Impact on Investigators of Enhancing Peer Review
In response to many comments and much input from the extramural community,
the NIH soon will implement changes to the peer review process. The changes
are centered on three priority areas: (1) engaging the best reviewers, (2)
improving the quality and transparency of review, and (3) ensuring balanced
and fair reviews across scientific fields and career stages. An additional aim is to reduce administrative burden.
The NIH will begin implementing changes in the Fiscal Year 2010 funding cycle. Investigators
submitting applications in January 2009 and later should be aware of the following
new policies.
Shorter Applications.
Shorter applications that align with review criteria will be implemented for
January 2010 receipt dates and beyond.
New Investigator and Early Stage Investigator Policy. NIH intends to support
New Investigators at success rates comparable to those for established investigators
submitting new applications, and Early Stage Investigators should comprise
a majority of the New Investigators. Details are posted in the NIH Guide
(NOT-OD-09-013).
Policy on Resubmission (Amended) Applications. Beginning with original
new applications (i.e., never submitted) and competing renewal applications
submitted for the January 25, 2009 due dates and beyond, the NIH will accept
only a single amendment to the original application. Details are posted
in the NIH Guide (NOT-OD-09-003).
Scoring and Review Criteria. When these applications are reviewed in
May 2009 review meetings, five new policies will be in place: (1) a 9-point
scoring system, (2) enhanced review criteria, (3) formatted reviewer critiques,
(4) scoring of individual review criteria, and (5) clustering of New Investigator
applications during review. Changes to the scoring and review criteria
are described in detail in the NIH Guide, NOT-OD-09-024 and NOT-OD-09-025.
For more details on the implementation timeline, including changes expected
for the Fiscal Year 2011 funding cycle, see the NIH Guide (NOT-09-023). Comprehensive
information on the enhancing peer review effort may be found at http://enhancing-peer-review.nih.gov/.
Below is the updated timeline for implementation of key actions in the NIH
peer review system:
January 2009 Receipt Dates
(FY2010 funding) |
- Revised New and Early Stage Investigator Policies
(NOT-OD-09-013)
- New NIH Policy on Resubmission (Amended) Applications
(NOT-OD-09-003) |
May 2009 Review Meetings
(FY2010 funding) |
- 9-Point Scoring System
- Formatted Reviewer Critiques
- Scoring of Individual Review Criteria
- Enhanced Review Criteria
- Reviewer Toolkit
-
Cluster New Investigator Applications During
Review |
January 2010 Receipt Dates
(FY2011 funding) |
- Shorter applications for R01s and Other Mechanisms
- Restructured Applications to Align with Review Criteria |
Return to Table of Contents |