Public Health
NICEATM-ICCVAM Home >> Test Method Evaluations >> Project Milestones

Alternative Test Method Project Milestones

Site Map
Site Map

This page provides a current summary of the status of ongoing and completed NICEATM-ICCVAM alternative test method evaluation projects, as well as projects to which NICEATM, ICCVAM, and agency scientists are contributing.

View summary of status of ongoing and completed NICEATM-ICCVAM test method evaluations for which U.S. agency endorsement has been received or is pending

Alternative test methods:

  • Reduce the number of animals used to the minimum number required to obtain scientifically valid data
  • Refine procedures to lessen or eliminate animal pain and distress
  • Replace animals with non-animal systems or one animal species with a less highly developed one (for example, replacing a mouse with a fish).
More information about the ICCVAM Test Method Evaluation Process

View status of test method evaluation projects grouped by project area

Acute Oral Systemic Toxicity Endocrine Disruptor
Biologics and Vaccines Genetic Toxicity
Dermal Corrosivity Immunotoxicity
Dermal Irritation Ocular Toxicity
Developmental Toxicity Pyrogenicity

Select project name in summary table to jump down the page to details and links


Acute Oral Systemic Toxicity Projects
Test Method R&D Validation Studies Evaluation Recommendations
for U.S. Agencies
U.S.
Acceptance
International
Acceptance
Additional Activities
Up-and-Down Procedure check mark check mark check mark check mark 2002 2002 .
Fixed Dose Procedure check mark check mark check mark check mark 2002 2002 .
Acute Toxic Class Method check mark check mark check mark check mark 2002 2002 .
In Vitro Cytotoxicity Test Methods: 3T3 Cells check mark check mark check mark check mark 2008 In progress .
In Vitro Cytotoxicity Test Methods: NHK Cells check mark check mark check mark check mark 2008 In progress .
Biologics and Vaccines Projects
Test Method R&D Validation Studies Evaluation Recommendations
for U.S. Agencies
U.S.
Acceptance
International
Acceptance
Additional Activities
Use of Humane Endpoints in Animal Testing of Veterinary Products check mark check mark check mark check mark 2004 . .
Use of Humane Endpoints in Animal Testing of Rabies Vaccines check mark check mark check mark check mark 2004 . .
In Vivo Refinement Alternatives for Botulinum Toxin Potency Testing check mark . . . . . .
Ex Vivo Alternatives for Botulinum Toxin Potency Testing check mark . . . . . .
Cell-based Alternatives for Botulinum Toxin Potency Testing check mark . . . . . .
Endopeptidase Assay Alternatives for Botulinum Toxin Potency Testing check mark . . . . . .
Alternative Methods for Animal Vaccine Potency and Safety Testing check mark . . . . . .
Dermal Corrosivity Projects
Test Method R&D Validation Studies Evaluation Recommendations
for U.S. Agencies
U.S.
Acceptance
International
Acceptance
Additional Activities
Corrositex® Assay check mark check mark check mark check mark 2000 2006 .
EpiDermTM Assay check mark check mark check mark check mark 2004 2004 .
EPISKINTM Assay check mark check mark check mark check mark 2004 2004 .
Rat Transcutaneal Electrical Resistance Assay check mark check mark check mark check mark 2004 2004 .
SkinEthic RHE Assay check mark check mark check mark check mark 2004 2004 .
Dermal Irritation Projects
Test Method R&D Validation Studies Evaluation Recommendations
for U.S. Agencies
U.S.
Acceptance
International
Acceptance
Additional Activities
EpiDermTM Assay check mark check mark In progress . . . .
EPISKINTM Assay check mark check mark In progress . . . .
SkinEthic RHE Assay check mark check mark In progress . . . .
Developmental Toxicity Projects
Test Method R&D Validation Studies Evaluation Recommendations
for U.S. Agencies
U.S.
Acceptance
International
Acceptance
Additional Activities
Frog Embryo Teratogenesis Assay: Xenopus (FETAX) check mark check mark check mark ICCVAM review in 2000 found that FETAX was not sufficiently reliable for regulatory use and provided recommendations for improving accuracy and reliability
Endocrine Disruptor Projects
Test Method R&D Validation Studies Evaluation Recommendations
for U.S. Agencies
U.S.
Acceptance
International
Acceptance
Additional Activities
In vitro Andogen Receptor (AR) Binding check mark ICCVAM review in 2004 found no adequately validated studies - ICCVAM published recommendations on future validation studies .
In vitro AR Transcriptional Activation (TA) check mark ICCVAM review in 2004 found no adequately validated studies - ICCVAM published recommendations on future validation studies .
In vitro Estrogen Receptor (ER) Binding check mark ICCVAM review in 2004 found no adequately validated studies - ICCVAM published recommendations on future validation studies .
In vitro ER TA check mark ICCVAM review in 2004 found no adequately validated studies - ICCVAM published recommendations on future validation studies .
LUMICELL® ER TA Assay Evaluation check mark In progress . . . . .
MCF-7 Cell Proliferation Assay Evaluation check mark In progress . . . . .
Genetic Toxicity Projects
Test Method R&D Validation Studies Evaluation Recommendations
for U.S. Agencies
U.S.
Acceptance
International
Acceptance
Additional Activities
In Vitro Micronucleus Assay check mark . . . . . In progress
Immunotoxicity Projects
Test Method R&D Validation Studies Evaluation Recommendations
for U.S. Agencies
U.S.
Acceptance
International
Acceptance
Additional Activities
Murine Local Lymph Node Assay (LLNA) check mark check mark check mark check mark 1999 2002 .
Reduced LLNA Test Method check mark check mark In progress . . . .
Nonradiolabeled LLNA Methods check mark check mark In progress . . . .
Use of the LLNA for Skin Sensitization Potency Categorization check mark check mark In progress . . . .
Use of the LLNA for Testing Mixtures, Metals, and Aqueous Solutions check mark check mark In progress . . . .
Development of LLNA Performance Standards check mark check mark In progress . . . .
Ocular Toxicity Projects
Test Method R&D Validation Studies Evaluation Recommendations
for U.S. Agencies
U.S.
Acceptance
International
Acceptance
Additional Activities
Bovine Corneal Opacity and Permeability (BCOP) - Ocular Corrosivity check mark check mark check mark check mark 2008 In progress .
Hen's Egg Test/Choriallantoic Membrane - Ocular Corrosivity (HET-CAM) check mark check mark check mark check mark ICCVAM review in 2008 found that HET-CAM was not sufficiently reliable for regulatory use and recommended additional studies
Isolated Chicken Eye (ICE) - Ocular Corrosivity check mark check mark check mark check mark 2008 In progress .
Isolated Rabbit Eye (IRE) - Ocular Corrosivity check mark check mark check mark check mark ICCVAM review in 2008 found that IRE was not sufficiently reliable for regulatory use and recommended additional studies
Integrated Nonanimal Testing Strategy for Eye Irritation Potential of Antimicrobial Cleaning Products check mark check mark In progress . . . .
BCOP - Mild to Moderate Ocular Irritation check mark check mark In progress . . . .
HET-CAM - Mild to Moderate Ocular Irritation check mark check mark In progress . . . .
ICE - Mild to Moderate Ocular Irritation check mark check mark In progress . . . .
IRE - Mild to Moderate Ocular Irritation check mark check mark In progress . . . .
Fluorescein Leakage Test Method - Mild to Moderate Ocular Irritation check mark check mark In progress . . . .
Cytosensor Microphysiometer Test Method - Mild to Moderate Ocular Irritation check mark check mark In progress . . . .
Neutral Red Release Test Method - Mild to Moderate Ocular Irritation check mark check mark In progress . . . .
Red Blood Cell Haemolysis Test Method - Mild to Moderate Ocular Irritation check mark check mark In progress . . . .
Pyrogenicity Projects
Test Method R&D Validation Studies Evaluation Recommendations
for U.S. Agencies
U.S.
Acceptance
International
Acceptance
Additional Activities
The Human Whole Blood/IL-1 In Vitro Pyrogen Test chck mark check mark check mark check mark In progress . .
The Human Whole Blood/ IL-1 In Vitro Pyrogen Test Using Cryopreserved Human Whole Blood check mark check mark check mark check mark In progress . .
The Human Whole Blood/IL-6 In Vitro Pyrogen Test (WB/IL-6) check mark check mark check mark check mark In progress . .
In Vitro Pyrogen Test Using Human Peripheral Blood Mononuclear Cells (PBMC/IL-6) check mark check mark check mark check mark In progress . .
An Alternative In Vitro Pyrogen Test Using the Human Monocytoid Cell Line MONO MAC 6 (MM6/IL-6) check mark check mark check mark check mark In progress . .

Back to top


Acute Oral Systemic Toxicity

Up-And-Down Procedure

Acute oral systemic toxicity testing identifies substances that are poisonous when ingested so that they may be appropriately labeled and packaged. The Up-And-Down Procedure reduces animal use for this purpose by up to 70%.

Milestone Date Document Link or
More Information
Publication of OECD Test Guideline 425 1998 PDF
Nomination by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) August 1999 -
Peer Review Panel Meeting July 2000 HTML
Peer Review Panel Follow-up Teleconference August 2001 HTML
Test Method Evaluation Report Published November 2001 Vol 1 - Vol 2
Recommendations Made to Federal Agencies March 2003 HTML
Federal Agency Responses Received December 2003 HTML

Fixed Dose Procedure

Acute oral systemic toxicity testing identifies substances that are poisonous when ingested so that they may be appropriately labeled and packaged. The Fixed Dose Procedure reduces animal use for this purpose by up to 70%.

Milestone Date Document Link or
More Information
Publication of OECD Test Guideline 420 1998 PDF

Acute Toxic Class Method

Acute oral systemic toxicity testing identifies substances that are poisonous when ingested so that they may be appropriately labeled and packaged. The Acute Toxic Class Method reduces animal use for this purpose by up to 70%.

Milestone Date Document Link or
More Information
Publication of OECD Test Guideline 423 1998 PDF

Back to top

Evaluation of In Vitro Cytotoxicity Test Methods

Acute oral systemic toxicity testing identifies substances that are poisonous when ingested so that they may be appropriately labeled and packaged. In Vitro Cytotoxicity Test Methods replace animal use for initial dose setting for these tests.

Milestone Date Document Link or
More Information
EPA Nomination August 1999 -
Workshop Held October 2000 HTML
Guidance Document Published August 2001 PDF
Workshop Report Published August 2001 PDF
Recommendations Made to Federal Agencies March 2003 HTML
Federal Agency Responses Received December 2003 HTML

Validation Study of In Vitro Cytotoxicity Test Methods

Acute oral systemic toxicity testing identifies substances that are poisonous when ingested so that they may be appropriately labeled and packaged. Neutral Red Uptake Test Methods replace animal use for initial dose setting for these tests.

Milestone Date Document Link or
More Information
Peer Review Panel Meeting May 2006 HTML
Peer Review Panel Report Published June 2006 PDF
Background Review Document Published November 2006 Vol 1 - Vol 2
Test Method Evaluation Report Published November 2006 HTML
Recommendations Made to Federal Agencies March 2008 HTML
Federal Agency Responses Received September 2008 HTML


Developing and Advancing In Vitro Alternatives to Acute Chemical Systemic Toxicity Testing

Acute oral systemic toxicity testing identifies substances that are poisonous when ingested so that they may be appropriately labeled and packaged. An ICCVAM-sponsored workshop explored ways to reduce, refine, or replace animal use for this purpose.

Milestone Date Document Link or
More Information
Workshop Held February 2008 HTML
Workshop Report Published Available online 2009 -

Back to top

Biologics

Use of Humane Endpoints in Animal Testing of Veterinary Products and Rabies Vaccines

Animal testing of biological products and rabies vaccines is performed to ensure that each lot of these products is safe and effective. A USDA directive refines animal use for this purpose.

Milestone Date Document Link or
More Information
USDA Directive Published April 2004 PDF


Alternative Methods for Botulinum Toxin Potency Testing

Animal testing of botulinum toxin is performed to ensure that each lot of this product is safe and effective. An ICCVAM-sponsored workshop explored ways to reduce, refine, or replace animal use for this purpose.

Milestone Date Document Link or
More Information
Nomination by the Humane Society of the United States October 2005 PDF
Workshop Held November 2006 HTML
Workshop Report Published February 2008 PDF

Back to top

Alternative Methods for Animal Vaccine Potency and Safety Testing

Animal testing of animal vaccines is performed to ensure that each lot of these products is safe and effective. An ICCVAM-sponsored workshop will explore ways to reduce, refine, or replace animal use for this purpose.

Milestone Date Document Link or
More Information
Workshop Planned Spring 2010 -


Dermal Corrosivity

Evaluation of Corrositex® for the Identification of Substances Potentially Corrosive to Human Skin

Dermal corrosivity testing identifies substances that cause chemical burns to the skin so that they may be appropriately labeled and packaged. Corrositex® reduces and refines animal use for this purpose.

Milestone Date Document Link or
More Information
Corrositex® Submission May 1998 -
Peer Review Panel Meeting January 1999 HTML
Peer Review Panel Report Published June 1999 PDF
Recommendations Made to Federal Agencies June 1999 -
Federal Agency Responses Received October 1999 HTML
Publication of OECD Test Guideline 435 July 2006 PDF


Evaluation of EpiSkinTM, EPIDERMTM and the Rat Skin Transcutaneous Electrical Resistance Assay (TER) for the Identification of Substances Potentially Corrosive to Human Skin

Dermal corrosivity testing identifies substances that cause chemical burns to the skin so that they may be appropriately labeled and packaged. Use of these in vitro tests reduces and refines animal use for this purpose.

Milestone Date Document Link or
More Information
Background Review Document Published August 2001 PDF
Test Method Evaluation Report Published June 2002 HTML
Recommended Performance Standards Published May 2004 PDF
Publication of OECD Test Guidelines 430 and 431 July 2006 TG 430 - PDF
TG 431 - PDF

Back to top

Dermal Irritation

Evaluation of EpiSkinTM, EPIDERMTM and the SkinEthic RHE Assay for the Identification of Substances Potentially Irritating to Human Skin

Dermal irritation testing identifies substances that cause irritation to the skin so that they may be appropriately labeled and packaged. Use of these in vitro tests reduces animal use for this purpose.

Milestone Date Document Link or
More Information
Submission of ICCVAM Comments on Draft
Test Guideline to U.S. OECD National Coordinator
August 2008 HTML
OECD Expert Meeting Scheduled for June 2009 -

Developmental Toxicity

Frog Embryo Teratogenesis Assay: Xenopus (FETAX)

Developmental toxicity testing identifies substances that may cause birth defects so that they may be appropriately labeled. Use of FETAX could reduce or replace animal use for this purpose.

Milestone Date Document Link or
More Information
EPA Nomination May 1998 -
Background Review Document Published March 2000 HTML
Expert Panel Meeting May 2000 PDF

Back to top

Endocrine Disruptor

Evaluation of In Vitro ER and AR Binding and TA Assays

Endocrine disruptor testing identifies substances that may interfere with normal human and animal development. Use of in vitro tests could reduce animal use for this purpose in the EPA Endocrine Disruptor Screening Program (EDSP).

Milestone Date Document Link or
More Information
EPA Nomination April 2000 -
Expert Panel Meeting May 2002 HTML
Expert Panel Report September 2002 PDF
Background Review Documents Published October 2002 HTML
Test Method Evaluation Report Published May 2003 HTML
Addendum to Test Method Evaluation Report Published September 2006 PDF

Back to top

Xenobiotic Detection Systems, Inc. LUMICELL® ER Assay Validation Study

Endocrine disruptor testing identifies substances that may interfere with normal human and animal development. Use of the LUMICELL® ER Assay could reduce animal use for this purpose in the EPA EDSP.

Milestone Date Document Link or
More Information
LUMICELL® ER Assay Nomination January 2004 PDF
Draft Pre-Screen Evaluation Released August 2004 PDF
Submission of the Standard Project Submission Form
to the OECD Test Guidelines Program:
Stably Transfected Transcriptional Activation Assay
for the Detection of Estrogen Receptor Agonists and Antagonists
September 2007 PDF
Validation Study Initiated November 2007 HTML
Peer Review of Draft Background Review Document and Draft ICCVAM Test Method Recommendations Projected September 2009 -


CertiChem Inc. MCF-7 Cell Proliferation Assay Evaluation

Endocrine disruptor testing identifies substances that may interfere with normal human and animal development. Use of the MCF-7 Cell Proliferation Assay could reduce animal use for this purpose in the EPA EDSP.

Milestone Date Document Link or
More Information
MCF-7 Cell Proliferation Assay Nomination June 2004 PDF
Pre-Screen Evaluation Released October 2006 PDF

Back to top

Genetic Toxicity

Draft Test Guideline for the In Vitro Mammalian Cell Micronucleus Test

Genetic toxicity testing identifies substances that may cause DNA damage and increase risk of cancer or birth defects. Use of the In Vitro Mammalian Cell Micronucleus Test could reduce animal use for this purpose.

Milestone Date Document Link or
More Information
Submission of ICCVAM Comments on Draft Test Guideline
to U.S. OECD National Coordinator
February 2007 HTML

Back to top

Immunotoxicity

Murine Local Lymph Node Assay (LLNA)

Immunotoxicity testing identifies substances that may act as sensitizers and cause the development of allergic contact dermatitis. Use of the LLNA reduces and refines animal use for this purpose.

Milestone Date Document Link or
More Information
Nomination by Sponsors January 1998 -
Peer Review Panel Meeting September 1998 HTML
Peer Review Panel Report February 1999 PDF
Recommendations Made to Federal Agencies February 1999 HTML
Publication of OECD Test Guideline 429 July 2006 PDF


Development of Performance Standards for the Murine Local Lymph Node Assay (LLNA)

Immunotoxicity testing identifies substances that may act as sensitizers and cause the development of allergic contact dermatitis. Accepted performance standards will enable the development of new versions of the LLNA for this purpose.

Milestone Date Document Link or
More Information
CPSC Nomination January 2007 PDF
Draft Performance Standards Published September 2007 PDF
Peer Review Panel Meeting March 2008 HTML
Peer Review Panel Report Published May 2008 PDF
Finalized ICCVAM Performance Standards Published April 2009 HTML


Reduced Murine Local Lymph Node Assay (LLNA)

Immunotoxicity testing identifies substances that may act as sensitizers and cause the development of allergic contact dermatitis. The reduced LLNA will reduce animal use for this purpose.

Milestone Date Document Link or
More Information
CPSC Nomination January 2007 PDF
Peer Review Panel Meeting March 2008 HTML
Peer Review Panel Report Published May 2008 PDF
Test Method Evaluation Report Published Projected early 2009 HTML

Back to top

Nonradioactive Murine Local Lymph Node Assay (LLNA)

Immunotoxicity testing identifies substances that may act as sensitizers and cause the development of allergic contact dermatitis. Nonradioactive version of the LLNA will refine and reduce animal use for this purpose by enabling more widespread use of the LLNA.

Milestone Date Document Link or
More Information
CPSC Nomination January 2007 PDF
Peer Review Panel Meeting March 2008 HTML
Peer Review Panel Report Published May 2008 PDF
Revised Background Review Documents and ICCVAM Recommendations Published March 2009 HTML
Second Peer Review Panel Meeting April 2009 HTML


Use of the Murine Local Lymph Node Assay (LLNA) for Skin Sensitization Potency Categorization

Immunotoxicity testing identifies substances that may act as sensitizers and cause the development of allergic contact dermatitis. Use of the LLNA will refine and reduce animal use for this purpose.

Milestone Date Document Link or
More Information
CPSC Nomination January 2007 PDF
Peer Review Panel Meeting March 2008 HTML
Peer Review Panel Report Published May 2008 PDF


Use of the Murine Local Lymph Node Assay (LLNA) for Testing Mixtures, Metals, and Aqueous Solutions

Immunotoxicity testing identifies substances that may act as sensitizers and cause the development of allergic contact dermatitis. Use of the LLNA will refine and reduce animal use for this purpose.

Milestone Date Document Link or
More Information
CPSC Nomination January 2007 PDF
Peer Review Panel Meeting March 2008 HTML
Peer Review Panel Report Published May 2008 PDF
Revised Background Review Documents and ICCVAM Recommendations Published March 2009 HTML
Second Peer Review Panel Meeting April 2009 HTML

Back to top

Ocular Toxicity

In Vitro Test Methods for Detecting Ocular Corrosives and Severe Irritants

  • Bovine Corneal Opacity and Permeability Test Method
  • Isolated Chicken Eye Test Method
  • Isolated Rabbit Eye Test Method
  • Hen's Egg Test - Chorioallantoic Membrane Test Method

Ocular toxicity testing identifies substances that may cause permanent or temporary blindness. Use of these in vitro test methods will reduce and refine animal use for this purpose.

Milestone Date Document Link or
More Information
EPA Nomination October 2003 -
Expert Panel Meeting January 2005 HTML
Expert Panel Report March 2005 PDF
Expert Panel Teleconference September 2005 HTML
Expert Panel Report Addendum November 2005 PDF
Background Review Documents Published October 2007 HTML
Test Method Evaluation Report Published October 2007 HTML
Recommendations Made to Federal Agencies October 2007 HTML
Federal Agency Responses Received May 2008 HTML
Draft OECD Test Guidelines Submitted to U.S. National Coordinator August 2008 HTML


In Vitro Test Methods for Detecting Nonsevere Ocular Irritants

  • Bovine Corneal Opacity and Permeability Test Method
  • Isolated Chicken Eye Test Method
  • Isolated Rabbit Eye Test Method
  • Hen's Egg Test - Chorioallantoic Membrane Test Method

Ocular toxicity testing identifies substances that may cause irritation to the eye. Use of these In Vitro Test Methods will reduce and refine animal use for this purpose.

Milestone Date Document Link or
More Information
EPA Nomination October 2003 -
Peer Review Panel Meeting May 2009 HTML

Back to top

In Vitro Test Methods for Detecting Nonsevere Ocular Irritants

  • Cytosensor Microphysiometer Test Method
  • Fluorescein Leakage Test Method
  • Neutral Red Release Test Method
  • Red Blood Cell Haemolysis Test Method

Ocular toxicity testing identifies substances that may cause irritation to the eye. Use of these In Vitro Test Methods will reduce and refine animal use for this purpose.

Milestone Date Document Link or
More Information
ICCVAM Working Group Comment on Background Review Documents submitted the European Committee for the Validation of Alternative Methods July 2008 -


Nonanimal Assessment Approach for Evaluating Eye Irritation Potential of Antimicrobial Cleaning Products

Ocular toxicity testing identifies substances that may cause irritation to the eye. Use of this in vitro approach could replace animal use for this purpose to meet EPA labeling requirements.

Milestone Date Document Link or
More Information
Submission by IIVS January 2008 PDF
Peer Review Panel Meeting May 2009 HTML

Back to top

Pyrogenicity

In Vitro Pyrogen Test Methods

  • The Human Whole Blood/IL-1 In Vitro Pyrogen Test
  • The Human Whole Blood/ IL-1 In Vitro Pyrogen Test Using Cryopreserved Human Whole Blood
  • The Human Whole Blood/IL-6 In Vitro Pyrogen Test (WB/IL-6)
  • In Vitro Pyrogen Test Using Human Peripheral Blood Mononuclear Cells (PBMC/IL-6)
  • An Alternative In Vitro Pyrogen Test Using the Human Monocytoid Cell Line MONO MAC 6 (MM6/IL-6)

Pyrogenicity testing is performed on products to be administered by injection to ensure that each lot of these products is free of substances that could induce a dangerous fever reaction. Use of these in vitro tests could replace animal use for this purpose.

Milestone Date Document Link or
More Information
Submission by ECVAM June 2005 PDF
Peer Review Panel Meeting February 2007 HTML
Peer Review Panel Report Published April 2007 PDF
Background Review Document Published October 2008 HTML
Test Method Evaluation Report Published October 2008 HTML
Recommendations to Federal Agencies November 2008 HTML



  Back to Top NICEATM-ICCVAM:
Advancing Public Health and Animal Welfare