IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF OHIO
WESTERN DIVISION
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, Plaintiff
v.
OPERATION RESCUE NATIONAL, an unincorporated association, PHILIP BENHAM, RUSTY L. THOMAS, BRYAN S. KEMPER, DAVID MEHAFFIE, JAMES F. ANDERSON, FRANK L. BALTES, ROGER L. HALL, HEATHER F. MECHANIC, OLIVIA A. ALAW, and numerous other individuals, currently known as JANE and JOHN DOES, Defendants
COMPLAINT
Plaintiff THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA alleges that:
1. The Attorney General files this civil action on behalf
of the United States of America pursuant to the Freedom of Access
to Clinic Entrances Act (the "Access Act"), 18 U.S.C. § 248. In
bringing this Complaint, the Attorney General has reasonable
cause to believe that three reproductive health care facilities
-- Women's Medical Center in Cincinnati, Ohio, Women's Medical
Center in Kettering, Ohio, and Dayton Women's Services in Dayton,
Ohio -- their employees and persons seeking reproductive services
at these facilities have been and may continue to be injured by
conduct constituting violations of the Access Act. The United
States files this Complaint to ensure that Defendants are
enjoined from committing future violations of the Access Act and
that statutory damages and civil penalties, as provided for under
the Access Act, are imposed on Defendants for their violations of
the Act.
I.
JURISDICTION, STANDING AND VENUE
2. This court has jurisdiction over this action under 18 U.S.C. § 248(c)(2) and 28 U.S.C. §§ 1331, and over the out-of-state Defendants pursuant to Ohio Rev. Code Ann. § 2307.382(A)(3) (Banks-Baldwin 1988).
3. The United States is authorized to initiate this action
pursuant to the Access Act, 18 U.S.C. § 248(c)(2).
4. Venue in the United States District Court, Southern
District of Ohio, is proper pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1391(b)(2).
The claims set forth in this Complaint all arose in this judicial
District.
II.
DEFENDANTS
5. Defendant OPERATION RESCUE NATIONAL ("Operation
Rescue"), on information and belief, is an unincorporated
association, located at 10935 Estate Lane, Dallas, Texas 75238.
6. Defendant PHILIP ("FLIP") BENHAM, on information and
belief, resides at 621 Dawn Drive, Garland, Texas 75040, and is
the Director of Operation Rescue.
7. Defendant RUSTY L. THOMAS, on information and belief,
resides at 2123 Colcord, Waco, Texas 76707, and is affiliated
with Operation Rescue.
8. Defendant BRYAN S. KEMPER, on information and belief,
resides at 1622 Southeast Harney, Portland, Oregon 97202, and was
at one time affiliated with Operation Rescue California.
9. Defendant DAVID MEHAFFIE, on information and belief,
resides at 542 Santa Cruz Avenue, Dayton, Ohio 45410.
10. Defendant JAMES F. ANDERSON, on information and belief,
resides at 1401 South Moore, Spokane, Washington 99203.
11. Defendant FRANK L. BALTES, on information and belief,
resides at 3648 State Route 66, Houston, Ohio 45333.
12. Defendant ROGER L. HALL, on information and belief,
resides at 5010 Mark Trail, Birmingham, Alabama 35242.
13. Defendant HEATHER F. MECHANIC, on information and
belief, resides at 13040 Cree Drive, Poway, California 92064.
14. Defendant OLIVIA A. ALAW, on information and belief,
resides at 12407 Meadowcrest Lane, Balch Springs, Texas 75180.
15. Defendants Jane and John Does, whose names and
addresses are unknown to plaintiff, are individuals who
participated in the conduct described herein at Paragraphs 22-36.
III.
FACTUAL ALLEGATIONS
16. The Women's Medical Center of Cincinnati, located at
3219 Jefferson Avenue, Cincinnati, Ohio (the "Cincinnati clinic")
is a facility that provides gynecological services to women,
including outpatient surgeries.
17. The Women's Medical Center of Kettering, located at
1401 East Stroop Street, Kettering, Ohio (the "Kettering clinic")
is a facility that provides gynecological services to women,
including outpatient surgeries.
18. The Dayton Women's Center (the "Dayton clinic"),
located at 1829 North Main Street, Dayton, Ohio, is a facility
that provides gynecological services to women, including
outpatient surgeries.
19. Individuals visit the Cincinnati, Kettering and Dayton
clinics to obtain medical, surgical, counseling or referral
services relating to the human reproductive system, including
services relating to the termination of pregnancy.
20. Between July 13-19, 1997, Operation Rescue organized
and directed a week-long campaign protesting abortion in the
Cincinnati/Dayton area entitled "The Return to Truth."
21. "The Return to Truth" campaign included daily "street
activities" at local reproductive health clinics. These street
activities took place at various clinics throughout the week.
22. On July 14, 1997, approximately 40 Jane and John Doe
Defendants, led by Defendants Thomas, Kemper and Mehaffie,
physically obstructed access to the Cincinnati clinic.
23. Beginning at approximately 8:00 a.m., Defendants
entered onto the Cincinnati clinic's property and stood or sat in
front of the clinic's two public entrances.
24. Defendants blocked the entrances to the Cincinnati
clinic in this manner for approximately one hour, dispersing only
after local police arrived in large numbers. Defendants had
previously ignored an order to leave the premises read to them by
the clinic director, who was accompanied by the Cincinnati Police
Chief.
25. Through their conduct, Defendants physically obstructed
the Cincinnati clinic by rendering access to the clinic
impassible or unreasonably difficult or hazardous.
26. Through their conduct, Defendants intentionally
interfered with or attempted to interfere with Cincinnati clinic
employees and clients because these individuals were seeking to
provide or obtain, or in order to prevent them providing or
obtaining, reproductive health services.
27. On July 15, 1997, over 100 Jane and John Doe Defendants
physically obstructed access to the Kettering clinic. On
information and belief, the group was led by Defendants Thomas,
Kemper, Mehaffie, Anderson and Benham.
28. Beginning at approximately 12:45 p.m., Defendants
entered onto the Kettering clinic's property and sat in front of
the clinic's three public entrances, two in front and one in
back.
29. Defendants blocked the entrances to the Kettering
clinic in this manner for approximately 1-1/2 hours, dispersing
only after local police began arresting the blockaders.
Defendants had previously ignored an order to leave the premises
read to them by the police.
30. Through their conduct, Defendants physically obstructed
the Kettering clinic by rendering access to the clinic impassible
and unreasonably difficult or hazardous.
31. Through their conduct, Defendants intentionally
interfered with or attempted to interfere with Kettering clinic
employees and clients because these individuals were seeking to
provide or obtain, or in order to prevent them providing or
obtaining, reproductive health services.
32. On July 16 and 18, 1997, over 200 Jane and John Doe
Defendants physically obstructed access to the Dayton clinic. On
information and belief, the group was led by Defendants Thomas,
Kemper, Mehaffie, Anderson and Benham.
33. On both July 16 and 18, 1997, Defendants blocked or
impeded access to the front and back entrances of the Dayton
clinic by standing and sitting in the alley leading to the
clinic's back entrance, and standing or sitting along and on the
entire front edge of the clinic's property, including the
sidewalk leading to the clinic's other entrance.
34. On July 16, 1997, Defendants blocked and impeded access
to the Dayton clinic in this manner for almost the entire day.
On July 18, 1997, Defendants blocked access to the clinic for
almost the entire afternoon.
35. Through their conduct, Defendants physically obstructed
the Dayton clinic by rendering access to the clinic unreasonably
difficult or hazardous.
36. Through their conduct, Defendants intentionally
interfered with or attempted to interfere with Dayton clinic
employees and clients because these individuals were seeking to
provide or obtain, or in order to prevent them providing or
obtaining, reproductive health services.
IV.
CAUSES OF ACTION FOR VIOLATIONS OF 18 U.S.C. § 248
37. Plaintiff realleges and repleads paragraphs 16 through
36 as though fully set forth here.
38. The conduct alleged in paragraphs 22 through 36
constitute violations of the Access Act, 18 U.S.C. § 248(a)(1).
39. Unless restrained by this Court, Defendants will
continue to engage in conduct and practices alleged above or
other conduct that violates the Access Act.
V.
PRAYER FOR RELIEF
40. The Attorney General is authorized under 18 U.S.C. § 248(c)(2)(B) to seek both permanent and preliminary injunctive relief, statutory damages for persons aggrieved by violations of the Access Act and civil penalties.
WHEREFORE, the United States prays that the Court:
1. Issue preliminary and permanent injunctions enjoining
and prohibiting Defendants, their agents, employees and all
individuals acting in concert with them from:
a. blocking, impeding, inhibiting or obstructing in any
way access to the Cincinnati, Kettering and Dayton
clinics, including access to the streets, alleys and
sidewalks that lead to these clinics;
b. being located on or within a specified distance of the
private property of the Cincinnati, Kettering and
Dayton clinics;
c. being located within a specified distance of the
entrance(s) to the alley(s) that lead to the Dayton
clinic's property or being located anywhere in the
alley(s); and
d. violating, or aiding, abetting or inciting others to
violate, the provisions of the Access Act, 18 U.S.C. § 248, anywhere.
2. Grant statutory damages against Defendants as
authorized by 18 U.S.C. § 248(c)(2)(B).
3. Assess civil penalties against Defendants as authorized
by 18 U.S.C. § 248(c)(2)(B).
4. Grant such other and further relief as the Court deems
just and proper.
Respectfully submitted,
JANET RENO, Attorney General of the United States
SHARON F. ZEALEY, United States Attorney, Southern District of Ohio
BILL LANN LEE, Acting Assistant Attorney General, Civil Rights Division
DALE A. GOLDBERG, Assistant United States Attorney, Chief, Civil Division
220 Potter Stewart Courthouse
100 East 5th Street
Cincinnati, Ohio 45202
(513) 684-3711
STEVEN H. ROSENBAUM, Chief, Special Litigation Section
MELLIE H. NELSON, Deputy Chief, Special Litigation Section
PAMELA K. CHEN
REBECCA E. EPSTEIN
Trial Attorneys
U.S. Department of Justice
Civil Rights Division
Special Litigation Section
Post Office Box 66400
Washington, D.C. 20035
(202) 514-6261
(202) 616-9017
Updated July 25, 2008