StartSMART: Evaluation of a Middle School Tobacco Prevention Program

Text version of PowerPoint Presentation [Download PPT file]

Slide # Title & Content
1 StartSMART:
Evaluation of a Middle School
Tobacco Prevention Program

NIDA Grant Number: 5 R44DAO16465-03

October 26, 2006

(image: DANYA International, Inc. logo, HHS and NIH logos)

2 Danya International, Inc.

  • Founded in 1996 by Dr. Jeffrey Hoffman
  • Guiding values: Integrity, Quality, and Creativity
  • A customer-focused, technology-enabled company
  • Offices in Silver Spring, MD, and Atlanta, GA
  • Extensive experience with SBIRs and product development
3 Sample of Danya Products

(image: photos of Danya products)

4 Objectives

  • Need for Prevention
    • Purpose of Study
    • National Education Guideline Recommendations
  • Components of StartSMART Program
    • Curriculum
    • Session Descriptions
    • Student Advertisements
  • Outcome Evaluation
    • Eligibility Requirements
    • Methods
    • Preliminary Results
    • Limitations
  • Next Steps
5 Need for Prevention

  • Tobacco use remains the leading cause of premature death in the United States
  • New data suggests that progress is slowing down
  • Rate of decline in 30-day smoking rates is slowing
  • Exposure to and effectiveness of anti-smoking ads is decreasing
  • State funding down
6 Purpose of the Study

  • StartSMART program acts as a mechanism to reduce tobacco use among youth 11 to 13 years of age by engaging the involvement of students, teachers, administrators, and parents.
  • The program allows students to observe anti-tobacco messages, learn the skills to both identify and resist tobacco use, and participate in delivering prevention messages to their peers.
7 National Education Guideline Recommendations

  1. Develop and enforce a school policy on tobacco use
  2. Provide health education about short- and long-term consequences of tobacco use
  3. Provide tobacco prevention programs across all school years (K-12)
  4. Provide program-specific training for teachers
  5. Involve parents and families to support school programs
  6. Support cessation efforts for both youth and staff
  7. Evaluate prevention programs
8 Components of StartSMART

  • The Facilitator's Curriculum
  • The Youth Workbook
  • Prevention Video
  • Training Package:
    • Facilitator's Training Video
    • One-Day Training Option
    • Teacher's Training Notes
  • Parent Support
  • Booster Sessions
  • Support Web site

(image: StartSMART logo)

9 StartSMART Curriculum

  • Session 1: Influence of Big Tobacco
  • Session 2: Environmental Influences of Smoking
  • Session 3: Smoking Misperceptions
  • Session 4: Short- and Long-Term Consequences of Smoking
  • Session 5: Resisting Tobacco Use
  • Session 6: What's Your Idea?
  • Session 7: Time, Talent, Tools
  • Session 8: Lights, Camera, Action

(image: cover of StartSMART Youth Workbook)

10 Session 1: Influence of Big Tobacco
Treasure Hunt

  • Identify anti-tobacco and pro-tobacco messages
  • Homework activity
  • Family involvement

(image: picture of city street with logos everywhere)

11 Session 1: Influence of Big Tobacco
Slick Tricks

Glamour, sophistication
Humor, fun
Lies, trickery
Celebrity, stardom

(image: Session 1 worksheet)

12 Session 1: Influence of Big Tobacco
Video Segment – Tobacco: Take One!

  • Deconstruct the ad
  • Examples of pro-tobacco advertisements
  • Tobacco industry's role

(image: Session 1 worksheet)

13 Session 1: Influence of Big Tobacco
Video Segment – Tobacco: Take One!

(image: video)

14 Session 1: Influence of Big Tobacco
That's a Wrap!

  • Recap of session's main points
  • Confirm that students understand concepts
  • Repeats at end of every session

(image: Session 1 worksheet)

15 Session 4: Short- and Long-Term
Consequences of Smoking
Smoking and Addiction

  • Why do people continue to smoke even though they know it's unhealthy to do so?
  • Video Game Example

(image: drawing of kid playing video game)

16 Session 5: Resisting Tobacco Use
Tobacco IQ Game

Interactive Game (recap of the first four sessions):

  • Wordshark
  • Scientist
  • Actor
  • Artist

(image: game cards of people mentioned above)

17 Session 6: What's Your Idea
Creating Storyboards

(image: storyboards)

18 Sessions 7 and 8

(image: StartSMART materials)

19 Student Anti-Tobacco Advertisements

  • Saving your child —The impact of a smoking mother on her asthmatic son's health.
  • Winded — What happens when two boys, one smoker and one nonsmoker, challenge each other to a race?
  • It's all about choice — A young person's decision whether to spend his money on cigarettes or other goods.
  • Why smoking, why not? — Peer influence on teenage girls and the results of their decisions.
  • We told him so! — The effect of a teenage boy's decision to smoke.
  • Who do you want to be? — Two girls, one homely, sickly, and smoking, the other healthy, popular, and smoke-free, sit uncomfortably beside each other on a park bench.
  • Fun times gone bad — A slumber party quickly takes a turn for the worse after the partiers become ill from smoking.
  • Don't be a stupid girl — A womanizing lad tries to entice a group of girls to smoke, but is left hanging after the girls realize it's not their cup of tea.
  • They know — A simple yet chilling message on the true intentions of the tobacco industry.
  • It's not worth it — A boy will do everything to please his new love — everything, that is, except to buy her a pack of cigarettes.
  • No thanks — Hip teens instruct viewers to say "No thanks" to peers and the entertainment industry who try to coax them into smoking.
20 "Who do you want to be?"

(image: photo of someone sleeping outdoors)

21 "They know"

(image: video)

22 "No thanks"

(image: video)

23 Outcome Evaluation

  • Randomized control trial (189 enrolled)
  • Seven schools recruited from Washington, D.C., area
  • Data collected at four points in the evaluation: baseline, 8 weeks, and follow-up at 1 month and 6 months
  • Treatment group attended 8-session program
24 Eligibility Requirements

  • Enrolled in 6th or 7th grade
  • Cannot be participating in other tobacco prevention or cessation programs
  • Able and willing to attend all sessions
  • Able and willing to provide physiological measures (saliva, breath)
25 Data Collection Methods

  • Knowledge
  • Stages of change:
    • Non-smokers
    • Smokers
  • Susceptibility and intentions
  • Attitudes toward smoking
  • Physiological measures
26 Baseline Demographics and Smoking History

Participants

  • 15 female middle school students (subsample)
  • Mean age: 12.3 ± 0.5 years
  • 73% Caucasian
  • 33% reported having at least one parent currently smoking
  • None of the children reported trying cigarettes
  • None of the children reported having siblings or friends who smoked cigarettes
27 Preliminary Results
End of Treatment Analyses for Treatment Group

  • None of the students reported trying smoking
  • Youth improved their scores on the knowledge questionnaire from 8.5 to 9.9 correct answers out of 13 (p < .05)
  • The improvement was largely due to 27%-40% more students getting questions right about how cigarette companies advertise, limitations on counter-marketing ads, and the effects of nicotine (questions 4, 6, and 10; p < .05)
28 Preliminary Results
End of Treatment Analyses for Treatment Group

  • Participants in the StartSMART group reported that activities were helpful (average rating of activities: 3.0)
  • The only activity that was not rated above the midpoint was homework, which was rated at 2.2 on a 5-point scale, with 1 being "not very helpful or not fun" and 5 being "very helpful or a lot of fun"
  • Of the other activities, the treasure hunt and developing a counter-marketing ad were reported as being the most helpful
29 Preliminary Results
Importance of StartSMART Exercises

(image: bar graph titled "Preliminary Results, Importance of StartSMART Exercises")

30 Preliminary Results
Importance of StartSMART Exercises

(image: bar graph titled "Preliminary Results, Importance of StartSMART Exercises")

31 Limitations

  • Recruitment
  • Small subsample
  • Biochemical verification not evaluated
32 Next Steps

  • Complete outcome evaluation
  • Facilitator training
  • Booster sessions
  • Parent support
  • Support Web site
33 Danya Project Team

  • Henry Wong, Ph.D. — Principal Investigator
  • Susanna Nemes, Ph.D. — Co-Principal Investigator
  • Jeffrey Hoffman, Ph.D. — Corporate Monitor
  • Sharon Zack, MS — Project Director
  • Kelly Munly, MS — Co-Project Director
  • Jenn Weil — Senior Research Associate
  • Jennifer Jones — Research Associate
  • Jeff Owczarazk — Graphic Designer
  • Emily Glaeser — Technology Project Director
  • Suzanne Willis — Editor
  • Kathleen Cooke — Quality Assurance
34 Thank you!

(image: StartSMART logo)

View list of available presentations