The
Strange and Wonderful Myco-heterotrophs
There are a number of flowering plants that have abandoned
photosynthesis, but not all of these are haustorial parasites.
These plants are frequently mistaken for parasitic plants but
are more accurately called myco-heterotrophs
(also sometimes mycotrophs). These plants can live without
photosynthesis because they have established a coevolutionary
relationship with a mycorrhizal fungus that is attached to the root of
a photosynthetic, woody plant. So, there is a three way
association such that
nutrients (carbon) flow from plant root, to mycorrhizal fungus to the
myco-heterotroph.
One may see
these plants called myco-heterotrophic
epiparasites or ectomycorrhizal epiparasites.
These epithets are quite descriptive (albeit cumbersome) in
that
the
flowering plant could be considered a parasite of the fungus.
But
personally, I prefer avoiding the term "parasite" when describing these
organisms because they do not obtain their nutrition in the same manner
as haustorial parasites that actually invade host stems or roots by
means of a modified root called the haustorium.
The mycotrophs don't directly invade the photosynthetic
"host" roots but
indirectly obtain nutrients via the intermediate fungus. And
by
the way, myco-heterotrophs are frequently mistakenly called saprophytes.
There are no true saprophytes in the angiosperms.
Only
fungi can directly utilize dead organic material.
As reviewed in Bidartondo (2005), many plants, e.g.
bryophtyes, lycophytes, ferns, gymnosperms (such as Parasitaxus),
monocots and dicots, are myco-heterotrophic during some phase of their
life cycle, especially during early
establishment phases (seeds, gametophytes). Some of these
(e.g.
many
orchids) continue this association throughout their life
cycles.
In this latter category, some myco-heterotrophs are
photosynthetic (e.g. Burmannia,
Galeola,
and Pyrola)
whereas others lose their photosynthetic capacity to some degree or
another. There are even mixed trophic modes in the orchid Cephalanthera damasonium
where some individuals are photosynthetic and others are not (Julou et
al. 2005). Fully nonphotosynthetic myco-heterotrophs
include Thismia
and Gymnosiphon
(Burmanniaceae), Corsiaceae, Rhizanthella
(Orchidaceae), Petrosaviaceae, Triuridaceae, Monotropeae,
Pterosporeae, and Voyria
(Gentianaceae). In some cases, the evolution of a
nonphotosynthetic myco-heterotroph from a photosynthetic ancestor is
clearly documented (e.g. monotropes) whereas in other cases the
situation is not as clear (e.g. Arachnitis
in Corsiaceae or Voyria
in Gentianaceae). These scenarios very much parallel the
situations with haustorial parasitic angiosperms where there exists
several cases of the evolution of nonphotosynthetic parasites
(holoparasites) from photosynthetic relatives (hemiparasites).
For example, holoparasitism has evolved at least five times
independently in Orobanchaceae.
Maybe we should start using the words "hemimyco-heterotrophic"
and "holomyco-heterotrophic"
to describe these (talk about cumbersome terminology!).
The myco-heterotrophic habit has evolved several times in unrelated
angiosperm
families. Listed below are the angiosperm families
that have
genera exhibiting this syndrome, with photographs of representative
species.
Monocots
Burmanniaceae
(Dioscoreales)
- Afrothismia.
3 species of central Africa.
- Apteria.
One species widely distributed in tropical and subtropical
America (southeastern USA to southern Brazil).
- Burmannia.
60 tropical species in Mabberley. Only some
achlorophyllous, e.g. B.
championii, B. liukiuensis, B. tenella.
- Campylosiphon.
1 species
of tropical S America.
- Dictyostega.
1 species of Mexico to Brazil.
- Gymnosiphon.
47 unique species names in ePIC. Mabberley say ca. 50 species
of Old and New World tropics.
Sarcosiphon is a synonym.
- Hexapterella.
2 tropical S American species.
- Thismia.
28 species of tropical Asia, Australia, New Zealand, tropical America).
Including Geomitra
(G. clavigera Becc.
and G. episcopalis
Becc., both of Malesia); Glaziocharis
(G. abei Akasawa, G. macahensis Taub.
ex Warm., G. macahensis
Taub. in Overs.)
Corsiaceae (Liliales)
- Arachnitis.
1 species (A.
uniflora) of Chile.
- A. uniflora.
Habit of the plant. Sergio Moreira.
- A. uniflora.
Close-up of flower. Sergio Moreira.
- A. uniflora.
Another close-up of the flower. From
Martín’s Treasure Chest. Photo by Martin
Bidartondo.
- A. uniflora.
Group of plants. From Martín’s Treasure Chest.
Photo by Martin Bidartondo.
- A. uniflora.
Root system. From Martín’s Treasure
Chest. Photo by Martin Bidartondo.
- Corsia
(16-25 species of Papuasia and Australia)
- Corsiopsis. 1 species (C. chinensis) from Guangdong province, China. Illustration from Zhang et al. (1999).
Iridaceae [formerly
Geosiridaceae] (Asparagales)
- Geosiris.
1 (?) species of Madagascar, G.
aphylla [=
G. ophilla Baillon?].
- G. aphylla.
Madagascar, Toamasina, Nosy Mangabe RS. Collection by G. E.
Schatz, J. Klackenberg & D. Baum (number 1677), 14 October
1987.
Photo archived on TROPICOS database at Missouri Bot. Gard.
- G. aphylla. Parc
National de Masoala, near Ambohitsitondroina on the Masoala Peninsula
ridge, Madagascar. On the Madagascar
Biodiversity and Conservation website, Missouri Botanical
Garden. Photo by Dave Parks
- Geosiris sp.
Humid forests on the Island of Mayotte (a French territory in the
Comoros archipelago, between Madagascar and Africa).
Photo
by Fabien Barthelat.
Orchidaceae (Asparagales)
Given
that nearly all orchids are myco-heterotrophs initially, this listing
focuses on those that are also leafless, i.e. are loosing
photosynthetic function. A number of these link to the
Internet Orchid Encyclopedia.
- Aphyllorchis.
15 species of SE Asia, Indomalaysia.
- Corallorhiza.
15 species of north temperate regions; Europe (1 sp.), E.
North America to Guatemala.
- C.
maculata
- C.
mertensiana
- C.
striata
-
C. striata var.
vreelandii
Image
1 and 2.
Santa Fe National Forest, Johnson Mesa, Sangre de Cristo
Mountains. Photos by D. L. Nickrent.
- C.
trifida
- C.
wisteriana. Image 1
and 2
of flowering shoots. Santa Fe National Forest, Johnson Mesa,
Sangre de Cristo Mountains. Photos by D. L. Nickrent.
- Cymbidium. One mycotrophic species, C. macrorhizon of Japan.
- Cyrtosia.
5 species of Indomalaysia (related to Galeola).
- Cystorchis.
8 species of China and Asia. Only C. aphylla
mycotrophic.
- Didymoplexis.
10 species of Old World tropics except W. Africa and India.
- Cephalanthera.
1 species, C.
austinae A. Heller. [= Eburophyton; =
Chloraea].
- Epipogium.
3 species of temperate Eurasia.
- Eulophia.
Ca. 200 tropical species, some mycotrophic.
- Galeola.
10 species of Madagascar, Indomalaysia to Australia. G. altissima (Bl.)
Reichb. large!
- Gastrodia.
35 species of E Asia, Indomalaysia to New Zealand, Australia.
Some mycotrophic species.
- Hexalectris.
7 species of the US and Mexico.
- Lecanorchis.
20 species of Indomalaysia to Japan. Some species mycotrophic.
- Limodorum.
1 species of the Mediterranean and Europe to Iran: L. abortivum.
- Neottia.
9 species of temperate Eurasia. N. nidus-avis is
the bird's-nest orchid.
- Pterostylis.
70 species of Australia, Malaysia to New Caledonia.
Only some mycotrophic.
- Rhizanthella.
2 species of subterranean orchids from SW and E Australia. R. gardneri occurs
on Melaleuca uncinata.
- Stereosandra.
Acc. to Mabberley, 1 species, S. javanica, of SE Asia and W
Malaysia.
- Stigmatodactylus.
4 species of E Asia to Malaysia.
- Wullschlaegelia.
2 species (W. aphylla,
W. calcarata) of tropical America.
- Yoania.
2 species of Himalayas and Japan.
Peterosaviaceae [also
called Melanthiaceae] (Petrosaviales)
- Petrosavia.
2-4 species of E Asia and W Malaysia.
- Petrosavia.
Line art. From: Engler, A. and Prantl, K. 1908, Die
Naturlichen
Pflanzenfamilien, Nachtrage II und III zum II. - IV. Teil. Figure 8.
Image archived on Plant
Systematics.org website (K. Nixon).
- Protolirion.
2 species: P.
miyoshia-sakuraii Makino and P. paradoxum Ridl.
Sometimes placed in Triuridaceae.
Triuridaceae
(Pandanales). Including Lacandoniaceae.
- Lacandonia.
1 species, L.
schismatica.
A very rare and unusual plant from the Lacondon rainforests
of
southeastern Mexico with "inside out" flowers where stamens are
inserted above carpels on the receptacle. Talk about breaking
the
rules!
- Flowers. They are tiny! Photos by cytediano. Link goes to Flickr.
- Flower,
with yellow bilocular anthers in the center. Scale bar = 0.5
cm. From Vergara-Silva et al. (2003).
- SEM
plate of L.
schismaticafrom Vergara-Silva
et al. (2003). A, Dissected preanthesis
floral bud, showing carpels at an early developmental stage
and
three fully developed anthers in the center of the
flower. Scale
bar = 200 µm. B, Mature flower, showing the papillose aspect
of
carpel epidermal cells surrounding three dehiscent
anthers. Scale
bar = 200 µm. C, Dissected unisexual floral bud, showing two
stamens and no carpels. Scale bar = 200 µm. D,
Inflorescence
bearing two pistillate flowers, where stamens are replaced by
additional carpels. Scale bar = 2 mm.
E, Dissected floral bud showing one central stamen and a diminished
number of carpels, at a developmental stage comparable to
A. Scale
bar = 200 µm. F, Mature flower with four central
stamens. Scale bar = 200 µm; c = carpel; an = anther.
- Sciaphila.
31 species of tropical and warm regions. 108 names in ePIC!
- Triuris.
3 species of Guatemala, Guyana, and Brazil. 8 names in ePIC.
- T. brevistylis.
A, Male flowers with arrowheads pointing at stamens (anthers) and
androphores indicated (a). Note long caudate tepals. B, Female flower
with multiple carpels (c). Scale cm. bars = 0.5 cm .
From Vergara-Silva et al. (2003). Individuals of
this
species can also display the "inside out" floral morphology seen in Lacandonia.
- T.
hexophthalma. Male flower. Guyana. Collected by Maas
& Westra (no. 2595). From the Myco-heterotrophs
Gallery by S. Imhof.
- T.
hexophthalma. Female flower. Guyana. Collected by Maas
& Westra (no. 2595). From the Myco-heterotrophs
Gallery by S. Imhof.
- T.
hyalina. From webpage
entitled: "Spezielle Botanik." Parasitic and mycotrophic flowering
plants: structural, ecological, and phylogenetical aspects by Stephan
Imhof.
Dicots
Diapensiaceae (Ericales)
- Berneuxia.
1 species of Himalayas.
- Diapensia.
4 species of Himalayas, W. China, Europe (Scotland).
- Diplarche.
2 species of E Himalayas and SW China.
- Galax.
1 species of SE US: G.
urceolata (= G.
aphylla).
- Pyxidanthera.
1 species of SE US: P.
barbulata.
- Shortia.
1 species of E North America, 5 of E Asia.
Ericaceae (Ericales)
Ericaceae s. lat. (in the broad sense) now includes Empetraceae,
Epacridaceae (Styphelioideae), Monotropaceae, and
Pyrolaceae].
Mycotrophic plants likely occur in all of these groups.
For
this page, I will present only the mycotrophs that are now
considered members of subfamily Monotropoideae of Ericaceae. Within
that subfamily are "hemimycotrophic" members (tribe Pyroleae) and
"holomycotrophic" members (tribes Monotropeae and Pterosporeae).
Pyroleae
- Chimaphila.
4-5 species of Eurasia, N and tropical America.
- Monoses.
- Orthilia.
1 circumboreal species.
- Pyrola.
35 species of N hemisphere (Europe 7) to Sumatra, temperate S America. [P. picta ssp. aphylla) has
individuals with expanded leaf blades and other individuals lacking
leaves.]
Monotropeae
- Allotropa.
1 species of W US: A.
virgata Torr. & A. Gray.
- A. virgata.
Inflorescence. Federation Forest, Washington, USA. Photo by
J. R. Manhart.
- A. virgata.
Closer view of inflorescence. Federation Forest, Washington,
USA. Photo by J. R. Manhart.
- A. virgata.
Close-up of flowers. Photo by K. Kron
- Hemitomes.
1 species of W US: H.
congestum A. Gray.
- H. congestum. Federation
Forest, Washington, USA. Photo by J. R. Manhart.
- H. congestum.
Clear Lake, Mackenzie Pass Highway, Oregon, USA. Photo by A.
G. Smith.
- H. congestum.
Loc. unknown. Photo by A. G. Smith.
- Monotropa
(including Hypopitys).
1 species N temperate regions.
- M. hypopitys.
Habit. Federation Forest, Washington, USA. Photo by
J. R. Manhart.
- M. hypopitys.
Close-up of flowers. Federation Forest, Washington, USA.
Photo by J. R. Manhart.
- M. hypopitys.
Young shoots emerging from ground. Cedar Butte,
King Co., Washington, USA. Photo May 26, 1996 by A. Colwell.
- M. hypopitys.
Excavated shoots showing morphological variation.
Cedar
Butte, King Co., Washington, USA. Photo May 26, 1996 by A.
Colwell.
- Monotropastrum.
ca. 4 species of S and E Asia and Malaysia. Includes the
genera Cheilotheca
and Andresia. Wirtgenia is a
synonym for plants in Asteraceae and Anacardiaceae. Monotropa uniflora
has been shown to be part of the Monotropastrum
clade using molecular methods, hence will be treated in this
genus.
- M. coccinea.
Flowering shoots. Las Alturas, Costa Rica. Photo by
D. L. Nickrent.
- M. coccinea.
Close-up of flowers. Las Alturas, Costa Rica. Photo
by D. L. Nickrent.
- M. globosum.
Flowering shoots. Japan. From the Yamasaki
Lab Plant Photo Gallery.
- M. globosum.
Two flowering shoots. Japan. Faculty
of Education, Fukushima University.
- M. humile.
Flower. Otanigahara, Japan. From a Japanese blog So-net
blog. (Sony).
- M. humile.
Two flowers, emerging from soil. Photo by Kinmatsu Lin. From Kinmatsu’s
Realms in Taiwan.
- M. humile.
Close-up of flowers. Japan. Photo by Kiyoshi
Hotta.
- M. uniflora.
Flowering shoots showing unusual pigmentation. McCormick's
Creek, Indiana, USA. Photo by W. Welch.
- M. uniflora.
Flowering shoots. Midland Hills, Illinois.
Photo by W. Welch.
- M. uniflora.
Flowering shoots. Great Smoky Mts., North Carolina,
USA. Photo by D. L. Nickrent.
- M. uniflora.
Excavated plant in hand showing myco-heterotrophic root ball.
Great Smoky Mts., North Carolina, USA. Photo by D.
L.
Nickrent.
- M. uniflora.
Close-up view of roots associated with mycorrhizal fungi.
From Martín’s
Treasure Chest. Photo by Martin Bidartondo.
- Monotropsis.
1 species of N America: M.
odorata Elliott.
- Pityopus.
1 species of W US: P.
californicus H. F. Copel (P. oregona Small)
- P.
californicus. Young flowering shoots just emerging from soil.
California. Photo 1981 by Robert E. Preston.
- P.
californicus. Mature shoots. California.
Photo 2004 by Debra Valov.
- Pleuricospora.
2 species of W N America: P.
fimbriolata A. Gray and P. densa Small.
Pterosporeae
- Pterospora.
1 species of W N America: P.
andromeda Nutt.
- Sarcodes.
1 species of the W US: S.
sanguinea Torrey (snow plant).
- S. sanguinea.
Flowering shoot. From Ericaceae
Homepage. Photo by K. Kron
- S. sanguinea.
Flowering shoot. From Univ. Hawaii, Vascular
Plant Families web pages. Photo by G. D. Carr.
- S. sanguinea.
Habit of plant. Farview Point, San Bernardino Co.,
California. Photo July 1998 by D. L. Nickrent.
- S. sanguinea.
Close-up of developing fruits. Same loc. as above. Photo July
1998 by D. L. Nickrent.
- S.
sanguinea. Image 1
and 2
of flowering shoots. Idyllwild, California. Photo by W. Welch.
Gentianaceae (Gentianales)
- Bartonia.
3-4 species of E N America.
- Cotylanthera.
4 species of Himalayas, SW China, C Malaysia, Polynesia.
- Obolaria.
1 species of E N America: O. virginica L.
- O.
virginica. Habit of flowering plant. Carbondale,
Illinois, USA. Photo by W. Welch.
- O. virginica.
Close-up of flowering shoot. Jackson Co., Illinois, USA.
Photo by D. L. Nickrent.
- O.
virginica. Close-up of flowers. Jackson Co.,
Illinois, USA. Photo by D. L. Nickrent.
- Voyria
(including Leiphaimos).
20 species of tropical America and W Africa.
- Voyriella.
2 species of NE S America.
Polygalaceae (Fabales)
- Salomonia
(= Epirhixanthes).
8 species of Indomalaysia to Australia.
Links
The
Mycoheterotroph Gallery, by Stephan Imhof (Marburg
University, Germany) with input from Hiltje and Paul Maas.
See also "Spezielle
Botanik." Parasitic and mycotrophic flowering plants:
structural, ecological, and phylogenetical and Afrothismia winkleri
(Engl.) Schlecht, also by Stefan Imhof.
Martin's
Treasure Chest. Martin Bidartondo (w/ Tom Bruns,
currently working at Kew Gardens in London England).
Thismia americana:
A mystery that still haunts — and helps —
the Calumet region. Chicago Wilderness Magazine.
Article in
Coastweek.com about Afrothismia
baerae: "A Rare Plant 'Find'
In Shimba Hills Reserve". Kenya.
Ericaceae
Homepage. Blueberries, Heathers, and Rhododendrons.
Kathy Kron, Wake Forest University. Go to Monotropoideae.
Fungus
flowers: Flowering plants that resemble fungi.
Wayne's Word.
Gentian
Research Network. Rutgers University and Cook
College.
SIUC /
College of Science / Parasitic Plant Connection / Mycotrophs
URL: http://www.parasiticplants.siu.edu/Mycotrophs.html
Last updated: 31-Dec-08 / dln