![spacer](https://webarchive.library.unt.edu/eot2008/20090119072844im_/http://www.ehponline.org/siteimages/transpixel.gif)
| | ![spacer](https://webarchive.library.unt.edu/eot2008/20090119072844im_/http://www.ehponline.org/siteimages/transpixel.gif) | | ![spacer](https://webarchive.library.unt.edu/eot2008/20090119072844im_/http://www.ehponline.org/siteimages/transpixel.gif) |
Book Review | New Books
|
|
|
![spacer](https://webarchive.library.unt.edu/eot2008/20090119072844im_/http://www.ehponline.org/siteimages/transpixel.gif) |
Book Review
The Bhopal Saga: Causes and Consequences of the World's Largest Industrial Disaster
By Ingrid Eckerman
Hyderabad, India:Universities Press, 2005. 283 pp. ISBN: 81-7371-515-7. Rs250
After 20 years, victims, health care workers, and governments are still trying to comprehend what has been called the world's worst industrial accident. The Bhopal Saga is an attempt to bring order from the chaos of events before, during, and after the methyl isocyanate (MIC) release. Not a scientific analysis, the book summarizes events leading up to the accident of December 1984 and the relief work in the ensuing two decades.
![May book cover](maybookcov.jpg) | image: Arnold Greenwell/EHP |
Eckerman's primary strength is her on-scene experience as a member of the International Medical Commission on Bhopal. She describes comprehensively the long-term health effects documented in the exposed population and suggests what might be done to improve health care for the victims. The paucity of data on certain end points, notably women's reproductive health, childhood outcome, and cancer, is stressed. Also included is a summary of the positive and negative effects of various interim relief efforts on the population. Eckerman includes societal, economic, environmental, and political aspects that she considers imperative for integrated long-term health care.
The range of acute and chronic health effects in the exposed population is placed in terms of the toxicity of the probable major components of the gas cloud. Unfortunately, Eckerman relied on secondary sources for this information, although the database for most of the individual chemicals is robust and contains controlled experiments in both humans and animals. The primary literature would have informed her that beyond contact irritation, toxicity of the isocyanates varies widely. For example, MIC is not a sensitizer and causes systemic toxicity, whereas other isocyanates are potent sensitizers and local irritants only.
Nevertheless, the acute symptoms, delayed pulmonary effects, and chronic health problems are otherwise well correlated in the context of the known toxicities of the chemicals discussed. Both Union Carbide Corporation and the state and national Indian governments may deserve the constant accusations aimed at them in The Bhopal Saga, but this is almost a distraction. The known safety violations at the plant, the lack of education and training of workers, and the documented incidents of noncompliance before the leak speak for themselves; Eckerman even refers to the accident as a "massacre" or the "killings" in several places. The belief that Union Carbide is withholding data, especially the composition of the gas cloud, is speculation on her part. Current efforts by researchers in the United States to recreate the chemical reaction may soon answer the question of component gases. Although the issue is still debated in the medical community, Eckerman firmly believes that sodium thiosulfate should have been widely used as an antidote for the exposed victims: Eckerman concludes that sodium thiosulfate must have been necessary, not because of patient presentation, but because Union Carbide withdrew the initial recommendation for use of the cyanide antidote. Although it is probable that hydrogen cyanide was generated in the chemical reaction and was present in the gas cloud, cyanide has not been shown to be a breakdown product of MIC in human or animal systems. It is impossible to judge whether Union Carbide was basing its treatment recommendation on toxicity data or for some other reason.
A list of other accidents at Union Carbide plants worldwide contains a mistake (Table 10, p. 267). Large quantities of mercury were used in the 1950s and 1960s at a U.S. Department of Energy facility that was managed at the time by Union Carbide's Nuclear Division. Eckerman incorrectly states that half of the workers involved were killed, when in fact no adverse health effects have been found. In addition, effects of released mercury on the environment and surrounding communities have been studied extensively.
Eckerman's biases against industry and government can be forgiven when compensation was delayed for years, a reliable health care infrastructure is still not in place, environmental laws are not enforced, and worker safety appears compromised by lapses in oversight. Unfortunately, Eckerman offers no new solutions to the human rights issues specific to the Bhopal tragedy or to the world population in general.
Carol S. Wood
Carol S. Wood is a toxicologist in the Life Sciences Division at Oak Ridge National Laboratory, Oak Ridge, Tennessee. She wrote the technical support documents on MIC and toluene diisocyanate for the National Advisory Committee on Acute Exposure Guideline Levels, which have been published by the National Academy Press. She also analyzes developmental, reproductive, and neurotoxicity data on a wide variety of pesticides.
New Books
-
An Introduction to Human Molecular Genetics: Mechanisms of Inherited Diseases, 2nd ed.
Jack K. Pasternak
Hoboken, NJ:John Wiley & Sons, 2005. 656 pp. ISBN: 0-471-47426-6, $83.95
-
CCN Proteins: A New Family of Cell Growth and Differentiation Regulators
Bernard Perbal, Masaharu Takigawa
Hackensack, NJ:World Scientific Publishing, 2005. 250 pp. ISBN: 1-86094-552-X, $80
-
Computation in Cells and Tissues: Perspectives and Tools of Thought
R. Paton, H. Bolouri, M. Holcombe, J.H. Parish, R. Tateson, eds.
New York:Springer-Verlag, 2004. 343 pp. ISBN: 3-540-00358-4, $69.95
-
Data Analysis and Visualization in Genomics and Proteomics
Francisco Azuaje, Joaquin Dopazo, eds.
Hoboken, NJ:John Wiley & Sons, 2005. 284 pp. ISBN: 0-470-09439-7, $150
-
Energy in the 21st Century
John R. Fanchi
Hackensack, NJ:World Scientific Publishing, 2005. 256 pp. ISBN: 981-256-185-4, $52
-
Environmental Economics for Non-Economists: Techniques and Policies for Sustainable Development, 2nd ed.
John Asafu-Adjaye
Hackensack, NJ:World Scientific Publishing, 2005. 392 pp. ISBN: 981-256-123-4, $58
-
Evolution in Four Dimensions: Genetic, Epigenetic, Behavioral, and Symbolic Variation in the History of Life
Eva Jablonka, Marion J. Lamb
Cambridge, MA:MIT Press, 2005. 472 pp. ISBN: 0-262-10107-6, $34.95
-
Implications of Nanotechnology for Environmental Health Research
Lynn Goldman, Christine Coussens, eds.
Washington, DC:National Academies Press, 2005. 70 pp. ISBN: 0-309-09577-8, $18
-
Intelligent Bioinformatics: The Application of Artificial Intelligence Techniques to Bioinformatics Problems
Edward Keedwell, Ajit Narayanan
Hoboken, NJ:John Wiley & Sons, 2005. 256 pp. ISBN: 0-470-02175-6, $110
-
Medical Biomethods Handbook
John M. Walker, Ralph Rapley
Totowa, NJ:Humana Press, 2005. 656 pp. ISBN: 1-58829-288-6, $150
-
Molecular and Cellular Signaling
Martin Beckerman
New York:Springer-Verlag, 2005. 450 pp. ISBN: 0-387-22130-1, $99
-
Molecular Models of Life: Philosophical Papers on Molecular Biology
Sahotra Sarkar
Cambridge, MA:MIT Press, 2005. 352 pp. ISBN: 0-262-19512-7, $38
-
Mouse Phenotypes: A Handbook of Mutation Analysis
Virginia E. Papaioannou
Woodbury, NY:Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory Press, 2005. 235 pp. ISBN: 0-87969-640-0, $80
-
Protein Nanotechnology: Protocols, Instrumentation, and Applications
Tuan Vo-Dinh
Totowa, NJ:Humana Press, 2005. 480 pp. ISBN: 1-58829-310-6, $115
-
Selective Sweep
Dmitry Nurminsky
New York:Springer-Verlag, 2005. 130 pp. ISBN: 0-306-48235-5, $129
-
The Global Genome: Biotechnology, Politics, and Culture
Eugene Thacker
Cambridge, MA:MIT Press, 2005. 464 pp. ISBN: 0-262-20155-0, $39.95
-
The Inside Story: DNA to RNA to Protein
Jan Witkowski, ed.
Woodbury, NY:Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory Press, 2005. 220 pp. ISBN: 0-87969-750-4, $45
-
The Proteomics Protocols Handbook
John M. Walker
Totowa, NJ:Humana Press, 2005. 1,016 pp. ISBN: 1-58829-343-2, $175
-
XML for Bioinformatics
Ethan Cerami
New York:Springer-Verlag, 2005. 304 pp. ISBN: 0-387-23028-9, $69.95
|
|
![spacer](https://webarchive.library.unt.edu/eot2008/20090119072844im_/http://www.ehponline.org/siteimages/transpixel.gif) |
|
| |