The Samuel Roberts Noble Foundation, Inc.    
     
1996-97 Comparison of Planting Dates for Rye, Oat, Wheat &Triticale Varieties and Strains
 
 
     

by Jerry L. Baker

TABLE 1. SMALL GRAINS FORAGE SUMMARY
COMPARING PLANTING DATES AT BURNEYVILLE, OK, 1996-97

  Pounds of Oven-Dry Forage
 

September 13 Planting

Clipping Dates    
 

Small Grain Variety

11/21 2/4 Total
thru
2/4
3/5 3/26 4/23 5/29 1996-97
Total
% Forage
Produced
by 2/4
1. Oklon rye 1968 1781 3748 468 451 660 0 5327 70
2. Maton rye 1855 1618 3473 339 600 689 0 5101 68
3. Bates rye 1572 1628 3200 443 606 586 0 4835 66
4. Trical 2700 triticale 1624 616 2240 80 271 873 632 4096 55
5. 2180 wheat 1114 1417 2531 472 603 351 0 3957 64
6. Coker 9134 wheat (soft) 853 1490 2343 457 579 501 0 3880 60
7. Harrison oat 629 481 1110 76 334 1086 878 3484 32
8. NF 21 triticale 1139 1138 2277 304 429 445 0 3455 66
9. 833 oat 481 226 707 88 469 1211 765 3240 22
10. Longhorn wheat 920 879 1799 352 392 527 0 3070 59
  Average 1216 1127 2343 308 474 693 227 4045 58
  L.S.D. (.05) 380 362 620 105 NS 200 153 674  
  C.V. (%) 18.2 18.7 15.4 19.9 33.7 16.8 39.2 9.7  

October 3 Planting

Clipping Dates    

Small Grain Variety

11/20 2/4 Total
thru
2/4
3/5 3/26 4/23 5/28 1996-97
Total
% Forage
Produced
by 2/4
1. Bates rye 1352 2520 3872 916 599 688 0 6075 64
2. Oklon rye 1382 2387 3769 900 527 707 0 5903 64
3. Harrison oat 674 1923 2597 397 713 1232 910 5849 44
4. Coker 9134 wheat (soft) 901 2410 3311 1014 699 623 0 5648 59
5. Maton rye 1019 2098 3117 749 1047 723 0 5636 55
6. 833 oat 407 1587 1994 315 721 1490 938 5458 37
7. Longhorn wheat 841 2025 2866 949 654 477 0 4946 58
8. 2180 wheat 738 2183 2921 975 643 377 0 4916 59
9. NF 21 triticale 991 2212 3203 769 313 505 0 4790 67
10. Trical 2700 triticale 1011 1838 2849 313 502 980 0 4644 61
  Average 932 2118 3050 730 642 780 185 5387 57
  L.S.D. (.05) 164 381 470 107 83 183 62 654  
  C.V. (%) 10.3 10.5 9.0 8.6 7.6 13.7 19.6 7.1  

TABLE 2. GRAIN YIELDS OF SMALL GRAIN VARIETIES
PLANTED ON TWO DATES AT BURNEYVILLE, 1996-97

  Bushels/Acre
 

Variety

September 13
Planting
October 3
Planting
1. 833 oat 90.1 31.5
2. Harrison oat 52.0 56.0
3. Longhorn wheat 43.2 48.0
4. Trical 2700 triticale 38.2 61.2
5. Oklon rye 16.5 16.5
6. Maton rye 14.8 17.0
7. Bates rye 12.4 18.4
8. NF 21 triticale 6.0 5.8
9. Coker 9134 wheat (soft) 0.0 0.0
10. 2180 wheat 0.0 0.0
  Average 27.3 25.4
  L.S.D. (.05) 18.3 9.7
  C.V. (%) 39.1 22.2

SOME INFLUENCING FACTORS

Location: Red River Demonstration and Research Farm, Burneyville, OK.
Planted: September 13 and October 3.
Seeding Rate: 2,000,000 live seed/acre.
Seeding Method: Drilled in seven-inch rows.
Replications: Three (3).
Soil Type: Minco fine sandy loam.
Fertilization: Preplant: none.
  Topdress: 100 lb. N/acre on December 11, 1996 and 60 lb. N/acre on February 5, 1997.
Weed Control: Pre-emergence: 0.56 oz. Amber/acre.
Management: Disked and roller-harrowed.
Clipping: Both plantings were clipped to simulate rotational grazing.
Grain Harvest Dates: Both plantings on June 18.
Pounds/Bushel: Wheat – 60; rye – 56; triticale – 50; and oats – 32.
Diseases: Leaf rust infection was heavy on wheat, triticale, and rye. Longhorn and 2180 wheats and Trical 2700 triticale maintained the best leaf rust resistance among this group of small grains. Ideal weather during the grain-fill period minimized the losses in grain yield due to the leaf rust outbreak.
Winter Damage: The hard freezes on April 12-14 caused extensive grain yield reduction among the wheat, triticale, and rye varieties. In general, the early-maturing varieties that were headed at the time of the freeze, suffered the most freeze damage.
Temperatures: The low temperature was 7°F on January 29, 1997. Temperature were 20°F or lower on 15 dates in December and January (Refer to NF FOR 97-03 for more detail).

Rainfall (inches):

Month 3-Year
Average
1995-96
Season
1996-97
Season
September 5.66 3.53 6.82
October 3.56 1.11 2.57
November 3.60 0.44 5.01
December 2.21 2.93 0.93
January 1.32 1.65 0.48
February 2.28 0.00 6.60
March 3.13 4.27 1.43
April 4.23 2.57 5.21
May 3.95 0.56 5.05
Total 29.94 17.06 34.10

Information in this report is not conclusive, but should be of valuable assistance when used with similar information from other sources.

All available information pertaining to the subject should be used in making conclusions and decisions. This publication is intended to furnish supplemental information to aid in making a more sound decision and to stimulate thinking for new ideas.

I would like to acknowledge the following Research Assistants for their valuable assistance in the collection and analysis of data used in this report: Julie Barrick, Bret Flatt, Roger Hartwell, Sean Maher and Frank Motal.

 

Discussion
Early fall plantings were hampered by wet weather conditions. At Ardmore, we were unable to establish two dates of planting of small grains due to heavy rains in September. Two dates of planting were established at Burneyville on September 13 and October 3. However, stand development and initial plant growth of the early-planted test was slow because of heavy rainfall following planting.

Both plantings at Burneyville were clipped six times for forage production (Table 1). The October planting produced an average of 33% (1342 pounds/acre) more total forage than the September planting. This yield advantage developed during the winter months as the late planting had produced 30% more forage by February 4. The rye varieties produced the most early forage and oats were the slowest to make forage in both plantings. The early forage advantage of the ryes relative to the other small grains is much more evident in the September planted test.

Table 2 shows grain yields from both plantings at Burneyville. Hard freezes on April 12-14 resulted in drastic grain yield reduction of the ryes, wheats, and triticales in both plantings. In general, the early maturing varieties were damaged the most by the cold temperatures. Coker 9134 and 2180 wheats had headed prior to the freezes and were completely devastated in both plantings. With the exception of 833 oat and Trical 2700 triticale, yields were fairly consistent for the other varieties across the two planting dates. Heavy lodging and grain shatter contributed greatly to the reduced yield of 833 oat in the October planted test.

A two-year comparison of forage and grain production from early and late fall plantings at Burneyville is shown in Table 3. Note that both forage and grain production of rye, triticale, and wheat has been higher for the late fall planting in both years. In 1995-96, the late-planted oat varieties did not produce any forage or grain because of complete winterkill.


 

 

 

 


 
         
       
© 1997-2008 by The Samuel Roberts Noble Foundation, Inc.