The Samuel Roberts Noble Foundation, Inc.    
     
1997-98 Grain Yields and Estimated Returns from Rye, Oat, Wheat, Triticale Varieties and Strains
 
 
     
Table 1. Grain Yields and Estimated Gross Returns
from Small Grain Varieties, 1997-98, Ardmore, OK
          Estimated Gross Returns/Acre
   

Variety

Yield:
Bu/Ac
Test
Weight:
Lbs/Bu
Grain Forage
Produced
by Feb. 9
Total
Grain
& Forage
Total Forage,*
No Grain
Harvest
Rye: 1. Maton 51.2 57.5 179.20 71.08 250.28 167.15
  2. Bonel 40.4 57.4 141.40 66.20 207.60 157.08
  3. NF 39 38.6 57.0 135.10 120.05 255.15 188.23
  4. Wintermore 38.5 57.6 134.75 87.42 222.17 168.47
  5. Bates 37.5 56.8 131.25 105.57 236.82 179.36
  6. Oklon 36.5 56.4 127.75 96.43 224.18 162.23
  7. Wrens Abruzzi 35.9 57.6 125.65 96.26 221.91 164.01
  8. TRT-2000 (blend) 35.1 50.9 122.85 53.23 176.08 138.70
  9. Wrens 96 35.0 57.2 122.50 131.74 254.24 190.34
  10. NF 94 33.3 56.6 116.55 100.02 216.57 160.05
  11. NF 28 32.8 56.5 114.80 110.32 225.12 177.57
  12. Elbon 30.1 55.5 105.35 66.86 172.21 145.10
  13. NF 58 29.7 56.0 103.95 81.71 185.66 145.60
  14. Wintergrazer 70 29.2 57.0 102.20 111.74 213.94 165.99
  15. Wintermore 95 28.8 57.0 100.80 84.05 184.85 154.41
  16. NF 65 28.6 56.8 100.10 118.01 218.11 179.22
  17. Wintermore 96 28.5 56.5 99.75 84.78 184.53 147.81
  18. Barr Blend 27.6 57.1 96.60 81.51 178.11 145.99
  19. NF 51 25.6 56.7 89.60 99.53 189.13 159.72
  20. Wheeler 1.2 56.0 4.20 70.82 75.02 139.49
                 
Wheat: 1. Lockett 73.9 59.3 199.16 55.28 254.44 177.87
  2. Coker 9663 (soft) 72.3 57.7 179.30 123.35 302.65 213.31
  3. Coker 9134 (soft) 71.6 57.8 177.57 120.19 297.76 227.01
  4. 2174 71.0 64.3 191.70 71.02 262.72 168.20
  5. 2137 69.3 62.2 187.11 64.88 251.99 176.32
  6. Custer 66.1 62.3 178.47 79.46 257.93 181.63
  7. Coker 9543 (soft) 64.7 58.4 161.10 102.17 263.27 196.91
  8. NF 134 63.7 59.1 171.67 106.43 278.10 202.62
  9. NF 165 62.8 61.2 169.56 96.49 266.05 200.48
  10. 2163 62.1 60.9 167.67 53.23 220.90 143.48
  11. Tomahawk 61.3 58.3 164.59 51.38 215.97 166.62
  12. Coker 9803 (soft) 59.8 59.9 149.20 84.08 233.28 171.63
  13. Coronado 59.2 61.4 159.84 94.94 254.78 181.83
  14. NF 35 57.8 55.6 156.06 110.29 266.35 201.04
  15. Florida 302 (soft) 57.2 53.0 131.56 105.93 237.49 190.38
  16. NF 4 55.1 60.4 148.77 111.64 260.41 203.87
  17. Tonkawa 52.5 63.1 141.75 57.12 198.87 174.90
  18. Longhorn 51.7 59.0 139.07 67.88 206.95 161.04
  19. Jagger 49.2 58.8 132.10 98.37 230.47 183.98
  20. 2180 47.5 58.1 127.54 64.58 192.12 148.93
                 
Oat: 1. Dallas 112.5 36.4 180.00 90.19 270.19 209.25
  2. Chapman 111.0 34.0 177.60 109.89 287.49 226.74
  3. La. 604 105.1 34.8 168.16 82.76 250.92 210.84
  4. Ozark 102.7 35.8 164.32 82.30 246.62 211.76
  5. Harrison 100.7 32.5 161.12 108.17 269.29 225.19
  6. 833 94.4 35.9 151.04 87.29 238.33 209.42
  7. 811 91.8 37.0 146.88 90.98 237.86 209.25
  8. NF 188 88.6 36.6 141.76 93.52 235.28 214.63
                 
Triticale: 1. NF 57 51.1 49.7 114.98 88.08 203.06 168.99
  2. Trical 2700 46.9 51.7 105.53 89.00 194.53 191.43
  3. NF 87 46.0 51.1 103.50 124.11 227.61 198.69
  4. NF 11 44.5 51.3 100.13 119.03 219.16 204.90
  5. Trical Stan I 44.1 53.5 99.23 68.90 168.13 184.44
  6. Presto 42.5 54.7 95.63 83.23 178.86 187.24
  7. RSI 2+7 (blend) 34.3 49.2 77.18 73.39 150.57 184.90
  8. Trit II (blend) 23.9 50.8 53.78 52.67 106.45 170.35

* Forage yields and influencing factors are reported in NF FOR 98-02.

Grain Values:
Rye $3.50/bu. Soft Wheat $2.50/bu.
Triticale $2.25/bu. Hard Wheat $2.70/bu.
Oat $1.60/bu.

Forage Value: $3.30/cwt. for oven-dry forage.

Assumptions:
Stocker calves
Average Daily Gain (ADG) = 2 lb.
Consumption = 3% (.03) of body weight.
Average weight = 600 lb./calf

Calculations:
600 lb. x .03 = 18 lb./head/day
2,000 lb./ton ¸ 18 lb. = 111 animal days
2 lb. ADG x 111 animal days = 222 lb. gain
$0.30 = custom rate for one pound of gain
222 lb. x $0.30 = $66.60/ton = $3.30/cwt.

NF numbers are Noble Foundation experimental strains and are not commercially available.

Table 2. Grain Yields and Estimated Gross Returns
from Samll Grain Varieties, 1997-98, Burneyville, OK
          Estimated Gross Returns/Acre
    Variety Yield:
Bu/Ac
Test
Weight:
Lbs/Bu
Grain Forage
Produced
by Jan. 28
Total
Grain
& Forage
Total Forage,*
No Grain
Harvest
Rye:  1. Maton 66.6 58.8 233.10 66.93 300.03 227.47
   2. Bonel 57.6 58.3 201.60 58.11 259.71 193.91
   3. NF 28 54.5 57.4 190.75 127.15 317.90 245.59
   4. TRT-2000 (blend) 53.7 55.9 187.95 63.23 251.18 184.31
   5. Wintermore 51.5 57.3 180.25 84.32 264.57 207.01
   6. NF 94 49.9 58.2 174.65 114.84 289.49 232.16
   7. NF 65 48.4 57.7 169.40 105.47 274.87 223.15
   8. NF 39 48.3 57.7 169.05 111.80 280.85 231.03
   9. Bates 48.3 57.9 169.05 93.59 262.64 214.70
  10. Barr Blend 48.2 57.9 168.70 86.36 255.06 204.83
  11. Wrens Abruzzi 48.2 56.6 168.70 97.78 266.48 220.08
  12. Wintermore 96 46.2 57.2 161.70 95.90 257.60 206.22
  13. NF 58 46.0 57.0 161.00 106.36 264.36 213.94
  14. Wintermore 95 45.4 55.9 158.90 74.68 233.58 212.78
  15. Oklon 44.5 56.6 155.75 100.88 256.63 226.55
  16. NF 51 44.1 57.0 154.35 109.76 264.11 213.35
  17. Wrens 96 43.3 57.2 151.55 114.54 266.09 223.34
  18. Wintergrazer 70 42.9 57.4 150.15 138.47 288.62 243.21
  19. Elbon 42.8 55.9 149.80 60.16 209.96 193.91
  20. Wheeler 27.3 52.5 95.55 75.87 171.42 191.66
                 
Wheat:  1. 2137 67.8 63.2 183.06 8.12 191.18 126.65
   2. Lockett 66.4 59.2 178.95 19.34 198.29 132.17
   3. Coker 9663 (soft) 66.0 60.1 165.00 30.99 195.99 134.18
   4. Tonkawa 59.5 63.2 160.65 13.63 174.28 132.66
   5. Coker 9134 (soft) 58.9 58.3 146.66 26.33 172.99 131.01
   6. NF 4 56.2 61.3 151.74 32.70 184.44 144.87
   7. 2174 56.1 62.9 151.47 14.95 166.42 131.84
   8. Coker 9543 (soft) 54.9 60.9 137.25 25.58 162.83 122.79
   9. Coker 9803 (soft) 53.4 62.7 133.50 19.70 153.20 128.87
  10. Tomahawk 53.1 60.9 143.37 9.74 153.11 117.22
  11. Custer 50.5 61.4 136.50 14.62 151.12 128.87
  12. NF 165 50.4 61.1 136.08 33.73 169.81 134.21
  13. Longhorn 50.1 60.8 135.27 25.51 160.78 131.57
  14. 2163 49.9 60.8 134.73 14.29 149.02 121.37
  15. NF 35 48.9 59.2 131.79 34.19 165.98 140.25
  16. NF 134 48.3 61.3 130.41 21.81 152.22 115.34
  17. 2180 44.9 59.3 121.00 18.78 139.78 121.44
  18. Coronado 43.5 60.5 117.45 21.88 139.33 119.69
  19. Florida 302 (soft) 41.4 56.3 100.19 33.79 133.98 118.70
  20. Jagger 36.4 60.5 98.28 28.22 126.50 117.28
                 
Oat:  1. Ozark 86.4 37.7 138.24 41.28 179.52 174.31
   2. Dallas 79.6 36.5 127.36 36.66 164.02 164.67
   3. NF 188 76.4 36.7 122.24 53.30 175.54 185.76
   4. 833 75.0 36.7 120.00 38.48 158.48 164.93
   5. Harrison 73.1 35.4 116.96 44.29 161.25 150.28
   6. Chapman 71.3 34.0 114.08 48.94 163.02 143.35
   7. La. 604 69.8 36.0 111.68 41.02 152.70 167.11
   8. 811 67.4 37.0 107.84 49.37 157.21 148.43
                 
Triticale:  1. RSI 2+7 (blend) 63.5 50.8 142.88 27.32 170.20 141.21
   2. Presto 60.1 54.7 135.23 30.86 166.09 144.90
   3. Trical 2700 55.3 52.2 124.43 46.43 170.86 142.69
   4. NF 57 51.8 49.8 116.55 46.46 163.01 134.48
   5. Trical Stan I 51.5 53.9 115.88 23.20 139.08 135.30
   6. NF 11 45.1 50.3 101.48 50.69 152.17 148.70
   7. NF 87 39.9 49.8 89.78 56.96 146.74 145.66
   8. Trit II (blend) 38.7 51.1 87.08 15.61 102.69 148.70
 * Forage yields and influencing factors are reported in NF FOR 98-02.

Grain Values:
Rye $3.50/bu. Soft Wheat $2.50/bu.
Triticale $2.25/bu. Hard Wheat $2.70/bu.
Oat $1.60/bu.

Forage Value: $3.30/cwt. for oven-dry forage. See Table 1 for assumptions and calculations.

NF numbers are Noble Foundation experimental strains and are not commercially available.

Table 3. Two Location Grain Performance Comparison
of Commercial Small Grain Varieties, 1995-98

    Bushels/Acre
    Ardmore (silt loam)   Burneyville (sandy loam)
                 
  Variety 1995-96 1996-97 1997-98   1995-96 1996-97 1997-98
 Rye: Bates 41.6 18.7 37.5   25.2 12.4 48.3
  Barr Blend 39.4 15.9 27.6   27.0 13.1 48.2
  Bonel 37.5 19.3 40.4   27.3 17.2 57.6
  Elbon 39.7 13.2 30.1   28.7 8.2 42.8
  Maton 41.6 23.0 51.2   30.5 14.7 66.6
  Oklon 36.0 18.4 36.5   27.6 16.5 44.5
  Wintergrazer 70 38.4 14.5 29.2   30.1 10.4 42.9
  Wintermore 35.2 13.4 38.5   30.4 11.6 51.5
  Wrens Abruzzi 37.1 15.0 35.9   20.0 13.8 48.2
  Wintermore 95 - 17.0 28.8   - 12.7 45.4
  Wintermore 96 - 16.3 28.5   - 12.6 46.2
  Wrens 96 - 13.9 35.0   - 15.8 43.3
  Average 38.5 16.6 34.9   27.4 13.3 48.8
                 
Oat: Chapman 43.6 39.2 111.0   30.4 80.3 71.3
  Harrison 43.5 39.8 100.7   19.4 51.7 73.1
  Ozark 86.7 52.7 102.7   58.4 88.8 86.4
  811 40.6 52.4 91.8   30.7 98.5 67.4
  833 61.6 54.5 94.4   35.2 89.5 75.0
  Average 55.2 47.7 100.1   34.8 81.8 74.6
                 
Wheat: Coker 9134 (soft) 47.4 0 71.6   27.9 0 58.9
  Coker 9543 (soft) 63.0 0 64.7   38.7 0 54.9
  Coker 9803 (soft) 46.3 0 59.8   32.7 0 53.4
  Custer 53.4 4.2 66.1   36.8 0 50.5
  Florida 302 (soft) 28.9 11.2 57.2   11.6 0 41.4
  Jagger 48.7 0 49.2   26.4 0 36.4
  Longhorn 42.5 49.8 51.7   33.0 43.6 50.1
  Tomahawk 45.1 49.2 61.3   36.4 47.9 53.1
  Tonkawa 47.7 7.9 52.5   31.3 0 59.5
  2180 44.3 0 47.5   24.6 0 44.9
  2163 53.7 9.5 62.1   28.7 0 49.9
  2137 - 12.5 69.3   - 0 67.8
  Coronado - 0 59.2   - 0 43.5
  Average 52.1 12.0 64.4   32.8 7.6 55.4
                 
 Triticale: Presto 50.4 13.5 42.5   23.3 16.5 60.1
  Trical Stan I 39.6 53.6 44.1   14.3 55.9 51.5
  Trical 2700 26.0 57.1 46.9   7.2 38.7 55.3
  Trit II 30.5 38.5 23.9   15.1 32.5 38.7
  Average 36.6 40.7 39.4   15.0 35.9 51.4
                 
  Overall Average 46.1 22.6 56.1   28.9 24.3 55.4

 

Table 4. Grain Yields of Twelve Small Grain Varieties
Planted on Two Dates at Ardmore and Burneyville, 1997-98

    Ardmore (silt loam)
    September 30 Planting   October 30 Planting
 

Variety

Yield:
Bu/Ac
Test
Weight:
Lbs/Bu

 

Yield:
Bu/Ac
Test
Weight:
Lbs/Bu
 1. La. 604 oat 105.1 34.8   96.8 30.4
 2. Harrison oat 100.7 32.5   91.7 31.8
 3. 833 oat 94.4 35.9   89.7 34.4
 4. Coker 9134 wheat (soft) 71.6 57.8   69.8 61.0
 5. Longhorn wheat 51.7 59.0   41.6 61.4
 6. Maton rye 51.2 57.5   48.1 58.2
 7. Jagger wheat 49.2 58.8   56.3 63.2
 8. NF 87 triticale 46.0 51.1   63.1 53.0
 9. Trical Stan I triticale 44.1 53.5   40.6 52.3
10. Presto triticale 42.5 54.7   65.8 56.3
11. Bates rye 37.5 56.8   45.6 57.4
12. Oklon rye 36.5 56.4   36.0 57.3
  Average 60.9 50.7   62.1 51.4
  L.S.D. (.05) 14.8 2.1   17.7 2.2
  C.V. (%) 14.4 2.4   16.8 2.6
             
    Burneyville (sandy loam)
    October 6 Planting   October 29 Planting

 

Variety

Yield:
Bu/Ac
Test
Weight:
Lbs/Bu

 

Yield
Bu/Ac
Test
Weight:
Lbs/Bu
 1. 833 oat 75.0 36.7   113.0 40.0
 2. Harrison oat 73.1 35.4   110.2 39.4
 3. La. 604 oat 69.8 36.0   96.9 37.6
 4. Maton rye 66.6 58.8   73.5 57.9
 5. Presto triticale 60.1 54.7   81.7 51.9
 6. Coker 9134 wheat (soft) 58.9 58.3   81.0 61.4
 7. Trical Stan I triticale 51.5 53.9   61.7 50.5
 8. Longhorn wheat 50.1 60.8   77.6 61.5
 9. Bates rye 48.3 57.9   64.8 56.6
10. Oklon rye 44.5 56.6   62.1 56.9
11. NF 87 triticale 39.9 49.8   73.5 50.2
12. Jagger wheat 36.4 60.5   77.4 62.7
  Average 56.2 51.6   81.1 52.2
  L.S.D. (.05) 24.5 1.6   14.3 1.8
  C.V. (%) 25.8 1.9   10.4 2.1

Table 5. Multi-Year Date of Planting Comparison of
Grain Yields at Ardmore and Burneyville

Bushels/Acre
Ardmore (silt loam)
Fall
Planting
Year* Planting
Date
Rye Oat Triticale Wheat
Early 1990-91 10/4 36.4 53.8 30.5 32.4
  1991-92 10/2 21.2 79.0 25.7 18.1
  1993-94 9/30 34.0 36.1 21.2 25.0
  1994-95 9/27 10.7 37.9 11.3 12.8
  1995-96 9/28 39.7 52.6 29.4 44.7
  1997-98 9/30 41.7 100.1 44.2 57.5
  Average 9/30 30.6 59.9 27.1 31.8
             
Late 1990-91 10/30 42.3 64.1 41.9 32.1
  1991-92 10/23 31.4 115.5 48.1 42.8
  1993-94 10/27 35.7 27.4 32.2 25.2
  1994-95 11/2 21.4 86.1 43.1 32.9
  1995-96 10/18 41.2 67.0 32.5 56.2
  1997-98 10/29 43.2 92.7 56.5 55.9
  Average 10/27 35.9 75.5 42.4 40.9
Burneyville (sandy loam)
Early 1995-96 9/27 27.8 27.3 12.8 28.5
  1996-97 9/13 14.6 71.1 22.1 14.4
  1997-98 10/6 53.1 72.6 50.5 48.5
  Average 9/25 31.8 57.0 28.5 30.5
             
  1995-96 10/17 41.0 0 24.7 38.2
  1996-97 10/3 17.3 43.8 33.5 16.0
  1997-98 10/29 66.8 106.7 72.3 78.7
  Average 10/16 41.7 50.2 43.5 44.3

*No comparison can be made at Ardmore for the 1992-93 and 1996-97 seasons.
The early planting was not harvested for grain yield in 1992-93 because of ryegrass infestation.
The late test was not planted because of wet conditions in the fall of the 1996-97 season.

 

Discussion
Early Small Grain Variety Trials

Considering the dry soil conditions in April and May, grain yields and test weight were good to excellent in the small grains variety tests at Ardmore and Burneyville in the 1997-98 season (Tables 1 and 2). An abundant accumulation of soil profile moisture during the winter and early spring was apparently sufficient to carry the crops through the late, dry grain fill period.

At Ardmore, the overall grain yield average of 53.8 bushels/acre was the highest since the 1976-77 season. Wheat yields were probably the best overall since the small grain variety testing program was initiated in 1967-68. The ryes produced the most variable yields in the test, ranging from 1.2 to 51.2 bushels/acre. The ryes and a few of the early maturing wheats and triticales suffered some degree of damage as a result of the low temperatures during March 10-12.

Overall grain production at Burneyville was almost identical to Ardmore at 53.9 bushels/acre. However, rye and triticale yields were higher and wheat and oat yields were lower at Burneyville. March freeze damage was most evident on the early maturing wheat and triticale varieties, rather than ryes. The oats produced the most uniform yields in the test, ranging from 67.4 to 86.4 bushels/acre.

The estimated gross returns as shown in Tables 1 and 2 were calculated on the basis of values at the bottom of the tables. If they do not agree with prices in your situation, your values can be substituted. The gross income estimates are shown to encourage the calculation of possible returns and profit from various varieties and management in your particular situation.

Table 3 shows the grain yields of commercially available varieties that have been tested at both Ardmore and Burneyville over the last three growing seasons. Keep in mind that grain yields are taken after the varieties have been clipped for forage production prior to jointing or first hollow stem. Generally the "cut-off" date for clipping varies from year to year because of temperatures and moisture during the winter months, planting dates, and varieties within each crop. The early maturing varieties are likely to suffer the most grain yield reduction due to delay in the "cut-off" clipping in the spring. In 1995-96, winter damage was very evident on most oat varieties at both locations. Notice the excellent yields of the Ozark variety and the stability and consistency of yield over the entire three-year period. In 1996-97 the April freeze caused varying degrees of damage in all small grains. However, the damage to the wheats was most catastrophic. The earliest maturing varieties were damaged more severely than the late maturing varieties. Note that Longhorn and Tomahawk were consistently at the top at both locations. Maton, a mid-maturity rye variety, has been the most dependable rye over the three-year testing period. Under our forage clipping regime, early-maturing varieties such as Oklon and Wrens Abruzzi are often penalized for grain yield because of early jointing.

Small Grain Varieties – Comparison of Planting Dates
Planting dates during the 1997-98 season were September 30 and October 29 at Ardmore and October 6 and 29 at Burneyville. The grain yields of both plantings at each respective location are shown in Table 4.

At Ardmore, the overall grain yield of the late planting (62.1) was 2% greater than the early planting (60.9). However, eight varieties produced more grain from the early planting. Jagger wheat, Bates rye, and Presto and NF 87 triticale responded much better under the late planting regime. It appeared that these varieties might have suffered tiller damage in the early planting as a result of the March 10-12 freeze.

At Burneyville, overall grain yields were much higher (44%) for the late planting. All twelve varieties produced more grain from the late planting. The March 10-12 freeze may have contributed to some yield loss on all varieties in the early-planted test as a result of damage to primary tillers.

A multi-year comparison of grain production from early and late fall planting at both locations is shown in Table 5. Note that grain production of rye and triticale has averaged higher for the late fall planting each year at both locations. Oat grain yields have been the most variable for planting date from year to year. This is probably due to the fact that oats are more subject to winter damage than the other small grain crops.

 
         
       
© 1997-2008 by The Samuel Roberts Noble Foundation, Inc.