Text representation of Figure 5 titled: Figure 5: Net Non-Core Funding Dependence

Figure Title: Figure 5: Net Non-Core Funding Dependence - Compared to Peer
Description of Figure 5: The graph is a grouped bar chart with 5 separate groupings. The horizontal axis - Exam Date. The vertical axis - Ratio.

Group 1 - Oct-03
Columbian - 27.53%
Peer - 12.56%

Group 2 - Apr 05
Columbian - 38.73%
Peer - 15.21%

Group 3 - May 06
Columbian - 49.16%
Peer - 22.16%

Group 4 - Jul 07
Columbian - 52.24%
Peer - 22.85%

Group 5 - Jan 08
Columbian - 60.29%
Peer - 25.62%

Source: OIG review of ROEs for Columbian.