy Communications Director 202.224.7824
Email This
Print This
Chairman Rockefeller's Remarks on Consumer Choices and Transparency in the Health Insurance Industry
 
Washington, D.C. -
Today’s hearing is about protecting consumers so I want to start by talking about a consumer.
 
Her name is Jill Faddis.  Back in 2001, she and her husband were living in Seattle, Washington.  They had health insurance coverage through the Aetna insurance company.
 
Their Aetna policy covered visits to doctors who were not part Aetna’s network.  The policy promised the Faddises that if they went to see out-of-network doctors, Aetna would reimburse them at the “usual and customary” rate for the Seattle area.
 
So relying on Aetna’s promise, Jill Faddis’s husband went to visit a local periodontist.  A periodontist is a dentist who has special training in treating serious gum problems.  The periodontist charged Mr. Faddis $140 dollars for the visit.   The charge was sent to Aetna, which processed the claim and reimbursed the Faddises only $65 for the visit.  
 
Aetna told Mrs. Faddis that $65 dollars was the “usual and customary” charge for this service, and that she and her husband would have to pay the $75 dollar balance on the bill. 
 
Mrs. Faddis didn’t take Aetna’s word for it.  She took out her Yellow Pages and called every periodontist in her area.  There were about eleven or twelve of them.
 
I’d like to pass out a chart showing what she found.
 
She found that the actual “usual and customary” fee periodontists in her area were charging for the service was somewhere between $110 and $163 for the service.
 
She shared her research with Aetna.  She told them they had made a mistake.  Aetna told Mrs. Faddis they had not made a mistake.   Aetna told her that THEIR calculation of the “reasonable and customary” for the service was $65.
 
This story doesn’t have a happy ending.  Mr. and Mrs. Faddis paid the $75 dollars out of their own pocket, and went on with their lives, rather than continuing to fight a big insurance company.
 
This is a disheartening story.  And the thing that’s most disheartening about it is that it gets repeated millions of times a year.  Over and over again, consumers turn to their health insurer for help and clarity and they don’t get it.
 
They think they’ve paid for protection against the risk of high health-care expenses, but the insurance company has figured out a way to wiggle out of providing this protection.
 
The Faddises paid their $75 dollars and moved on.  But think about the consumer with $100,000 of medical bills for her breast cancer treatment.  Or think about the heart attack victim whose bills total $80,000. 
 
When insurance companies fail to meet their obligations to these people, it literally becomes a matter of life and death.
 
Consumers can’t make real choices because the insurance industry doesn’t use standard language or definitions.   And consumers can’t challenge insurance companies’ decisions because the companies don’t explain the terms of coverage in clear, understandable language.
 
This is unacceptable.
 
I’m very happy we have two health care experts today who can help us understand why consumers get such a raw deal from their insurance companies.  And I’m hoping they can give us some ideas about how we can level the playing field between consumers and the insurance industry. 
 
I’m also very pleased to welcome Mr. Wendell Potter to the Committee today.  He is a former insurance executive who is going to tell us about some of the tactics insurance companies use to keep consumers in the dark.
 
I want to express my sincere appreciation to Mr. Potter for coming forward at this important juncture in the health care debate, and for speaking publicly about the industry where he spent most of his career.
 
Before I close my remarks, I want to add a very important point:
 
A few months ago, this Committee started looking at the many problems consumers have with the health insurance industry, and we’re going to continue doing it.   In March, we had two hearings about the deceptive Ingenix database products that the insurance industry used to under-reimburse millions of consumers.
 
The Committee staff has been continuing to investigate this issue, and recently sent me a written report on what they have found so far.  I circulated this staff report to members this morning, and now ask unanimous consent to insert this report and its exhibits into the record of this hearing.
 
I look forward to our discussion today and to what we may learn about the parts of our health care system that are so desperately in need of reform.  As we pursue our goal of comprehensive health care reform legislation, we can’t forget consumers.     
 
###
 
« Previous Press Release Press Releases Next Press Release »
 
June 2009 Press Releases  « May | July »   « 2008 | 2010 » 
 
30th -  Chairman Rockefeller Calls for Further Investigation into Seafood Inspection Practices
 
29th -  Chairman Rockefeller Calls for Safe and Secure Disposal of Sensitive Consumer Information
 
26th -  Chairman Rockefeller Statement on Nominees Confirmed
 
25th -  Hutchison Statement on Confirmation of Larry Strickling to Lead NTIA
 
25th -  Hutchison Statement on Confirmation of FCC Nominees Genachowski and McDowell
 
25th -  Senator Hutchison Voices Support for Republican FCC Nominee Meredith Attwell Baker
 
24th -  Hearing Summary: Consumer Choices and Transparency in the Health Insurance Industry
 
24th -  current Press Release
 
24th -  BREAKING NEWS: Chairman Rockefeller Releases New Investigative Report Revealing Widespread Deceptive Health Insurance Practices
 
24th -  SENATE COMMERCE COMMITTEE RELEASES INVESTIGATIVE STAFF REPORT
 
23rd -  Chairman Rockefeller's Remarks on "High-Speed Passenger Rail: How Fast Will It Get Here?"
 
23rd -  Hutchison: High Speed Rail is Crucial to America’s Transportation Future
 
22nd -  Chairman Rockefeller Statement on Travel Promotion Act
 
22nd -  Chairman Rockefeller and Senator Boxer Request Rail Safety Funding
 
18th -  Hearing Summary: Freight Transportation In America: Options For Improving The Nation’s Network
 
18th -  Chairman Rockefeller's Remarks on Freight Transportation in America: Options for Improving the Nation's Network
 
18th -  Chairman Rockefeller Statement on FCC Nominations
 
18th -  Commerce Committee Approves Nominees
 
17th -  Chairman Rockefeller Applauds President Obama’s Financial Proposal
 
17th -  Hearing Summary: The Consumer Wireless Experience
 
17th -  IN CASE YOU MISSED IT: Senator Hutchison Gives Updates on GM and Chrysler Automotive Dealers on Senate Floor
 
17th -  Chairman Rockefeller's Remarks on the Consumer Wireless Experience
 
17th -  Hutchison Statement on Consumer Wireless Experience
 
17th -  Sen. Hutchison’s Opening Statement to NASA’s Human Space Flight Review Panel
 
17th -  Hearing Summary: Aviation Safety: The Role and Responsibility of Commercial Air Carriers and Employees
 
17th -  Chairman Rockefeller Introduces Bill To Protect Public Access To Key Information During Emergencies
 
17th -  Chairman Rockefeller's Opening Remarks on Aviation Safety: The Role and Responsibility of Commercial Air Carriers and Employees
 
17th -  IN CASE YOU MISSED IT: Create fair highway-funding formula; do not institute tolls as a double tax
 
16th -  Chairman Rockefeller's Opening Remarks at the CPSC Nomination Hearing
 
16th -  Chairman Rockefeller's Opening Remarks at FCC Nominations Hearing
 
16th -  Senate Commerce Committee Receives Requested Responses From GM and Chrysler
 
16th -  Hutchison Grills FCC Nominees on Fairness Doctrine, Improved Internet Access, and Broadcast Decency
 
16th -  Hearing and Witness List Advisory: The Consumer Wireless Experience
 
16th -  Senator Hutchison Calls for Committee Hearing to Fix New CPSC Law
 
15th -  Sen. Hutchison: Chrysler Makes Additional Concessions for Auto Dealer Community
 
12th -  Chairman Rockefeller Applauds President Obama’s Efforts To Improve The Blue Economy
 
11th -  Today’s Hearing on the FY 2010 NOAA Budget: Opening Statement – John D. (Jay) Rockefeller IV, Chairman
 
11th -  Hearing Summary: Aviation Safety: FAA’s Role In The Oversight Of Air Carriers
 
11th -  Hearing Summary: FY 2010 NOAA Budget Hearing
 
10th -  Statement For The Record Chairman John D. (Jay) Rockefeller IV Aviation Subcommittee Hearing on Aviation Safety: FAA’s Oversight of Commercial Air Carriers
 
9th -  Hearing Summary: The Blue Economy: The Role of the Oceans in Our Nation’s Economic Future
 
9th -  Sen. Hutchison’s Statement on Texas Auto Dealership Closures
 
9th -  Senator Hutchison Op-Ed: With DTV Deadline Looming, Not too Late to Prepare
 
9th -  Sen. Hutchison’s Statement on General Motors' New Chairman Ed Whitacre, Jr.
 
9th -  News: Chairman Rockefeller And Senate Commerce Committee Members Release Bipartisan Letters To GM CEO And Chrysler President Demanding Action
 
9th -  Chairman Rockefeller's Opening Remarks for Blue Economy Hearing
 
5th -  Statement from Sen. Hutchison on Chrysler’s Announcement That They Will Commit to Redistribute 100% of Inventory at Dealers Forced to Close
 
5th -  Chairman Rockefeller Statement On The Transition To All Digital Programming
 
5th -  Ride The Wave To Ocean Week On Capitol Hill
 
3rd -  Chairman Rockefeller's Opening Statement on GM And Chrysler Dealership Hearing
 
3rd -  Senator Hutchison’s Statement on GM and Chrysler Dealership Closures
 
3rd -  Key Quotes from Hearing On Chrysler/GM Bankruptcies
 
2nd -  Senator Hutchison’s Statement on President’s Intent to Nominate Robert McDowell for Another Term at the FCC
 
1st -  Commerce Committee Takes Lead On Railroad Legislation
 
1st -  Chairman Rockefeller Holds Hearing On Chrysler/GM Bankruptcies
Public Information Office: 508 Dirksen Senate Office Bldg • Washington, DC 20510-6125
Tel: 202-224-5115
Hearing Room: 253 Russell Senate Office Bldg • Washington, DC 20510-6125
Home | Privacy Policy | Graphics On | Site Map | Help/Faqs | Search
Back to TopBack to Top