Theft Notices & Recoveries
Recoveries - Civil War Battlefield Flag

In January of 1999, the FBI arrested a man trying to sell a very rare Civil War relic -- a flag carried into battle by the 12th Regiment Corps d'Afrique, one of the first black Army units formed during the Civil War.In February, during a ceremony at FBIHQ, Director Louis Freeh returned the flag to U.S. Army officials. During the ceremony, he remarked that "there are two ways to steal history: one is to steal a valuable artifact -- a regimental flag which represents so much bravery and sacrifice; the other is not to teach or write about it in a manner that is noteworthy and memorable."

Photograph of Ceremony
Lieutenant General John Dubia, Director of the Army Staff, accepting the return of the 12th Regiment Corps d'Afrique Civil War B
attle flag from FBI Director Louis J. Freeh.

Photograph of Ceremony
Director Freeh with Civil War reenactor and retired Army Sergeant Major Joseph Lee with recovered battle flag.

How it all began

New Orleans, Louisiana, 1861 - The Louisiana Native Guard was formed by free black men who wanted to defend the city of New Orleans during the Civil War. Initially organized to fight for the South, once the North captured New Orleans, the Native Guard was incorporated into the Union Army in 1862 and renamed the Corps d'Afrique. Former slaves also joined its ranks. The flag was obtained for the regiment at this time. Flags were extremely important because they were used to "dress" the lines, allowing opposing forces to know where the battle lines were drawn. They became symbols of pride to their regimental units. 

In October 1998, Les Jenson, a curator at the Army Center of Military History, Washington, D.C., got in touch with the FBI, advising that he had recently been contacted by a dealer who was approached by Charles Wilhite, an antique military collectible dealer from Kansas. Wilhite told the dealer he had a 12th Regiment Corps d'Afrique battle flag for sale. Jenson knew the man could be telling the truth: that flag had been discovered missing by the Army sometime in 1975 or 1976. The flag, previously on display at West Point, had been placed into the collection of the Army Historical Property Section in 1963.

The Special Agent initiated an undercover operation posing as a Civil War artifacts dealer in an attempt to recover the flag.

The first use of Black troops took place along the Mississippi River. Two fortified cities enabled the Confederacy to maintain control of 200 miles of river. Vicksburg to the North and Port Hudson to the South.... These strategic cities had to fall in order for the Union to control the Mississippi River and split the Confederacy in two. The first chance for the Corps d'Afrique units to fight came at Port Hudson, Louisiana.

<Vicksburg National Military Park website>

The operation advances

Port Hudson, May 26, 1863 - "I have just had a stirring hour, occasioned by the arrival of the black infantry, one thousand strong, who halted in our midst and attracted much attention. I was interested to see how my men would regard such neighbors and was glad to see there was not much merriment and no contempt...."

<Diary of William Logan Rodman, Infantry>

The Bureau worked the case in conjunction with the Army Criminal Investigative Division. In November, undercover FBI Agents traveled to a Civil War collectibles show in Richmond, Virginia, hoping to learn more about Mr. Wilhite. And they did: one relic dealer told the two Agents that he too had been contacted by Charles Wilhite a couple of months earlier about the battle flag, but he declined to purchase the flag when told there were some ownership "problems."

Port Hudson, May 27, 1863 - The day of reckoning had arrived. Gripping the unfurled banner was Color Sgt. Anselino Planciancois with the order to "protect, defend, die for, but do not surrender these flags." Sgt. Planciancois responded, "Colonel, I will bring these colors to you with honor or report to God the reason why." 

<Vicksburg National Military Park website>

In December 1998, posing as a dealer, an FBI Agent called Wilhite and asked him if the flag was still for sale. Wilhite said "yes," confessed there were some ownership problems with the flag, but he wouldn't go into any more detail over the phone. He told the agent if he wanted to see the flag he'd have to come to Kansas.

Several weeks later, the agent called Wilhite again. This time, Wilhite was more talkative. He admitted the flag had been stolen, and he warned the Agent that the flag should go into a private collection. He offered it for the bargain basement price of $20,000 (claiming he could get $40,000 or more on the open market).

The victory

Port Hudson, May 27, 1863 - The bugle sounded "Charge!" The Confederate rifle pits and batteries opened fire with everything they had.... Black soldiers wavered, halted, then rushed for cover only to reform and again advance...The Color Sergeant was decapitated and fell still clutching the banner. Six men died for the honor of carrying the flags. 

<Vicksburg National Military Park website>

Arrangements were made for Wilhite to sell the flag to the undercover Agent for $28,000. On January 11, 1999, upon presentation of the flag to the Agent, Wilhite was immediately placed under arrest.

Wilhite was charged with Interstate Transportation of Stolen Property and Theft of Major Artwork.

Port Hudson, July 8, 1883 - Port Hudson surrenders to the Union.