skip navigational links United States Department of Labor
May 9, 2009        
DOL Home > OALJ Home > Whistleblower Collection
DOL Home USDOL/OALJ Reporter

Ass't Sec'y & Avigal v. Fairbanks Anchorage Express, 2000-STA-45 (ALJ Oct. 17, 2000)


U.S. Department of LaborOffice of Administrative Law Judges
Heritage Plaza Bldg. - Suite 530
111 Veterans Memorial Blvd
Metairie, LA 70005

(504) 589-6201
(504) 589-6268 (FAX)

DOL Seal

DATE ISSUED: October 17, 2000

CASE NO.: 2000-STA-45

In the Matter of

ASSISTANT SECRETARY OF LABOR
FOR OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY AND HEALTH
    Prosecuting Party

    and

GAL AVIGAL
    Complainant

    v.

FAIRBANKS ANCHORAGE EXPRESS
    Respondent

DECISION AND ORDER APPROVING SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT

   The parties have entered into a Settlement Agreement, copy of which is attached hereto and approved;

   It is hereby ORDERED that the Agreement entered into between the parties is adopted as the final Decision and Order of the undersigned and all parties are ORDERED to strictly comply with the terms contained therein. Upon compliance with the Agreement, this claim shall stand dismissed.

   SO ORDERED this 17th day of October, 2000, at Metairie, Louisiana.

       C. RICHARD AVERY
       Administrative Law Judge

CRA:kw


1    Rochelle Kleinberg
    Associate Regional Solicitor
2    Matthew L. Vadnal, Attorney
    Office of the Solicitor
3    U.S. Department of Labor
    1111 Third Avenue, Suite 945
4    Seattle, Washington 98101
    (206) 553-0940
5

6                UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF LABOR
                OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGES
7
     ASSISTANT SECRETARY OF LABOR FOR        )
8    OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY & HEALTH,           )
                                             )
9                   Prosecuting Party        )    Case No.
                                             ) 
10             and                           )
                                             )    2000 - STA - 45
11   GAL AVIGAL                              )
                         Complainant,        )
12        VS.                                )
                                             )
13   FAIRBANKS ANCHORAGE EXPRESS, INC.       )
                                             )
14                  Respondent.              )
      __________________________________________
15

16                         SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT

17

          18        COME NOW the Secretary of Labor, (the Prosecuting Party

19   herein), the Complainant, and the Respondent, by and through

20   their undersigned representatives of record, and in settlement of

21   this proceeding arising under §405 of the Surface Transportation

22   Assistance Act of 1982, 49 U.S.C. App §2305 (1982) (hereinafter

23   referred to as the "STAA"), and the regulations at 29 C.F.R.
Part

24   1978, do move, represent, and agree as follows:

25   1. The Respondent agrees to future compliance with the Act.

26   The Respondent shall not, contrary to §31105 of the STAA,

27   discharge, demote or in any manner discriminate against any

28   employee because said employee has filed a complaint or

    SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT     Page - 1
1    instituted or cause to be instituted any proceeding under or

2    related to the STAA or has testified or is about to testify in

3    any such proceeding or because of the exercise by such employee

4    on behalf of himself or others of any right afforded by the STAA.

5         2. The Respondent agrees to pay Mr. Avigal, $4,500.00 (less

6    applicable employee withholdings). The Prosecuting Party and the

7    Complainant agree to accept this sum as all back wages or other

8    monetary compensation due Mr. Avigal for alleged violations of

9    the STAA by the Respondent on or about November 19, 1999. The

10   Respondent agrees to pay this sum within 30 days of the date of

11   the Order accepting this agreement is entered by the Office of

12   Administrative Law Judges.

13        3. The Respondent agrees to expunge any adverse information

14   from the Complainant's personnel record.

15        4. The Respondent agrees that upon receiving inquiries from

16   future prospective employers, it will provide a neutral reference

17   limited to the Mr. Avigal's dates of employment, his position of

18   employment and his rate(s) of pay.

19        5. Respondent agrees to post a fully signed copy of this

20   Settlement Agreement in a conspicuous place in its facility

21   including all places where notices to employees are customarily

22   posted for 60 days.

23        6. The Respondent shall also post a copy of OSHA Fact Sheet

24   No. 93-30 and poster in a conspicuous place in its facility

25   including all places where notices to employees are customarily

26   posted.

27        7. The Respondent's entry to this Settlement Agreement

28   shall not constitute an admission of any violation of the STAR or

    SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT Page - 2
1    its implementing regulations and shall not be admissible as a

2    violation of the STAA in any other proceedings except in

3    proceedings brought directly by the Secretary under the STAR to

4    enforce the terms of this Settlement Agreement.

5         8. The Secretary deems the above to be a fair and equitable

6    settlement of all the matters at issue.

7         9. The parties agree upon the Respondent's payment of

8    $4,500.00 to the Complainant, the complaint filed by Gal Avigal

9    in this matter, along with the Secretary's findings and order

10   dated May 11, 2000, can be dismissed, with prejudice.

11        10. The parties further agree that the foregoing Settlement

12   Agreement addresses and resolves all the issues presently in

13   controversy between the parties and that an appropriate order may

14   be entered. The Office of Administrative Law Judges retains

15   jurisdiction to enforce the terms of this Agreement.

16   - - - -

17
     - - - -
18

19   - - - -

20
     - - - -
21

22   - - - -

23
     - - - -
24

25   - - - -

26
     - - - -
27

28   - - - -


SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT Page - 3
1    11.       Each party agrees to bear its own costs including but

2     not limited to attorneys' fees.

3
      Henry L. Solano
4     Solicitor of Labor

5     Daniel W. Teehan
      Regional Solicitor
6                                             Clarence J. Mitchell
      Rochelle Kleinberg                      Vice President
7     Associate Regional Solicitor

8     Matthew L. Vadnal                       Dated:  8-31-00
      Attorney
9

10    By
      Matthew L. Vadnal                      By 
11                                           James J. Hanlon  
      U.S. DEPARTMENT OF LABOR               Attorney for Respondent
12
      Dated: 9/28/00                         Dated:  8/30/00
13

14

15    Gal Avigal
      Complainant
16

17    Dated: 10-6-00

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28



SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT          Page - 4



Phone Numbers