skip navigational links United States Department of Labor
May 8, 2009        
DOL Home > OALJ Home > Whistleblower Collection > SDWA Decisions
DOL Home USDOL/OALJ Reporter: Whistleblower Decisions
SAFE DRINKING WATER ACT (SDWA)


1978-SDW-1 Greenwald v. The City of North Miami Beach
 Recommended Findings of Fact, Conclusion of Law, & Order (ALJ Mar. 15, 1978) (Samuel A. Chaitovitz)HTML
 Memorandum Decision (Sec'y Apr. 3, 1978) HTML
 Greenwald v. North Miami Beach, 587 F.2d 779 (5th Cir. 1979), cert. denied, 444 U.S. 826, 62 L.Ed. 2d 33, 100 S. Ct. 49 (1979)

1979-SDW-1 Bauch v. Joseph W. Landers, Jr. Secretary and Agents, State of Florida Dept. of Environmental Regulation
 Recommended Findings of Fact, Conclusion & Order (ALJ Apr. 13, 1979) (William Naimark)HTML
 Decision of the Secretary (Sec'y May 10, 1979)HTML

1979-SDW-2 Ray v. Harrington
 Recommended Decision (ALJ June 5, 1979) (George A. Fath)HTML
 Decision of the Secretary (Sec'y July 13, 1979)HTML

1980-SDW-1 Ray v. Metropolitan Government of Nashville
 Recommended Decision (ALJ Mar. 18, 1980) (Rhea M. Burrow)HTML
 Decision of the Secretary (Sec'y Apr. 14, 1980)HTML

1980-SDW-2 Greenwald v. The City of North Miami Beach
 Recommended Decision (ALJ Mar. 11, 1980) (Nahum Litt)HTML
 Memorandum Decision (Sec'y Apr. 14, 1980)HTML

1983-SDW-1 Prafke v. City of Fairmont, Minnesota
 Recommended Decision (ALJ Oct. 19, 1983) (Rhea M. Burrow)HTML
 Final Decision & Order (Sec'y Nov. 4, 1985)HTML

1986-SDW-1 McFarland v. City of New Franklin, Missouri
 Recommended Decision & Order (ALJ Sept. 26, 1986) (Richard D. Mills)HTML
 Notice of Review & Briefing Schedule (Sec'y July 17, 1990)HTML
 Order Approving Settlement & Dismissing Case (Sec'y Aug. 17, 1993)HTML

1987-SDW-1 Henthorne v. Carter
 Recommended Order (ALJ July 6, 1987) (Robert J. Feldman)HTML
 Order Approving Settlement (Sec'y Aug. 21, 1987)HTML

1989-SDW-1 Ewald v. Commonwealth of Virginia Dept. of Waste Management
 Recommended Order Granting Summary Decision & Dismissing (ALJ Oct. 19, 1992) (Stuart A. Levin)HTML
 Decision & Remand Order (Sec'y Apr. 20, 1995)HTML
 Remand Order (ARB Aug. 21, 2000)HTML
 Order Denying Motion to Withdraw Order & Granting Time to Respond to Motion to Dismiss (ALJ Nov. 29, 2000)HTML
 Prior history:Ewald v. Commonwealth Dept. of Waste Management, 1991 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 15828 (E.D. Va. 1991) (memorandum decision; various Constitutional and state law claims), aff'd, 972 F.2d 339 (4th Cir. 1992) (unpublished decision available at 1992 U.S. App. LEXIS 16863)
 Decision & Order (ALJ Dec. 5, 2001)HTML
 Order (ARB Oct. 4, 2002)HTML
 Final Decision & Order (ARB Dec. 19, 2003)HTML

1989-SDW-2 Heffley v. NGK Metals Corp.
 Recommended Decision & Order (ALJ Sept. 28, 1989) (Ainsworth H. Brown)HTML
 Order to Submit Settlement (Sec'y Mar. 6, 1990)HTML
 Final Order Approving Settlement (Sec'y Apr. 20, 1990)HTML

1989-SDW-3 Bush v. Olympus Terrace Sewer District
 Recommended Decision & Order (ALJ Dec. 7, 1989) (Henry B. Lasky)HTML
 Order Approving Settlement (Sec'y Aug. 5, 1994) HTML

1990-SDW-1 Dubois v. Village of Cobden
 Recommended Dismissal (ALJ Apr. 4, 1991) (Robert L. Cox)HTML
 Final Order of Dismissal (Sec'y Apr. 24, 1991)HTML

1990-SDW-2 Eisner v. United States Environmental Protection Agency
 Decision & Order of Dismissal (ALJ Mar. 27, 1991) (James J. Butler)HTML
 Decision & Order of Remand (Sec'y Dec. 8, 1992) HTML
 Certification to 9th Cir. No. 93-70092 (Sec'y Mar. 24, 1993)
 Recommended Decision & Order (ALJ July 16, 1993) (Alexander Karst)HTML
 Final Order Approving Settlement Agreement & Dismissing Case (Sec'y Aug. 16, 1993)HTML

1991-SDW-1 Scott v. Yeargin
 Order (ALJ May 21, 1991) (Michael P. Lesniak)HTML
 Recommended Order of Dismissal (ALJ Apr. 1, 1992)HTML
 Final Order of Consolidation, & Dismissal (Sec'y May 6, 1992) HTML
 [Consolidated with 91-SDW-2]

1991-SDW-2 Scott v. Mauldin & W.M.I., Inc. Crane Service
 Recommended Order of Dismissal (ALJ June 7, 1991)(Michael P. Lesniak)HTML
 See 91-SDW-1 for: Recommended Order of Dismissal (ALJ Apr. 1, 1992) (Michael P. Lesniak)
 [Consolidated with 91-SDW-1]
 See 91-SDW-1 for subsequent orders

1992-SDW-1 Fones v. Santa Fe Business Products
 Recommended Order Approving Settlement Agreement (ALJ Aug. 5, 1992) (John M. Vittone)HTML
 Final Order Approving Settlement & Dismissing Complaint (Sec'y Aug. 31, 1992)HTML
 Errata (Sec'y Sept. 3, 1992)HTML

1992-SDW-2 Daugherty v. General Physics Corp.
 Recommended Decision & Order (ALJ Dec. 14, 1992) (E. Earl Thomas)HTML
 Final Decision & Order (Sec'y Apr. 19, 1995)HTML

1993-SDW-1 Martin v. The Department of the Army
 Recommended Decision & Order (ALJ Dec. 22, 1993) (Theodor P. von Brand)HTML
 Decision & Order of Remand (Sec'y July 13, 1995)HTML
 Recommended Decision & Order on Remand (ALJ May 24, 1996)(Fletcher E. Campbell, Jr.)HTML
 Decision & Order (ARB July 30, 1999)HTML

1993-SDW-2 Hammer v. Brush Wellman, Inc.
 Recommended Order Approving Settlement & Dismissing Complaint (ALJ Sept. 7, 1993) (J. Michael O'Neill)HTML
 Final Order Approving Settlement & Dismissing Complaint With Prejudice (Sec'y Sept. 29, 1993) HTML

1993-SDW-3 Merritt v. Mishawaka Municipal Utilities, the City of Mishawaka
 Recommended Decision & Order (ALJ Dec. 9, 1993) (Rudolf L. Jansen) HTML
 Order of Remand (Sec'y Feb. 22, 1994) HTML
 Recommended Order of Dismissal (ALJ Mar. 24, 1995) HTML
 Final Decision & Order (Sec'y Sept. 11, 1995) [note: caption on Secretary's order states, in error, 93-SWD-3]HTML

1993-SDW-4 Emory v. United States Environmental Protection Agency
 Order Denying Motion of Barry Hartman to Quash Subpoena (ALJ Dec. 3, 1993) (Edith Barnett)HTML
 Order Denying Respondent's Motion to Dismiss or for Summary Judgment (ALJ Dec. 3, 1993)HTML
 Order Recommended Approval of Settlement (ALJ Jan. 14, 1994) HTML
 Final Order Approving Settlement (Sec'y Feb. 22, 1994) HTML

1994-SDW-1 Haymes v. D.P. Associates, Inc.
 (ALJ)
 Final Order of Dismissal (Sec'y Aug. 16, 1994) HTML

1994-SDW-3 Bush v. Olympus Terrace Sewer District
 (ALJ)
 Order Approving Settlement (Sec'y Aug. 5, 1994)

1995-SDW-1 White v. The Osage Tribal Council
 Recommended Decision & Order (ALJ May 31, 1996) (Quentin P. McColgin)HTML
 Recommended Decision & Order Awarding Costs & Expenses (ALJ July 9, 1996)HTML
 Decision & Order of Remand (ARB Aug. 8, 1997)HTML
 Order Returning Case to Administrative Review Board Pending Respondent's Appeal to the Tenth Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals (ALJ Mar. 30, 1998)HTML
 The Osage Tribal Council v. USDOL, No. 97-9564 (10th Cir. Aug. 4, 1999)(available at 1999 WL 570477)HTML
 Remand Order (ARB Sept. 29, 1999)HTML
 Cert. denied: Osage Tribal Council v. United States Department of Labor, No. 99-1482 (June 12, 2000)
 Order Returning Filing (ARB Aug. 7, 2000)HTML
 Decision & Order on Remand & Order Denying Respondent's Motion for Additional Discovery &/or Briefing & Joinder of Additional Party(ALJ Aug. 10, 2000)HTML
 Final Decision & Order (ARB Apr. 8, 2003)HTML

1997-SDW-1 Beliveau v. Naval Undersea Warfare Center
 [consolidated with 97-SDW-4]
 Order Denying Interlocutory Appeal (ARB Aug. 14, 1997)HTML
 Recommended Decision & Order (ALJ June 29, 2000)HTML
 Final Order Approving Settlement & Dismissing Appeals (ARB Nov. 30, 2000)HTML
 [consolidated with 97-SDW-4 and 6]

1997-SDW-2 White v. The Osage Tribal Council
 Stipulation of Dismissal with Prejudice (ALJ July 18, 1997)(John C. Holmes)(order approving)HTML

1997-SDW-3 Singal v. ICF Kaiser Engineers, Inc.
 Recommended Decision & Order (ALJ June 4, 2001) (Alexander Karst)HTML

1997-SDW-4 Beliveau v. Naval Undersea Warfare Center
 [consolidated with 1997-SDW-1 and 6]
 see 1997-SDW-1 for orders

1997-SDW-5 Hall v. U.S. Army, Dugway Proving Ground
 Recommended Decision & Order (ALJ Aug. 8, 2002) (David W. Di Nardi)HTML
 Final Decision & Order (ARB Dec. 30, 2004) PDF
 Hall v. USDOL, Administrative Review Board, No. 05-9512 (10th Cir. Feb. 13, 2007) PDF | HTML

1997-SDW-6 Beliveau v. Naval Undersea Warfare Center
 Recommended Order of Dismissal (ALJ Sept. 9, 1997)(Jeffrey Tureck)HTML
 Final Decision & Order (ARB June 26, 1998)HTML
 Certification to 1st Cir., No. 98-1786 (ARB Aug. 6, 1998)
 Amended certification (ARB Feb. 17, 1999)
 Beliveau v. U.S. Dept. of Labor, No. 98-1786 (1st Cir. Mar. 10, 1999) (available at 1999 WL 118047)HTML
 Order (ARB June 30, 1999)HTML
 Order (ARB June 30, 1999) (corrected version)HTML
 Errata (ARB July 2, 1999)HTML
 Order Awarding Costs (ALJ Apr. 19, 2000)HTML
 Order Denying Motion For Reconsideration of Order Denying Protective Order (ALJ May 31, 2000)HTML
 [later consolidated with 1997-SDW-1 and 4]
 see 1997-SDW-1 for later orders
 Order Transferring Case to Administrative Review Board (ALJ Nov. 2, 2000) (Jeffrey Tureck) HTML

1997-SDW-7 Anderson v. Metro Wastewater Reclamation District
 Order Granting Respondent's Motion for Summary Decision (ALJ Feb. 19, 1998)(Samuel J. Smith)HTML
 Decision & Remand Order (ARB Mar. 30, 2000)HTML
 Recommended Decision & Order (ALJ Sept. 18, 2001) (David W. Di Nardi)HTML
 Final Decision & Order (ARB May 19, 2003)HTML
 Certification to 10th Cir., No. 03-9570 (ARB Sept. 5, 2003)
 Anderson v. USDOL No. 03-9570 (10th Cir. Sept. 2, 2005) (affirming the ARB)PDF

1997-SDW-8 Allen v.EG & G Defense Materials, Inc.
 [consolidated with 97-SDW-10]
 Order Granting Complainant's Motion for Default Judgment (ALJ Jan. 26, 1998)(Samuel J. Smith)HTML
 Order Denying Interlocutory Appeal (ARB Sept. 28, 1998)HTML
 Order Granting Motion for Reconsideration (ALJ Aug. 21, 2001) (Thomas M. Burke)HTML
 Recommended Decision & Order Approving Settlement (ALJ May 23, 2002)HTML

1997-SDW-9 Hall v. EG & G Defense Materials, Inc.
 Recommended Order of Dismissal (ALJ Feb. 6, 1998)(Samuel J. Smith)HTML
 Final Decision & Order (ARB Sept. 30, 1998)HTML
 Certification of record to 10th Cir., EG&G Defense Materials, Inc. v. USDOL, No. 98-9547 (ARB Jan. 8, 1999), amended (June 15, 1999)
 Hall v. USDOL, No. 98-9547 (10th Cir. Oct. 13, 1999) (unpublished) (decision available at 1999 WL 815830)HTML

1997-SDW-10 Allen v.EG & G Defense Materials, Inc.
 [consolidated with 97-SDW-8]
 see 97-SDW-8 for orders

1998-SDW-1 Truman v. Parker Excavating, Inc.
 Recommended Decision and Order Approving Settlement and Dismissing Complaint Without Prejudice (ALJ May 13, 1998)(Daniel L. Stewart)HTML

1998-SDW-2 Rimar v. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
 Recommended Decision & Order Approving Settlement (ALJ Oct. 14, 1998)(Paul A. Mapes)HTML
 Order Denying Reconsideration (ALJ Feb. 16, 1999)HTML

1998-SDW-3 Mohr v. EG & G Defense Materials, Inc.
 Recommended Decision & Order Approving Settlement (ALJ Oct. 9, 1998)(Alexander Karst)HTML

1999-SDW-1 Johnson v. E G & G Defense Materials, Inc.
 Recommended Decision & Order Approving Settlement Agreement (ALJ Feb. 23, 2000) (Daniel J. Roketenetz)HTML

1999-SDW-2 Kirman v. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
 Recommended Order of Dismissal (ALJ May 18, 1999) (Richard A. Morgan)HTML

1999-SDW-3 Leford v. Tennessee Valley Authority
 Recommended Decision & Order Approving Settlement (ALJ June 22, 1999) (Thomas M. Burke)HTML

2000-SDW-1 Ayotte v. Arc-rite Precision Welding
 Recommended Decision & Order Approving Voluntary Dismissal (ALJ Aug. 15, 2000) (Daniel F. Sutton)HTML

2002-SDW-1 Alger v. City of Missoula
 Recommended Decision & Order Approving Settlement (ALJ Feb. 25, 2002) (Alice M. Craft)HTML

2002-SDW-2 Yates v. EG&G Defense Materials, Inc.
 Recommended Order of Dismissal (ALJ Oct. 3, 2002) (Daniel J. Roketenetz)HTML

2002-SDW-3 Yates v. United States Army
 Recommended Order of Dismissal (ALJ Oct. 3, 2002) (Daniel J. Roketenetz)HTML

2002-SDW-4 Mugleston v. EG&G Defense Materials, Inc.
 Recommended Decision & Order (ALJ Feb. 12, 2004) (Richard D. Mills)HTML
 Final Decision & Order (ARB June 30, 2004) HTML | PDF

2003-SDW-1 Caldwell v. E.G.&G.
 Recommended Decision & Order Approving Settlement Agreement (ALJ May 10, 2005) (Paul A. Mapes)PDF
 Final Decision and Order (ARB Oct. 31, 2008) PDF | HTM
 Errata (ARB Dec. 10, 2008) PDF | HTML

2003-SDW-2 O'Donnell v. Primax Recoveries, Inc.
 Recommended Decision & Order Approving Settlement Agreement (ALJ Jan. 21, 2004) (Daniel J. Roketenetz)HTML

2004-SDW-1 Dollens v. Bechtel SAIC Co., LLC
 Order Approving Settlement Agreement & Dismissing Complaint (ALJ Dec. 8, 2008) (William Dorsey) PDF

2004-SDW-2 Collvins v. EG & G Defense Materials, Inc.
 Recommended Order for Dismissal (ALJ Dec. 1, 2004) (Gerald M. Etchingham)PDF

2004-SDW-3 Yarbrough v. U.S. Dept. of the Army, Chemical Agent Munitions Disposal System (CAMDS)
 Recommended Decision & Order Granting Respondent's Motion for Summary Dismissal of David J. Yarbrough's Complaint (ALJ June 9, 2005) (Gerald M. Etchingham) PDF
 Order of Remand (ARB Aug. 30, 2007) PDF | HTML
 Recommended Decision & Order Approving Settlement & Dismissing Action Due to Settlement of Parallel MSPB Litigation (ALJ May 1, 2008) PDF

2005-SDW-1 Brock v. City of Pickens, South Carolina
 Recommended Decision & Order Dismissing Complaint (ALJ Nov. 21, 2005) (Daniel A. Sarno, Jr.)PDF

2005-SDW-2 Johnson v. EG&G Defense Materials, Inc.
 Recommended Decision & Order (ALJ Feb. 13, 2006) (Richard E. Huddleston)PDF
 Final Order Granting Complainant's Motion to Withdraw Petition for Review (ARB May 25, 2006) PDF

2005-SDW-3 Thorp v. City of Pickens, South Carolina
 Recommended Decision & Order Dismissing the Complaint (ALJ Mar. 1, 2007) (Richard K. Malamphy)PDF

2005-SDW-4 Dann v. Bechtel SAIC Co., LLC
 [consolidated with 2005-SDW-5 and 6]
 Order Granting Complainant's Motion to Recognize Bechtel Nevada As a Proper Co-Respondent (ALJ May 11, 2005) (Paul A. Mapes) PDF
 Order Granting in Part & Denying in Part Bechtel SAIC's Motion to Compel (ALJ May 13, 2005) PDF
 Order Granting in Part & Denying in Part Bechtel SAIC's Motion for Protective Order (ALJ May 25, 2005) PDF
 Order Denying Bechtel Nevada's Request to Be Dismissed (ALJ June 1, 2005) PDF
 Order Denying Request for Continuance (ALJ June 23, 2005) PDF
 Order Granting Request for Continuance (ALJ July 4, 2005) PDF
 Order Denying Bechtel Nevada's Motion for Summary Decision (ALJ Aug. 9, 2005) PDF
 Order Granting Motion to Compel Discovery Responses (ALJ Aug. 9, 2005) PDF
 Order Denying Bechtel Nevada's Requests to Re-Open Discovery, to Compel the Complainants to Take Pre-Trial Depositions & to Be Furnished a Subpoena Compelling the Testimony of Nick Fiore (ALJ Aug. 26, 2005) PDF
 Order Granting Motion to Impose Sanctions on Bechtel Nevada (ALJ Aug. 26, 2005) PDF
 Final Decision & Order (ARB Oct. 31, 2005) (approving withdrawal of interlocutory appeal) PDF
 Order Approving Settlement (ALJ Nov. 5, 2007) (Jennifer Gee) PDF

2005-SDW-5 Fuller v. Bechtel SAIC Co., LLC
 Order Approving Settlement (ALJ Nov. 5, 2007) (Jennifer Gee) PDF

2005-SDW-6 Koscik v. Bechtel SAIC Co., LLC
 Order Approving Settlement (ALJ Nov. 5, 2007) (Jennifer Gee) PDF

2005-SDW-7 Higgins v. Glen Raven Mills, Inc.
 Recommended Decision & Order Granting Respondent's Motion to Dismiss (ALJ Aug. 5, 2005) (Richard E. Huddleston) PDF
 Final Decision & Order (ARB Sept. 29, 2006) PDF | HTM

2005-SDW-8 Dixon v. U.S. Dept. of Interior, Bureau of Land Management
 Recommended Decision & Order (ALJ Aug. 31, 2006) (Richard K. Malamphy) PDF
 Final Decision and Order (ARB Aug. 28, 2008) PDF | HTML

2006-SDW-1 Craig v. City of Torrington, WY
 Decision & Order Approving Settlement Agreement (ALJ July 19, 2006) (William Dorsey) PDF
 Order of Remand (ARB Apr. 30, 2008) HTML | PDF

2006-SDW-2 Fox v. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
 [consolidated with 2004-CAA-4, 2004-CAA-10, 2005-CAA-6, AND 2005-CAA-14]
 see 2004-CAA-4 for orders

2006-SDW-3 Collins v. Village of Lynchburg, Ohio
 Recommended Decision & Order (ALJ May 8, 2007) (Joseph E. Kane) PDF
 Final Decision & Order (ARB Mar. 30, 2009) HTML | PDF

2006-SDW-5 Kelly v. United States Enrichment Corp.
 [consolidated with 2006-ERA-15]
 see 2006-ERA-15 for orders

2006-SDW-6 Klein v. BART
 Recommended Decision & Order Dismissing Complaint (ALJ June 18, 2008) (Jennifer Gee) PDF

2006-SDW-7 Gritzuk v. City of Phoenix
 Order Dismissing Appeal & Remanding to Administrator (ALJ July 1, 2007) (Russell D. Pulver) PDF

2007-SDW-1 Powell v. City of Ardmore, California
 Decision & Order (ALJ Nov. 25, 2008) (Thomas M. Burke) PDF

2008-SDW-1 Wright v. City of Las Vegas
 Decision & Order of Dismissal (ALJ Feb. 12, 2009) (William Dorsey) PDF

2009-SDW-1 Peake v. Martinrea Fabco Hot Stamping, Inc.
 Decision & Order of Dismissal & Order Cancelling Hearing (ALJ Apr. 9, 2009) (Joseph E. Kane) PDF



 Claimant Name Policy HTML | PDF
 Courtroom Security - Washington, DC
 e-Judication Portal
 e-Judication Disclaimer
 Public Access Notice
 Social Security Numbers on Subpoenas
 2005 Notice
   HTML | PDF
 2007 Notice
   HTML | PDF


 Questions
 National Office
 District Offices


 About OALJ
 ADR and Settlement Judges
 Attorneys and Representatives
    How to Find
    Information for
 Forms
 How to Find Decisions
 Offices/Contacts
 FAQs
 Subpoenas
 Witnesses



Phone Numbers