Opening Statement
Ranking Member Dan Burton
Subcommittee on the Western Hemisphere
Committee on Foreign Affairs
June 11th, 2008
The New Challenge: China
in the Western Hemisphere
To begin, I would like to
thank the Chairman for holding today’s hearing on the complex issue of China’s ambitions within the Western
Hemisphere. I look forward to discussing the influence of those
ambitions on U.S.
strategic interests as well as the growing impact on our neighbors.
I chaired a hearing on this
topic back in April of 2005, and it seems to me that many of the same concerns
are still valid today. The foreign and military relations China is
pursuing around the globe are still very troubling in nature. China continues to further ties with Iran, supports the brutal military rulers of Burma and has become the largest weapons supplier
to the government of Sudan.
It appears that China
is more than willing to turn a blind eye to these brutal regimes in order to
feed its ravenous energy appetite.
China’s aggressive move into our Hemisphere has proven to
be equally as blind. This purely
economic motive pursued by China
has resulted in the deepening of relations with rogue states such as Cuba and Venezuela. China is appealing to the developing world as an
alternative model for ending poverty, and Latin America
is eating it up as the region has seen billions of dollars of Chinese money
earmarked for infrastructure, transport, energy and defense projects.
The countries that make up
the Western Hemisphere continue to face considerable
challenges to their still maturing democracies. Persistent poverty, violent
guerrilla conflicts, drug trafficking, corruption, terrorist infiltration and
non-democratic leaders flush with petro dollars are making it difficult for
many in the region to fully embrace and develop strong democracies.
Countries where transparency,
accountability and strong institutional structures are still developing provide
fertile ground for Beijing’s agenda and China’s leaders
are definitely exploiting this opening.
Latin America is an
attractive destination for China
due to its rich mineral resources, commodities and particularly energy sources.
As the second-largest consumer of oil, China
is a leading competitor of the United
States in the search for oil, gas and
minerals across the globe.
According to statistics
released in
April of this year by the China Petroleum
and Chemical Industry Association (CPCIA), China's consumption of oil products
composed of gasoline, diesel and kerosene has risen by 16.5 percent to 52.73
million tons in the first three months, and crude oil, rose by 8 percent
to 91.8 million tons. These numbers show unprecedented growth in the first
quarter of 2008.
As we all know, oil is a
finite resource and the competition to exploit it is a zero-sum game. The more global oil the Chinese gobble up,
the less oil available to flow into American power plants, commercial trucks
and home heating systems. Given that we are unable to use the oil resources
within our own country- which in my opinion is a huge mistake- our future
progress and security relies on access to oil in outside countries.
Recent developments are compounding these concerns that I have addressed in
the past. First, China’s
growing influence can be seen in the shift away from support for Taiwan that is being fueled through China’s “dollar
diplomacy”. Three countries (Dominica, Grenada
and Costa Rica) shifted
their allegiance since 2004, and if the President Elect of Paraguay follows
through with his promises, the last South American country with ties to Taiwan may
shift as well.
Second, I have strongly promoted free trade agreements with our allies in Latin America in an effort to secure long term trade and
investment among our countries. If we do not pursue these markets they will be
lost to a country that cares little for the well-being of our hemisphere in
favor of the communist model of success. The failure to pass the U.S.-Colombia
FTA provides an open door for China’s
encroaching influence and is a direct threat to our national security.
Third, China is also exerting itself into the
Hemisphere through the Manta Airbase located in Ecuador that has served as a U.S.
Military Forward Operating Location for 10 years. In 2006 alone aircrews flew
more than 1,200 missions from Manta and helped seize more than 258 tons of
illegal drugs with an estimated street value of $5.2 billion. China’s take
over of this airbase is a huge blow to the regional efforts to fight drugs as
the Chinese will most likely use the renovated airbase for cargo transit in
trade and not to fight the detrimental trafficking of drugs throughout the
region. This new agreement between Ecuador
and China, if it moves
forward as planned in 2009 when the U.S. contract expires, will also work
to secure Chinese capital for fulfilling Manta's
future role as one of the largest Sino-Latin American trade trans-shipment hubs.
Finally, the trade
imbalance and poor business practices that follow China’s
investment in a region continue to be a growing area of concern for Latin America. The
United States has the most
dynamic and powerful economy in the world and yet even our economy and
industries are being staggered by the massive trade imbalance with China. It is
not hard to imagine the impact this unlevel playing field, as well as the long
term costs of poor business practices on developing economies, is having on the
economies of smaller countries in Latin America.
As you can tell, I am very concerned with the rise of
influence China is pursuing
in our Hemisphere and I believe it is important that the United States grasps the economic, social and
national security implications of a Latin America under the thumb of China. Once China is able
to move in and expand control, it will be difficult to turn the tide.
I look forward to hearing from our distinguished
panelists on these and other topics China’s
interest and growing influence in Latin America.