Helping Students Make Better Food Choices in School

Text version of PowerPoint Presentation [Download PPT file]

Slide # Title & Content
1 Helping Students Make Better Food Choices in School

Alicia Moag-Stahlberg, MS, RD
Executive Director

October 26, 2006

(image: photos of kids in upper left and lower right corners; Action for Healthy Kids logo)

2 Overview

  • Background
  • Project goals
  • Methods
  • Results
  • Summary

(image: photo of girl eating school lunch)

3 What Kids Are Not Eating

*Consumption data from NHANES 2001-2002

(image: bar graph titled "What Kids Are Not Eating")

4 Translating Guidelines Into Action

  • Adequate nutrients within calorie needs
  • Weight management
  • Physical activity
  • Food Groups to Encourage – special nutrients of concern for children
    • Calcium
    • Potassium
    • Magnesium
    • Vitamin E
    • Fiber

(image: cover of Dietary Guidelines for Americans 2005)

5 Making Better Food Choices

  • Pilot projects 2004-2005 school year with dozen Chicago-area schools
  • Key Findings - Recommendations
    • Involve Students
    • Tastings and Promotions Get Attention
    • Information is Powerful
    • Support and Collaboration are Necessary
    • Packaging Counts
    • Price Advantage for Healthy Options
    • Be Consistent and Comprehensive
    • OK to Imitate
6 Project Goals – Phase II

  • Test simple promotional strategies to increase awareness and consumption of Food Groups to Encourage
    • Low Fat Dairy, Fruit/Vegetables, Whole Grains
  • Develop practical student/school evaluation methods
  • Based on findings, develop model approach for schools to utilize as a component of Wellness Policy implementation
    • Increase selection of key food groups
    • Increase student choice and consumption
    • Increase exposure to nutrition information; provide supplement to classroom nutrition education
7 Participating Schools - Students

  • Evanston High School (urban)
    • 3200 students
    • 48% Caucasian, 39% African American, 9% Hispanic, 2% Pacific Islander/Asian
    • 32% enrolled free/reduced school meal
  • Quincy High School (rural)
    • 1726 students
    • 89% Caucasian, 9% African American, 1% Hispanic, 1% Pacific Islander/Asian
    • 28% enrolled free/reduced school meal
8 Participating Schools - Students

  • Baldwin Intermediate School (rural, Quincy)
    • 1468 students
    • 88% Caucasian, 10% African American, 1% Hispanic, 1% Pacific Islander/Asian
    • 55% enrolled free/reduced school meal
  • Thomas & South Middle School (suburban, Arlington Heights)
    • 1700 students total in both schools
    • 90% Caucasian, 4% African American, 2% Hispanic, 5% Pacific Islander/Asian
    • 7% enrolled free/reduced school meal
9 Promotion Design

  • Nutrition promotion timing for each food group was one month long
  • Design criteria included: cost effective, not-duplicative, complement school context, easy to administer
  • Utilize Ag in Classroom materials and other USDA materials
  • Target audiences for materials included food service professionals, students, teachers, and parents
  • Utilize variety of communication vehicles and locations throughout school:
    • Morning announcement
    • Homeroom
    • Parent newsletter/menu
    • Posters in bathrooms, cafeteria, nurse office, halls
    • Cafeteria
    • Promotions included
      • Taste tests
      • Balloons, music, signage
      • Point of choice nutrient information
10 Assessment

  • What aspects of the promotion did students notice, like the most?
  • Did student's make better food choices during the promotion?
  • Are student's likely to continue choosing food groups highlighted?
  • Did student's report a willingness to select the food group outside of school?
  • Did food service professionals note differences in product utilization/selection?
  • Would food service be willing to conduct promotions in the future?

(image: photo of girl jumping off chair)

11 Focus Group Findings

  • Formative information and immediate learnings
    • After each promotion one group completed
    • 15 focus groups total; 214 students total
  • 83% of students were aware of promotions
  • Promotional items noticed/liked most included
    • Taste testing most memorable/liked
    • Balloons, music
    • Posters
  • Majority of :
    • Students understood the purpose of promotion
    • Middle school students reported trying food groups/products being highlighted
    • Students that did try new product/food, they did like it
  • More of the school students reported NOT trying food group or product being highlighted
12 Quantitative Survey Findings

  • Total of 353 students completed survey
    • 57% female and 43% male
    • 62% middle school and 38% high school
  • 93% of students were aware of promotions throughout the school year; 41% remembered all promotions similarly, 36% remembered fruit/vegetable (completed previous month) and 15% remembered dairy the most (done at start of school year)
  • Promotional items most memorable/effective
    • Taste tests 83%
    • Posters 68%
    • Balloons 45%
    • Hand outs/announcements 28%
13 Learned Why Important For Me

(image: bar graph illustrating students responses to whether they learned why dairy, grains, and vegetables are important)

14 I Eat More In Cafeteria

Since promotion, I eat more _____ product in cafeteria

(image: bar graph titled "I Eat More In Cafeteria")

15 I Eat More At Home, Other Places

Since promotion, I eat more at home and in other places

(image: bar graph titled "I Eat More At Home, Other Places")

16 In Future, Will Eat More

In the future, I plan to eat more

(image: bar graph titled "In Future, Will Eat More")

17 Knowledge of Servings Needed

  • 63% correctly named number of servings from Dairy food group needed each day
  • 40% correctly named the number of servings from Grain food group needed each day
  • Less than 30% could correctly name the number of servings needed from Fruit or Vegetable food groups

18 Summary

  • Promoting nutrition and healthful food items is very necessary – hard to compete with current practices
  • Does not replace need for nutrition and health education – supplements classroom learning to drive at point of choice nutritious decisions
  • Students from 5th to 12th grade did respond to simple promotions
  • More intensive, longer lasting promotions would have greater effect
  • Need participation from many stakeholders for successful and lasting practices
  • Although not complicated, this approach takes time and resources to implement so collaborative approach is necessary

(image: photo of convenience store snacks)

19 "Best Practices" School-based Approaches

  • Cost-effective — resources available
  • Complement larger school context — fit within school schedule, align with a coordinated school health model
  • Be lasting — not just a one-time event without additional programs, want impact to be lasting
  • Supported by critical audiences — students, administrators, school food service, teachers, families/parents, and community leaders
  • On-going "body" charged with keeping the light on the issue -- School Health/Wellness Advisory Council
20 Action for Healthy Kids' Resources

(image: photos of other Healthy Kids' resources)

View list of available presentations