[Technology 1072] Re: findings on evidence of improvement of literacy and language skills through technologynancy.friday at alphaplus.ca nancy.friday at alphaplus.caFri Jun 15 13:37:11 EDT 2007
Hi Everyone, Nancy Friday here from the AlphaPlus Centre in Toronto, Ontario, Canada. I have been reading this discussion all week, intending to respond, and now its Friday and I am going to make this happen! The AlphaPlus Centre is a provincial adult literacy resource centre providing resource, technology and information support to over 300 adult literacy sites across Ontario in the English, Native, Deaf and Francophone communities. As a direct result of significant funding changes particularly at the National level, AlphaPlus is engaged in a strategic planning process to re-position ourselves within the new adult education environment in Ontario. For over 10 years now we have managed and developed an online learning environment called AlphaRoute. You can learn more about AlphaRoute and try it out at: www.resources.alpharoute.org For the past 4 years we have been working with sites across Ontario to realize as much as possible true distance delivery of literacy skills development and opportunity. We have couched our practice in research and have produced research reports that speak to varying degrees depending on the report to the subject of this discussion this week. In 2000 I believe we received funding fromthe Office of Learning Technologies, a branch of Human Resources Development Canada, to explore the efficacy of online learning for adult literacy students. We grappled with how to approach the research question for a couple years during the time that the AlphaRoute Web-based learning environment was being used by literacy students in programs across Ontario. We decided to approach the research by asking literacy students who had used AlphaRoute for a period of time. 142 learners from 42 literacy programs across Ontario participated in a telephone survey. The questions asked if and how using AlphaRoute impacted on their reading and related literacy skills, did the use of AlphaRoute impact on their use of computers at home, use of email, use of the Internet, how has using AlphaRoute impacted on the way they learn and their motivation to continue, how important and what kinds of support are important and critical to online learning? Our report is called What difference does it make? - Literacy learner perspectives on Web-based learning with AlphaRoute (2003). Here's a link to the full report: http://alphaplus.ca/images/pdf/Whatdifferencedoesitmake.pdf The use of AlphaRoute as reflected in this report was as a supplement to onsite literacy learning and primarily but not exclusively, learners were accessing AlphaRoute using computers at their literacy program. So not a distance learning application at that time. In 2001 AlphaPlus partnered with an agency called Contact North in northern Ontario and two established adult literacy programs, one French and one English, to explore how and if AlphaRoute could be used to support distance delivery of literacy programming. Contact North provided computer access to adult literacy students in two communities that did not have literacy programs. The two literacy programs provided mentors to support the learning at a distance of literacy learners in the remote towns. AlphaRoute and supplemental learning software were used for learning content, learning management, and interactice communication between learners and mentors. This was a very small project. What we learned from it was that distance learning support was possible, that partnering to create the access path for students was necessary and workable, but that there were some missing pieces, significantly a way to do assessment at a distance was one missing piece. We also started to realize that distance learning wouldn't be more cost effecitve than onsite learning. Starting in 2003, AlphaPlus and four literacy programs across Ontario with significant funding from our national and provincial partners, managed a larger exploration of how literacy skill development can be offered at a distance. This effort was carried out as formal research, under the guidance of Dr. Paul Porter from Sonoma State University in California and Matthis Sturm from the AlphaPlus Centre. A report on the result of that research, called Crossing the Great Divides: Distance learning and flexible delivery in Adult Basic Education (2006) is availalbe at http://distance.alphaplus.ca I will ask Matthias to share what he has learned from this research that speaks to the efficacy of distance learning in adult literacy. And I'll stop for now. Nancy in Toronto "Silver-Pacuilla, Heidi" <HSilver-Pacuilla at air.org> on 06/13/2007 09:32:50 AM Please respond to The Technology and Literacy Discussion List <technology at nifl.gov> To: technology at nifl.gov cc: (bcc: Nancy Friday) Subject: [Technology 1055] findings on evidence of improvement of literacy and language skills through technology Hello everyone - here is another chunk of my data to share for member checking with you. Does this resonate? Can you share an example that confirms or challenges these findings? **My key question to the group is: What has been your experience with the lowest skilled students? Thanks! Heidi Silver-Pacuilla ++++++++++++ To recap, I am posting preliminary findings (and not my full methodology or bibliography since both are currently incomplete) from the published and posted literature on adult online literacy and language learning. I hope you find them validating or provocative (or both!) and can join in a lively discussion of what's actually happening in your school or program. This is the second of the three main areas I am sharing with the listserv: program implementation issues, evidence of improvements of basic literacy and language skills, and student skills and dispositions associated with successful technology-based and online learning. Here are some key findings from the review of studies reporting evidence of improvement of basic literacy and language skills: There is growing evidence that adult learners' work with computer-based or online materials that are supplemental to adult literacy and ESOL classes contributes positively to their overall literacy and language acquisition plus complementary learning skills. The evaluations reviewed were of supplemental materials available to students with some type of program support (on-site trained teacher or support person, support person available online, tech support available through the program, and/or automated feedback system in the program) and varying degrees of integration with the regular class curriculum. Importantly, the supplemental materials and online interfaces were either uniquely developed or chosen for adult literacy and language learners. Programs have documented successful use of these materials with all levels of students, including those with the lowest levels of literacy and English proficiency. Quantifying specific academic skills achievement is difficult to pinpoint, but several significant studies report learning gains attributable to the supplemental use of technology in instruction and practice. It must be acknowledged that there is still no "body of evidence" with repeated and comparable studies that can definitely answer questions about particular interventions used with particular literacy or language levels with predictable results. How do these findings correlate with your experience and knowledge? ---------------------------------------------------- National Institute for Literacy Technology and Literacy mailing list Technology at nifl.gov To unsubscribe or change your subscription settings, please go to http://www.nifl.gov/mailman/listinfo/technology Email delivered to nfriday at alphaplus.ca =========================================================== Nancy Friday AlphaRoute Coordinator AlphaPlus Centre (http://alphaplus.ca) Telephone: (416) 322-1012 x.305 Fax: 1-800-788-1417 TTY: 1-800-788-1912 nancy.friday at alphaplus.ca ============================================================
More information about the Technology mailing list |