4. Achieving Inherently Safer Designs:
Inherent Safety
An iterative risk assessment will enable researchers
to integrate safety and health throughout the life
cycle of products or processes. Inherently safer
technologies are intended to significantly reduce or
eliminate biological, chemical, and physical hazards
simultaneously, so that issues such as chemical
toxicity are evaluated concurrently with explosion
potential, flammability, ergonomic or injury hazards,
radiation, and noise [Zwetsloot and Ashford 2003].
Inherent safety is an intrinsic feature of the design.
It is best implemented early in the design process
prior to huge capital expenditure and can even lead
to cost savings [Mannan 2002; Christensen and
Manuele 1999].
The simplification of the production process for
the chemical synthesis of DNA is an example of an
inherently safer design. Two principles of inherent
safety—simplification and substitution—were
applied to reduce the hazard and cost of bringing
this technology to market. The production process
underwent redesign to use fewer solvents and
reagents by halving the number of steps from four
to two. The use of the most highly toxic reagents
and solvents was eliminated and chemical waste was
reduced by 75%. Not only was safety improved, but
the expense of hazardous solvent and reagent waste
disposal was reduced—a cost that was equivalent to
the purchase of the chemicals [Sprackland 2002].
The occupational safety and health community can
play an important role in improving the evaluation
of emerging technologies for inherently safer
design opportunities by nurturing partnerships to
pilot these approaches. It can assist firms in these
tasks as well as to provide businesses, government
and academia with the tools they need to partner
in these efforts. For example, occupational safety
and health professionals should be involved in the
prospective analysis steps and iterate within the
process to distinguish potential benign technologies
for hazardous technologies.
How to Achieve Inherently Safer
Designs
Inherently safer technologies emerge from designs
that focus on the elimination of hazards from the
production process rather than the management and
control of those hazards. In theory the inherently
safer design process is less vulnerable to failure
since the hazards have been significantly reduced or
eliminated [Ashford 2000]. Nonetheless, a broad
array of inherently safer design methods must be
considered so a technology will not create a new
problem while solving another. Inherently safer
design, simply defined, is one that “avoids hazards
instead of controlling them” [Hendershot 1999]
and involves several methods, also called principles
[Hazell 2000; Hendershot 1999; Bollinger et al.
1996]. The following list describes several inherently
safer design methods:
- Intensification (also referred to as minimization)
involves using minimal amounts of hazardous
materials so that releases are not catastrophic.
While this method may lead to storing smaller
quantities of a chemical, it may also result in
more frequent deliveries of the chemical, and
thus, increase the potential for transport spills
[Mannan 2002]. This example illustrates that an
array of methods must be considered, because
focusing on only one method may create new
hazards.
- Substitution occurs when safer materials are
used. For example, the Phosphorous Match
Act of 1912 led to the elimination—through
substitution—of the use of white phosphorous in manufacturing matches, and thus, the elimination
of the devastating disease, phosphorous necrosis
of the jaw [Myers and McGlothlin 1996].
- Alternative reaction routes is a method exemplified
by a change in the process used to produce the
insecticide, Carbaryl, for which methyl isocyanate
was an intermediate product. Methyl isocyanate
was the chemical released at Bhopal, India, where
approximately 3,800 people died. By using the
same raw materials but changing the process by
sequencing the chemical reactions in a different
order, methyl isocyanate was eliminated as an
intermediate product [Bollinger et al. 1996].
- Modified storage requirements keep chemicals
such as ammonia or chlorine at a pressure below
their boiling point where, in case of a leak, the
evaporation rate would be relatively low.
- Energy limitation reduces the amount of energy
available in the production process. A historical
example serves to illustrate this method in
preventing hazardous exposures. Gustave Eiffel,
in constructing his tower in 1889—an emerging
technology of his day—assembled parts of the
tower on the ground to avoid exposure to falls
from a high elevation on the tower. No employee
lost his life while working on this project [Barry
1972].
- Simplification uses processes and facilities that
are designed to eliminate unnecessary complexity
and be tolerant of operators’ errors. The nuclear
power plant incident at Three-Mile Island in
1979 is an example of a complex process that
encouraged errors [Perrow 1999].
- Optimal plant layout is an additional method
which is an inherently safer design for logistical
activities [Zwetsloot and Ashford 2003].
Inherently safer and cleaner technologies may result
from technology-forcing performance regulations
[Strasser 1997]. More than a century ago, the
Safe Appliances Act of 1893 required that railroad
companies use the latest safety innovations to
protect their workforce, and as a result air brakes
and automatic couplers were adopted nationwide
followed by many other technologies that steadily
reduced the rates of fatal and serious injuries to
workers [MacLaury 1981; Holbrook 1939]. The
resulting design principles need to incorporate
intervention and prevention strategies based on
safety and health research findings.
The long-range implications of the technology need
to be understood to ensure that technology forcing
does not shift one kind of risk into another type of
risk. Moreover, all of these principles need to be
considered together so as to avoid the creation of
unanticipated hazards [Mannan 2002].
The investigation of candidate principles can include
the results of other investigations. One of these is
the Theory of Inventive Problem Solving [Rantanen
and Domb 2002], which is an engineering
design approach that uses 40 principles to resolve
contradictions between risks and benefits. It is a
tool for engineers to view problems outside of their
experience and avoid tradeoffs by eliminating risks
and exploiting benefits at the design stage (Altshuller
et al. 1997).
Cleaner Production
Technologies and the Work
Environment
The relationship between environmental
innovations and worker health is an important
example of unintended hazards. The substitution of
hydrochlorofluorocarbons for chlorofluorocarbons
reduced damage to the ozone layer, but it created
both a carcinogenic and flammability risk to workers.
In another example, water-based paints eliminated
volatile organic solvents but created a biocide hazard
for workers [Ashford 1997].
Ensuring worker safety and health and environmental
improvement must be seen as interrelated rather than
as separate activities. Environmental concerns now
are increasingly factored into design and operational
decisions, but in order to further integrate the work
environment, managers need to encourage scientists,
engineers, and technology developers to include
safety and health concerns in both their design and
operational criteria. The recent occupational health
literature contains a growing number of studies
addressing the theory and practice of the integration
of industrial hygiene and environmental preventive
procedures [Armenti 2002; Roelofs 2001; Bartlett
et al. 1999; Quinn et al. 1998; Enander et al. 1998;
Ellenbecker 1996; Goldschmidt 1993]. Finally,
a recent study of the benefits and barriers of next
generation environmental technologies in a number
of U.S. industries concluded that, although in its
infancy, green chemistry technologies provide
significant benefits for occupational health,
environmental health, and economic security
[Lempert et al. 2003].
The diversity of work environments, however,
makes implementing such strategies challenging.
It is difficult to know every organization’s facility
layout, degree of automation, equipment status,
engineering controls, and administrative practices
such as shift work [Ashford 1997].
Chemical manufacturing processes in the United
States, Italy, and China, for example, range from
manual reactor vessel charging, mixing, packaging,
and maintenance to processes that are enclosed
and automatic. The same process under these
different conditions has different implications for
worker safety and health. If a worker was exposed,
the physiologic route of entry cannot always be
anticipated, because knowledge of the physical state
of the substances at different stages in the process is
lacking.
![robotic welders](images/figure5.JPG)
Figure 5. Robotic welders in a modern
automotive assembly. Note the absence
of sparks and intense UV radiation.
Manufacturing engineers responsible for
the robotic system operate in front of a
control panel that is not in view.
Robotic welding: New and advanced
manufacturing systems have generally led
to a safer workplace. Robotic welding in
the automotive industry since the 1970s
has led to higher quality products and
reduced human exposures to welding fumes,
ozone, UV radiation, and other hazards
associated with welding (see Figure 5), but
new hazards need to be avoided [NIOSH
1984]. Smart manufacturing systems with
sensors to provide real time feedback to an
operator have improved product quality and
occupational safety and health.
|
In order to facilitate exposure reduction and injury
prevention, researchers must articulate and evaluate
technical options using multivariate criteria,
which include safety and health, economic, and
environmental factors. These criteria can also be
used to compare improvements that each option
might offer over existing technological solutions
[Zwetsloot and Ashford 2003]. One approach
is Technology Options Analysis (TOA), which
entails the identification of inherently cleaner and
safer options for the technology being considered.
TOAs can identify designs that might be expanded
into widespread use, technologies that might be
transferred from one industrial sector to another, or
benign technologies that still need to be developed.
TOAs expand risk assessments to include alternative
production technologies, e.g., input substitution
and process redesigns [Ashford 1997].
TOAs need to be augmented by analyses that
identify where in the production process changes
to inherently safer inputs, processes, and products
could be made. Such analyses have addressed
environmental impacts, but they need to be
expanded to include the occupational environment.
The Toxics Use Reduction (TUR) Institute of
Massachusetts evaluated the application of TUR in
OSHA programs [Penney and Moure-Eraso 1995;
Roelofs et al. 2000]. It evaluated the impact on
occupational health practices in 35 Massachusetts
firms where the State promoted cleaner production
alternatives. The study concluded that TUR
activities improved the work environment, but
that such improvements were neither systematically
planned nor incorporated into their activities.
Information about superior technologies regarding
existing options to protect both workers and the
environment were also missing.
An opportunity for improved occupational safety
and health exists with firms that develop emerging
technologies, because they are more likely to adopt
more benign technologies in new facilities or
operations [Zwetsloot and Ashford 2003].
New operations, which may be driven by emerging
technologies, are most receptive to modifying their
processes and final products. Firms in transition
may delay implementing safety improvements
even though they require new investments in an
existing facility. Nonetheless, these firms may adopt
emerging technologies with inherently safer designs
if they are searching for ways to improve safety,
protect the environment, or reduce high costs
related to energy, water, or materials.
The receptivity to inherently safer designs differs
for primary, secondary, and ancillary production
processes as well as final products. These processes
are exemplified in Table 2. The most resistance to
innovation might be expected from existing firms
whenever demands are placed on changing their
primary process. When a new process is adopted,
usually by the diffusion of an alternative technology,
the firm may be hesitant to change a proven method
and take a chance on altering the appearance of its product. It may be relatively easy for the firm
to find an alternative, safer process if it focuses on
the ancillary process. Inherently safer designs are
better received with emerging technologies in the
later stages of production, although in the designto-
technology adoption process, a design freeze will
need to be anticipated.
Advancing Inherently Safer
Designs
Expanding Inherently Safer Designs
Most attention to inherent safety principles for
workers has occurred in the chemical manufacturing
sector [Hunter 1999], but these approaches need
to be explored in other sectors such as agriculture,
construction, transportation, healthcare, and
services. Scientific research is needed to advance
the foundations for inherently safer and cleaner
industrial processes and to translate that knowledge
into practice. Systematic analytic methodologies
are needed to measure the degree of inherent safety
to allow for the comparison of alternative designs.
Research is needed so emerging technologies that
are designed to improve the environment also
improve occupational safety and health [Ashford
et al. 1996]. A systems approach is needed for
integrating occupational and environmental
assessments into operations at the firm and corporate
levels. This includes the development, validation,
and dissemination of data elements and models
that can be used by safety and health professionals
throughout industry to support early and effective
technology evaluation. Researchers also need
methods to identify benign emerging technologies
during the prospective analysis that can substitute
for traditionally risky technologies.
Table 2. The stage of production explained
by an example of casting and electroplating in
metal screw manufacturing.
Stage of
production |
Example |
Potential
occupational
hazards |
Primary |
Casting |
Toxic fumes and
molten metal
contact |
Secondary |
Electroplating |
Toxic and
corrosive
hazards |
Ancillary |
Cleaning or
degreasing |
Toxic and
flammable
solvents |
Product |
Metal screws |
Injury |
Integrating Inherently Safer Design
into Business Practice
Experts in occupational safety and health need to
attend conferences or other forums to identify
workplace applications for new technologies. Such
forums will also allow these experts to share their
expertise with technology developers so that new
applications will either enhance occupational safety
and health or at least be introduced safely in the
workplace. Research is needed to overcome barriers
in improving workplace conditions and economics,
while maintaining high-quality and innovative
products or services. Firms that have succeeded in
these improvements have developed strategies that
enable them to thrive in the midst of change. Their
example suggests a need for research strategies that
identify information needs and technology gaps in
order to encourage widespread development and implementation of inherently safer technologies.
These include a need to:
- Access knowledge about inherently safer
technologies;
- Apply or adapt emerging technology to specific
workplaces or facilities;
- Overcome resistance to change;
- Ensure that inherent safety is implanted early in
the design of emerging technologies.
Applying Science to Engineering
Green chemistry [Anastas and Williamson 1998],
green engineering [Allen and Shonnard 2002], and
inherently safer chemical processes [Bollinger et al.
1996] represent current attempts at filling some of
the gaps for new synthetic pathways, production
processes, and design as a comprehensive system, but
attempts are also needed in areas beyond chemical
production. In addition, progress needs to be made
in methods to interpret data and information by
broadening the criteria upon which technologies are
evaluated.
|