WSJ: Martin Feldstein - Tax Increases Could Kill the Recovery
The cap-and trade levy would hit low-income earners especially hard. |
|
MAY 13, 2009
By MARTIN FELDSTEIN The barrage of tax increases proposed in President Barack Obama's budget could, if enacted by Congress, kill any chance of an early and sustained recovery.
Historians and economists who've studied the 1930s conclude that the tax increases passed during that decade derailed the recovery and slowed the decline in unemployment. That was true of the 1935 tax on corporate earnings and of the 1937 introduction of the payroll tax. Japan did the same destructive thing by raising its value-added tax rate in 1997.
The current outlook for an economic recovery remains precarious. Although the stimulus package will give a temporary boost to growth in the current quarter, it will not be enough to offset the combined effect of lower consumer spending, the decline in residential construction, the weakness of exports, the limited availability of bank credit and the downward spiral of house prices. A sustained economic upturn is far from a sure thing. This is no time for tax increases that will reduce spending by households and businesses.
Even if the proposed tax increases are not scheduled to take effect until 2011, households will recognize the permanent reduction in their future incomes and will reduce current spending accordingly. Higher future tax rates on capital gains and dividends will depress share prices immediately and the resulting fall in wealth will cut consumer spending further. Lower share prices will also raise the cost of equity capital, depressing business investment in plant and equipment.
The Obama budget calls for tax increases of more than $1.1 trillion over the next decade. Official budget calculations disguise the resulting fiscal drag by treating Mr. Obama's proposal to cancel the 2011 income tax increases for taxpayers with incomes below $250,000 as if they are real tax cuts. The plan to modify the Alternative Minimum Tax to avoid increases for some taxpayers is also treated as a tax cut.
But those are false tax cuts in which no one's tax bill actually declines. In contrast, the proposed tax increases are very real. And despite the proposed tax increases, the government's new spending and transfer programs would cause the annual budget deficit in 2019 to exceed $1 trillion, or 5.7% of GDP.
Mr. Obama's biggest proposed tax increase is the cap-and-trade system of requiring businesses to buy carbon dioxide emission permits. The nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office (CBO) estimates that the proposed permit auctions would raise about $80 billion a year and that these extra taxes would be passed along in higher prices to consumers. Anyone who drives a car, uses public transportation, consumes electricity or buys any product that involves creating CO2 in its production would face higher prices.
CBO Director Douglas Elmendorf testified before the Senate Finance Committee on May 7 that the cap-and-trade price increases resulting from a 15% cut in CO2 emissions would cost the average household roughly $1,600 a year, ranging from $700 in the lowest-income quintile to $2,200 in the highest-income quintile. Since the amount of cap-and-trade tax rises with income, the cap-and-trade tax has the same kind of adverse work incentives as the income tax. And since the purpose of the cap-and-trade plan is to discourage the consumption of CO2-intensive products, energy or means of transportation by raising their cost to consumers, the consumer-price increases would be the same for a 15% reduction in C02 even if the government decides to give away some of the CO2 emissions permits.
But while the cap-and-trade tax rises with income, the relative burden is greatest for low-income households. According to the CBO, households in the lowest-income quintile spend more than 20% of their income on energy intensive items (primarily fuels and electricity), while those in the highest-income quintile spend less than 5% on those products.
The CBO warns that the estimate of an $80 billion-a-year tax increase could be significantly higher or lower, depending on how the program is designed. The Waxman-Markey bill currently before Congress calls for reducing greenhouse gasses 20% by 2020 and by an incredible 83% by 2050. As the government reduces the amount of CO2 that is allowed, the price of the CO2 permits would rise and the pass-through to consumer prices would also increase.
The next-largest tax increase -- with a projected rise in revenue of more than $300 billion between 2011 and 2019 -- comes from increasing the tax rates on the very small number of taxpayers with incomes over $250,000. Because this revenue estimate doesn't take into account the extent to which the higher marginal tax rates would cause those taxpayers to reduce their taxable incomes -- by changing the way they are compensated, increasing deductible expenditures, or simply earning less -- it overstates the resulting increase in revenue.
Since the projected revenue from this source is already designated to be used for Mr. Obama's health plan, some other tax increases will be needed. Moreover, Mr. Obama's budget characterizes the projected $634 billion outlay for health-care reform as just a down payment on the program. The budget notes that there would be "additional resources and new benefits to be determined with Congress." Those additional resources would no doubt be even higher taxes.
The third major tax increase is the plan to raise $220 billion over the next nine years by changing the taxation of foreign-source income. While some extra revenue could no doubt come from ending the tax avoidance gimmicks that use dummy corporations in the Caribbean, most of the projected revenue comes from disallowing corporations to pay lower tax rates on their earnings in countries like Germany, Britain and Ireland. The purpose of the tax change is not just to raise revenue but also to shift overseas production by American firms back to the U.S. by reducing the tax advantage of earning profits abroad.
The administration is likely to be disappointed about its ability to achieve both goals. Bringing production back to be taxed at the higher U.S. tax rate would raise the cost of capital and make the products less competitive in global markets. American corporations would therefore have an incentive to sell their overseas subsidiaries to foreign firms. That would leave future profits overseas, denying the Treasury Department any claim on the resulting tax revenue. And new foreign owners would be more likely to use overseas suppliers than to rely on inputs from the U.S. The net result would be less revenue to the Treasury and fewer jobs in America.
It's not too late for Mr. Obama to put these tax increases on hold. If he doesn't, Congress should protect the recovery and the longer-term health of the U.S. economy by voting down this enormous round of higher taxes.
Mr. Feldstein, chairman of the Council of Economic Advisers under President Reagan, is a professor at Harvard and a member of The Wall Street Journal's board of contributors.
Note: To view this article, click here.
###
For Additional Information
Contact Matt Lloyd or Mary Vought at
(202) 226-9000 or matt.lloyd@mail.house.gov
Related Documents
May 12, 2009
Budget Shortfalls Prompt Mass LayoffsBy Alec MacGillisWashington Post Staff WriterTuesday, May 12, 2009Eleven weeks after Congress settled on a stimulus...
May 11, 2009
"The AP findings suggest the White House raised expectations too high for the transportation spending, said a spokesman for Rep....
May 11, 2009
When it comes to federal spending, there's a pattern emerging with President Obama, and it's not a flattering one. The...
May 11, 2009
President Obama's chief economics forecaster said on Sunday that the country was not likely to see positive employment growth until...
May 07, 2009
"Color us not particularly impressed with the record of the president for fiscal discipline to date, but hope springs eternal,"...
May 06, 2009
House Republican Leader John Boehner appeared on Fox News to speak on how House Republicans will cut government waste and...
April 29, 2009
Washington, DC - U.S. Congressman Mike Pence, Chairman of the House Republican Conference, made the following statement today in response...
April 28, 2009
Rep. Kevin McCarthy (CA) and Rep. Steve Scalise (LA) spoke with bloggers today about the cap and tax energy bill...
April 28, 2009
Rep. Kevin McCarthy (CA) and Rep. Steve Scalise (LA) spoke with bloggers today about the cap and tax energy bill...
April 27, 2009
After three days of hearing on the cap and tax global warming legislation last week, Republicans are billing it a...
April 27, 2009
Gail Johnson doesn't think of herself as wealthy. The former pediatric nurse has spent 20 years building a chain of...
April 27, 2009
Gail Johnson doesn't think of herself as wealthy. The former pediatric nurse has spent 20 years building a chain of...
April 27, 2009
Today, April 26, is Debt Day for this fiscal year. That is, today is the day the federal government's expenses...
April 24, 2009
"Debt Day," marking the point in the fiscal year when government spending exceeds revenue, falls this Sunday. That's the earliest...
April 23, 2009
Washington Post: "President Obama is requiring government agencies to find $100 million in savings. Next year's budget deficit will be...
April 23, 2009
*This post originally published on Townhall.comby Rep. Steve Scalise (LA)President Obama is proposing a “cap and trade” energy tax that...
April 23, 2009
*This post originally published on Townhall.comby Rep. Steve Scalise (LA)President Obama is proposing a “cap and trade” energy tax that...
April 23, 2009
by Rep. Erik Paulsen (MN)Yesterday, a report was issued by the special inspector overseeing the Troubled Asset Relief Program (TARP)...
April 20, 2009
by Rep. Robert Aderholt (AL-04)Last week’s Tea Parties were a powerful message to Washington in protest to the “spend and...
April 20, 2009
by Rep. Robert Aderholt (AL-04)Last week’s Tea Parties were a powerful message to Washington in protest to the “spend and...
April 20, 2009
House Leader John Boehner appeared yesterday on "This Week" with George Stephanopoulos, saying legislators should beware of "trillion dollar deficits...
April 20, 2009
House Leader John Boehner appeared yesterday on "This Week" with George Stephanopoulos, saying legislators should beware of "trillion dollar deficits...
April 16, 2009
To view the video, click here. Excerpts from the transcript: "Candidly, now I know how the old settlers back in the West...
April 15, 2009
WASHINGTON, DC - U.S. Congressman Mike Pence, Chairman of the House Republican Conference, made the following statement today regarding Tax...
April 15, 2009
WASHINGTON, DC - U.S. Congressman Mike Pence, Chairman of the House Republican Conference, made the following statement today regarding Tax...
April 03, 2009
Guest post by Rep. Ed Royce (CA)The Democrat Leadership’s 2010 budget calls for an unprecedented $3.5 trillion in spending and...
April 03, 2009
Guest post by Rep. Ed Royce (CA)The Democrat Leadership’s 2010 budget calls for an unprecedented $3.5 trillion in spending and...
April 02, 2009
That was thenFor years, House Democrats criticized the Bush White House for proposing a five-year budget:Then-Ranking Member John Spratt, February...
April 02, 2009
That was then...Democrats criticized a budget that “excluded” a permanent fix for the Alternative Minimum Tax (AMT)… House Budget Chairman...
April 01, 2009
It was a special day for Republicans on Capitol Hill, as House and Senate leaders gathered for a rare bi-cameral...
April 01, 2009
It was a special day for Republicans on Capitol Hill, as House and Senate leaders gathered for a rare bi-cameral...
March 27, 2009
Click here to listen to the audio.Below is an excerpt from the interview:PENCE: "The Republican proposal is going to...
March 27, 2009
Fiscal Policy: President Obama claims that Republicans "don't offer an alternative budget." In fact, they do, and it costs far...
March 26, 2009
House Republicans today released the "Republican Road to Recovery," an 18-page booklet specificying the steps they will take to find...
March 26, 2009
House Republicans today released the "Republican Road to Recovery," an 18-page booklet specificying the steps they will take to find...
March 25, 2009
Washington, DC - U.S. Congressman Mike Pence, Chairman of the House Republican Conference, made the following statement today on the...
March 25, 2009
House Leader John Boehner's office was quick to break down President Obama's address to the nation last night. After the...
March 25, 2009
House Leader John Boehner's office was quick to break down President Obama's address to the nation last night. After the...
March 24, 2009
By Rep. Jeb HensarlingI hope Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner's plan to rescue America's largest financial institutions works. Inaction is not...
March 24, 2009
House Whip Eric Cantor's office has done a great job compiling facts for Republicans to lean on as America's economic...
March 23, 2009
The White House predicts 7.9% unemployment in 2010. The Congressional Budget Office (CBO) predicts 9.2% unemployment in 2010. Where are...
March 23, 2009
After a Democrat Administration passed an omnibus bill with language to eliminate a vital school choice program, swiping vouchers from...
March 23, 2009
Rep. Paul Ryan (WI), the ranking Member on the Budget Committee, has been hard at work drafting Republican budget alternatives...
March 23, 2009
Rep. Paul Ryan (WI), the ranking Member on the Budget Committee, has been hard at work drafting Republican budget alternatives...
March 23, 2009
House Republicans want you to know there is a better way and we've got an alternative plan that is almost...
March 23, 2009
House Republicans want you to know there is a better way and we've got an alternative plan that is almost...
March 23, 2009
Rep. Jeff Flake (AZ) gets a few words in at the American Spectator this morning, offering insight from the mind...
March 23, 2009
Rep. Jeff Flake (AZ) gets a few words in at the American Spectator this morning, offering insight from the mind...
March 20, 2009
Rep. Virginia Foxx (NC) has been stirring the pot lately, with her explosive House floor ventures and determined messages on...
March 20, 2009
Video is powerful. Most people don't sit around watching C-SPAN2 all day but guess what? Everything that happens on the...
March 19, 2009
House Republican Chairman Mike Pence appeared on MSNBC today to comment on AIG bonuses and question the provision that allowed...
March 19, 2009
House Republican Chairman Mike Pence appeared on MSNBC today to comment on AIG bonuses and question the provision that allowed...
March 19, 2009
As Republicans fought to protect taxpayers from $350 billion in additional Wall Street bailouts, Democrats assured the American people President...
March 18, 2009
House Republicans are outraged. They are outraged about bailouts. They are outraged about massive overspending. They are outraged about AIG....
March 18, 2009
THAT WAS THEN: On February 12, President Obama visited employees at an Illinois Caterpillar plant and said, "when they [Congress]...
March 17, 2009
Washington, DC - U.S. Congressman Mike Pence, Chairman of the House Republican Conference, made the following statement at a press...
March 17, 2009
It was JUST TWO WEEKS AGO that the Administration said it was "confident" it knew how AIG was spending taxpayer...
March 17, 2009
PROTECTING JOBS AND LOWERING TAXESInstead of raising taxes on all Americans in the midst of a recession, Republicans seek to...
March 16, 2009
WASHINGTON - When it comes to President Obama and the Democrats these days, you couldn't knock Republican leaders of Congress...
March 13, 2009
Republicans have a few big things on their side when it comes to the economy: the facts. These include statistics...
March 12, 2009
Washington, DC - U.S. Congressman Mike Pence, Chairman of the House Republican Conference, made the following statement on the House...
March 11, 2009
President Obama once criticized out-of-control spending and “enormous deficits” but...President Obama once criticized an “orgy of spending and enormous deficits”Then-Candidate...
March 10, 2009
Washington, DC- Today, U.S. Congressman Mike Pence, Chairman of the House Republican Conference, made the following...
March 10, 2009
Washington, DC - Today, U.S. Congressman Mike Pence, Chairman of the House Republican Conference, made the following statement in response...
March 06, 2009
Republicans in the News:Rep. Michele Bachmann appeared on FOX Business Happy Hour to discuss the "cramdown" housing bill.Rep. Joe Barton...
March 06, 2009
WASHINGTON, DC - U.S. Congressman Mike Pence, Chairman of the House Republican Conference, made the following statement today on the...
March 04, 2009
President Obama says he supports slashing earmarks and making all spending decisions open to the public…President Obama Pledges to Bring...
March 04, 2009
The American people are hurting. Congress was right to take action to get this economy moving, but higher taxes and...
March 03, 2009
President Obama promises that taxpayers making less than $250,000 would not have their taxes "increased a single dime."President Barack Obama:...
March 03, 2009
"We have an agenda in this country now that I would regard as being a radical agenda. I think that...
February 27, 2009
Washington, DC - U.S. Congressman Mike Pence, Chairman of the House Republican Conference, made the following statement today after joining...
February 26, 2009
(CNN) - Mississippi Democratic Rep. Gene Taylor blasted the budget outline President Obama submitted to Capitol Hill today, saying "I...
February 26, 2009
Washington, DC - Today, U.S. Congressman Mike Pence, Chairman of the House Republican Conference, made the following statement in opposition...
February 26, 2009
President Obama's address to Congress on Tuesday night foreshadowed the next development in the Troubled Asset Relief Program (TARP) blockbuster...
February 26, 2009
"At first blush it seems somewhat strange that the Bankruptcy Code should provide less protection to an individual's interest in...
February 25, 2009
The American people are hurting, and Republicans want to work with the President to get the American people back...
February 24, 2009
WASHINGTON, DC - With consideration of the Democrats' omnibus spending bill set for tomorrow, U.S. Congressman Mike Pence released the...
February 24, 2009
“Let's do what every American family, what every small business is doing - let's freeze federal spending immediately and come...
February 24, 2009
American families and small businesses are making sacrifices and cutting expenses. Whether through tightening family budgets, or cutting expenses for...
February 24, 2009
American families and small businesses are making sacrifices and cutting expenses. Whether through tightening family budgets, or cutting expenses for...
February 23, 2009
Missouri Congressman Roy Blunt, a Republican and U.S. Senate candidate from southwest Missouri, today responded to President Obama's call for...
February 13, 2009
WASHINGTON -- No, the big stimulus plan won't "save or create 3.5 million jobs," as the president and congressional Democrats...
February 13, 2009
"The Congressional Budget Office says President Obama's giant economic recovery bill will actually hurt Americans' paychecks in the long run,...
February 12, 2009
WASHINGTON, DC - U.S. Congressman Mike Pence, Chairman of the House Republican Conference, made the following statement today in response...
February 11, 2009
U.S. Congressman Mike Pence, Chairman of the House Republican Conference, made the following statement today in response to reports of...
February 11, 2009
By Michael D. Shear and Anne E. KornblutWashington Post Staff WritersWednesday, February 11, 2009; A06FORT MYERS, Fla., Feb. 10 --...
February 11, 2009
House Republicans know we are in a serious recession.
The American people are hurting and Republicans know Congress must act...
February 11, 2009
New York Post: CONGRESS $HOPPING CARTS
Access the original article here.By GEOFF EARLEPost Correspondent ELECTRIC BUZZ: Hillary Clinton in 2005 rides...
February 10, 2009
WASHINGTON, DC - U.S. Congressman Mike Pence, Chairman of the House Republican Conference, responded to charges from House Democrats on...
February 09, 2009
WASHINGTON, DC - U.S. Congressman Mike Pence, chairman of the House Republican Conference, appeared on NBC's "Meet the Press" yesterday...
February 05, 2009
WASHINGTON, DC -- U.S. Congressman Mike Pence, Chairman of the House Republican Conference, issued the following statement today in response...
February 05, 2009
Contrary to conventional Beltway wisdom, the House Republicans' zero votes for the Obama presidency's stimulus "package" is looking like the...
February 04, 2009
- Our nation is in a recession and millions of Americans are hurting. - Congress and the President are right...
February 03, 2009
"... the economic measures racing through Congress would devote tens of billions of dollars to causes that have little to...
February 03, 2009
Note: To view the speech, click here WASHINGTON, DC -- Following are the remarks delivered by Congressman Pence, Chairman of the...
February 03, 2009
House Republican leaders on Tuesday called for public release of the proposed omnibus legislation that would encompass the nine remaining...
January 28, 2009
Today the House passed H.R. 1 [digest | votes], the "American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009." The bill...
January 27, 2009
WASHINGTON – In response to the filing of the Democrat version of a stimulus bill, Congressman Mike Pence, chairman of...
January 23, 2009
The American people are hurting and our economy is in a recession.
Congress is right to take action to stimulate...
January 23, 2009
House GOP Leader: “Our proposals are rooted in the belief that fast-acting tax relief, rather than slow-moving and wasteful government...
January 22, 2009
TALKERS ON THE STIMULUS
The American people are hurting and our economy is in a recession.
Congress is right to take action...
January 22, 2009
TALKERS ON THE STIMULUS
The American people are hurting and our economy is in a recession.
Congress is right to take action...
January 14, 2009
Today, the House Republican Study Committee (RSC) unveiled its economic stimulus bill, the Economic Recovery and Middle-Class Relief Act. Rep....
January 14, 2009
Investor's Business Daily Editorial: "Show Us The Money"
Excerpts:
"One of the key principles of those who want to shrink government, lower...
January 14, 2009
We are in a recession, and the American people are hurting. House Republicans are on the side of the...
January 08, 2009
U.S. Congressman Mike Pence, Chairman of the House Republican Conference, gave the following speech on the floor of the U.S....
January 07, 2009
"[The Democrats' stimulus bill] doesn't include substantial tax cuts for American families, and it doesn't include necessary tax relief for...
|
|