Printer-Friendly Version
FLSA2008-16
December 18, 2008
Dear Name*:
This is in response to your
request for an opinion concerning whether a Latino Victim Specialist (LVS)
employed by a Police Department may volunteer as a Reserve Police Officer for
the same public agency under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA).[1]
Based on a review of the information provided, it is our opinion that the LVS
may not volunteer as a Reserve Police Officer because he is compensated for
part of those services at greater than a nominal fee. Under appropriate
circumstances, however, he may be employed in that position pursuant to section
7(p)(2) of the FLSA.
You state that a Police
Department employee works full-time in a civilian capacity as the Crisis Unit
LVS, providing victim assistance and other social work services. The employee
also volunteers as a Reserve Police Officer. The Crisis Unit is the social
work arm of the Police Department. Crisis Unit personnel provide counseling
and other assistance to, among others, victims of crime, families experiencing
domestic violence, citizens with mental or psychological difficulties who
become involved in law enforcement matters, homeless persons, and parents
having difficulties with delinquent children.
The major duties of the LVS
are civilian rather than law enforcement in nature, and include providing
follow-up services such as safety planning, counseling, court support/advocacy,
and case management to all Latino crime victims within the jurisdiction of the
Police Department; developing and maintaining a close working relationship with
the District Attorney’s Office and Court Liaison assigned to domestic violence
and sexual assault cases; training police officers regarding cultural diversity
and victim issues pertaining to Latino victims; developing a data collection and
case tracking system for cases responded to by the Police Department; preparing
case summaries of domestic violence and sexual assault cases involving Latino
crime victims; counseling Latino crime victims to determine needs and
appropriate services; assisting clients with obtaining domestic violence
protective orders and warrants; providing crisis intervention services and
counseling to Latino crime victims; reporting potential child and elder abuse
to the appropriate agency; and assisting service agencies with program
development, including ensuring coordination of services for clients.
Positions in the Crisis Unit do not require law enforcement training or
certification and, with the exception of the LVS, no other Crisis Unit
employees are certified.
The individual also serves as
a Reserve Police Officer. In order to be a Reserve Police Officer with the
Police Department, officers must meet firearms qualifications, complete other
training requirements, and work as a police officer for ten hours per quarter
during the year. If the Police Department requests the services of a Reserve
Police Officer for a special assignment, e.g., for Halloween, NCAA
celebrations, or street fairs, the officer’s work counts toward the required
ten quarterly hours and the officer is paid for the work. When the Reserve
Police Officer volunteers for hours that the Police Department has not
specifically requested, the work is counted toward the ten-hour requirement,
but the volunteered time is unpaid.
In a discussion with a member
of the Wage and Hour Division staff, you stated that Reserve Police Officers
receive $17.31 per hour during the special assignments requested by the Police
Department. This hourly rate is equivalent to the entry level pay of a Police
Officer I employed in the Police Department. After two years of satisfactory
service the Reserve Police Officer may receive an hourly rate of $18.18, which
is equivalent to the entry level pay of a Police Officer II employed in the
Police Department. Reserve Police Officers are covered by the Police
Department’s workers’ compensation and general liability insurance policies.
For the two-quarter period from October 2004 to March 2005, the LVS in question
served as a Reserve Police Officer on paid special assignments requested by the
Police Department for a total of 20.5 hours. During the same time period, the
LVS performed 8 hours of unpaid volunteer Reserve Police Officer service.
The FLSA recognizes the
generosity and public benefits of volunteering and does not seek to impose
unnecessary obstacles to bona fide volunteer efforts for charitable and
public purposes. The Department of Labor is committed to ensuring that
citizens are able to volunteer their services freely for charitable and public
purposes within the legal constraints established by Congress.
FLSA section 3(e)(4)(A)(i)
provides that an individual who volunteers to perform services for a public
agency is not an employee if the individual receives no compensation or is paid
expenses, reasonable benefits or a nominal fee. In addition, FLSA section
3(e)(4)(A)(ii) requires that the volunteer services cannot be the same type of
services that the individual is employed to perform for the agency. The
regulations, 29
C.F.R. §§ 553.101-.103, in addition to the statutory requirements, indicate
that individuals are volunteers, not employees of a public agency, when they
perform hours of service for civic, charitable, or humanitarian reasons without
promise, expectation, or receipt of compensation for the services rendered and
offer their services freely and without pressure or coercion, direct or
implied, from the employer. Under the regulations, individuals can qualify as
volunteers if they either volunteer to perform services for a different agency
or perform different services than they are employed to perform for the same
public agency.
In order to determine whether
the LVS may perform volunteer duties as a Reserve Police Officer for the Police
Department, we assume, for discussion purposes, that the LVS performs Reserve
Police Officer duties for civic, charitable, or humanitarian reasons, and
offers his services freely, without pressure or coercion, direct or implied,
from the employer. For the volunteer arrangement to meet the criteria above,
we must then determine whether the LVS and Reserve Police Officer perform the
“same type of services,” and whether the amounts paid the LVS for performing
Reserve Police Officer duties during special assignments requested by the
Police Department constitute a “nominal fee” under FLSA section 3(e)(4)(A)(i).
Determining whether the
services volunteers seek to provide are the “same type of services” they are
employed to perform requires “consideration of all the facts and circumstances
in a particular case.” See 29 C.F.R. § 553.103(a). One factor
considered under the regulation is how the volunteered services and the
services that the volunteer is employed to perform are defined by the three
digit categories of occupations in the Dictionary of Occupational Titles
(DOT), as supplemented by the O*NET system, published by the Employment and
Training Administration (ETA). Of equal weight to the DOT/O*NET system, the
Administrator of the Wage and Hour Division will consider whether the volunteer
services are “closely related to the actual duties performed or
responsibilities assigned to the [paid] employee.” See Wage and Hour
Opinion Letter FLSA2004-6
(July 14, 2004).
The O*NET description (copy
enclosed) for duties performed by police officers under the classification of
“protective service occupations” are to “[m]aintain order, enforce laws and
ordinances, and protect life and property in an assigned patrol district.
Perform combination of following duties: patrol a specific area on foot or in a
vehicle; direct traffic; issue traffic summonses; investigate accidents;
apprehend and arrest suspects, or serve legal processes of courts.” O*NET § 33-3051.00.
See also DOT 375.263-014 Police Officer I (copy enclosed). On
the other hand, the LVS is a civilian employee of the Crisis Unit of the Police
Department. Civilian employees are not considered to be engaged in law
enforcement activities. See 29
C.F.R. § 553.211(g). Moreover, the job duties and responsibilities of the
LVS as described above are similar to the job duties performed by social
workers and counselors, which are classified under O*NET as “community and
social services occupations.” O*NET § 21-0000
(copy enclosed). See also DOT 195.107-010 Caseworker, and DOT
195.367-018 Community Worker (copies enclosed). The DOT/O*NET system does not
regard a social worker and police officer as being in the same job family and,
thus, does not treat them as related occupations.
After reviewing the
information you provided and the DOT/O*NET treatment of these occupational
categories, we believe that a LVS and Reserve Police Officer are not providing
the same or similar services. See Wage and Hour Opinion Letter
September 17, 1999 (finding that work of juvenile counselor does not constitute
same type of services as work of reserve sheriff), nominal fee determination
withdrawn by Wage and Hour Opinion Letter
FLSA2005-51 (Nov. 10, 2005); Wage and Hour Opinion Letter January 8, 2001
(concluding that youth services counselor employed by city police department
may participate in city’s reserve officer force) (copies enclosed). As
discussed below, however, it does not appear that the amounts paid to
“volunteer” Reserve Police Officers for work performed during special
assignments for the Police Department constitute a “nominal fee,” as defined by
the statute and regulations. Therefore, the special assignment work is not
performed as a volunteer.
In enacting the 1985 FLSA
Amendments, Congress sought to ensure that true volunteer activities were
neither impeded nor discouraged. Congress was explicit in its 1985 Amendments
that a “volunteer” may receive “no compensation,” but may be paid “expenses,
reasonable benefits, or a nominal fee.” 29 U.S.C. § 203(e)(4)(A)(i); see
also 29
C.F.R. § 553.106(a) (“Volunteers may be paid expenses, reasonable benefits,
a nominal fee, or any combination thereof, for their service without losing
their status as volunteers.”); 29 C.F.R. § 553.106(e) (“individuals do not lose
their volunteer status if they receive a nominal fee from a public agency”).
Neither the FLSA nor the Senate Committee Report to the 1985 Amendments further
defines the term “nominal fee.” Rather, the Committee Report directed the
Department to issue regulations providing guidance in this area.
The regulations focus on
preventing payment for performance, which is inconsistent with the spirit of
volunteerism contemplated by the FLSA. Thus, a fee would not be considered
nominal if it is, in fact, a substitute for compensation or tied to
productivity. See 29 C.F.R. § 553.106(e); see also Wage and Hour
Opinion Letter FLSA2005-51 (Nov. 10, 2005) (“[T]he regulations are focused on
preventing payment for performance, which is inconsistent with the spirit of
volunteerism . . . .”); Wage and Hour Opinion Letter FLSA2004-6
(July 14, 2004) (“to the extent payments are tied to productivity (e.g.,
payment of hourly wages for services rendered) . . . there is a greater
likelihood that such fees are not nominal”). Generally, a key factor in
determining if a payment is a “substitute for compensation” or “tied to
productivity” is “whether the amount of the fee varies as the particular
individual spends more or less time engaged in the volunteer activities.” Wage
and Hour Opinion Letter FLSA2005-51. If the amount varies, it may be
indicative of a substitute for compensation or tied to productivity and
therefore not nominal. See id.; see also 29 C.F.R. §
553.106(e). Whether the nature and structure of payments made to individuals
would result in their losing volunteer status is determined by examining the
total amount of payments made (expenses, benefits, and fees) in the context of
each particular situation. See 29 C.F.R. § 553.106(f); Wage and Hour
Opinion Letter FLSA2002-4
(July 19, 2002).
We have opined that generally
an amount not to exceed 20 percent of the total compensation that the employer
would pay someone for performing comparable services would be deemed nominal. See
Wage and Hour Opinion Letter FLSA2005-51. Thus, it is our opinion that payment
of $17.31 or $18.18 per hour for services performed by Reserve Police Officers
during special assignments, which corresponds respectively to the entry level
pay of a Police Officer I and Police Officer II employed by the Police
Department, cannot be considered a “nominal fee.” Therefore, the Police
Department’s practice of paying volunteer Reserve Police Officers hourly rates
that are in excess of what can be considered “nominal” under the FLSA creates
an employment relationship.
A separate issue arises
regarding whether the hours worked as an LVS must be combined with the hours
worked as a Reserve Police Officer in calculating the hours for which the
employee is entitled to overtime compensation. Under FLSA section 7(p)(2),
where employees of a public agency, solely at their option, work occasionally
or sporadically on a part-time basis for the same public agency in a different
capacity from their regular employment, the hours worked in the different jobs
shall not be combined for the purpose of determining overtime compensation due
under the FLSA. As noted in 29
C.F.R. § 553.30(b), “[t]he term occasional or sporadic means
infrequent, irregular, or occurring in scattered instances.” As stated
earlier, it is our opinion that employment as a Reserve Police Officer is
employment in a different capacity than an LVS. Furthermore, we believe that
performing services as a Reserve Police Officer during paid special
assignments, which occurs an average of ten hours per quarter, may be deemed
“occasional or sporadic.” See Wage and Hour Opinion Letter December 6,
2001 (copy enclosed). Therefore, if the provisions of section 7(p)(2) are met,
the Police Department would not have to combine the hours worked on both paid
jobs for purposes of computing overtime pay.
Finally, we note the general
rule that if the LVS is employed part-time as a Reserve Police Officer, he may
not volunteer as a Reserve Police Officer for the same public agency due to the
FLSA’s prohibition against an individual being an unpaid “volunteer” while
performing the same type of services that the individual is employed to perform
for his employer. See 29 U.S.C. § 203(e)(4); Wage and Hour Opinion
Letter FLSA2005-32
(Sept. 9, 2005); Wage and Hour Opinion Letter August 19, 1994 (copy
enclosed); Wage and Hour Opinion Letter June 9, 1988 (copy enclosed); Wage and
Hour Opinion Letter September 12, 1985 (copy enclosed). However, where the
compensated work of the part-time Reserve Police Officer is performed only on
an occasional or sporadic basis, the Reserve Police Officer would be considered
to be a paid Reserve Police Officer of the Police Department only during
workweeks when such special assignment work is performed and, therefore, would
retain his or her volunteer status during other workweeks in which no
compensated work is performed. If, however, the compensated work of the
part-time Reserve Police Officer occurs at regular intervals, or occurs on a
predictable basis, the part-time Reserve Police Officer would be precluded from
volunteering his or her services in the Reserve Police Officer corps in any
workweek, as he or she would be considered an employee in all workweeks. See
Wage and Hour Opinion Letter FLSA2005-32 (Sept. 9, 2005); Wage and Hour Opinion
Letter June 9, 1988 (copy enclosed).
Therefore, based on an
analysis of the information provided, it is our opinion that the LVS may be
employed, solely at the employee’s option, on a part-time basis as a Reserve
Police Officer during paid special assignments, which occur on an occasional or
sporadic basis, in accordance with FLSA section 7(p)(2) without needing to
combine the hours worked on a part-time basis with the hours worked in regular
employment for purposes of calculating entitlement to overtime. In order for
the LVS who is employed on an occasional and sporadic part-time basis as a
Reserve Police Officer also to volunteer in the Reserve Police Officer corps,
he should be considered a paid Reserve Police Officer during workweeks when he
performs special assignments requested by the Police Department and be
ineligible to volunteer during those workweeks. The Police Department may then
terminate the LVS’s occasional and sporadic part-time employment as a Reserve
Police Officer at the conclusion of such special assignments and return him or
her to volunteer Reserve Police Officer status during other workweeks in which
no compensated work is performed, provided that the part-time Reserve Police
Officer position was not converted unilaterally by the Police Department to
volunteer status in order to avoid the minimum wage and overtime provisions of
the FLSA. See Krause v. Cherry Hill Fire Dist., 969 F. Supp.
270, 277-79 (D.N.J. 1997); Wage and Hour Opinion Letter FLSA2005-32.
This opinion is based exclusively
on the facts and circumstances described in your request and is given based on
your representation, express or implied, that you have provided a full and fair
description of all the facts and circumstances that would be pertinent to our
consideration of the question presented. Existence of any other factual or
historical background not contained in your letter might require a conclusion
different from the one expressed herein. You have represented that this
opinion is not sought by a party to pending private litigation concerning the
issues addressed herein. You have also represented that this opinion is not
sought in connection with an investigation or litigation between a client or
firm and the Wage and Hour Division or the Department of Labor.
We trust that this letter is
responsive to your inquiry.
Sincerely,
Alexander J. Passantino
Acting Administrator
*
Note: The actual name(s) was removed to preserve privacy in accordance with 5 U.S.C. § 552(b)(7).
| |
|