HOT TOPICS >> New survey • Spring will come • Raw milk • Global warming? • Plant potatoes

Ask Our Experts > Green Transportation

Although you might think it’s easier on your car to let it sit and gently warm up, doing so is a bad idea for a number of reasons. Most importantly, it does indeed waste gas.

The vast majority of cars on the road today use electronic fuel injection. When your car’s engine is cold, the computer tells the fuel injectors to stay open longer, allowing more fuel into the engine to help it run cold. As the engine warms up, the injectors let in less fuel and everything returns to normal, so to speak. 

The problem is, letting your car sit and idle is the slowest way to bring it up to operating temperature because it’s generally sitting in your drive at just above idle speed. And this method to warm up also invites other problems. Remember that modern cars are equipped with a multitude of devices to help them run clean, including a catalytic converter (sometimes three of them), a device in the exhaust system that works to burn off unburned hydrocarbons in the exhaust stream. A cold engine emits a far higher percentage of unburned hydrocarbons than a warm engine. Unfortunately, the average catalytic converter can’t process 100 percent of unburned hydrocarbons even in the best of times. Importantly, the catalytic converter needs high exhaust temperatures to work properly. Throw in a cold engine emitting a high percentage of unburned hydrocarbons, repeat several hundred times, and you can end up with what’s called a “plugged” converter. In a nutshell, the converter becomes overwhelmed and literally ceases to function. This won’t happen all at once but over time, the end effect is the same: poor mileage and significantly dirtier exhaust.

The best bet? Even when it’s 10 degrees F outside, start your car, let it run for 30 to 60 seconds to get all the fluids moving, then drive off gently. Your engine will warm up faster, your exhaust system will get up to temperature faster so the catalytic converter can do its thing, and you’ll use less fuel. Which is what you wanted all along anyhow, right?

If it's below zero outside, it would be a good idea to give the engine five minutes or a little less before you drive off into the frozen wilderness!

— Richard Backus, editor in chief, Gas Engine and Motorcycle Classics magazines

15 Comments

  • FeralFemale 2/1/2009 2:03:22 PM

    I live in NE Minnesota. When the temps get as low as they do here, you HAVE to let your car warm up, at least a minute or two, even with a headbolt heater. The fluids need to warm up.

  • Molly 1/31/2009 1:40:01 PM

    With a small child and an infant in the family. And having to get everyone up and out before the roads are plowed most mornings. I have to let my mid sized SUV warm to "operating temp" before heading out and putting the kids in the back seat. If it were just us adults and older kids, not a problem. But an infant in a sub zero vehicle isnt right

  • Jason 1/28/2009 10:08:31 PM

    I was thinking about my response after I left it, and decided I should clarify. People might think that I mean letting the car warm up to operating temp. I didn't mean that. Personally, I give the car about 2-3 minutes of idling to warm up. The idea isn't to waste gas, or to have a warm car when you get out there in the morning, but to give your beloved automobile a chance to get some major miles on her without a rebuild. I've got nearly a quarter of a million miles on my car with no engine problems yet (knock wood). As I stated before, ask your mechanic if you want a second opinion.

  • MSturr 1/24/2009 12:04:32 PM

    Bags on the mirrors is a great idea!
    A number of trucks and cars have an option for an engine block-heater. (My SAAB does, and had one installed decade(s) ago on a VW Scirocco in Massachuttes from a diesel Rabbit kit, but I digress)
    Various heaters available, but be warned that there are some cheap junky ones also. One (good) variation heats the water in the engine block. Advanced units have built-in thermostats and timers, which are used on industrial diesels.
    Note that the oil will still be cold, as is in the oil-pan hanging down in the cold! So drive easy also. Use synthetic oil rather than conventional, as does not jello in the cold- drawbacks?-can't be a cheapskate and will need to fork over an extra 3 or 4 bucks a quart, i.e. approx. $20 extra per oil change, but well worth it as Jason points out engine wear rebuild costs!
    There are some oil-heaters, including some dip-stick variations, but be cautious about poorly-designed units burning the oil!

  • Jason 1/21/2009 3:57:27 PM

    I'll throw my two cents in here from the car's point of view. It may waste more gas, but the cost in the long run is less to let the car warm up a bit before driving. Oil starvation during start-up in cold weather wears the engine parts down greatly. In cold weather (below freezing) oil is like Jello. It pumps very slowly, and takes time to warm up. Letting the engine idle to warm up keeps the RPMs low, thus reducing wear. This is the simple explanation, and no one has to believe me, get a second opinion from an honest mechanic... preferably when you're not in there for a premature engine overhaul.

  • Jason 1/21/2009 3:56:58 PM

    I'll throw my two cents in here from the car's point of view. It may waste more gas, but the cost in the long run is less to let the car warm up a bit before driving. Oil starvation during start-up in cold weather wears the engine parts down greatly. In cold weather (below freezing) oil is like Jello. It pumps very slowly, and takes time to warm up. Letting the engine idle to warm up keeps the RPMs low, thus reducing wear. This is the simple explanation, and no one has to believe me, get a second opinion from an honest mechanic... preferably when you're not in there for a premature engine overhaul.

  • Darwin 1/21/2009 10:08:00 AM

    Another suggestion for(at least)the windsheild....
    break a mediun to large cardboard box down to a very Large retangular shape....turn the wipers "on"...then turn off the engine..to leave the wiper blades engaged halfway up the windsheild...then prop the cardboard behind the blades
    WAH LAH!!...Windsheild is protectected from ICE and mounds
    of Snow...and can easily to removed...shaken OFF and used for another occasion. Now for the rear view side mirrors...take a plastic grocery bag and tightly wrap the rear view mirrors.....if iced over....there should be enough air in between the bag and the mirror to allow for You to manevuer the bag loose...and down the road you GO

  • amy 1/19/2009 12:03:17 PM

    My goodness, Doug Smith. Lay off. First of all, it was a question, not a statement. Also, not everyone has a garage, and the average scraper is practically useless against a frozen sheet of ice. Your temper makes YOU sound like an idiot.

  • Cabby 1/19/2009 8:10:12 AM

    When I lived in the Joplin, Missouri area we were more likely to get ice than snow, I learned that chipping an inch thick layer of ice off the windshield wasn't fun. I tried using a tarp as a cover, and that worked but was sometimes difficult to get loose if the ice was thick... now I use a mover's quilt I keep for that purpose for our occasional OK ice storms. If the ice is thick, you can tap it a bit to break it up, the quilt is thick enough to provide a flexible cushion layer between the ice and the windshield, to protect the glass from the impacts. I rarely have to hit it though, usually the quilt will come right off. Then lay the quilt in the bathtub or shower until it melts, and throw it in the dryer or hang it to dry inside. The only issue would be two icing events in succession, in which case I leave the quilt outside where it'll stay icy but a bit flexible. BTW, it works better if the quilt is Scotch-guarded, as it keeps most of the moisture out of the fabric.

  • Honey Phillips 1/18/2009 3:28:14 PM

    Re: Doug Smith's comments below

    Hey guy just a note on the whole ice on the windshield thing, Use a scraper duh!.
    Do us all a favor, don't post unless you know what you are talking about. You really look like an idiot. Not saying you are, but you sure look like one with that statement.

    I find them offensive and uncalled for in this type of publication. Who would want to ask and learn if experts like Doug will be answering!

  • John Rockhold 1/14/2009 10:35:54 AM

    Carmi -- great question. In the case of subzero temps, it would be better for the engine if you gave it about five minutes or a little less before you drive away. Just enough for all the fluids to really be moving. But don't feel like you have to let it sit longer than that. Stay warm!

  • Carmi Anderson 1/14/2009 10:03:31 AM

    In Minneapolis the standing temperature is -6°F today and could get down to -20. Is this still valid in subzero temps?

  • Carmi Anderson 1/14/2009 10:03:13 AM

    In Minneapolis the standing temperature is -6°F today and could get down to -20. Is this still valid in subzero temps?

  • Doug Smith 1/13/2009 11:03:51 AM

    Hey guy just a note on the whole ice on the windshield thing, Use a scraper duh!. Oh, or you could leave your car under cover like a , I don't know GARAGE!. A tarp draped over the window is easily removed and will protect against ice as well.

    Do us all a favor, don't post unless you know what you are talking about. You really look like an idiot. Not saying you are, but you sure look like one with that statement.

  • Brad Lovejoy 11/28/2008 9:43:45 AM

    What about removing ice from the windshield?

Add Your Comment

Line breaks and paragraphs are automatically converted — no need to use <p> or <br> tags.

New to Mother Earth News?
Sign up to share comments.
Asterisks(*) indicate required fields.
Name*
Your name appears next to your comment.

E-mail Address*
This will be your login ID.

City State Zip Code

Password*


Confirm Password*

Comments
(Offensive materials and/or spam will be removed, no HTML allowed)
Please Note: Your sign-up must be verified via e-mail before your comment is published.

Ask your question, get an answer:

Question:
Name:   
City: State:
Email: